Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guardian is publishing Russian Propaganda

309 replies

Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 15:45

AIBU to be very disappointed that the Guardian has resorted to publishing Russian propaganda. It was shocking to read, largely inaccurate and wholly from the Russian perspective. I am all for listening to all sides, but there was no effort to understand how Ukraine feels, Ukraine's objective is clearly to win the war and reclaim their nation, and blaming the western leaders for arming Ukraine and the bloodshed caused by the Russians is somewhat misleading, Ukraine have every right to defend themselves.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/apr/27/ukraine-war-end-putin-russia-talks

OP posts:
HardyBuckette · 04/05/2022 06:58

None of your post is really filling in any gaps @Alexandra2001. I mean, nobody thinks the Russian state will be completely without resources or money. These facts still don't tell us how this rearmament process is going to take place to the extent that it allows Russia to be as successful as you have claimed it will.

Do you think Russia will be buying from elsewhere, or making their own? If the former, presumably you understand that unlike Ukraine, this isn't likely to be any of the best stuff. The West won't, and the Chinese so far have been disinclined to help much, which is interesting in itself.

If the latter, how will this be achieved to a sufficiently high standard given the constraints of sanctions (note, the fact that Russia are still receiving money doesn't mean there is no impact) the increasing desire for energy security of most of the countries where they're actually able to transport their energy to, their lack of access to Western technology and talent plus the brain drain and probably most importantly, how will it be paid for in a manner that keeps enough of the Russian population onside? Are they going to cooperate sufficiently with a war footing? Then after this, how are the massive ongoing structural problems in the army going to be mitigated, particularly when they're quite literally haemmhoraging generals? Because you have to do more than just keep the frequently poor quality weapons coming. These are the sort of things you need to have answers to when you're talking about Russia being able to keep going for the long term as a fact.

It's on my list @FatherBuzzCagney! Agree the Donbass offensive isn't currently working for Russia. Which is another vital point.

FatherBuzzCagney · 03/05/2022 23:14

HardyBuckette · 03/05/2022 20:29

Thank you.

And honestly, I'd be open to explanations as to how any of this Russian rearmament is going to work, given all the constraints they'll be operating under, but all we get is vague assumptions.

Not sure how high your tolerance is for nerdy war stuff, but Michael Kofman's War on the Rocks podcast of a couple of days ago is excellent on the multiple challenges to the Russian army and why he thinks the Donbas offensive is Russia's last chance for an offensive operation in this war - but one they are currently failing to make work. Everything he says is very sensible.

Alexandra2001 · 03/05/2022 23:12

HardyBuckette · 03/05/2022 20:29

Thank you.

And honestly, I'd be open to explanations as to how any of this Russian rearmament is going to work, given all the constraints they'll be operating under, but all we get is vague assumptions.

We are still sending billions in USD to Russia, much of the world isn't sanctioning Russia, either in banking or in materials.
The UK has given Russia £220 million in the last 3 months in oil alone.

Russia still holds much of the East and south of Ukraine, will soon have a land corridor to Crimea, holds the Black Sea...

Much of the RoW has no intention of sanctioning Russia.

So i don't really understand why you think Russia will not be able to produce weapons for years to come?

Take your point on the separatists but also bare in mind, many of these were Russian military.

Hawkins001 · 03/05/2022 23:12

LaburnumAlpine · 03/05/2022 22:55

Gotcha!

без какашек шерлока, вы желаете

LaburnumAlpine · 03/05/2022 22:55

Gotcha!

Thereisnolight · 03/05/2022 21:55

Current war aside….All this Oxford smugness about backing arguments up with facts and evidence is all very well provided the facts are not lies. Lots of “facts” are actually lies. Or errors. Errors (and even lies) happen in medicine and science, which strive to be meticulous and unbiased, so I think it’s safe to assume they happen in politics and war which are often nothing of the sort.

Hawkins001 · 03/05/2022 20:37

LaburnumAlpine · 03/05/2022 20:33

Hawkins, your syntax is much too akin to direct Russian translation to English. I wonder why.

так ли это на самом деле

LaburnumAlpine · 03/05/2022 20:33

Hawkins, your syntax is much too akin to direct Russian translation to English. I wonder why.

HardyBuckette · 03/05/2022 20:29

LemonDrizzleSlice · 03/05/2022 20:11

What a great explanation @HardyBuckette. A lot of people still seem to be in total awe of supposed Russian military might, when the last few months have shown that to be a mirage.

Thank you.

And honestly, I'd be open to explanations as to how any of this Russian rearmament is going to work, given all the constraints they'll be operating under, but all we get is vague assumptions.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 03/05/2022 20:11

What a great explanation @HardyBuckette. A lot of people still seem to be in total awe of supposed Russian military might, when the last few months have shown that to be a mirage.

HardyBuckette · 03/05/2022 20:08

Alexandra2001 · 03/05/2022 19:49

That article is complete bollocks and coming from a very unrealistic position of a naïve perspective. So basically the author is saying its easier and less destructive to just bend over and say to Putin okay if you have a cease fire, we will grit our teeth and discuss the possibility of Russia taking any thing they want as long as the oppressed guaranteed to stop defending it

But he isn't just saying that, he he also saying an alternative would be for NATO to intervene.
The fact remains, however unpalatable, is that Russia has the means to keep this war going for as long as it likes, even if Russia was pushed out of Ukraine, they can still fire cruise missiles from '000s of km's away, launch insurgent attacks and support separatist armies.

Russia has so much of the worlds raw materials and if its not the 'west, plenty of other countries will trade with Russia, that gives them the ability to rearm and there is nothing we can do about that.

As far as i could see (having re read the article) this is basically what he is saying....what do we then do?

The word 'fact' is taking some abuse here.

Nobody has yet been able to explain to us how exactly the Russians are going to rearm. Yes, they've got lots of raw materials, some of which are difficult to access and require Western tech (not Chinese) to access. They're going to need more than that. How is this going to be accomplished in the face of the sanctions? Remember they'll need to do more than simply acquire a few weapons here and there.

There's also the issue Russia face with soldiers and the army culture generally. They do have a bigger population than Ukraine, it's true. They also have to contend with already massive losses and they're currently losing a general about once a week. That sort of expertise is not quickly replaced. Conscription was already something that Russians with options sought to evade, in no small part because of the horrific hazing systems. The prospect of dying in Ukraine is not going to make that any better. And they have a fossilised, Soviet era military culture plus a massive theft problem in the army. Morale is low, which is all bound up with the failure to look after their equipment and do things like routine tank tyre maintenance. Again we're talking about a significant military culture change that would be necessary. Where's this coming from?

Actual defence experts, people whose understanding of the Russian military goes well beyond Roxburgh's, have provided very detailed analysis on Russia's problems here. I linked to some upthread. It's not as simple as got lots of people and lots of resources so no problem.

On the separatist armies point, those look like rather less of a threat than they did before the invasion. Because the Russian invaders have treated Russian speakers and ethnic Russians badly too. There are Ukrainian politicians who were previously pro Russian who are now, well, not so much. So these armies would have to actually exist before they could be armed, which becomes less likely when you've been stupid and venal enough to commit a shitload of war crimes.

Basically, if people want to argue that it's inevitable that Russia will be able to keep an actual war going to the extent that the West's current tactics are doomed to fail, they're going to need to do a better job at explaining how. Roxburgh didn't, and neither has anyone in this thread who agrees with him.

Hawkins001 · 03/05/2022 20:08

LemonDrizzleSlice · 03/05/2022 19:48

Because it's nice for a change to wonder more and be more flowing with the thinking aspects, rather than bolting all the view points with hard evidence to back up each point

English as she is spoke

Mark Twain said of English as She Is Spoke that "Nobody can add to the absurdity of this book, nobody can imitate it successfully, nobody can hope to produce its fellow; it is perfect."

Alexandra2001 · 03/05/2022 19:49

That article is complete bollocks and coming from a very unrealistic position of a naïve perspective. So basically the author is saying its easier and less destructive to just bend over and say to Putin okay if you have a cease fire, we will grit our teeth and discuss the possibility of Russia taking any thing they want as long as the oppressed guaranteed to stop defending it

But he isn't just saying that, he he also saying an alternative would be for NATO to intervene.
The fact remains, however unpalatable, is that Russia has the means to keep this war going for as long as it likes, even if Russia was pushed out of Ukraine, they can still fire cruise missiles from '000s of km's away, launch insurgent attacks and support separatist armies.

Russia has so much of the worlds raw materials and if its not the 'west, plenty of other countries will trade with Russia, that gives them the ability to rearm and there is nothing we can do about that.

As far as i could see (having re read the article) this is basically what he is saying....what do we then do?

LemonDrizzleSlice · 03/05/2022 19:48

Because it's nice for a change to wonder more and be more flowing with the thinking aspects, rather than bolting all the view points with hard evidence to back up each point

English as she is spoke

Hawkins001 · 03/05/2022 19:47

Besides unless your in the know on various intelligence aspects of various operations and missions etc, you can only guess possible strategies based on similar operations carried out in previous wars, and trying to sell that idea to an Oxford tutor would Certainly be untenable.

Hawkins001 · 03/05/2022 19:45

FatherBuzzCagney · 03/05/2022 19:41

You're right in the sense that if you had been someone with a degree from Oxford it certainly wouldn't be an indicator of superior intelligence - after all, Jacob Rees Mogg and Louise Mensch both have Oxford degrees - but it would have given you a pretty rigorous training in evidence-based argumentation. It's the complete opposite of the "hey, maybe the Ukrainians started the war themselves, who knows, just asking questions" Russia Today style.

Because it's nice for a change to wonder more and be more flowing with the thinking aspects, rather than bolting all the view points with hard evidence to back up each point,

FatherBuzzCagney · 03/05/2022 19:41

You're right in the sense that if you had been someone with a degree from Oxford it certainly wouldn't be an indicator of superior intelligence - after all, Jacob Rees Mogg and Louise Mensch both have Oxford degrees - but it would have given you a pretty rigorous training in evidence-based argumentation. It's the complete opposite of the "hey, maybe the Ukrainians started the war themselves, who knows, just asking questions" Russia Today style.

Hawkins001 · 03/05/2022 19:30

FatherBuzzCagney · 03/05/2022 19:21

At Oxford, it was the who, what, why, when, and how approach when learning about various topics and subjects that was taught to help when researching.

Are you trying to imply you have a degree from Oxford University? Just come out and say it if you have, that's what actual Oxford graduates do 😂Doubt it will impress anyone, but you can give it a crack.

Not that it's relevant - but that "just asking questions, nudge nudge wink wink" approach really isn't how academic debate or research is conducted at Oxford or anywhere else. Anyone who tries it (mediocre undergrads IME) normally gets told to put up or shut up pretty fast.

In the tutorial system you have to have to defend your perspectives and analysis rather than just think therefore it is, I would never brag about an Oxford degree, because at the end of the day, it would not make me any better, we all have different perspectives, different knowledge, different education, etc,

FatherBuzzCagney · 03/05/2022 19:21

At Oxford, it was the who, what, why, when, and how approach when learning about various topics and subjects that was taught to help when researching.

Are you trying to imply you have a degree from Oxford University? Just come out and say it if you have, that's what actual Oxford graduates do 😂Doubt it will impress anyone, but you can give it a crack.

Not that it's relevant - but that "just asking questions, nudge nudge wink wink" approach really isn't how academic debate or research is conducted at Oxford or anywhere else. Anyone who tries it (mediocre undergrads IME) normally gets told to put up or shut up pretty fast.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 03/05/2022 19:20

2bazookas · 03/05/2022 19:08

Perhaps you forgot to read the first paragraph.

The one where the author starts with a bit of negativity towards Russia in order for us to realise how reasonable he is being later when he says Ukraine should roll over?

Yes, that cannot possibly be propaganda!

LemonDrizzleSlice · 03/05/2022 19:19

IvorCutler · 03/05/2022 19:07

It’s clearly an opinion piece.

And so of course cannot possibly be propaganda! Because propaganda is clearly labelled as such.

Hawkins001 · 03/05/2022 19:11

FatherBuzzCagney · 03/05/2022 19:06

Not saying any of those events you listed are False flags, but until the intelligence services released the files of all information pertaining to those events, then there would always be some margin of speculation.

None of the actual or attempted murders were false flags. Russian interference in the 2016 US presidential election was not a false flag.

One thing that was very possibly a false flag was the sequence of apartment block bombings in Russia in 1999 that killed hundreds of Russians, was blamed on the Chechens (but was the only terrorist action I'm aware of that they denied), and which played a significant role in the re-starting of the Chechen war and Putin's landslide first election victory. That's widely thought to have been the work of the FSB.

No idea whether you're Russian or not @Hawkins001 , and really don't care, but your wide-eyed "just asking some innocent questions" line is strikingly similar to the approach of RT and other Russian disinformation sources.

At Oxford, it was the who, what, why, when, and how approach when learning about various topics and subjects that was taught to help when researching.

2bazookas · 03/05/2022 19:08

Perhaps you forgot to read the first paragraph.

IvorCutler · 03/05/2022 19:07

It’s clearly an opinion piece.

FatherBuzzCagney · 03/05/2022 19:06

Not saying any of those events you listed are False flags, but until the intelligence services released the files of all information pertaining to those events, then there would always be some margin of speculation.

None of the actual or attempted murders were false flags. Russian interference in the 2016 US presidential election was not a false flag.

One thing that was very possibly a false flag was the sequence of apartment block bombings in Russia in 1999 that killed hundreds of Russians, was blamed on the Chechens (but was the only terrorist action I'm aware of that they denied), and which played a significant role in the re-starting of the Chechen war and Putin's landslide first election victory. That's widely thought to have been the work of the FSB.

No idea whether you're Russian or not @Hawkins001 , and really don't care, but your wide-eyed "just asking some innocent questions" line is strikingly similar to the approach of RT and other Russian disinformation sources.