Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Girls don't like hard math

222 replies

2New · 28/04/2022 07:24

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10759687/Fury-tiger-head-claims-female-pupils-shun-level-physics-dislike-hard-maths.html

Katharine Birbalsingh, founder of the Michaela Community free school in Wembley claims that girls can't be bothered with advanced maths 😂.

Ms Birbalsingh, chairwoman of the Government's Social Mobility Commission, said: 'I just think they don't like it. There's a lot of hard maths in there that I think they would rather not do.'

When pressed on why girls would not want to do harder maths, she added: 'The research generally … just says that's a natural thing... I don't think there's anything external.'

AIBU to think that Ms Birbalsingh is talking rubbish?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MrsMangelsPortrait · 29/04/2022 07:10

I'm not quite sure why everyone's getting worked up over an article in the Daily Mail, as it's the most misogynistic source of mainstream press to pollute this country. Anything on there needs to be read with a pinch of salt. Please don't anyone contribute more to its hateful agenda by clicking in the article 🤦‍♀️

EmoIsntDead · 29/04/2022 07:05

RachelshouldvegonetoParis · 28/04/2022 07:46

I think one of the issues is that girls tend to get better marks across the board so are more likely to choose other subjects, especially if they then see that none of their friends are in Maths class.

Rubbish

Tynetime · 29/04/2022 06:45

In DDs school it is Computer Science teachers through struggle with keeping. Also low number of girls taking subject at GCSE although A level class about 50/50

ThomasinaGallico · 28/04/2022 23:43

noblegiraffe · 28/04/2022 23:29

There’s also a severe shortage of qualified maths teachers and it’s even worse in physics.

Which suggests to me that this is not just a problem with girls doing maths, but with everyone doing maths. STEM subjects are precisely the sort that you can’t blag your way into; you know your stuff or you don’t. Really good teachers are gold dust.

Unfortunately girls tend to be very good at spotting when they’re on to a loser with teachers. I wish I’d done that better myself.😆

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 28/04/2022 23:34

I remember reading that boys were better at getting the answer whereas girls were better at understanding how.

Just made me want to study it more

noblegiraffe · 28/04/2022 23:29

There’s also a severe shortage of qualified maths teachers and it’s even worse in physics.

ThomasinaGallico · 28/04/2022 23:20

I did maths A-level. Sadly I barely scraped through, thanks to a Pure Maths teacher with poor English, a heavily accented and almost inaudible voice and a tendency to mutter into the blackboard as she chalked up endless proofs. The one girl who got an A in our group had, I suspect, plenty of outside help as well as ability; nobody else got above a C, and several failed outright.

We get our STEM teaching so wrong in this country. We begin by underestimating the capabilities of primary schoolchildren (teaching them ludicrously roundabout and tortured methods of doing straightforward arithmetic), then forget to keep them motivated in the tricky teenage years, and finally, for those who have managed to stay the course, we top-load them with a ridiculously content-heavy and time-compressed syllabus that seems designed to crush out all remaining enthusiasm for the subject.

mudgetastic · 28/04/2022 22:57

MangyInseam · 28/04/2022 22:21

There is some research that has said when they can choose without pressure, women are more likely to be interested in jobs where they spend more time with people, compared to men. Which may not lead them towards choosingphysics and advanced maths as often as male students do.

I don't think that's a problem so long as those who want to, can. Because while you can make statements like that in the aggregate obviously they don't apply to all individuals.

You should say When there is no obvious external pressure

We have no idea what jobs women would choose if they weren't taught from babyhood that girls should be caring whilst boys should be clever

That's what social conditioning is

noblegiraffe · 28/04/2022 22:28

OutDamnedSpot · 28/04/2022 07:42

I’m just here to see what @noblegiraffe has to say about this… 😅

Funnily enough I have Opinions.

KB should be aware of the research posted upthread that shows that girls in single sex schools are much more likely to take physics than in mixed schools suggesting that at least part of the problem isn't the 'hard maths' but the presence of boys (perhaps the knowledge that they'll be in a minority is off-putting, obviously one of the ways to tackle this is to try to ensure that more girls take physics so they're not massively outnumbered).

PP have rightly pointed out that girls have more choice at A-level due to better general performance at GCSE. The subjects where boys outperform girls at the top grades which would be needed for A-level are maths and physics...however the percentage difference in results isn't big enough to fully explain the lesser take-up of maths, and definitely not the far fewer girls taking physics.

For boys, it's more likely than girls that their good grades in maths and physics are their best results so they take them at A-level where girls might have several strong subjects.

BUT this doesn't mean that we should just shrug like KB and say 'I don't care if only 16% of girls take physics, let them choose.' She's the bloody social mobility tsar and should be well aware that a lot of the better paying jobs are in STEM. If she has a school stuffed with disadvantaged girls, then how about trying to improve social mobility by at least making some effort to improve their financial prospects by opening up the higher-paying job market to them?

I've found that confidence is a big issue with girls taking A-level maths. I've taught top set girls predicted a grade 9 who have needed a conversation about their suitability. They need someone to say 'of course you are good enough to take it' or to even just suggest it as a possibility for them. I expect the same goes for physics, particularly if it has a perception of being hard.

KB isn't doing girls any favours by reinforcing that perception.

Girls don't like hard math
MangyInseam · 28/04/2022 22:21

There is some research that has said when they can choose without pressure, women are more likely to be interested in jobs where they spend more time with people, compared to men. Which may not lead them towards choosingphysics and advanced maths as often as male students do.

I don't think that's a problem so long as those who want to, can. Because while you can make statements like that in the aggregate obviously they don't apply to all individuals.

Teacherontherun · 28/04/2022 18:45

The gender gap on Maths Alevel is much less than Physics, if her view was correct then surely there would be less doing maths?!

Gizacluethen · 28/04/2022 18:23

I've always just got maths. But I'm autistic and not particularly feminine.

Moomeh · 28/04/2022 17:46

Schulte · 28/04/2022 16:35

The Bunsen burner would have been used in the chemistry lab rather than physics, no? 😉

Both!
In physics:
The gas laws
Make your own optical fibres
Convection, conduction
Spectra and blackbody radiation

WalkerWalking · 28/04/2022 17:26

Apologies if this has already been linked:

www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.iop.org/sites/default/files/2019-04/its-different-for-girls.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjH2qqtlbf3AhWZQkEAHbiCCFkQFnoECAMQAQ&usg=AOvVaw3II597KBMRoPCfi-qJxm9l

Girls from single-sex schools are 2.5 times more likely to take A Level physics than from mixed schools (just amongst maintained schools)

PurpleDaisies · 28/04/2022 17:05

What makes you think you wouldn’t use a Bunsen burner in a physics lab? Thermodynamics? 😉

ddl1 · 28/04/2022 17:01

Schulte · 28/04/2022 16:35

The Bunsen burner would have been used in the chemistry lab rather than physics, no? 😉

We used it in both.

RoseLunarPink · 28/04/2022 16:41

You do use a bunsen burner in physics - one example is for heating a bimetallic strip.

Schulte · 28/04/2022 16:35

The Bunsen burner would have been used in the chemistry lab rather than physics, no? 😉

ddl1 · 28/04/2022 16:33

Personally, the reason why I didn't do physics longer than I had to, had nothing to do with fearing 'hard maths' (I did maths A level and studied a science subject at university) and everything to do with my being both badly co-ordinated and a physical coward and therefore very frightened of lighting the bunsen burner.

Dixiechickonhols · 28/04/2022 16:31

Does the new GCSE grading to 9 put more girls off. Thinking about confidence and perfectionism. My teen views herself as weaker at maths as she’s predicted an 8 and has chosen A levels where she’s predicted 9. In my day an A was as good as it got so she’d not have evidence she was ‘weak’ at maths which makes her discount it.

ddl1 · 28/04/2022 16:26

Most research nowadays shows that males and females perform similarly in maths, but girls are more anxious about it. Perhaps partly because of the Birbalsinghs of the world. I thought this attitude was declining: even 30 years ago, though a talking Barbie doll was programmed to say 'Math is hard!', there was a lot of protest and the doll was withdrawn. And there have been lots of changes over time. Whereas 30 years ago, females were less likely than males to go to university, nowadays they are more so. Whereas in the past, they were less likely to study science subjects, now they are more likely than males to study sciences that involve living things (biology, zoology, experimental psychology, and, in complete contrast with the past, medicine) and less likely than males to study sciences that deal with non-living things (physics, engineering, computer science). It's certainly not as simple as females not wanting to do hard maths.

Dixiechickonhols · 28/04/2022 16:23

Rosehugger yes that’s us we both did Humanity A levels and have bred a child who is choosing similar A levels to us. I’ve tried not to influence and discussed benefits of taking maths or science eg keeping options open, variety, not all essay based but her heart isn’t in it.
If parents or relatives haven’t studied it probably less likely to chose it.

poetryandwine · 28/04/2022 16:19

Thank you, @Discovereads. These articles are interesting. I am not trained in social science so I wonder if someone can tell us why there may be controversy around this? I am not seeing it.

Rosehugger · 28/04/2022 16:05

Dixiechickonhols · 28/04/2022 13:07

My DD is 16 at a state grammar. Predicted an 8 in maths and physics.
She isn’t doing maths or science A levels.
Another poster hit nail on head with girls achieving highly in maths tend to be high achieving across board. My DD is doing better in humanities and enjoys those more so those are her choices. Her friends are same.
The standard of maths and physics teaching has been woeful. The physics teacher has a psychology degree and is a disorganised shambles, DD has pretty much self taught it. Maths teachers - her current one is good but leaving (to trade bit coin?!)Trainee one on a Wednesday has answers written down and constantly needs to look, can’t answer questions and has poor spoken English eg DD had a medical apt and I was worried at her missing maths - don’t worry is Mrs X We don’t learn anything in her class. DD is going to school sixth form so why sign up for A levels with poor teachers. The subjects chosen she likes and respects teachers.

Confidence. The school cream off 30 and call them set 1 and make them do extra maths gcse. No setting in any other subjects. Knock on is fact the other 120 pupils think they aren’t good at maths even though predicted 8 or 9. She said to me that she was surprised kids with worse grades were doing maths and science A level as she perceives them as her weaker subjects.
Medicine doesn’t need physics the friends thinking of medicine are doing biology chemistry and another subject of choice.

That may well be the case. DD1 got a 9 in Maths at GCSE and 8s and 9s in single subject sciences but got 8s and 9s in everything and could not wait to stop doing Maths and sciences as she loves design, languages and humanities.

Very much like DH and me though we tried not to influence her with our preferences.

Dixiechickonhols · 28/04/2022 16:00

TeenPlusCat Yes definitely think there’s something in that less risk taking theory same way men will apply for jobs only meeting some criteria but women only apply if meet 9/10 etc.
For my teen she’d do well but I’d be less confident of her getting an A than in Humanities so why take risk unless you absolutely love Maths.

Swipe left for the next trending thread