Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guardian is publishing Russian Propaganda

309 replies

Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 15:45

AIBU to be very disappointed that the Guardian has resorted to publishing Russian propaganda. It was shocking to read, largely inaccurate and wholly from the Russian perspective. I am all for listening to all sides, but there was no effort to understand how Ukraine feels, Ukraine's objective is clearly to win the war and reclaim their nation, and blaming the western leaders for arming Ukraine and the bloodshed caused by the Russians is somewhat misleading, Ukraine have every right to defend themselves.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/apr/27/ukraine-war-end-putin-russia-talks

OP posts:
alexander2001 · 30/04/2022 07:47

Yep, Putin is thought to use the Victory celebrations to declare war... but on whom? Ukraine or NATO?

And as we've seen in the 'West, nothing like a war to galvanise public opinion on your side.

Swayingpalmtrees · 30/04/2022 06:59

There are certain facts that are without question though, so although some points are opinion - others are pure facts such as:

Russia invaded Ukraine without provocation, and are now at war with Ukraine. Russia is and has killed thousands of innocent civilian people.

Mass genocide has now been proved by all reasonable doubt and has been heavily audited by neutral observers and agencies/organisations in order to compile a war crimes case in due course.

Russia's objectives have failed - they were unable to secure and take over the whole of Ukraine as planned. They have reduced their ambitions as a result.

Russia have lost tens of thousands of soldiers. They seem prepared to continue the loss for the foreseeable future.

Most commentators on both sides agree we are now entering the most dangerous stage of the war.

OP posts:
alexander2001 · 30/04/2022 06:48

Alohaaa · 29/04/2022 17:07

How are you both so knowledgeable? This thread is really interesting and also making me feel really uninformed.

Its opinions not knowledge... no one on here knows what is really going on or what Putins aims are, let alone how the war will end.
As Hawkins said, read decent newspapers and news channels, i find R4 very informative.

Hawkins001 · 29/04/2022 20:24

Alohaaa · 29/04/2022 17:07

How are you both so knowledgeable? This thread is really interesting and also making me feel really uninformed.

Don't trust the information as gospel, in the newspapers, yes it helps give an overview, but with any military conflicts, what's happening at that time, history shows later on their was a lot more different operations ect, e.g. Operation mince meat, for example.

Alohaaa · 29/04/2022 17:07

How are you both so knowledgeable? This thread is really interesting and also making me feel really uninformed.

alexander2001 · 29/04/2022 15:26

@Swayingpalmtrees Don't really disagree of any of your last post 👏

Swayingpalmtrees · 29/04/2022 15:23

Ukraine will have to rebuild, Russia will be picking up the tab in compensation for decades to come. That will be end result.

Even a flattened country is better than NO country. In the same way countries recovered after the world wars, this will be no different. How dare Russia inflict this carnage on its neighbour is all I can say. The good news is that most of Ukraine outside the heavily bombed areas are perfectly fine and undamaged including the world heritage sites, so it is not across the board.

Ukraine has also gained an incredible amount of world status and is highly respected now. Once a back water that hardly anyone had ever heard of, it has now been catapulted into global consciousness and they have shown themselves to the most resilient, kind spirited and strong nation. I will be visiting as soon as it is safe (ish), as will millions of others to show our support and help them return to prosperity. Russia will be out in the cold for generations.

I am hopeful for Ukraine, they have much to fight for, and a wonderful country and I wish them every ounce of luck in retaining their beautiful country, and the millions that fled can return and live in safety again. It is not all lost, very far from it.

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 29/04/2022 15:15

But going back to the original article... how much of Ukraine will remain? after less than 3 months, most of the major eastern cities are flattened, 2/3rd of Ukrainian children have fled, 10m refugees - what will it look like in 3 years time?

Russia has the population, the control of the media, the raw materials to continue this war for years to come and, as you say, Ukraine the will and means to defend, indeed push back... but the aim now has shifted - its go back to the Ukrainian borders post 2014 and prosecute the entire chain of command up to and inc Putin.

Look, i never wanted this war, i ve seen the aftermath of a war and all options pre invasion had to be considered, inc no nato membership.
BUT once he invaded, gloves off all in with our support... so i'm really at a loss to why you said "you want talks now your losing" i wanted the MiGs sent, i wanted the blockade lifted and anti ship missiles sent.. long before Truss got on board.

Swayingpalmtrees · 29/04/2022 13:47

Stalemate really means an endless civil war until Russia is driven out/forced out or runs out of money/men. Ukraine can carry on to the end of time, they have nothing to lose unlike Russia, that has limited support for their 'non war'

Russia will issue a general mobilisation rather than withdraw, which means Russia will hold on to much if not all of the territory gained

You are deluded if you think Russia can successfully gain and hold on to any part of Ukraine, we have already seen this fail multiple times in the last two months.
General mobilisation is only possible once the area in question is fully under control and secure, but Russia can not achieve that with a hostile nation that are essentially looking for any way possible to eliminate the invaders. They will be constantly under attack. Russia will not even manage that in smaller areas such as the Donbas. Ukraine is not Russia, it will not capitulate - not now, not ever.

I wonder where you get the idea from that you simply move in and mobilise the area?? Russia to date have not achieved that anywhere in Ukraine so far, and for a 'lightening' invasion that was only supposed to last 48 hours I wouldn't say the odds were in Russia's favour, have you seen the state of their army?

Most wars do end with talks, but we are not witnessing most wars are we? We are dealing with a very unstable despot that is showing no sign of reasoned thinking. Most people of average intelligence have given up on the idea this war will end up like most wars. Russia needs to be beaten back, and it is as simple as that. They need to lose so badly it will take generations to recover, that is the only language Putin understands.

OP posts:
Alohaaa · 29/04/2022 13:03

What are the chances of Putin being overthrown? Also, if he dies anytime soon I wonder who they’ll have lined up to take his place?

Alexandra2001 · 29/04/2022 12:39

LemonDrizzleSlice · 29/04/2022 12:28

Most wars end with talks, its an historical fact.

Only at the point that the aggressor has no choice, because they are losing.

Or until there is stalemate?

Many experts with far more military experience than you or i, think this is the most likely outcome, a long protracted war of attrition.

Caveat being Putin dying or being overthrown, Russia pulling back, blaming everything on Putin and we ease sanctions.. BAU.

Floydthebarber · 29/04/2022 12:34

LemonDrizzleSlice · 29/04/2022 12:26

It's not propaganda, it is an opinion piece.

Ha ha ha. Do you think that propaganda has big red flags and THIS IS PROPAGANDA printed all over it? 😆Of course not. It is disseminated in opinion pieces, tweets, Facebook posts, etc etc. All under the guise of "reasonable opinion".

No but how much of The Guardian pages are devoted to pro-Ukraine. The Guardian might get a lot wrong imo (womens' rights spring to mind) but they are firmly against the war in Ukraine. They are allowed to publish pieces with slightly different views without it being Russian propaganda. News without dissenting voices becomes an echo chamber. Or perhaps you are fine with UK propaganda?

LemonDrizzleSlice · 29/04/2022 12:28

Most wars end with talks, its an historical fact.

Only at the point that the aggressor has no choice, because they are losing.

Alexandra2001 · 29/04/2022 12:26

I wondered when you might pop up. In fact I am amazed it took you so long. Of course you think talking is better, now you are losing

An all out war is most definitely the preferred route given the two options. Why? Because if we appease Putin this time (I am thinking of Crimea) he will be back next year to take Moldova, Georgia, Poland and many more, we will be simply delaying the inevitable, and giving Russia time to rebuild its army. Emboldened by his win, Putin will stop at nothing with appeasement

Firstly, MN isn't just for you & your opinions... secondly, i want nothing more than Russia to lose, Putin to die a horrible death, a severe stroke would be just deserts... and would very much like the US to open up the Black Sea....
Your opening remark is one reason i don't like the NC facility but we've crossed swords before, so no surprises.

BUT none of that is going to happen.

Anyone who prefers all out war is as crazy as Putin... lives on another planet & sounds like one of those Generals from WW1 happy to send others to their deaths.

Russia will issue a general mobilisation rather than withdraw, which means Russia will hold on to much if not all of the territory gained.

This is not 1938/9, war with Russia risks nuclear annihilation, highly unlikely at present, which why we should ignore his threats but should Russia be pushed back out of Donbass and ultimately Crimea, then all bets are off.

Most wars end with talks, its an historical fact.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 29/04/2022 12:26

It's not propaganda, it is an opinion piece.

Ha ha ha. Do you think that propaganda has big red flags and THIS IS PROPAGANDA printed all over it? 😆Of course not. It is disseminated in opinion pieces, tweets, Facebook posts, etc etc. All under the guise of "reasonable opinion".

LemonDrizzleSlice · 29/04/2022 12:19

Ukraine's democracy, I mean. Putin can't afford for his subjects to see Ukrainians enjoying a successful democray.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 29/04/2022 12:18

Alexandra2001 · 29/04/2022 11:54

@LemonDrizzleSlice Stopped reading when a PP said it wasn't about NATO but about a successful Ukraine, ignoring the fact that Finland is also on Russia's border, is highly successful and then digressed to Nuclear war and travel to Scotland.

I was replying to the article and the OP 's opinion on that its propaganda and not you... is that allowed or are you a MN moderator?

The big difference is that Finland has never been part of the Soviet Union, and did not recently overthrow a hated government (in 2014...). That is why Putin needs to shut its democracy down.

Swayingpalmtrees · 29/04/2022 12:14

You keep saying in shrill tones that that means world war with Russia alexandra

Yes, we know.

We have accepted that there is now a distinct possibility of a war with Russia, anyone can see this is a possibility of course, as Putin does not appear to have any interest whatsoever in resolving this conflict through bilateral talks. His answer is 'the time is not ripe' to world leaders when questioned why he is not involved in the peace talks.

We all know by now that Putin certainly does not want peace talks, he does not want peace full stop. He wants to blow the shit out of Ukraine and take over the country before moving onto Moldova, which is a far smaller country and easy target compared to Ukraine.

At some point the west will need to reconcile its wish to avoid war, with the reality that we may not have the choice if it comes to it. It is not quite inevitable though, if Russia retreats, and Ukraine is restored and there is an agreement around Nato positions with Russia. That is the very best case scenario now that I can see, and I would invite anyone to share their views on possible outcomes.

OP posts:
Floydthebarber · 29/04/2022 12:05

It's not propaganda, it is an opinion piece. And it does make a good point. Prolonging the war to to deplete Russia's supplies and bleed the economy dry isn't helping Ukraine. It's like when the US sat back and let the Soviet army rampage across Afghanistan. The USSR eventually ran out of money for the conflict but it destroyed Afghanistan.

Swayingpalmtrees · 29/04/2022 12:03

alexandra I wondered when you might pop up. In fact I am amazed it took you so long. Of course you think talking is better, now you are losing.

An all out war is most definitely the preferred route given the two options. Why? Because if we appease Putin this time (I am thinking of Crimea) he will be back next year to take Moldova, Georgia, Poland and many more, we will be simply delaying the inevitable, and giving Russia time to rebuild its army. Emboldened by his win, Putin will stop at nothing with appeasement. We will end up fighting a far larger war, with potentially enormous casualties if we do not deal with this now.

Clearly, Putin is not a reasonable or honest broker, and any deal he concocts is unlikely to hold anyway. We need to take a breath, and take Putin on now as we are doing, and I imagine that is the conclusion of the decision makers in the West. The mask has slipped from the true face of Russia, and yes people might not like what they see, but we have to accept the facts as they are and deal with it.

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 29/04/2022 12:01

What it actually looks like this morning, reading between the lines that NATO are perhaps expecting, although not hoping, that at some point they are going to be involved. I am shocked at the sheer numbers of NATO troops and the build up. At first I thought it was a show of strength, but looking at the aerial footage I am not so sure. Perhaps they are preparing now for Putin to take desperate measures, as it is obvious to all that Russia is now not going to win - when it finally dawns on Putin, when he finally gets the memo, we need to be ready

Russia doesn't need to win! he can wage war on Ukraine in the south and east indefinitely (or as long as he wants too)
China and India will continue trading with Russia and its a country rich in raw materials.

NATO militarily intervening means a world war with Russia, there has never been war a full on war between two nuclear countries/alliances, so whilst we have to be ready for any possibility, it also has to be remembered that the number of NATO troops in eastern europe is tiny compared to pre 1991 levels.

bumblingbovine49 · 29/04/2022 11:54

Swayingpalmtrees · 29/04/2022 10:50

What it actually looks like this morning, reading between the lines that NATO are perhaps expecting, although not hoping, that at some point they are going to be involved. I am shocked at the sheer numbers of NATO troops and the build up. At first I thought it was a show of strength, but looking at the aerial footage I am not so sure. Perhaps they are preparing now for Putin to take desperate measures, as it is obvious to all that Russia is now not going to win - when it finally dawns on Putin, when he finally gets the memo, we need to be ready.

I think you might be right about this

Alexandra2001 · 29/04/2022 11:54

@LemonDrizzleSlice Stopped reading when a PP said it wasn't about NATO but about a successful Ukraine, ignoring the fact that Finland is also on Russia's border, is highly successful and then digressed to Nuclear war and travel to Scotland.

I was replying to the article and the OP 's opinion on that its propaganda and not you... is that allowed or are you a MN moderator?

bumblingbovine49 · 29/04/2022 11:52

I think that article has some very valid points but my conclusion from the articles is that NATO has appeased Putin for too long and if I had to choose from full out war between all the NATO countries and Russia and appeasing Putin,.I'd say all out war has a better chance of success, though it is of course incredibly risky, especially if China doesn't stay neutral ( well neutralish) .

You may of course disagree that all out war would be a better long term outcome and you may be right as there are no easy answers but I'd say that there is a good argument that all out war might just defeat Putin.

So no, that article is so far away from propaganda it is laughable to call it that. It is an opinion piece and the fact that we don't seem to be able to tell the difference between that article and real propaganda goes a long way to explaining how we have such polarised opinion nowadays with no room for nuance

LemonDrizzleSlice · 29/04/2022 11:49

Alexandra2001 · 29/04/2022 11:48

Its a good article and correct.
Russian isn't going to be defeated, sanctions won't stop him mass producing shells and rockets, even if he runs out of hi tech smart missiles and if he issues a general mobilisation, he wont run out of soldiers either.

Equally Nato isn't going to intervene and risk a wider conflict, nato/us wont even lift the Black sea blockade, which probably the most risk free thing they could do.

Former US and Nato Generals are saying this war will go on for years, how much of Ukraine will be left and how will Europe integrate 30 plus million traumatised refugees? the UK has taken just 17k.

So ultimately, the only way to end the war is by talking.

Have you read any of this thread?