Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guardian is publishing Russian Propaganda

309 replies

Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 15:45

AIBU to be very disappointed that the Guardian has resorted to publishing Russian propaganda. It was shocking to read, largely inaccurate and wholly from the Russian perspective. I am all for listening to all sides, but there was no effort to understand how Ukraine feels, Ukraine's objective is clearly to win the war and reclaim their nation, and blaming the western leaders for arming Ukraine and the bloodshed caused by the Russians is somewhat misleading, Ukraine have every right to defend themselves.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/apr/27/ukraine-war-end-putin-russia-talks

OP posts:
HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 20:48

Libertaire · 28/04/2022 19:02

I’m old enough to remember when Angus Roxburgh was the BBC’s Moscow correspondent, and when he was thrown out of the country or displeasing the government.

That’s an excellent article, written by someone with more knowledge and expertise of Russia & Putin than 99.9% of the rest of the U.K. media put together. We should be learning from him, not criticising him.

And yet he still grossly overestimates Russian military capacity, thus has been subject to furious criticism from people whose understanding of military matters is much better than his.

Hawkins001 · 28/04/2022 19:31

Swayingpalmtrees · 28/04/2022 11:55

A question for people more knowledgeable than me, is agreeing to peace talks another way of giving up, ? Unless your country fights until they are completely defeated ?

I can't comment if I am more knowledgeable than the next person that is subjective, however I do know there is simply no point in holding peace talks unless both side genuinely wish to find an agreement and solution.

If we consider Ukraine has been illegally invaded, why would they give up an inch of their land to a murderous dictator if there is even a small, even tiny chance they could win the war outright?

Putin is dishonest and disingenuous player, already proved, so even if a deal was brokered do we actually believe he will abide by it? I think it would be rather naive to imagine a simple gentleman's handshake and a signature will finish this war even if Zelensky makes it out alive (poisoning being the most worrying possibility)

As unpalatable as it sounds, Putin needs his 'arse handed to him' in street speak, that is the only language he understands. Russia need to be pulverised to such a degree that it will take years to rebuild what is left the tattered and broken army - decades to recover economically and longer still for the world to trust them ever again. It is the ONLY way Europe will be safe again. The only question is can Ukraine do it with the help and support of the west?

Putin will have to deal with his battered ego at the end regardless, this was not the war he was promised. Perhaps he should book himself in for some early counselling sessions to discuss and process what humiliation feels like. I have zero time and energy for anyone that prints apologist pieces in leading newspapers hoping to chip away at UK support for Ukraine and sow discord, division and disquiet. Disappointed doesn't really cover it.

I appreciate your perspectives and analysis, to be honest rather than relying on the narrative of the media, I'd prefer to study the files of the various intelligence, military, defence, energy ect agencies and companies, to assemble the narrative that would hopefully be gleaned from the files.

blueshoes · 28/04/2022 19:15

Swayingpalmtrees · 28/04/2022 18:48

theadultsaretalking You are beginning to sound a little like Angus himself, perhaps unintentionally one hopes.
Seriously, @Swayingpalmtrees , you do realise that the only way that Russia can get 'pulverised', is if there is a full-scale war between Nato and Russia

With respect, I think you are seriously underestimating the sheer volume of fire power and specialist training that is being pumped into Ukraine as we speak. Do you not think the Western leaders have considered all of the angles and realised that if they do not stop Putin somehow then Moldova, Georgia, possibly Poland etc will be next?
The idea is to pulverise the Russians to STOP the war, not to expand it.
Only today the US have committed another $33 BILLION dollars and when you combine the sum total with all the other countries around the world, you begin to see a picture emerging of a much more powerful Ukraine, one that can hold its own certainly against a weakening Russia - Ukraine have the army, a very very highly motivated army - they have an enormous amount of weapons arriving by the hour and global support, and they are on the right side of history. They have totally clear consciences. Ukraine is THEIR country. In fact I would go as far as to say the Ukrainians will stop at nothing to win, they have nothing further to lose. When we weigh this up, and consider Russia's fast depleting army, weapon arsenal and with no clear reasoned game plan - the first one has been aborted. It is possible to see quite easily that Russia may very well lose. Which is exactly why we see Putin again threatening nuclear war again - because that is all he has left, he knows this is going very badly and he is resorting to atrocities and desperation.

Russia have now exposed themselves not as a world class war machine, but a tattered, badly managed, terribly trained out of date rag tag army - a bunch of barbarians.

Ukraine has shown itself to be a strong, powerful nation with a real beating heart, that has captured the world's attention and heart. When this is all over they will benefit from their new world status for many generations to come.

Hear hear

Swayingpalmtrees · 28/04/2022 19:09

but I am not sure the current status quo is working for the Ukrainian people

So what do you think would be better for the Ukrainians? To give up their country and live under Putin? What future do you imagine will be waiting for them?

What we are doing now seems to be 'hiding' - not fully fighting, but giving aid and arms - and so allowing huge humanitarian atrocities to continue against the Ukrainian people

How would you propose to stop those atrocities? By asking Putin nicely to stop raping women and children and killing them en masse? Do you think those atrocities will stop if he were to win? Because you would be in a distinct minority if that is what you are suggesting. At best Ukraine would end up in a never ending civil war if Putin were to win, including endless atrocities and mounting death tolls on both side, or worst case a continuation for decades of a fully blown war until Russia runs out of money/men/both.

There is no way out for Russia, they can not win this war. The sooner they understand this basic fact, the better. The Ukrainians will never accept their occupation, and the loss of their nation. Putin has already lost, even if he is the last to know.

OP posts:
Libertaire · 28/04/2022 19:02

I’m old enough to remember when Angus Roxburgh was the BBC’s Moscow correspondent, and when he was thrown out of the country or displeasing the government.

That’s an excellent article, written by someone with more knowledge and expertise of Russia & Putin than 99.9% of the rest of the U.K. media put together. We should be learning from him, not criticising him.

Swayingpalmtrees · 28/04/2022 19:00

Yes Lemon and all this under the cover of the lies that Putin spins to the Russian people that there is no war - which is going to be a harder sell as time passes. If anyone even believes that now. Hard to imagine with the rolling footage of nuclear weapons and threats...

OP posts:
CorsicaDreaming · 28/04/2022 18:56

@LemonDrizzleSlice -

So, to answer @CorsicaDreaming's question, I would continue exactly what is being done. Fight, and sanction. And remember that it is not actually up to us, it is up to Ukraine.

I agree it is up to Ukraine, but if it was fully up to them to decide what happened, we (the West) would have stepped in already and instigated a no fly zone... and would probably now be in a fully escalated war.

What we are doing now seems to be 'hiding' - not fully fighting, but giving aid and arms - and so allowing huge humanitarian atrocities to continue against the Ukrainian people as a fallout of the current strategy - which is committed but not really committed.

I am not advocating a war, and I can't see any better solution myself, but I am not sure the current status quo is working for the Ukrainian people.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 28/04/2022 18:53

And of course there is now no way that Russia can get any kind of weapon, pretendy-civilian use or not, from the West. Even France and Germany have been made to stop supplying them.

Sanctions are hitting Russia hard in all sorts of ways.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 28/04/2022 18:49

They will need Western technological assistance to keep exploiting those resources, because their own isn't up to the job.

Indeed. And they need Western input for many things in their industries, technology sector and economy. But, with sanctions, cannot now get it.

So, to answer @CorsicaDreaming's question, I would continue exactly what is being done. Fight, and sanction. And remember that it is not actually up to us, it is up to Ukraine.

Swayingpalmtrees · 28/04/2022 18:48

theadultsaretalking You are beginning to sound a little like Angus himself, perhaps unintentionally one hopes.
Seriously, @Swayingpalmtrees , you do realise that the only way that Russia can get 'pulverised', is if there is a full-scale war between Nato and Russia

With respect, I think you are seriously underestimating the sheer volume of fire power and specialist training that is being pumped into Ukraine as we speak. Do you not think the Western leaders have considered all of the angles and realised that if they do not stop Putin somehow then Moldova, Georgia, possibly Poland etc will be next?
The idea is to pulverise the Russians to STOP the war, not to expand it.
Only today the US have committed another $33 BILLION dollars and when you combine the sum total with all the other countries around the world, you begin to see a picture emerging of a much more powerful Ukraine, one that can hold its own certainly against a weakening Russia - Ukraine have the army, a very very highly motivated army - they have an enormous amount of weapons arriving by the hour and global support, and they are on the right side of history. They have totally clear consciences. Ukraine is THEIR country. In fact I would go as far as to say the Ukrainians will stop at nothing to win, they have nothing further to lose. When we weigh this up, and consider Russia's fast depleting army, weapon arsenal and with no clear reasoned game plan - the first one has been aborted. It is possible to see quite easily that Russia may very well lose. Which is exactly why we see Putin again threatening nuclear war again - because that is all he has left, he knows this is going very badly and he is resorting to atrocities and desperation.

Russia have now exposed themselves not as a world class war machine, but a tattered, badly managed, terribly trained out of date rag tag army - a bunch of barbarians.

Ukraine has shown itself to be a strong, powerful nation with a real beating heart, that has captured the world's attention and heart. When this is all over they will benefit from their new world status for many generations to come.

OP posts:
forinborin · 28/04/2022 17:32

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 10:39

A Ukrainian perspective on the article

twitter.com/DMokryk/status/1519424770818940929

That is quite accurate and from what I can say reflects the opinion of the majority of Ukrainians.

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 16:45

Yes, one thing that Russia losing sight of sanity now has done is to provide a very strong incentive against relying on them for energy security. In the short term, this is going to be painful for those countries who previously bought Russian oil and gas. In the long term, it's going to be painful for Russia.

Note as well that many of their remaining reserves are in areas where it's more difficult to extract. They will need Western technological assistance to keep exploiting those resources, because their own isn't up to the job.

CorsicaDreaming · 28/04/2022 16:45

LemonDrizzleSlice · 28/04/2022 11:38

For those who think "peace talks" and letting Putin "save face" are the way ahead, what do you think he'll do when he's given the bit of Ukraine he insists on in any peace treaty? Do you think he will skip through the streets handing out flowers and sweeties? Or do you think he will crush all opposition, perform dreadful revenge against those who fought him, and insist all Ukrainians in the area speak Russia and submit to Russia?

Yes, it will all be lovely if we can just let Putin get what he wants so he stops. And I'm sure he won't just crack on again in a few months/years. Just like he didn't after annexing Crimea...

@LemonDrizzleSlice

Yes, hear you loud and clear. You are just restating the same points.

So what do you think would work?
What would you actually do?

LemonDrizzleSlice · 28/04/2022 16:37

We, ie the US and UK, are already in this fight. We've been preparing Ukraine for it since 2014, with hardware and military training, and we are supplying them now. More countries will now finally start supplying them as well.

And, aside from sanctions, the fact that they're happy to threaten to turn off the gas to various countries will harm them for years to come.

theadultsaretalking · 28/04/2022 16:35

LemonDrizzleSlice · 28/04/2022 16:23

We can decimate Russia's army to the degree that it would take them years to recover. Not to mention ongoing sanctions that are beginning to seriously affect its economy, which is not that strong at the best of times.

Putin's deal with his supporters in the govt and army is that he brings them strength and success. Once that stops, the deal's off, because they and the oligarchs have no personal loyalty to Putin.

'We' can, but not Ukraine alone, and if 'we' get into the fight there will be a WWIII. Economically it will be tough for Russia, but again it is very far from collapsing at the moment.

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 16:28

LemonDrizzleSlice · 28/04/2022 16:24

Also, this war has already drawn back the curtain on Russia's capabilities. No longer is it the all-powerful war machine that people were afraid of. They're on about nukes now because they've lost most of their hard power over this.

Yup.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 28/04/2022 16:24

Also, this war has already drawn back the curtain on Russia's capabilities. No longer is it the all-powerful war machine that people were afraid of. They're on about nukes now because they've lost most of their hard power over this.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 28/04/2022 16:23

theadultsaretalking · 28/04/2022 16:06

Seriously, @Swayingpalmtrees , you do realise that the only way that Russia can get 'pulverised', is if there is a full-scale war between Nato and Russia? Is that what you think we should be getting into? Everything else will require having some sort of negotiation, however unpleasant that might sound to all involved.

We can decimate Russia's army to the degree that it would take them years to recover. Not to mention ongoing sanctions that are beginning to seriously affect its economy, which is not that strong at the best of times.

Putin's deal with his supporters in the govt and army is that he brings them strength and success. Once that stops, the deal's off, because they and the oligarchs have no personal loyalty to Putin.

theadultsaretalking · 28/04/2022 16:06

Seriously, @Swayingpalmtrees , you do realise that the only way that Russia can get 'pulverised', is if there is a full-scale war between Nato and Russia? Is that what you think we should be getting into? Everything else will require having some sort of negotiation, however unpleasant that might sound to all involved.

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 11:57

LemonDrizzleSlice · 28/04/2022 11:45

Indeed @HardyBuckette . It's jolly lucky that Putin hasn't stated that the fall of the Soviet Union was a massive tragedy, isn't it? I'm sure he will stop at a little bit of Ukraine, if only we appease him with a peace treaty.

Definitely. After all, it worked in 2014.

Swayingpalmtrees · 28/04/2022 11:55

A question for people more knowledgeable than me, is agreeing to peace talks another way of giving up, ? Unless your country fights until they are completely defeated ?

I can't comment if I am more knowledgeable than the next person that is subjective, however I do know there is simply no point in holding peace talks unless both side genuinely wish to find an agreement and solution.

If we consider Ukraine has been illegally invaded, why would they give up an inch of their land to a murderous dictator if there is even a small, even tiny chance they could win the war outright?

Putin is dishonest and disingenuous player, already proved, so even if a deal was brokered do we actually believe he will abide by it? I think it would be rather naive to imagine a simple gentleman's handshake and a signature will finish this war even if Zelensky makes it out alive (poisoning being the most worrying possibility)

As unpalatable as it sounds, Putin needs his 'arse handed to him' in street speak, that is the only language he understands. Russia need to be pulverised to such a degree that it will take years to rebuild what is left the tattered and broken army - decades to recover economically and longer still for the world to trust them ever again. It is the ONLY way Europe will be safe again. The only question is can Ukraine do it with the help and support of the west?

Putin will have to deal with his battered ego at the end regardless, this was not the war he was promised. Perhaps he should book himself in for some early counselling sessions to discuss and process what humiliation feels like. I have zero time and energy for anyone that prints apologist pieces in leading newspapers hoping to chip away at UK support for Ukraine and sow discord, division and disquiet. Disappointed doesn't really cover it.

OP posts:
leadmeaway · 28/04/2022 11:54

Hawkins001 · 28/04/2022 11:33

A question for people more knowledgeable than me, is agreeing to peace talks another way of giving up, ? Unless your country fights until they are completely defeated ?

Unfortunately this situation is now as straight forward as agreeing to peace talks. Every one wants peace talks, but Putin has already stated his intentions are to removed the democratically elected government in Ukraine and insert his own people who are pro Russian, ensure Ukraine never become members of NATO and essentially become part of Russia, those are non negotiable.

Also Putin has a history or going back and breaking his agreements historically. Peace talks require both party's to find a midway point and stick to it. So for an hypothetical situation, say you were speaking for Ukraine, and you entered peace talks with some one like Putin who cannot be trusted and takes advantage as any perceived weakens, what would you be willing to give up? Would you agree live in a country with an unelected government, who was installed because your homes were bombed, families murdered and women raped and every one including children were killed en-mass. Who takes what ever they like because they threatened to destroy you, and prevents you from ever seeking protection or help from NATO.

Even if you find an agreement in peace talks, and give up every thing above. Regimes like Putin`s do not have the same values or live in a bubble like most western people, they do not see the world as you or I, most likely he will see it as a green light and proceed to do the same with other country's that is how Russia has worked in the past, bomb them into submission. Also how does that translate to other regimes in the world it shows that the west will not intervene and are weak, so it them it becomes a legitimate way to take control and land, as there are no repercussions.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 28/04/2022 11:45

Indeed @HardyBuckette . It's jolly lucky that Putin hasn't stated that the fall of the Soviet Union was a massive tragedy, isn't it? I'm sure he will stop at a little bit of Ukraine, if only we appease him with a peace treaty.

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 11:42

LemonDrizzleSlice · 28/04/2022 11:38

For those who think "peace talks" and letting Putin "save face" are the way ahead, what do you think he'll do when he's given the bit of Ukraine he insists on in any peace treaty? Do you think he will skip through the streets handing out flowers and sweeties? Or do you think he will crush all opposition, perform dreadful revenge against those who fought him, and insist all Ukrainians in the area speak Russia and submit to Russia?

Yes, it will all be lovely if we can just let Putin get what he wants so he stops. And I'm sure he won't just crack on again in a few months/years. Just like he didn't after annexing Crimea...

Yes, fortunately there aren't any other sovereign states nearby that he thinks are rightful Russian territory, and luckily we all know full well Russia will treat the occupied population beautifully in any land they occupy.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 28/04/2022 11:38

For those who think "peace talks" and letting Putin "save face" are the way ahead, what do you think he'll do when he's given the bit of Ukraine he insists on in any peace treaty? Do you think he will skip through the streets handing out flowers and sweeties? Or do you think he will crush all opposition, perform dreadful revenge against those who fought him, and insist all Ukrainians in the area speak Russia and submit to Russia?

Yes, it will all be lovely if we can just let Putin get what he wants so he stops. And I'm sure he won't just crack on again in a few months/years. Just like he didn't after annexing Crimea...

Swipe left for the next trending thread