Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD on cause for concern PGCE

113 replies

feelikeraindrops · 27/04/2022 22:15

My DD is on her PGCE, she has been on a cause for concern which has been reviewed and she’s been told she’s made good progress in some of her targets but there are some areas that need fine tuning and working on still. Because of this she has been put on the next stage of a cause for concern.

DD is feeling worried about passing but I’ve told to try her best and just listen to and respond to feedback, which she is determined to do.

OP posts:
JazzApple · 28/04/2022 07:15

Frankly the playground thing sounds like nonsense. They should be looking at how she interacts with kids in the classroom.
Yes, obviously they should be looking at how she interacts with the children in the classroom as well but presumably this was an example of what the student had been told. Not the reason for the cause for concern in it's entirety.

And you do have to talk with the children in the playground. It's where you can spend time getting to know them as individuals. Sometimes it might be the only time that day you connect with that child. It's an opportunity to see who they are as people when they have the freedom to do what they want with who they want.

ChocBloc · 28/04/2022 07:06

Maybe it's not for her, just be there to support her.

palmplantcirca1980s · 28/04/2022 06:57

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

cansu · 28/04/2022 06:53

Frankly the playground thing sounds like nonsense. They should be looking at how she interacts with kids in the classroom. The students in class need to be confident she is in charge and feel secure to answer questions. All teachers have their own personality. It sounds like they are criticising her personality rather than her skills.

DrDreReturns · 28/04/2022 06:48

I left a pgce in April. I was going to fail, there was no point continuing. It was the best thing I wouldn't have been a good teacher. There's no shame in leaving the course if she decides it's not for her.

malificent7 · 28/04/2022 06:43

If it's any consolation to your daughter it will be a massive bullet dodged if she leaves teaching...believe me...i did it! Awful job.

STARCATCHER22 · 28/04/2022 06:31

Marmite17 · 28/04/2022 00:34

Is this her only school placement? Tbh some schools are better than others with training.
Would hope that she would have an opportunity to try out in a different school
Most important thing to begin with is establishing respect, and engaging in the classroom imo. Relationships follow, in time, so hard on short term placement.
Establishing relationships also is a vague target.

I appreciate it might seem like a vague target but she’s been given clear advice on what the school would like her to do.
Establishing respect and engaging in the classroom is almost impossible to do with most children without building a relationship with them.
I agree that some schools are not great at supporting trainees but that doesn’t sound like the case here.

Marmite17 · 28/04/2022 00:34

Is this her only school placement? Tbh some schools are better than others with training.
Would hope that she would have an opportunity to try out in a different school
Most important thing to begin with is establishing respect, and engaging in the classroom imo. Relationships follow, in time, so hard on short term placement.
Establishing relationships also is a vague target.

me4real · 28/04/2022 00:29

@feelikeraindrops She has virtually lasted to the end of the course. So I imagine she'll be fine. x

me4real · 28/04/2022 00:28

It's not extremely rare for someone to be on Cause for Concern. I tried to do a Secondary PGCE, we were a farly small group and at least one woman was on it at one point. She passed fine.

I was one of the two that dropped out. I didn't like not having my evenings free etc and found the day incredibly draining. What they ask isn't human/humane really IMHO. I had a lot of undiagnosed mental health issues too which mean I don't handle stress well. Just not for me. Smile

Tilltheend99 · 28/04/2022 00:19

If she loves teaching but is struggling with communicating with the kids she could take up a drama class to help her with the ‘performance’ aspect of teaching. If she is naturally introverted she will always find the social interaction aspects exhausting but she can learn to act confident. (Some people describe this as masking)

Backtomyoldname · 28/04/2022 00:16

feelikeraindrops · 27/04/2022 22:38

School expect her to interact with children during playground duty and get to know them for example.

Not an unreasonable ask. Its part of the job really.

Not that hard to fix either - and once you start you soon get into a comfort zone doing that.

Chattering with children makes other parts of the job easier/ possible.

If your DD really can’t do this then one has to ask is she entering the right career?

I’m naturally quiet and shy - but I managed this quite easily.

Generally schools and colleges rarely fail pgce students. This is a fixable thing - or should be.

In my career in teaching I’ve only known 1 fail - and he was rscorted off the premises.

saraclara · 28/04/2022 00:15

If she's uncomfortable interacting with the children, then sadly, teaching really isn't for her.

I was shy whe I was young, and am still introverted. But I never had a problem with the kids, and I was able to do the acting bit of teaching. When I was a new teacher, in some ways I was more confident at work than anywhere else, because it was a role that I was acting. And then I basically faked it until I made it.

I know that loads of people have already said it, but teaching, especially now, really is brutal. If she doesn't have the self-confidence to interact with the kids (and her colleagues) to stand up for herself professionally with stroppy parents (and chat warmly to all the parents), and deal with all the stress and pressure involved, she really does need to think again about her choice of career.

There's an issue with trainers not failing students who really aren't up to the job. There are way too many young teachers who shouldn't have been passed, and consequently they have a horrible time in their first year/s, their confidence is shattered, and they end up leaving or being pushed anyway. Much better to make an active choice to bail on the course and do something else. It might well be that her trainers are doing her a favour by giving her a heads up.

caringcarer · 28/04/2022 00:15

She should approach a group of girls, smile and say any of you doing anything nice at the weekend girls? They will respond. She needs to look interested, agree oh that sounds fun, anyone else....I am going to a BBQ etc, who likes bbq's. Approach boys anyone enjoy the football at weekend? Which teams do you support? Let them respond and chat to her. Ask who do they think will win the league. If they say City laugh and say, not Liverpool or vice versa. Ask about things they like. The more she tries the easier it gets. If she wonders around playground not speaking to children that is not good.

LastMinuteBreak · 28/04/2022 00:03

Has she tried secondary? Or a different school for the placement?

This happened to someone I know and it was more that the school had form for 'breaking' trainees in the belief it made them better feeling like they were at the bottom and toughing it out. Year after year people on their placements struggled and failed to thrive at that school.

maddy68 · 28/04/2022 00:03

Honestly the pgce is absolutely awful. Sometimes it means your daughter isn't cut out for teaching. Is she taking their advice on board andskkng changes? She needs to speak to her uni mentor and ask for a placement change as a matter of urgency

QueenofLouisiana · 28/04/2022 00:00

If she’s shy, can she look at it as “acting” as a more confident person? As a PP said, teaching is like performing: most of us put on our teaching face at 8.30 and have it firmly in place until 4pm! It’s one of the reasons that we are all exhausted by hometime.
that said, yes she really does need to build relationships with the children. It’s the basis of safeguarding, maintaining control of 30 children at once and getting them to tell you if they just don’t understand what you said. If that relationship isn’t there, everything else is a lot harder- and in the case of safeguarding (absolutely at the core of what we do), impossible.

PurpleFlower1983 · 27/04/2022 23:57

Building positive relationships with children is absolutely essential as a teacher, is this really the career for her? Does she have much prior experience in the school setting. Teacher and introvert don’t really go together.

Motheranddaughtertotwo · 27/04/2022 23:51

It doesn’t sound as if teaching is for her. I’m naturally shy, as are a lot of my colleagues, but I love interacting with the children. That’s the nice part, seeing them having fun and relax. It’s the easy part and if she doesn’t enjoy it, she’s going to struggle. I would encourage her to take the advice and spend some breaks with them and then think long and hard about if this really is what she wants.

ThanksItHasPockets · 27/04/2022 23:46

The school should absolutely not have to tell your DD to talk to the children while
on duty. That is basic, basic stuff.

It probably doesn’t feel like it but it is good that she has a university and placement school who have the guts to put her on CFC. Many of them fudge their way through and pass frankly inept students, which is a disservice to literally everyone involved. CFC and the associated support plans are a huge amount of extra work for both the university tutor and the school-based
mentor (who is not paid any extra for their time supporting the trainee) and as pp have said they are not entered lightly.

I assume she doesn’t have an ECT job lined up yet. It’s time for some very honest reflection on her part.

Fuuuuuckit · 27/04/2022 23:45

If she's not prepared to interact with the kids, how on earth does she/do you think she's going to manage to teach them? Teaching is pretty much all about relationships - recognising each student's ability, personality, earning their trust and confidence, with a bit of learning thrown in.

Is she on her first placement? It's a real ball-ache to put a trainee on a cfc plan but she really does need to up her game.

Interacting with kids and being 'on duty' at all times is part of the professional capability criteria.

And yeah, whilst duty might not be officially part of her roll, any teaching student should be falling over themselves to go that extra mile. Is she sure she's up for the rigours of being a teacher?

LuluBlakey1 · 27/04/2022 23:43

If she does not naturally and easily make good relationships with children she should leave now.

earsup · 27/04/2022 23:42

Yes she ought to try to interact more ....i did my pgce years ago....honestly found most of it useless....led by hippy drippy lecturers who spent hours in the pub and left us alone for hours.....i found the city and guilds 7307 much more useful as did that before...!!

Gagaandgag · 27/04/2022 23:40

Galwayg · 27/04/2022 23:28

If I was her I’d take that as my get out and run for the hills 🙈 It’s sad but so true! I did the same course and just kind of stumbled my way through it somehow. I kept passing all the crits I was expecting to fail. Each time I thought ‘well when I fail this time I’ll drop out then’.. it just never happened. I got some pretty harsh feedback, as did 99% of the course. The feedback from observations can be so brutal, especially when it’s basically criticizing you, your personality etc. I forced myself further and further down this road, purely because ‘I’d’ passed’ so I must be good enough. I’m 6 years in and so wish I’d done something else. The constant criticism, the never quite being good enough, the expectation to be an expert on literally every subject under the sun, the parents complaining if you so much as breathe near their child in the wrong way.. I just can’t take it anymore. I’m on a Facebook group called exit the classroom and thrive. It’s full of people like me who are now anxious, constantly on edge and feel like they have no self worth due to the demands of this job. To me, all the holidays on earth wouldn’t be worth it anymore. I’ve started up my own business and I can’t believe how much less stressful that is! Im making so much more money, I’m not being assaulted or sworn at by children and I don’t have someone following me around telling me I could have done every single thing better 😊 it’s amazing!

Good luck to your daughter, I hope she makes the right decision for her

Hahha yep! So true. So glad to be out!

saleorbouy · 27/04/2022 23:37

If she's shy and cannot communicate with the pupils other than in a formal classroom setting then I'd say she's probably not best suited to the profession.