Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government suggestions to help with cost of living crisis

113 replies

ThankGodItsThursday · 27/04/2022 16:39

Is it me? I don't think so. Latest suggestions being reported include making MOT 's bi annual. How will this help. My MOT in March cost £37. That's a drop in the ocean compared to rising petrol prices, increased fuel costs, food prices etc.

Plus wouldn't this be a safety issue. Cars being driven that are potentially unsafe and it won't help anyone who owns a garage will it. There will be less people having a MOT so less income for the business.

Why is everything this government suggests or does a complete and utter cock up.

And no I don't have any suggestions myself that won't cost the government anything which is what I understand they are looking for. But any ideas surely need to be safe and actually save people a decent amount of money if it is to genuinely help.

OP posts:
HardyBuckette · 27/04/2022 17:45

Bolognia · 27/04/2022 17:30

I don't think people wanting living standards to drop are the problem
Yes of course there are some people who are genuinely struggling. But the fact that money is still being spent in pubs and restaurants and on holidays and days out means that a lot of people have room to pull their belts in but aren’t.

But nobody thinks everyone in the country is struggling with the basic costs of living, though? And actually, it's a good thing if people who do still have disposable income are spending it on days out, pubs etc rather than pulling in their belts.

desiringonlychild2022 · 27/04/2022 17:44

@Fishwishy my area of London had stagnant prices from 2016-2021. This enables me to buy. Now increased by 50k back to 2015 peak due to return to office. London has one of the highest rates of immigration. The main issue is inequality. There are some people with inheritances from London parents, who will earn 100k by the time they are 29 and will marry someone similar. They are not unusual. Yet most Londoners are not so lucky and most earn significantly less or have no inheritance. th e ones luckier to have bought earlier also cash out and roam the country in search of large properties in exchange of the tax free equity they have gained causing house price increases all over the country. There are also some who scrimp and save and beg and borrow from relatives - and this is the reality for every FTB I know

nairyw · 27/04/2022 17:44

They can get to fuck on the childcare ratios - I'd never send my pre-schooler to somewhere without decent ratios that allow staff to nurture and teach as well as keep children physically safe

the cynical part of me reckons they know those that don't have won't. I certainly wouldn't .

Hiddenmnetter · 27/04/2022 17:44

The issue with the cost of living crisis is a crisis of supply. The only way to address this is to suppress demand. So prices rise.

Nothing will return to normal until global gdp returns to normal. This means with china locking down, the war in Ukraine and sanctions against Russia we are cluster fucked. We are all 10-20% poorer than we used to be. We just didn’t know it. Covid lockdowns are responsible for 90% of this, but as this war stretches on it will cause more and more issues.

Our government can do nothing about this. It’s not in their gift. It’s not that they’re out of ideas, they’re just not being honest that the global penchant for lockdown has ruined everyone’s lives.

Mirrorball2022 · 27/04/2022 17:44

As a former nursery nurse if they increased ratios there would be no way I’d work in one. The current ratios are already very full on, many staff are now degree or level 4 educated yet paid paid poorly. I used to take home planning etc as not enough time to do it while looking after the kids. I would no way be doing all that plus extra ratios for minimum ( or just over) wage. It’s so unsafe it’s untrue. What parent would want to put their child into a nursery with unsafe ratios?

The same goes for the mot unsafe cars in the road causing accidents, it’s not cheaper just bigger bills every 2 years, garages lose regular income and put prices up anyway or close.

nothing surprises me though anymore with this government .

Bolognia · 27/04/2022 17:43

desiringonlychild2022 · 27/04/2022 17:35

@Bolognia if we didn't spend £19 at the pub yesterday, wouldn't that affect the pub's business and if the pub closes down, then wouldn't the staff lose their jobs? People not spending money has an effect on other people's jobs..and its always the mid range that gets hit. The luxury restaurants and shops generally have pretty high margins and their customers are not really affected.

Yes, but I as an individual don’t care if the pub or restaurant closes down. If I spend £10 at a restaurant that means I can afford to spare the £10. So clearly every person sitting in a restaurant today is not on the poverty line because they have at least a spare tenner. And they have room to pull their belts in if they need to, by staying at home and saving that tenner.

Tumbleweed101 · 27/04/2022 17:42

All those suggestions are crazy and compromise peoples safety. I work in a nursery, it is hard enough to watch children, educate children, do the work of health visitors and social workers, do all the paper work required for SEN children and do physical care such as nappy changes in the ratios we already have. The government need to fund their 'free' childcare scheme properly for it to work for families not compromise the development and safety of our youngest members of society.

ThankGodItsThursday · 27/04/2022 17:41

Agrudge · 27/04/2022 17:33

As I've said other countries manage fine. It would have to bigger fines for failing to maintain the obvious stuff like tyres ,break pads . The bi-annual mot would check for anything major

Any car that's 40yrs+ old doesnt need an mot . Ok fair enough they arent used Daily.

Agrudge You appear to be missing the point that I was, making in my original post.

Whether or not other countries do bi annual MOTs is not the issue. The issue is that saving £37 is not really going to help anyone who is struggling with the increased cost of living. If it was a monthly bill and the idea meant you would be saving £37 per month that would help.

Only spending £37 every two years instead of annually isn't really going to make any noticeable difference is it?

OP posts:
WoodenClock · 27/04/2022 17:40

Crimesean · 27/04/2022 17:36

They can get to fuck on the childcare ratios - I'd never send my pre-schooler to somewhere without decent ratios that allow staff to nurture and teach as well as keep children physically safe.

But who decides what decent ratios are? 1:8 for 3 & 4 yo in nursery but classes of 30 4yos in school?

1:4 for 2 yos, but 8 suddenly OK on their 3rd birthday?

BurnDownTheDiscoHangTheDJ · 27/04/2022 17:38

It’s eye-rollingly pathetic what they’ve come up with. What next, a non uniform day? Bake sale?

Crimesean · 27/04/2022 17:36

They can get to fuck on the childcare ratios - I'd never send my pre-schooler to somewhere without decent ratios that allow staff to nurture and teach as well as keep children physically safe.

Fishwishy · 27/04/2022 17:35

The mot is silly it is a basic safety check. The rest What can they do? They can stop with housing market subsidising that just pushes up prices. Maybe cut demand for housing by tackling second home ownership, immigration and maybe looking at reducing incentives for children. And properly invest in renewable energy and defense and manufacturing jobs. We need a high wage productive economy to tackle the cost of living crisis. Instead of gimmicks like the council tax rebate ect.

desiringonlychild2022 · 27/04/2022 17:35

@Bolognia if we didn't spend £19 at the pub yesterday, wouldn't that affect the pub's business and if the pub closes down, then wouldn't the staff lose their jobs? People not spending money has an effect on other people's jobs..and its always the mid range that gets hit. The luxury restaurants and shops generally have pretty high margins and their customers are not really affected.

Agrudge · 27/04/2022 17:33

EvilPea · 27/04/2022 17:20

Are you serious?
do you know how many people don’t check their tyre treads? at 3 points a corner, that’s you license gone. It’s also the only point of contact their car has with the road.
how would most people check welding or suspension without a ramp? Headlamp levelling, brake capability.

Not MOT, but oil, so few people check it, yet it can write their car off if their engine fails.

As I've said other countries manage fine. It would have to bigger fines for failing to maintain the obvious stuff like tyres ,break pads . The bi-annual mot would check for anything major

Any car that's 40yrs+ old doesnt need an mot . Ok fair enough they arent used Daily.

balalake · 27/04/2022 17:32

Not putting the clocks back in winter would reduce energy costs, and not cost the government anything apart from parliamentary time to pass the legislation.

Bolognia · 27/04/2022 17:30

I don't think people wanting living standards to drop are the problem
Yes of course there are some people who are genuinely struggling. But the fact that money is still being spent in pubs and restaurants and on holidays and days out means that a lot of people have room to pull their belts in but aren’t.

nairyw · 27/04/2022 17:23

They keep increasing minimum wage, which is a good thing and thank god for it. However, it creates wage inflation at all levels and pushes up costs on everything we buy.

I don't the current inflation issue has been caused by this months increase to minimum wage. If anything salaries have been stagnant for decades.

desiringonlychild2022 · 27/04/2022 17:23

@Agrudge ah yes. Maybe they can cap the value. Like say £15 off all your cumulative shopping trips per week.

nairyw · 27/04/2022 17:21

The problem is that people want to maintain the same standard of living and won’t accept genuine solutions to reduce costs. Like eating less meat and less in general, stop buying alcohol and smoking and eating out, less new stuff like clothes and toys, etc. Can you imagine the outcry if the government told people to stop drinking to save money? So they come up with nonsense suggestions.

I don't think people wanting living standards to drop are the problem.

Windfall tax for energy companies. 20% discount cards to be issued to all UC /disability claimants, claimable at all major supermarkets. Waive business taxes and vat for childcare providers,; increase amount that can be claimed on tax free childcare. I don't know what to do about Increasing rents as that is linked to the increasing cost of repairs for landlords as well as increasing demand.

We should be doing this & far higher levies imo on 2nd home ownership/foreign ownership.

desiringonlychild2022 · 27/04/2022 17:21

Ok long term solution for renters and to help solve housing crisis (aside from building more social housing and houses in general) - allow people to salary sacrifice (this can be capped) into a account which is used to buy housing (only primary residence). This account also has 5% interest rate on the first 25k. Might reduce demand for rental if more people can buy their homes.

Not perfect but from my experience, it's the deposit raising that is hard, I had to live with family for 3 years to save our deposit.

EvilPea · 27/04/2022 17:20

Agrudge · 27/04/2022 17:10

Lib annual mot is a good idea. Even after a mot it's still your responsibility to make sure its roadworty

Isle of man doesnt have an mot. And they seem to manage

Are you serious?
do you know how many people don’t check their tyre treads? at 3 points a corner, that’s you license gone. It’s also the only point of contact their car has with the road.
how would most people check welding or suspension without a ramp? Headlamp levelling, brake capability.

Not MOT, but oil, so few people check it, yet it can write their car off if their engine fails.

WoodenClock · 27/04/2022 17:17

This is a bit of a chicken and egg situation.

They keep increasing minimum wage, which is a good thing and thank god for it. However, it creates wage inflation at all levels and pushes up costs on everything we buy.

EvilPea · 27/04/2022 17:16

WoodenClock · 27/04/2022 17:08

The MOT suggestion ruins the business of every MOT garage overnight too.

The nursery thing might have some merit but it's not something to be implemented on a whim to reduce costs. If there is too much red tape/ ratios are too low and costs are unnecessarily high, that should be changed, but after proper research. E.g. if it's OK for a reception teacher to have 30 children, it probably is OK to increase group sizes for 3/4 yo?

Mot garages at the moment are eerily quiet because of the 6 month extension anniversary. They are mentally busy in September - March now, but March - September, quiet

EvilPea · 27/04/2022 17:14

Slycat · 27/04/2022 17:04

A lot of other countries either have no MOT equivalent or a bi annual one so its not that outrageous to suggest it

The police have more powers (and probably more funding!) in Germany for instance, the test is more stringent and it’s more expensive.

first things first the police would need to be properly trained and funded to stop and prosecute drivers of poorly maintained or poorly modified cars .

Agrudge · 27/04/2022 17:14

desiringonlychild2022 · 27/04/2022 17:08

Windfall tax for energy companies. 20% discount cards to be issued to all UC /disability claimants, claimable at all major supermarkets. Waive business taxes and vat for childcare providers,; increase amount that can be claimed on tax free childcare. I don't know what to do about Increasing rents as that is linked to the increasing cost of repairs for landlords as well as increasing demand.

20% discount for people on u/c would never. People will just get someone they know to do their shopping.

The should cap private rent to 25% above social housing rent