Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guardian is publishing Russian Propaganda

309 replies

Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 15:45

AIBU to be very disappointed that the Guardian has resorted to publishing Russian propaganda. It was shocking to read, largely inaccurate and wholly from the Russian perspective. I am all for listening to all sides, but there was no effort to understand how Ukraine feels, Ukraine's objective is clearly to win the war and reclaim their nation, and blaming the western leaders for arming Ukraine and the bloodshed caused by the Russians is somewhat misleading, Ukraine have every right to defend themselves.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/apr/27/ukraine-war-end-putin-russia-talks

OP posts:
Hawkins001 · 28/04/2022 11:33

A question for people more knowledgeable than me, is agreeing to peace talks another way of giving up, ? Unless your country fights until they are completely defeated ?

Hawkins001 · 28/04/2022 11:30

Swayingpalmtrees · 28/04/2022 11:21

And just to be clear the thing that angers me about this particular Kremlin mouthpiece in the Guardian is not because I don't welcome all views, of course I do, but because this war is being fought on two fronts, and one of this disinformation, Russian propaganda and fake news.

The Russians are masters of manipulation and are very experienced at twisting the facts, and are doing a great job already winning the narrative and disinformation war far better than their performance are in the battlefields and on the front line. We should not be helping and paying for them to achieve this.

We can well do without yet more disinformation supported by the Guardian, this time aiming for I assume for the Corbyn types that no doubt feel the Ukrainians could be more reasonable and moderate, and should be giving up their country for the greater good or some other BS Confused

Id say all sides can be equally as good, with disinformation, etc, even from the days of Edward berneys and his various public relations.

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 11:29

I don't welcome all views. The ones from former Putin helpers who grossly overestimate Russia's military capabilities either through ignorance or worse we could very well do without. The right to be a disingenuous apologist of tyrants must of course be protected in a free society, but that's all. We certainly don't have to pretend it merits welcome, or anything other than tolerance.

Swayingpalmtrees · 28/04/2022 11:21

And just to be clear the thing that angers me about this particular Kremlin mouthpiece in the Guardian is not because I don't welcome all views, of course I do, but because this war is being fought on two fronts, and one of this disinformation, Russian propaganda and fake news.

The Russians are masters of manipulation and are very experienced at twisting the facts, and are doing a great job already winning the narrative and disinformation war far better than their performance are in the battlefields and on the front line. We should not be helping and paying for them to achieve this.

We can well do without yet more disinformation supported by the Guardian, this time aiming for I assume for the Corbyn types that no doubt feel the Ukrainians could be more reasonable and moderate, and should be giving up their country for the greater good or some other BS Confused

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 28/04/2022 11:13

Thank you all for such brilliant points! Especially for your twitter link hardy clearly the Ukrainian perspective is the most important and should be respected, they are the ones that are suffering the worst atrocities and are having their lives shattered.

birdy The issue with Ukraine giving an inch lets say some part of their country to Putin, do you really imagine he will simply stop there? His intention was to take all of Ukraine and that hasn't changed, and indeed in the last few days he has also spoken of invading Moldova and 'assisting' Russian speakers there. We have a new Hitler on our hands, and you don't get peace through talks with people like Putin and Hitler, the only way out of this is to drive Russia out and give them such an awful time that they are unlikely to try again for another generation. Putin may think he will stop at nothing to win, but maybe it will take that much - ie reducing his army to nothing, but you no one should expect anything from the peace talks apart from Ukraine capitulation. So a non starter.
Putin does not want to peacefully meet a brokered deal, he wants to resurrect the USSR so unless we understand his goal, and that is to take back what he thinks is Russia's then we really can't even begin to imagine what the end looks like.

We have to do more for Ukraine not less, they need bigger and better weaponry - more than they asked for, specialist training and everything we can throw at it the war to ensure the outcome is a win for Ukraine - or we won't just have mass genocide towns across Ukraine but in all of Europe eighteen months from now.

OP posts:
Hawkins001 · 28/04/2022 11:07

“The quickest way to end a war is to lose it.” -George Orwell
I'm only asking this question, and I'm not advocating one way or another,
How effective would it stop the conflict if one side or another surrendered ?

Hawkins001 · 28/04/2022 10:59

SpindleInTheWind · 27/04/2022 16:04

In a democracy, all opinions must be welcome; even the ones that offend you.

These days, with the rise of no platforming, and rewriting of various perspectives in history, or 're understanding, and how it relates to modern day perspectives in democracy, would make an intriguing study, if someone was to write a dissertation on the issues.

valerianaofficiana · 28/04/2022 10:55

I have no connection to the area but I work wit organisation that has a rather good grasp on the geopolitical situation.
Whenever people start political conversations with ' I feel...', the opinions coming forthwith are not worth much🙄. Unless one is talking to/about loved ones et al.

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 10:39

A Ukrainian perspective on the article

twitter.com/DMokryk/status/1519424770818940929

Alohaaa · 28/04/2022 09:37

Really informative thread, threads like this always makes me feel really ignorant…
@FatherBuzzCagney Your posts are really interesting, what do you think in regard to the comments made yesterday by Sergei Lavrov? Do you think there’s a genuine risk of the UK getting bombed?

theadultsaretalking · 28/04/2022 09:08

valerianaofficiana · 28/04/2022 08:14

@Laetitaleghorn, yes, that's the way to go. The Russian-apologist hand-wringers without even slightest hint of understanding of the geopolitical situation, yet who still believe that their witterings should be heard, should be the first to give up their worldly belongings.

Do you have connections to the region? Because I do and I do have a pretty good understanding of the geopolitical situation there and I don't find this piece to be particularly Russian-apologist, hand-wringing propaganda. We need to find a solution and the solution is not trying to get into a bigger war, as it will be the civilians on all sides paying for it.

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 09:04

Aishah231 · 27/04/2022 19:32

I'm sick of people dismissing any chance of peace talks with Putin. Yes it might be futile - but it might not and unless the West is prepared to send serious forces in then they have a duty to at least attempt to set up peace talks. Anyone would think they just want a long drawn out war of attrition which we can all 'learn lessons from' in the future after 100s billions have been made by arms manufacturers.

I'm sick of people who pretend peace talks at this point are anything other than entirely futile. It's laughable.

valerianaofficiana · 28/04/2022 08:14

@Laetitaleghorn, yes, that's the way to go. The Russian-apologist hand-wringers without even slightest hint of understanding of the geopolitical situation, yet who still believe that their witterings should be heard, should be the first to give up their worldly belongings.

LetitiaLeghorn · 28/04/2022 02:56

I'm actually getting to the point of feeling that maybe Ukraine should give up some of their land for the sake of peace

They already gave up the Crimea. Maybe they should give up Kiev? Or their industry? Or their parliament building. Then maybe Putin will turn his eye on Finland and Sweden as he's threatened. What would you like them to give up? Or maybe he will eye up the UK and he'll want something from us to keep the peace. Maybe we should give them your house or your bank account or your kids. I mean it's all for peace after all.

TomPinch · 28/04/2022 01:42

I think I overstated my previous post. There was widespread condemnation of the invasion originally. But look at who the abstainers included even then. Not just China. India, South Africa, Bangladesh, Pakistan and again a whole bunch of African countries. I worry that it reflects decreasing influence of 'the West'.

blueshoes · 28/04/2022 01:30

FatherBuzzCagney · 27/04/2022 19:42

But peace talk are futile. The Russian government has shown no interest at all in meaningful talks. They may do at some point, if they feel they have no choice but to go to the negotiating table, but they absolutely do not mean anything they say about peace talks at this stage.

It's not the West's duty to set up peace talks - that's the responsibility of the two parties to the conflict. And in any case, given that the Kremlin are trying to frame the war as a conflict with the West, there's not a chance in hell that they would accept Western-brokered talks. Unless you include Turkey in the West - they've been hosting talks and both parties have accepted that. Israel has also been suggested as a possibility.

The idea that somehow it would be ethically or strategically better to send Western (I assume NATO) forces in to Ukraine is the worst one since the call for NATO to set up a no-fly zone. On the plus side it would greatly increase the chances that the war ended quickly. On the minus side, the quick end to the war would be via nuclear holocaust. Swings and roundabouts, I guess.

This. 100%

It is not as if there hasn't been peace talks. Both sides and all sides have been talking peace since day 1 except Putin keeps violating his word or not agreeing and then committing atrocities and blaming Ukraine. This is still happening.

Peace talks is not some brain wave unless you really haven't been following the news. FFS

TomPinch · 28/04/2022 01:28

Outside the West this piece wouldn't be considered particularly pro-Russian, let alone propaganda. Have a look at the votes in the UN concerning this war. Outside the West and the Americas the world is decidedly neutral or pro-Russia. Take, for example, the vote to remove Russia from the UNHRC. The African vote:

5 for
24 abstain (including South Africa)
8 against

A Chinese friend tells me that the consensus there is pro-Russia.

It's pretty disappointing, to be honest, bit then people around the world remember the Iraq war and think sauce for the goose etc...

valerianaofficiana · 28/04/2022 00:56

Nobody but nobody has a right to say what Ukrainian people should or shouldn't do. It's their country, their lives and their future.
Some half-witted and poorly informed western hand-wringer has no say in it. End of.🤬

valerianaofficiana · 28/04/2022 00:53

Absolutely agree OP. The Russian-apologist drivel passed on as 'opinion piece' in every bloody paper is shocking.
Same with BBC, especially Radio 4. So disappointing.

Birdy78 · 28/04/2022 00:26

I thought the article made some very good points and think it’s a shame that every time anyone puts forward a viewpoint that isn’t in line with sending more and more weapons to Ukraine they get slated and called a mouthpiece for Putin. Every war and every side in a war uses propaganda. Remember the story about all the neonatal incubators being looted from hospitals in Kuwait and taken to Iraq ? About tiny premature babies being thrown out of them and left to die ? It made the front pages of every paper in the UK. All sworn to by doctors and nurses who had witnessed it. Except they didn’t - it was all a lie. All propaganda invented to create hatred and fuel public opinion to justify a war. Nobody in their right mind agrees with the horrific invasion of Ukraine by Russia, but nobody in their right mind ignores the fact that for a chance of peace then lines of communication have to be opened which offer all parties something at the end of it.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 27/04/2022 21:36

Thereisnolight · 27/04/2022 20:14

I’ll bet that many Ukrainians wish there had been more negotiation and diplomacy. Not every Ukrainian wants to keep fighting or ever did. Otherwise why did their men need to be prevented from leaving the country?

Putin lied and lied before he invaded. Said he wasn't going to invade. The US and UK insisted that he was. And then - he did. People like him don't want negotiation or diplomacy, unless it gives them the totality of what they want.

When will people understand that Putin doesn't want peace, or to "save face". He wants to win.

balkangrill · 27/04/2022 21:12

From my personal perspective, I find people in the West espousing and defending Russian propaganda very upsetting. It's not possible to pander to bullies and get good results. Negotiations will end this war, but it should be on Ukrainian terms also, not just giving that psychopat everything he wants.
And arms embargo certainly didn't stop war in my country, Nato air strikes and our and Croatian army gains did. Then we did negotiate successfully, and all negotiations failed before that.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 27/04/2022 20:46

I'm actually getting to the point of feeling that maybe Ukraine should give up some of their land for the sake of peace which I wouldn't have said when it started. It's hard to know what would make Putin stop though. He is completely mad.

Why do you think he is mad ? He could just be bad ? Or if the rumours are true, very sick ? He is also coming to the end of a very long reign, fuelled mainly by fear.
Lots of people have lied to him about very big things, some are no longer alive, some are in prison and some are hiding. He doesn't need to worry about those people. But the people who have lied and lied well, they are still close to him. Interesting times ahead for Old Vlad.

Forgotthebins · 27/04/2022 20:44

I would agree that these are Kremlin talking points - makes Ukraine sound like the puppet of the West, as if Ukraine has no thoughts of its own about its future. The Guardian publishes a range of stuff and quite a lot of it is toss. I am not sure this is technically propaganda, but it is certainly toss.

theadultsaretalking · 27/04/2022 20:33

Thereisnolight · 27/04/2022 20:14

I’ll bet that many Ukrainians wish there had been more negotiation and diplomacy. Not every Ukrainian wants to keep fighting or ever did. Otherwise why did their men need to be prevented from leaving the country?

I am always amazed at how easy people find it to push for the continuation of war when they are not the ones that are doing the fighting...More guns will only bring more deaths.

Swipe left for the next trending thread