Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government suggestions to help with cost of living crisis

113 replies

ThankGodItsThursday · 27/04/2022 16:39

Is it me? I don't think so. Latest suggestions being reported include making MOT 's bi annual. How will this help. My MOT in March cost £37. That's a drop in the ocean compared to rising petrol prices, increased fuel costs, food prices etc.

Plus wouldn't this be a safety issue. Cars being driven that are potentially unsafe and it won't help anyone who owns a garage will it. There will be less people having a MOT so less income for the business.

Why is everything this government suggests or does a complete and utter cock up.

And no I don't have any suggestions myself that won't cost the government anything which is what I understand they are looking for. But any ideas surely need to be safe and actually save people a decent amount of money if it is to genuinely help.

OP posts:
JollyGoodBunting · 27/04/2022 18:04

ThankGodItsThursday · 27/04/2022 16:39

Is it me? I don't think so. Latest suggestions being reported include making MOT 's bi annual. How will this help. My MOT in March cost £37. That's a drop in the ocean compared to rising petrol prices, increased fuel costs, food prices etc.

Plus wouldn't this be a safety issue. Cars being driven that are potentially unsafe and it won't help anyone who owns a garage will it. There will be less people having a MOT so less income for the business.

Why is everything this government suggests or does a complete and utter cock up.

And no I don't have any suggestions myself that won't cost the government anything which is what I understand they are looking for. But any ideas surely need to be safe and actually save people a decent amount of money if it is to genuinely help.

I agree OP. Also annual MOTs on older cars actually save money in the long run because any problems are spotted earlier and are therefore cheaper to fix.

They are completely out of touch with reality.

nairyw · 27/04/2022 18:03

I also think the BOE should have raised rates earlier than then did, they've been somewhat asleep at the wheel.

nairyw · 27/04/2022 18:02

The pandemic and now war were always going to be big problems, but also we went into them in a real state.

exactly

Blossomtoes · 27/04/2022 18:01

So this is Labour’s policy. Sounds a lot more sensible to me.

So they’re the party of excess oil and gas profits and we’re the party of working people.

This government’s had its head in the sand throughout the cost of living crisis. First they let prices got out of control. Then they denied it was happening. They failed to do anything about it. And then they made it worse with higher taxes.
Because of his choices, we are set to have the slowest growth and the highest inflation in the G7.

A vote for Labour next week is a vote for a very different set of choices. We would ask oil and gas companies to pay their fair share of reduced energy costs. We would not hammer working people with the worst possible tax at the worst possible time. We would insulate homes to get bills down. And we’d close the tax avoidance schemes that have helped his chancellor - where is he? - reduce his family’s tax bill while putting everyone else’s up. That’s proper plan for the economy. So why doesn’t he get on with it and finally make choices that make things better not worse for working people.

LakieLady · 27/04/2022 18:01

What would really help those who are struggling would be an increase in benefit rates and raising the threshold at which workers start to pay tax/NI.

HardyBuckette · 27/04/2022 18:01

nairyw · 27/04/2022 17:59

@Hiddenmnetter I didn't say that the financial crisis was as bad but I do think the economy barely recovered from it before pandemic. Imo the QE for too long & there was not enough investment into the economy in general & too many housing market props. Look at wage stagnation & the productivity issue we have.

This is true. The pandemic and now war were always going to be big problems, but also we went into them in a real state. We could've been facing the pandemic without having had over a decade of emergency interest rates, and deliberately propped up housing costs.

EvilPea · 27/04/2022 18:01

Agrudge · 27/04/2022 17:33

As I've said other countries manage fine. It would have to bigger fines for failing to maintain the obvious stuff like tyres ,break pads . The bi-annual mot would check for anything major

Any car that's 40yrs+ old doesnt need an mot . Ok fair enough they arent used Daily.

Most classic owners still get theirs mot’d as it’s another set of eyes over the car. It also proves insurance road worthiness. Some policies stipulate it.

WoodenClock · 27/04/2022 18:01

It will come down to the fact that those struggling most are unlikely to be Conservative voters, in many cases won't be voters at all.

I think the dilemma for the Government is to try and help the "right" people, which for them, means Tory voters. Those are likely to be people who aren't facing destitution, but are starting to have to think twice about purchases or trips they would once have made easily.

Kendodd · 27/04/2022 18:00

Bolognia · 27/04/2022 17:04

The problem is that people want to maintain the same standard of living and won’t accept genuine solutions to reduce costs. Like eating less meat and less in general, stop buying alcohol and smoking and eating out, less new stuff like clothes and toys, etc. Can you imagine the outcry if the government told people to stop drinking to save money? So they come up with nonsense suggestions.

Maybe that's the solution, the 99% should just expect a drop in living standards under the Tories and post Brexit, afterall, it's what we voted for.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/04/2022 17:59

The best bit fro the useless fuckwits is the mot saving is likely to be offset by reduced fuel efficiency from not getting cars tuned.

Yes, exactly. Most people who can afford to run a car aren't really that perturbed about the cost of the MoT itself - it's the potential work that will need to be done as revealed by the MoT that terrifies people.

Even if delaying repairs didn't lead to a reduction in safety or efficiency over those two years, how can they possibly think it's going to help people who are struggling financially to eventually have twice as big a bill all at once?

The government already deliberately exploits poorer motorists by charging an extra fee if you can't afford to pay your annual VED/road tax in one go and have to spread it out monthly. All in automated DD payments, of course, so it's not like it costs them more in admin.

Private insurance companies do this as they consider it a loan on a risk that's spread through the year - and they are private for-profit companies - but when it's an ongoing tax levied by the government to cover a specific period of time for the permission to use the vehicle, there's no possible justification for charging extra other than that they've decided they want to exploit the poor who have no other option.

LoveSpringDaffs · 27/04/2022 17:59

Slycat · 27/04/2022 17:04

A lot of other countries either have no MOT equivalent or a bi annual one so its not that outrageous to suggest it

But at under £50 a year, what's the actual point???

nairyw · 27/04/2022 17:59

@Hiddenmnetter I didn't say that the financial crisis was as bad but I do think the economy barely recovered from it before pandemic. Imo the QE for too long & there was not enough investment into the economy in general & too many housing market props. Look at wage stagnation & the productivity issue we have.

Longcovid21 · 27/04/2022 17:58

Why have they chosen 2 safety critical things? It's a joke.

HardyBuckette · 27/04/2022 17:58

nairyw · 27/04/2022 17:55

And they have room to pull their belts in if they need to, by staying at home and saving that tenner.

we have a service based economy. If everyone decides to save every bit of disposable income what will that do to the economy?

Exactly.

The existence of people who don't need to save a tenner not actually tell us anything about all the people who do, and the actual connection between the two is that we need the disposable income group to keep spending.

Jellycatspyjamas · 27/04/2022 17:57

Yes of course there are some people who are genuinely struggling. But the fact that money is still being spent in pubs and restaurants and on holidays and days out means that a lot of people have room to pull their belts in but aren’t.

But folk who do have a bit of room to pull in their belts stopping going out for drinks or a meal won’t help those who are struggling day by day. It may in fact make things worse as businesses who rely on folk spending their disposal income experience a down turn and need to lay off staff or close altogether.

Most people live their lives according to their means, recent changes in the economy means that some people who were just about managing now really aren’t but me not going out for dinner won’t affect them or change their situation. There are many things the government could do to alleviate the pressure, tinkering with health and safety measures won’t make a significant improvement for those living hand to mouth but neither will everyone pulling in their belts if they don’t need to.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 27/04/2022 17:56

The government have cut police numbers and a lot of road policing has gone or been automated. Other countries may do more road policing.

nairyw · 27/04/2022 17:55

And they have room to pull their belts in if they need to, by staying at home and saving that tenner.

we have a service based economy. If everyone decides to save every bit of disposable income what will that do to the economy?

Kendodd · 27/04/2022 17:55

Have the Britannia Unchained lot suggested we all just work harder and stop being so lazy?

Here's a suggestion, they could stop funneling money to they're cronies in dodgy contacts.

Hiddenmnetter · 27/04/2022 17:53

Imo it's been a clusterfuck since the financial crisis & not helped by Brexit. No investment in the economy & austerity which didn't even reduce debt.

The GFC was a drop of around 0.5% in global GDP. Covid lockdowns were around 5%. This situation is literally 10* worse. Fact is they more or less played the GFC the only way they could. But even then QE was always an inflationary move.

only thing I think they could have done is built a bunch of power plants to make energy way cheaper and frack the shit out of the north. But then no one expected this war, so…eh. Can’t blame them for not taking energy security seriously when globalised energy has made it proportionally cheaper than it’s ever been except for the last 12 months.

desiringonlychild2022 · 27/04/2022 17:50

@Bolognia but 50% struggling is a big deal, no. 20% in poverty, probably will rise to 30%>

Agrudge · 27/04/2022 17:50

ThankGodItsThursday · 27/04/2022 17:41

Agrudge You appear to be missing the point that I was, making in my original post.

Whether or not other countries do bi annual MOTs is not the issue. The issue is that saving £37 is not really going to help anyone who is struggling with the increased cost of living. If it was a monthly bill and the idea meant you would be saving £37 per month that would help.

Only spending £37 every two years instead of annually isn't really going to make any noticeable difference is it?

I get your point £37 a year is a drop in the ocean.

I was just saying a bi-annual mot wouldnt idea in general

desiringonlychild2022 · 27/04/2022 17:49

@Bolognia well yes I am not saying I am struggling! Honestly there are a lot of people who probably haven't noticed the cost of living increasing cos they have so much money otherwise. It's more like 50% struggling and 45% feeling the pinch but still able to have luxuries and 5% not caring either way cos it's just pennies to them..the 5% are overrepresented in the restaurants probably with some of the 45% in there once a week or once a month. But it would be a bit like going to the Louis Vuitton shop and saying 'what economic crisis', so many people here! I have been to the Louis Vuitton outlet at selfridges recently btw, it was packed!

nairyw · 27/04/2022 17:48

Yes of course there are some people who are genuinely struggling. But the fact that money is still being spent in pubs and restaurants and on holidays and days out means that a lot of people have room to pull their belts in but aren’t.

But the gaps between the haves & the have nots is bigger than ever so many won't have to pull their belts in.

WoodenClock · 27/04/2022 17:47

I also wonder just how widespread this crisis is. I know there's be some people very badly hit, but a cinema ticket is now £13.50 at our local cinema and you can't get in at weekends. Likewise the local chain restaurants here, no point going if you haven't booked Fri-Sun.

nairyw · 27/04/2022 17:45

We are all 10-20% poorer than we used to be. We just didn’t know it. Covid lockdowns are responsible for 90% of this, but as this war stretches on it will cause more and more issues

Imo it's been a clusterfuck since the financial crisis & not helped by Brexit. No investment in the economy & austerity which didn't even reduce debt.