Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD on cause for concern PGCE

113 replies

feelikeraindrops · 27/04/2022 22:15

My DD is on her PGCE, she has been on a cause for concern which has been reviewed and she’s been told she’s made good progress in some of her targets but there are some areas that need fine tuning and working on still. Because of this she has been put on the next stage of a cause for concern.

DD is feeling worried about passing but I’ve told to try her best and just listen to and respond to feedback, which she is determined to do.

OP posts:
eddiemairswife · 27/04/2022 23:35

How does she react when children approach her when she is on playground duty? In my experience there are always children who want to chat to the teacher on duty.

StaunchMomma · 27/04/2022 23:34

Teacher training is pretty brutal, for good reason. Chatting to the kids is absolutely a requirement. Of course it takes a bit of practice to get the balance right & find your groove of how you interact with the kids but you really do just have to get on with it. You can't avoid it due to your personality.

Unfortunately this is a fundamental element of teaching that can't be taught via the PGCE, you can just either do it or you can't. Being able to build relationships with the kids is absolutely crucial, though. You can't do the job effectively without it.

I agree with the previous poster who said teaching is like a performance. It absolutely is, often whilst under extreme pressure and/or whilst juggling behavioural issues. It takes balls.

I'm trying to say this kindly, but in reality would you want your 8 year old child being taught by someone who will only interact with them about maths or geography? Primary kids in particular need to feel a warmth/bond/support etc from their teachers.

watcherintherye · 27/04/2022 23:30

I’ve always thought teaching is somewhat akin to acting. Not in a bad way, but you’re on show, and you’ve got to perform with confidence, otherwise your audience will start to feel uncomfortable. If your dd doesn’t feel that she can happily do that every day of her working life, then she’s going to have a rather miserable time of it as a teacher, and I would encourage her to re-think.

Bluecheck679 · 27/04/2022 23:29

Just to offer another perspective - it might not be the worst thing. She's been given tangible feedback to improve on and now she knows what to do. A friend of mine was a cause for concern, another friend failed a placement and had to extend their PGCE to do an additional placement. Both teachers well established in their careers now.

Galwayg · 27/04/2022 23:28

If I was her I’d take that as my get out and run for the hills 🙈 It’s sad but so true! I did the same course and just kind of stumbled my way through it somehow. I kept passing all the crits I was expecting to fail. Each time I thought ‘well when I fail this time I’ll drop out then’.. it just never happened. I got some pretty harsh feedback, as did 99% of the course. The feedback from observations can be so brutal, especially when it’s basically criticizing you, your personality etc. I forced myself further and further down this road, purely because ‘I’d’ passed’ so I must be good enough. I’m 6 years in and so wish I’d done something else. The constant criticism, the never quite being good enough, the expectation to be an expert on literally every subject under the sun, the parents complaining if you so much as breathe near their child in the wrong way.. I just can’t take it anymore. I’m on a Facebook group called exit the classroom and thrive. It’s full of people like me who are now anxious, constantly on edge and feel like they have no self worth due to the demands of this job. To me, all the holidays on earth wouldn’t be worth it anymore. I’ve started up my own business and I can’t believe how much less stressful that is! Im making so much more money, I’m not being assaulted or sworn at by children and I don’t have someone following me around telling me I could have done every single thing better 😊 it’s amazing!

Good luck to your daughter, I hope she makes the right decision for her

RewildingAmbridge · 27/04/2022 23:22

Why does she want to be a teacher?
Not goady, but most people's answers are based on forming relationships to enable children to learn and grow etc. If that doesn't come naturally to get maybe this isn't the right career for her .
Would she be better suited teaching adults? Rapport is still important but the students will have more developed social skills of their own

Goodyetalso · 27/04/2022 23:05

Having good relationships with the children is the most important part of teaching. If she is struggling with this and it’s not improving then I don’t think teaching is for her. As a previous poster said, if she really does want to be a teacher she would be better taking a break to work with children in other settings for a couple of years until she feels comfortable and natural with them.

Seashor · 27/04/2022 23:03

Teaching is tough, really tough. Building relationships with the children is the easy part. I’d probably have my head in my hands if she was my student.

She needs some life experiences to help with her shyness because shyness and teaching are not compatible.

Magicandspiders · 27/04/2022 22:56

As others have said, cause for concern isn't given lightly. If she is struggling to build relationships with the students then she will find it very difficult to teach. It is your job as a teacher to get to know each child. If this doesn't come naturally then she will struggle to get a job once she has completed the PGCE. One of the first things the interviewers will look for is if the candidate is warm and interacts with the children. Can they build a rapport during a lesson observation. Good luck to her but I'd she really is struggling then she should consider if it right for her. It is a tough job- you need to be passionate to do it.

PurpleDaisies · 27/04/2022 22:48

It’s a hassle for providers to put students on cause for concern. It isn’t usually done lightly.

Ionlydomassiveones · 27/04/2022 22:48

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Catshaveiteasy · 27/04/2022 22:48

Being shy is one thing - I know several shy teachers. But being unable to establish rapport with pupils is not so good. It's fundamental really. I was a shy child and hated being so. I became a lot more confident as an adult but the shyness is there underneath still. But I could always talk to pupils as that is part of my role. Feeling shy was reserved, in my case, for times when I felt out of my comfort zone.

Teaching is tough and I wouldn't recommend it to anyone who is not suited to it. Maybe it's just not your dd's "thing'? I've also met many ex teachers - there's no shame in recognising something isn't working for you.

SignOnTheWindow · 27/04/2022 22:47

OK, yes - interacting with the kids while on playground duty is pretty key!
Does she find places like the playground/lunch hall difficult to cope with or is it more that she feels awkward around the kids in a more informal environment than the classroom?

Wolfiefan · 27/04/2022 22:47

Of course they expect her to get to know the children she teaches. If she’s shy and doesn’t feel able to do this then maybe teaching isn’t for her. Why did she want to teach?

LittleYellowDog · 27/04/2022 22:45

Being a teacher is being on stage in a performance for 7 hours a day every single day of the school year.

whoopsnomore · 27/04/2022 22:45

It does sound as if she needs to push herself to go towards the children and make moves to get to know them and be approachable. Maybe if she thought in terms of making it possible for them to come to her rather than vice versa if that makes sense? As in it's not about "making them like her" but showing she can listen and interact. If she is really not comfortable doing that, then she may not be cut out for teaching. If it's a shyness and getting over the first interaction hurdle, then she needs to practise and then carry out the basic openers: "Hello, how are you? It's lovely today, do you like the wind, I do! That looks like a difficult game. Gosh, you're trying very hard with that ball, etc"

LittleYellowDog · 27/04/2022 22:44

feelikeraindrops · 27/04/2022 22:38

School expect her to interact with children during playground duty and get to know them for example.

Thats a very basic ask, the TAs, lunchtime supervisors, cleaners, office staff and caretaker all do that.

YetDespiteTheLookOnMyFace · 27/04/2022 22:42

If I’m honest and having had students of my own, it’s not a great position for her to be in. This is the easy part really. Is it really really what she wants to do?

STARCATCHER22 · 27/04/2022 22:40

PeachCottonTree · 27/04/2022 22:38

Relationships are fundamental in teaching. Without a good rapport with pupils and their respect everything else is an uphill struggle. Does she have much experience working with children prior to her PGCE? If she is struggling it may be worth considering a break for a few years to gain more experience with children and then going back to the PGCE if that’s still what she wants to do.

This is really good advice. Particularly if your daughter is young.
The school are not asking for anything out of the ordinary. PGCE and NQT years are tough and everyone needs a break from children but this doesn’t seem like an unreasonable expectation from the school.

STARCATCHER22 · 27/04/2022 22:38

feelikeraindrops · 27/04/2022 22:27

DD is in a year 4 class, one of her main areas of development is forming relationships with children. DD is quite shy and school have said she doesn’t speak much as she should to the children when she’s not teaching.

From my experience this is really important. At job interviews, this is always something that schools are looking for (during observation lessons and school council interviews etc). This is potentially something that could impact her greatly moving forward.
Teaching is not a job where you can really be shy (or at least if you are shy, you’ve got to fake it). Building relationships with the children is a huge part of teaching in terms of getting them on side to follow instructions but also to help them feel safe and confident. This is something that your daughter is going to need to get over if she really wants to be a teacher.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 27/04/2022 22:38

better that she knows now so she can find out if she can do what she needs to? not nice for her, but I would guess this is pretty rare so they must be concerned to raise it. If she is very shy, teaching may not be a good match for her.

feelikeraindrops · 27/04/2022 22:38

School expect her to interact with children during playground duty and get to know them for example.

OP posts:
PeachCottonTree · 27/04/2022 22:38

Relationships are fundamental in teaching. Without a good rapport with pupils and their respect everything else is an uphill struggle. Does she have much experience working with children prior to her PGCE? If she is struggling it may be worth considering a break for a few years to gain more experience with children and then going back to the PGCE if that’s still what she wants to do.

SignOnTheWindow · 27/04/2022 22:37

Does she come out of her shell while teaching, though? What sort of things is the school expecting her to do with the kids when not teaching?
The PGCE and NQT years are challenging - she needs time out from constant interaction with the kids to recharge. I hope the school isn't treating her as a get-out-of- playground-duty card for the rest of the staff. I've seen that happen.

FrownedUpon · 27/04/2022 22:34

TBH if she’s struggling that much, it may be that teaching isn’t for her. Teaching is brutal & even teachers who breeze through their PGCE can still struggle in the first few years. Perhaps she needs to rethink?