Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government suggestions to help with cost of living crisis

113 replies

ThankGodItsThursday · 27/04/2022 16:39

Is it me? I don't think so. Latest suggestions being reported include making MOT 's bi annual. How will this help. My MOT in March cost £37. That's a drop in the ocean compared to rising petrol prices, increased fuel costs, food prices etc.

Plus wouldn't this be a safety issue. Cars being driven that are potentially unsafe and it won't help anyone who owns a garage will it. There will be less people having a MOT so less income for the business.

Why is everything this government suggests or does a complete and utter cock up.

And no I don't have any suggestions myself that won't cost the government anything which is what I understand they are looking for. But any ideas surely need to be safe and actually save people a decent amount of money if it is to genuinely help.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/04/2022 16:46

I replaced it with a 3 year old car 2 weeks ago, because it was dangerous. I knew that, as a responsible sane road user, I should replace it. But many road users are neither responsible OR sane.

To be fair, many are simply not financially able to do so, however responsible or sane they might otherwise be. Not saying that you did the wrong thing at all, but that car must have been seriously mistreated or have been in a terrible crash to be in that state after only 11 years - I'm guessing it wasn't German or Japanese?!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/04/2022 16:41

Also, as well as the basic safety essentials, the MoT does cover some things that, in an ideal world, you would repair/replace immediately but which, in the real world, could easily wait with no noticeable impact on overall safety.

We had an extremely unwelcome bill of £250 at a very difficult time, a few years ago, for a headlamp that had been chipped by a big stone - it looked like a kind of bullet-hole but not open to the elements, if that makes sense (still not 100% sure how it managed to chip but then seal itself back up). It could have gone as it was indefinitely, if not years, with no discernible difference to function and safety, but because it triggered a box to be ticked on the MoT, we had to find the money somehow, and you really wouldn't have known anything had been changed at all.

The whole car gave up the ghost less than a year after that - we still haven't been able to afford to replace it yet.

zingally · 28/04/2022 16:32

Total rubbish from the government, as per.

Until literally 2 weeks ago, I was driving an 11 year old banger, that was falling apart underneath me. I'd had a 6-month service in February, and frankly, it was being held together by luck and a prayer. It wasn't due an MOT until the end of summer, and the thought I could have driven it around for another 18 months would be horrifying!
I replaced it with a 3 year old car 2 weeks ago, because it was dangerous. I knew that, as a responsible sane road user, I should replace it. But many road users are neither responsible OR sane.

(In theory, my old car has gone off to auction... If they can drive it off the forecourt at the garage, where I practically dumped it in the far reaches of their carpark... it'll be a miracle!)

EvilPea · 28/04/2022 16:22

MapleMay11 · 28/04/2022 12:22

EvilPea or you could try driving to a garage and asking for a check of those things in between MOTs if you have cause for concern. It's called taking responsibility.

I’m not entirely sure why your so aggrieved. However. I’ll bite.

Luckily. I do have those things. however, if I didn’t you’d pay a garage more to check then an MOT.
I’m all for people taking responsibility, but there’s a limit to what people can do and that’s where the mot comes in and why the yearly check is good for all.
i do know a lot of people who don’t check their tyres, their oil, get the lights on the dash checked. Yes they should take responsibility, but they don’t or can’t for various reasons and leave it to the garage or mot station to check when they have it serviced or mot’d.

MapleMay11 · 28/04/2022 12:22

EvilPea or you could try driving to a garage and asking for a check of those things in between MOTs if you have cause for concern. It's called taking responsibility.

EvilPea · 28/04/2022 12:17

MapleMay11 · 28/04/2022 12:00

People are capable of maintaining their car and ensuring its roadworthy in between MOTs if they're concerned about killing someone. Some personal accountability is needed.

So you have the equipment to check your headlamp levels? Put your car on a ramp and check for corrosion, and suspension wear? You have an emissions tester at home?

MapleMay11 · 28/04/2022 12:00

KarenOLantern · 27/04/2022 17:07

As someone who has always driven very old second hand cars, and always dreaded the MOT because my cars almost always need a couple of hundred quid's worth of work every year, this horrifies me. It's a safety issue ffs. The cost of maintenance on your car can make you weep, but not as much as killing your family in an accident caused by driving a dangerous car around for a whole year.

But anything to avoid taxing people who can afford it, eh.

People are capable of maintaining their car and ensuring its roadworthy in between MOTs if they're concerned about killing someone. Some personal accountability is needed.

GiraffesInScarfs · 28/04/2022 11:55

nairyw · 27/04/2022 18:17

in june or july.

Not enougj to offset the increase in the %. So still a tax rise, partially offset by a smaller tax cut. Smoke and mirrors.

GiraffesInScarfs · 28/04/2022 11:43

balalake · 27/04/2022 17:32

Not putting the clocks back in winter would reduce energy costs, and not cost the government anything apart from parliamentary time to pass the legislation.

This is a great idea. It should have been done decades ago for a host of reasons.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/04/2022 10:58

There should be a hike in road tax to £200 per year for all cars - none of this £30 for low emission vehicles.

I'd be very happy for our road tax to be 'hiked' down to £200 for our 21yo small hatchback!

Poorer people who run old cars disproportionately pay a lot more road tax. Government motoring policy is always based on the pretext that people who 'choose' a newer car with lower emissions - and keep upgrading regularly - should be rewarded for their conscientiousness; but as always, it simply hasn't crossed the minds of the rich people who make the laws that many of us have no choice but to buy old cars and then keep them until they drop.

The government seems desperate to channel Marie Antoinette when deciding 'simple solutions' for those dirty poor people with the audacity to need to drive cars.

darlingdodo · 28/04/2022 10:48

Blossomtoes, I know - we really are a country who supports every man for himself! We purport to admire the way Sweden, Norway etc run their countries, but when push comes to shove, many of us couldn't give a shiny shite about anyone but ourselves.

Nothing I've suggested would realistically impact the quality of life of the haves, but might make a significant difference to the have-nots. But it would take a large shift in our collective mindset.

Blossomtoes · 28/04/2022 10:36

Blimey @darlingdodo, if ever I saw a manifesto for losing an election it’s yours!

darlingdodo · 28/04/2022 10:33

There should be a hike in road tax to £200 per year for all cars - none of this £30 for low emission vehicles.

There are over half a million second homes in this country. There should be a huge increase in council tax on second homes.

Also far more council tax bands should be introduced - it's ridiculous that someone living in a fairly standard house on a a suburban estate should only be paying £1000 less council tax than a mansion on acres.

There shouldn't have been a property built in this country in the last 10 years, whether commercial or residential, that didn't have renewable energy options included in planning requirements, whether that be solar panels on the roofs of every single Persimmon/Bellway etc etc home built, or on the roof of every warehouse, office block, Tesco superstore, or heat pumps, wind turbines etc.

It won't win votes but I would be seriously looking at capital gains on first properties. If we had 10% capital gains on property, it's not really hurting anyone. See also inheritance tax - should be 10% across the board and higher rates for estates of £1M+, £10M+ etc.

Close tax loopholes which allow tax avoidance, whether this be the likes of Rees-Mogg and Sunak with funds stashed offshore or Amazon paying miniscule tax here on their huge UK profits.

Tax overseas investors who buy up UK property with zero intention of ever living in it.

NHS needs a total overhaul from the ground up. Too many staff. Too many patients who with earlier intervention wouldn't be over utilising the system down the track.

Education also needs a complete overhaul. Bring back Sure Start to ensure those who need extra help are supported from the beginning of their lives.

Crikeyalmighty · 28/04/2022 10:24

I should have added, because neither capped rent or childcare costs are a big vote winner with most Tory voters . They area government playing to their own vote base, hence the focus on immigration and such stuff- not governing for the National good.

Crikeyalmighty · 28/04/2022 10:21

If living standards drop and people stop spending on non essentials , as a Previous poster said , then that's a viscious circle given that the UK is pretty much a service economy and we then end up with lots of unemployment or under employment. Sadly Britain shot itself in the foot- the main reason food prices are up rapidly is Brexit, a combination of import tariffs , increased logistic costs and the fact that HGV drivers and warehouse workers are now in short supply and hence their wages have risen quite a bit to attract people. It's good that those wages have risen, but it comes at a price. Utilities and fuel is another issue of course, and that is an issue globally- partly through dependence on Russia for gas and oil prices generally. Other factors such as rent and childcare prices are still within UK control but there doesn't seem the will with this government to either cap rent or subsidise childcare further, especially for very young children.

NippyWoowoo · 28/04/2022 10:10

Bolognia · 27/04/2022 17:30

I don't think people wanting living standards to drop are the problem
Yes of course there are some people who are genuinely struggling. But the fact that money is still being spent in pubs and restaurants and on holidays and days out means that a lot of people have room to pull their belts in but aren’t.

Not me! I'm not 'really struggling' but I'm also not spending money on holidays and pubs! I earn the average uk salary but live on my own therefore all bills are mine.

There is a vast gap between people who are in poverty and those who can afford the things you mention, the majority of people fall into the middle and could really do with extra help.

I think the UK can do like other European countries; France and the Netherlands cut energy taxes in order to keep costs down for consumers, that's a start.

NippyWoowoo · 28/04/2022 10:02

Maybe road tax might be a better suggestion as it costs me £200

However I wouldn't suggest something that would only help drivers! As a single woman with no children there are already a lot of things that exclude me from help and I wouldn't want something that helps only me but not others

jgw1 · 28/04/2022 09:58

GalactatingGoddess · 28/04/2022 09:00

The idea about nursery ratios was just shocking and unsafe. Unfair for staff also, when something inevitably goes wrong due to being overstretched then who will be to blame. The low paid nursery workers no doubt.

Well obviously, if the low paid nursery worker was as clever as Jacob Rees-Smugg then they too would have a nanny to look after them.

GalactatingGoddess · 28/04/2022 09:00

The idea about nursery ratios was just shocking and unsafe. Unfair for staff also, when something inevitably goes wrong due to being overstretched then who will be to blame. The low paid nursery workers no doubt.

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 08:56

Bolognia · 27/04/2022 22:41

Maybe that's the solution, the 99% should just expect a drop in living standards under the Tories and post Brexit, afterall, it's what we voted for.
We do need to accept a drop in living standards! Currently western countries have a higher standard of living than can reasonably be maintained in the long term. We’ve created that high standard of living by exploiting both the planet and human beings in poorer countries. If other countries are going to develop and become equal we can’t continue exploiting them - so our standard of living has to drop. If we’re going to save the planet we need to stop exploiting it - so our standard of living has to drop. It’s nothing to do with the Tories or Brexit - it’s simply unsustainable to live as we have been doing.

The problem is that people are unwilling to accept the necessary drop in living standards. It’s becoming increasingly obvious that our western standard of living is unsustainable but people are still clinging to it. Global circumstances are pushing us in the direction of a lower standard of living but people expect the government to push back instead of just saying “look, the era of cheap everything and exploitation is over and this is how things are going to be now”.

My original point was that most people have the capacity to pull their belts in otherwise the pubs and restaurants and non-essential shops would be empty (and they aren’t). People just don’t want to - they want the government to fix it for them so they don’t have to reduce their consumption.

Your original point wasn't a very good one, then. Because nobody thinks the increased cost of living is causing everyone to struggle with meeting their basic costs. It's a strawman. The existence of people who have disposable income to spend tells us absolutely fuck all about the position of people who don't.

Throwing the environmental argument in at this point in the discussion is not at all convincing either. If you wanted to argue that we all need to reduce consumption and accept that this will mean lots of people without money for basic necessities, you'd have done that way earlier rather than pretended that people who have money somehow negate the existence of people who don't.

gitbag · 27/04/2022 22:49

The problem is that people are unwilling to accept the necessary drop in living standards.

My standards have certainly dropped compared to my parents generation. I pay a big mortgage (still cheaper than rent), a load into a private pension which isn't as generous as it used to be. My state pension contributions have gone up even though my pension age will likely increase again. And I pay a fair amount of tax

Bolognia · 27/04/2022 22:41

Maybe that's the solution, the 99% should just expect a drop in living standards under the Tories and post Brexit, afterall, it's what we voted for.
We do need to accept a drop in living standards! Currently western countries have a higher standard of living than can reasonably be maintained in the long term. We’ve created that high standard of living by exploiting both the planet and human beings in poorer countries. If other countries are going to develop and become equal we can’t continue exploiting them - so our standard of living has to drop. If we’re going to save the planet we need to stop exploiting it - so our standard of living has to drop. It’s nothing to do with the Tories or Brexit - it’s simply unsustainable to live as we have been doing.

The problem is that people are unwilling to accept the necessary drop in living standards. It’s becoming increasingly obvious that our western standard of living is unsustainable but people are still clinging to it. Global circumstances are pushing us in the direction of a lower standard of living but people expect the government to push back instead of just saying “look, the era of cheap everything and exploitation is over and this is how things are going to be now”.

My original point was that most people have the capacity to pull their belts in otherwise the pubs and restaurants and non-essential shops would be empty (and they aren’t). People just don’t want to - they want the government to fix it for them so they don’t have to reduce their consumption.

carefullycourageous · 27/04/2022 22:25

Lincslady53 · 27/04/2022 20:35

You don't get your car tuned at an mot, just checked for safety.

FFS, you get your car checked, you get a list of items that need doing, or are advisory, doing them makes your car run more efficiently.

Don't split bloody hairs.

QuiEstLa · 27/04/2022 21:56

Bolognia · 27/04/2022 17:43

Yes, but I as an individual don’t care if the pub or restaurant closes down. If I spend £10 at a restaurant that means I can afford to spare the £10. So clearly every person sitting in a restaurant today is not on the poverty line because they have at least a spare tenner. And they have room to pull their belts in if they need to, by staying at home and saving that tenner.

The naïveté of this is breathtaking. Have you no understanding of how economies function and how and why crises occur? This isn’t a conversation about whether pennies can be pinched here or belts tightened there.

JollyGoodBunting · 27/04/2022 21:51

Is it possible that those in power are just not very good? If I’d been this bad at my job I’d have been fired long ago.

Bad at their jobs? They're doing exactly what the global elite want them to do. Fuck us plebs over.

Swipe left for the next trending thread