Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD on cause for concern PGCE

113 replies

feelikeraindrops · 27/04/2022 22:15

My DD is on her PGCE, she has been on a cause for concern which has been reviewed and she’s been told she’s made good progress in some of her targets but there are some areas that need fine tuning and working on still. Because of this she has been put on the next stage of a cause for concern.

DD is feeling worried about passing but I’ve told to try her best and just listen to and respond to feedback, which she is determined to do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RammyEwie · 28/04/2022 15:49

I found the PGCE very demanding and had a phase where I got bogged down in a negative spiral and things deteriorated for a while trying to keep up and deal with feedback. It wasn't the easiest of schools in a number of ways and I'd gone from a very prescriptive mentor in school one to a very hands-off, inexperienced mentor in school two. I did a repeat teaching practice and even that decision being made and easing the uncertainty lifted a weight. Repeat teaching practice went really well, I hit the ground running, understood the expectations and had a good, experienced mentor and came out with a strong grading.

I then launched straight into casual supply and did my NQT year across two long term supply jobs and it was so much easier. Less scrutiny and I'd found more of how to put myself into teaching. On teaching practice two there'd been too much "mask" of me trying to be too serious and grown-up because I felt that I should, and not giving enough hint of myself to make interactions easier and more genuine. I've enjoyed a decade of teaching before a lengthy break to prioritise family life (DC with additional needs) but would like to return longer term.

Getting this far into a PGCE before having issues does not inherently mean that you're unsuited to teaching. If you have a positive approach to feedback, are willing to tackle the core issues and potentially reset, it can be a valuable learning curve. Often the best teachers are those who've dealth with adversity and can use that to be more understanding with their pupils as they learn.

Rondvassbu · 28/04/2022 14:06

The playground thing is a bit of a red herring. You don’t get put on an action plan for that. This must be part of a wider picture.

Agree. It's an example of not meeting the standards in the forming positive relationships with children category. It won't just be in the playground, it could be in the classroom too. The interaction needs to go beyond just standing up and teaching the curriculum. The mentor will be looking to see that the trainee teacher interacts with the children positively and that the children respond positively to her, that she cares about them.

ThanksItHasPockets · 28/04/2022 13:38

To add to @CoffeeWithCheese’s very helpful post (and I hope @feelikeraindrops is still reading as many pp are offering really kind and constructive advice): I would advise your DD to volunteer to run a quiet play / colouring / craft / board games club for quiet or vulnerable children during playtime. Many primary schools have quiet areas or benches in the playground for just this purpose. The school will bite her hand off, she will build her confidence in interacting with children outside of the classroom, and she will be proactively showing that she is addressing her CFC targets as a well as teaching standard 8.

PurpleDaisies · 28/04/2022 13:31

The playground thing is a bit of a red herring. You don’t get put on an action plan for that. This must be part of a wider picture.

I don’t generally spend lots of time chatting to kids unless they come up to me during play time. It’s their break from me too! You often need to have an eye on the whole area to spot any trouble brewing and that hard if you’re deep in conversation.That’s pretty normal at most schools I’ve worked in.

JazzApple · 28/04/2022 13:26

Cattenberg · 28/04/2022 12:04

I know this is a minor point, but when I was at primary school, I don’t think many of us interacted with the teacher on playground duty. We were too busy playing! There were one or two little ones who sometimes liked to walk around with the teacher, holding her hand, but most of us didn’t do that.

Confused But if just a few different dc talk to a teacher every day for a couple of minutes that's the whole playtime. And you keep yourself busy by initiating contact with them while you are walking around. Each one would take 20 seconds and it's not something you would remember a decade later.

I didn't know you could skip Lou.
Good kick Jessica.
Have you had a haircut Joe?

crochetmonkey74 · 28/04/2022 13:19

Cattenberg · 28/04/2022 12:04

I know this is a minor point, but when I was at primary school, I don’t think many of us interacted with the teacher on playground duty. We were too busy playing! There were one or two little ones who sometimes liked to walk around with the teacher, holding her hand, but most of us didn’t do that.

Really gently- everyone has a very skewed version of their own school life

Until you are a teacher you don't realise the bigger picture

me4real · 28/04/2022 12:53

Lots of people don’t complete their pgce. Unless you’re going for teaching jobs, its not a problem. It’s the same as any career change. You just say you started but realised it wasn’t for you.

@PurpleDaisies I don't think that's anything OP's DD has to worry about (unless she decides to stop) as she's virtually at the end of the course.)

I know this is a minor point, but when I was at primary school, I don’t think many of us interacted with the teacher on playground duty. We were too busy playing!

@Cattenberg I agree.

It is a performance, my dad left due to stress eventually, partly because he's quite introverted.

Riv · 28/04/2022 12:28

LittleYellowDog · 27/04/2022 22:45

Being a teacher is being on stage in a performance for 7 hours a day every single day of the school year.

This is the most accurate statement about teaching that I have heard. It's this, plus educating and encouraging learning that is at the heart of teaching. The curriculum and lesson plan is the script and you are improvising and acting a role all day.
One of the best teacher I know came on supply to our school. She was so quiet and nervous I didn't think she'd make it. The bell went, students started lining up at the door and it was like "curtain up" for her! There was an instant transformation, She became a really confident woman within seconds. Chatting to the children, organising them, showing them she knew what she was doing and gaining their confidence and trust. I saw her at the end of the day quietly marking and assessing on her own, she was back to the timid mouse.

She's an experienced head teacher now, her school has excellent results. She's well respected and the children adore her.

Wisenotboring · 28/04/2022 12:23

Hi OP, things sound tough for your daughter. I'm a subject mentor for pgce and currently have a student who is on a support plan which is the stage before c 4 c. A few things that give me concern are her inability to take targets I set seriously. We agree she will do things in a certain time point and they don't materialise. When they are eventually completed they are poor quality and it's normally too late to do anything about it. She seems to go away and not take what I say seriously. She has also had to be pulled up on various professional behaviours such as being on time. Individually they aren't awful, but collectively they give a really poor impression. This lack of insight into how she comes across and her progress in meeting very specific targets makes me worry about her competence. Your daughter needs to show that she takes mentor feedback very seriously and is doing everything she can to develop weaker areas. She should show some initiative and not expect everything to be handed to her on a plate, especially at this time in the year.
In terms of specific ideas. Could she ask to spend a morning shadowing a really effective TA as she could see some excellent practice there in terms of relationship building. Is there an after school club where she could volunteer and be able to focus on having some fun with the children? If this isn't an option, could she identify some students in her class that might benefit from a small lunchtime club with a focus on building social relationships.

Cattenberg · 28/04/2022 12:08

That said, it was a nice school where the teachers remembered what was going on in our lives. For example, when my mum was pregnant, all the teachers knew and remembered and they helped prepare me for the arrival of my sibling.

katepilar · 28/04/2022 12:07

whoopsnomore · 27/04/2022 22:45

It does sound as if she needs to push herself to go towards the children and make moves to get to know them and be approachable. Maybe if she thought in terms of making it possible for them to come to her rather than vice versa if that makes sense? As in it's not about "making them like her" but showing she can listen and interact. If she is really not comfortable doing that, then she may not be cut out for teaching. If it's a shyness and getting over the first interaction hurdle, then she needs to practise and then carry out the basic openers: "Hello, how are you? It's lovely today, do you like the wind, I do! That looks like a difficult game. Gosh, you're trying very hard with that ball, etc"

I know this must be cultural /I am from a post-communist country/ but talking like this to children during playtime at school sounds absolutely ridiculous to me.
It may be even different now versus when I was a child but teachers or before&after school carers wouldnt approach children like this at all. Break time was not supervised in the classrooms, only lunchtime in the canteen was.

Cattenberg · 28/04/2022 12:04

I know this is a minor point, but when I was at primary school, I don’t think many of us interacted with the teacher on playground duty. We were too busy playing! There were one or two little ones who sometimes liked to walk around with the teacher, holding her hand, but most of us didn’t do that.

PurpleDaisies · 28/04/2022 11:59

Lots of people don’t complete their pgce. Unless you’re going for teaching jobs, its not a problem. It’s the same as any career change. You just say you started but realised it wasn’t for you.

yellowsuninthesky · 28/04/2022 11:56

HesterShaw1 · 28/04/2022 11:30

I think if teaching is not for you, it's better to find out during your PGCE. There's no shame in it.

no but you need to pass it surely? Otherwise it's a massive waste of money and how do you explain it when you go for future jobs? You see enough posts on here about flakey people changing their minds about what they want to do.

It's one thing saying I decided teaching wasn't for me, quite another saying I failed the PGCE.

Rondvassbu · 28/04/2022 11:51

I'd wonder how it was possible not to interact with children in the playground. When I was in primary teaching whoever happened to be on playground duty was constantly surrounded by children wanting to show them stuff, talk about their rabbit, get you to watch them do some skipping trip or whatever. I never had to make an effort to interact with them because they'd come running up anyway.

Is she perhaps portraying a "stand-offish" image, perhaps with body language - crossed arms etc, seems unfriendly etc? She should perhaps observe other people on playground duty, how they stand, how they move around the playground, facial expressions etc.

What else was flagged as an area for concern which you say she has improved on? There must be a bit more to this than meets the eye. Perhaps it's a general feeling from the school that teaching isn't the right fit for her.

If she doesn't enjoy interaction with the children or isn't able to overcome her shyness with them, then she really should think about a different career. It's the children who make teaching bearable - the fun you have with them and the various relationships. The rest of it is a really hard slog which you put up with because you enjoy working with children.

HesterShaw1 · 28/04/2022 11:30

I think if teaching is not for you, it's better to find out during your PGCE. There's no shame in it.

mummypie17 · 28/04/2022 11:17

It might not be a bad thing. I realised that teaching wasn't for me during my PGCE course. I didn't have any issues building relationships with the kids but I struggled with lesson planning and differentiating work for a large class. I've now been working for many years as a Youth Mentor in schools and also privately tutoring and it is definitely more suited to my strengths.

lostonadustyrock · 28/04/2022 11:12

Ooos, can't remember what I meant by 'I kno' so just ignore that 😂

lostonadustyrock · 28/04/2022 11:11
  1. It's quite hard to fail a PGCE. You have to have consistently failed to make improvements for quite a while. You also have to be a bit crap. Sorry, but it's true. As a PCGE and School Direct mentor (in my time) I watched a fair few 'alright but in no way amazing' teachers pass the year because they weren't bad enough to fail.
  1. The area you've given as an example (talking to the kids on playground duty) points to a bigger issue. Forming relationships is a huge part of teaching and the part that most teachers go into it (and stay) for - it's why they put up with the absolute crap that comes with teaching! If your daughter doesn't have that 'for the kids' motivation, she could find it really hard to cope when things get tough.
  1. That said, they should be putting support in place - for example asking her to shadow or observe a teacher / TA in the playground, dining room or classroom who is known for building rapport easily.
  1. Totally agree that she needs to find her persona. It takes a while to get it right but she's basically aiming for 'talking to the kids about their interests and lives (because who loves to talk more than most primary aged kids?!) and sharing the odd detail about her own life (children LOVE this, they still think that their teachers sleep in coffins in the basement).

To be honest she's going to have to get a grip on the shyness if she wants to carry on. I too am shy, verging on antisocial. School gate conversations at my son's pick up bring me out in a cold sweat. But as soon as I was in school that wasn't me. There's nothing wrong with being shy - until it stops you doing what you want to do. If what she wants to do is teach, she needs to work on that.

Best of luck to her. And thank goodness she isn't doing secondary - year 9 would eat her alive if there was even a shred of fear in her eyes.

I kno

Rosehugger · 28/04/2022 11:03

I found whenever I've been in a school helping as a parent that I couldn't help interacting with children, they come to me, chat, hold my hand, even hug me 😮- If your DD finds it difficult then there're no shame in saying that this isn't for her. A good friend of mine did a BEd and found she couldn't do it after the tecahing practice, she hated it.

crochetmonkey74 · 28/04/2022 10:42

Another PGCE mentor here OP - for many years and have only had one cause for concern- it really is more than just not quite being good enough.
Lots of my PGCE students have passed even though I knew they would not necessarily be a good teacher or have career longevity. Cause for concern is quite strong and she may then struggle to have a job, which makes it even harder.
I agree with others who have said the shyness is not compatible - you need a certain temperament and a proactive communication style.

Bluevelvetsofa · 28/04/2022 10:36

Forming relationships, whether in depth with your class, or on a less formal level in the playground, or lunch queue, or generally around the school, should be pretty much part of the DNA of a teacher, even if it’s the ‘face’ you wear during the school day. Not being able to do that instinctively is a major disadvantage.

Two terms in, it must have been on the radar long before now and if it’s not improving, I think she should question whether teaching is for her.

Time to rethink maybe.

wonderstuff · 28/04/2022 10:27

I am a teacher, I was cause for concern on my NQT. I passed, there was talk of doing an extra term, but in the end I made it. I'm still teaching about 20 years later. I am not a 'natural' teacher, I don't walk into a room and command the space, I'm not charismatic enough. However I do love working the the crazy school environment, I am passionate about education and I have had a decent career. I maybe should have run for the hills during PGCE - it is an absolutely brutal career even if you are great at it.

I now specialise in teaching children with SEN and I'm shit-hot at teaching kids who can't read at 11 to read well. It's my super-power. I have also discovered that some schools are just awful toxic places, and a change in leadership can change a previously lovely school to an awful place to work.

I'd encourage her to think really hard about whether she wants to continue. NQT year if anything is harder than PGCE (but it does start getting a bit easier after that). There are other jobs that are satisfying and useful and may better suit her, lots of jobs in health that involve working with children, but not 100s of them, social care and youth work are demanding, but in a different way. I'm currently completing a psychology degree with hopes of retraining to be an EP - I had no idea when I was making career choices at 21 that that was a thing, but I think it may be a better fit for my personality/skill set.

CoffeeWithCheese · 28/04/2022 09:47

It's not so much meeting the feedback but having the evidence that you've done so that's the big thing. Being shy is fine - I'm autistic and I taught for years and years - but I was always fine being "on" in front of the kids, and it was just at the end of the day when I dropped the mask that I burnt out.

So if she's been told she needs to be chattier and more engaged with the kids on the playground - how can she evidence that (and then if they carry on giving her hassle over it she'll have evidence to appeal against that) - taking the playground games comment someone mentioned earlier and something that I saw in a school I worked at - could she take a bit of a lead in setting something up like a "playground game of the week" that she uses some of the class kids to quickly demonstrate in assembly one morning and then there's stickers afoot for those kids who join in playing it on the yard when she's on duty... so she can show quite clearly that "you said I needed to do X, I've done Y"

University should be supporting her as well once concerns are raised.

I get it though - playground duty sometimes you do just want to switch your brain off a bit - but the kids want you to peel 57 million satsumas, watch 50 dance routines the girls have made up and tell you your choice of football team is shite ruthlessly (the football team were really shite to be fair). Then you're guaranteed to have at least three kids wanting to hold your hand and since you're only a two-armed creature and not an octopus - you end up having to navigate that! Schools really do appreciate it if you get caught up into the school life at large while on placement - my final PGCE report praised the fact I'd made a point of coming in for the summer fair and had also participated in watching the World Cup matches with the kids (no one else in our year group liked football and wanted to supervise the kids who wanted to watch the games so it was a hardship I was willing to endure) as well as the actual teaching stuff.

I'm also coming at this from having to navigate placement feedback recently for a different course which was somewhat similar in nature (see the comment about me being autistic) - so I contacted the uni staff, we discussed it, I made myself a plan of what I was going to be doing to be seen to be addressing points made - and I turned the whole thing around and passed it well in the end.

Silvercatowner · 28/04/2022 09:33

Nillynally · 28/04/2022 09:28

Forming relationships with children is one of the absolute basics. Is she sure teaching is for her?

This. She could (theoretically) have a job in 5 months and if she cannot do this then she won't be an effective teacher.

'Cause for concern' may well be the final stage in a long process of additional support for your daughter.