Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guardian is publishing Russian Propaganda

309 replies

Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 15:45

AIBU to be very disappointed that the Guardian has resorted to publishing Russian propaganda. It was shocking to read, largely inaccurate and wholly from the Russian perspective. I am all for listening to all sides, but there was no effort to understand how Ukraine feels, Ukraine's objective is clearly to win the war and reclaim their nation, and blaming the western leaders for arming Ukraine and the bloodshed caused by the Russians is somewhat misleading, Ukraine have every right to defend themselves.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/apr/27/ukraine-war-end-putin-russia-talks

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 04/05/2022 19:12

As far as i can tell, Russia is surviving Ukrainian attacks Russia need to be doing much more than merely surviving to have any hope of even a small and successful advance anywhere in Ukraine. I don't actually think they will hold out for very much longer, which is why almost certainly Putin will announce an all out war, and call up every man/cannon fodder he can get his dirty hands on. I genuinely feel sorry for the Russian mothers, who stand to lose all of their children before they are forced out of Ukraine. He will sell this as patriotism and it is nothing short of planned genocide using his own people.

I do understand the arguments that NATO should get more involved There is no need for NATO to get involved. Ukraine are doing an outstanding job without the alliance, and seem to understand the issues of escalation. Quite rightly the west are now arming Ukraine with everything they have asked for, making the war much easier to win.
Of course they can not lose now whatever happens, it is their country, and like most people they will fight to the death to keep it. Russia would need millions of soldiers to take over and control a country the size of Ukraine with a very hostile nation.
I am not even sure they have the appetite now. Many conscripts do not even understand why they are even there. Far from being the 'great war' this is looking like a global embarrassment and a shambles. Putin's great hero is Peter the Great. I imagine this is Putin's legacy to finally defeat the west, show the world NATO is a weakened and irrelevant alliance and bring the USSR back to life. It all looked quite simple when he was reading the books in lockdown.....

OP posts:
HardyBuckette · 04/05/2022 17:09

@FatherBuzzCagney excellent posts are doing a much better job than I was of explaining why the contention that Russia are just going to be able to carry on like this at leisure is such a shaky one, and certainly isn't anything close to a fact as has been claimed in this thread. They don't have the goods, in any sense of the term. Nobody has yet been able to explain where they're going to come from either.

I do understand the arguments that NATO should get more involved @Alexandra2001 , some of which are made in good faith. However, that's not on the cards at the moment: which isn't to say it won't happen in the future, but for now it's not likely. Roxburgh also knows this. He knows that the actual choices on the menu at the moment are between the West arguing the Ukrainians in order to allow them the opportunity to liberate themselves, or to not do that.

So when he says the West should either take an option that he knows isn't going to be chosen (and that let's be honest, nothing he's done in the past suggests he actually wants) or stop arming Ukraine, it's actually an argument to stop arming Ukraine. And he's hidden it behind claims about the Russian military that have been widely condemned by people who actually understand that field. It's a disingenuous bullshitting exercise.

FatherBuzzCagney · 04/05/2022 15:36

Alexandra2001 · 04/05/2022 14:14

@FatherBuzzCagney I hope your analysis is correct.

Most of the things I said are in the public domain and not contested.

The estimate of Russian active personnel is from the Military Balance, published by the International Institute of Strategic Studies, and widely recognised as an (maybe the) authoritative source on states' military capabilities.

The figure of 190K for the pre-war build-up of Russian troops around Ukraine was in the public domain for at least a couple of weeks before the start of the war.

That Russia has been pulling troops out of places like South Ossetia and redeploying troops from remote military districts inside Russia is a matter of public record. It's not doing this - or appealing for Syrian mercenaries, or advertising on Russian public transport offering high wages for short term military contracts - on a whim, it's doing these things because they are short of men to fight in Ukraine.

The US has pledged over $3bn of military aid to Ukraine just since the start of the war (had already given it a huge amount before the war) and much of that seems to have been delivered. US military aid to Ukraine is now equivalent to something like 2/3rds of Ukraine's 2021 military budget. Biden has asked Congress for another $20bn of military aid for Ukraine. If it's approved, US military aid to Ukraine will have been over a third of Russia's total military budget for last year.

Bear in mind that Russia's military budget has to cover everything from nukes to their bases in the Arctic to rations for conscripts doing military service inside Russia, plus the sums making their way into senior officers' bank accounts, so most of it isn't available for the Ukraine war. And, of course, they'll have to find the equivalent of many hundreds of millions, or billions, of dollars to replace tanks, helicopters, fighter jets and the warship lost in Ukraine, so they'll have to hugely increase spending in these areas just to get back to where they were at the start of the war.

Tl;dr Russia is losing trained personnel faster than it can replace them and will not be able to compete with US military aid to Ukraine. These are two of the many reasons why Russia almost certainly cannot win in Ukraine.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 04/05/2022 15:36

As other PPs have said, and as military commentators have said, bombing Syria to fuck is very different from occupying a country. Occupying a country that doesn't want to be occupied takes many more soldiers than just attacking that country. And you have to keep occupying it for years, taking up all your military.

Alexandra2001 · 04/05/2022 14:14

@FatherBuzzCagney I hope your analysis is correct.

Alexandra2001 · 04/05/2022 14:12

@HardyBuckette I specifically said Russia has the ability to manufacture non smart weapons pretty much forever and that it can use them to prosecute this war for many years.
The tech Russia has used to access its raw materials is still there and whilst you are correct that Russia is heavily sanctioned, i do not think outside of the US/Europe, the sanctions are anything what you suggest... Yes China has said it wont supply weapons but what about technology?
Russia also managed to get out its raw materials in Soviet era.

I thought we were talking about Ukraine/Russia conflict, so when i said "collapse" i meant Russia being quickly defeated...not a re run of the late 80s early 90s... apologies' for not making that clear.

As far as i can tell, Russia is surviving Ukrainian attacks and is moving to limit/stop the supply of western munitions from the west to the east, there is only so much that can be transported by road and the Russians seem to be going for the 'rail network now.

I want the 'West (this would be the US Navy) to lift the BlackSea blockade, if we are really serious about defeating Putin and seeing a free Ukraine, then this is urgently required, appreciate the Turkish angle but surely we cannot allow the crippling of Ukraines economy and the constant shelling of the south of the country/longer range cruise strikes to continue?

FatherBuzzCagney · 04/05/2022 12:29

Putin has barely used his armed forces- his military power is vast and, if he unleashes it, it could be catastrophic.

This is not correct. To conquer and hold cities, you need to win a ground war. That requires troops on the ground, not the kind of bomb the place to rubble and fuck off home approach of the Russian forces in Syria. So you need lots and lots of well-trained, well-equipped troops.

The Russian armed forces have around 900K active personnel. Around 190K of them - more than 20% of the total armed forces - were involved in the initial invasion. Many of them were the highest quality end of the armed forces, e.g. paratroop regiments, though there also seem to have been a lot of totally unsuitable conscript troops. Everyone - elite forces and conscripts - took an absolute hammering in the first phase of the war. The Russians have been redeploying from places like the Eastern Military District and Russian-occupied South Ossetia in Georgia, but still seem to be short of troops - the Pentagon assesses that they're still not up to their anticipated strength in Donbas, despite several weeks of the much-touted 'phase 2' of the war.

Many of the approx. 700K (probably less now) active personnel not already committed are not frontline troops. We've already seen the consequences of putting non-frontline troops into frontline positions (goes about as well as you'd expect).

Even in a war, Russia can't just try to put all its troops into Ukraine. It has ongoing interests elsewhere that need defending and it needs to keep a lot of men and equipment for the defence of Russia itself. Putin tried and failed to push Belarus and other Collective Security Treaty Organisation states into committing troops. Sooner rather than later Russia is going to be at the outer limit of its capacity to reinforce troops in Ukraine from active personnel elsewhere.

So then the next stage is to move to reserves, of which there are many, and beyond that to a call-up of other fighting-age men. But it takes time to get reserves up to speed and much longer (months) to make conscripts ready to go into battle.

Meanwhile, the remaining professional forces in Ukraine are being ground further down and more Russian equipment is being either destroyed or captured. A few weeks ago, the Pentagon estimated that the Ukrainians had more tanks than they began the war with, because they'd taken so many off the Russians.

Russia's ability to quickly replace men and equipment is degrading. Ukraine is not getting troops from NATO but they're on the receiving end of staggering levels of military aid from the US. Russia simply has no capacity to compete with that.

HardyBuckette · 04/05/2022 12:22

It does sound a bit like the Darth Putin twitter account, doesn't it? This was all part of a grand plan, I remain a master strategist.

I can quite understand feeling a bit sick at Boris getting the opportunity to do his Churchill impersonation, particularly given that he's been happy enough to benefit from Russian influence when it suited him. But him leveraging as much political benefit as he can from the situation is not very important in the grand scheme of things. The UK isn't acting alone, we're acting as part of a large and powerful group of nations. Now I doubt we'd be capable of successfully invading Ukraine in the face of widespread opposition, sanctions and sanction observance from nearly all the global economy and extensive weapon supply from the rest of the West, any more than Russia have been. But unlike them, we weren't that fucking stupid.

LaburnumAlpine · 04/05/2022 12:05

@LuluBlackey your post is wishful thinking at best and strangely degrading towards UK and Europe. Degrading them vehemently and emotionally enough to make me ask - why? Your statement is not factually correct but seems to be the hill you'll die on.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 04/05/2022 12:00

Power now resides in China, Russia and the US.

Russia has a smaller economy than most European countries, where's all this power going to come from once they've pulled their fingers out and stopped buying Russia's oil and gas?

Russia maybe had some proxy power via China, but China's distancing themselves now their economy is struggling and they don't need to be tarnished by Russia.

As for the UK being "done" and "tiny" - we're the fifth largest economy in the world. We're a permanent member of the UN Security Council. We're one of five members of the Five Eyes group. We're one of only three nuclear powers in NATO. We're only of only five established nuclear powers in the world. These are not opinions, they're facts.

theadultsaretalking · 04/05/2022 11:29

Swayingpalmtrees · 04/05/2022 09:46

Putin has barely used his armed forces- his military power is vast and, if he unleashes it, it could be catastrophic

So are you honestly saying Putin is suffering the terrible humiliation of his army being forced out and to the East, tens of thousands of deaths of young Russians if he has some mighty power yet to be unleashed?? Pull the other one! It might have bells on.

While not disagreeing with the above, I think there is a lot of misunderstanding in the West about the ability of Russia and its people to a) withstand hardships - the country is built on suffering, so tightening up belts is nothing new for its population - hence this can go on for longer than anticipated and b) the technological progress the country has made recently - while there is a lot of rural poverty and financial inequality in the country, the educational standards there are pretty good and it is not quite such a backwards place many in the West imagine.

Again, I am definitely not saying that Russia can win this war, only that this will potentially last longer than we think. We may well end up in a situation of stalemate unless NATO interferes directly.

Swayingpalmtrees · 04/05/2022 11:21

Exactly that is it in a nutshell hardy this has been an unmitigated disaster on an epic scale for Russia.
Sweden and Finland will join NATO in the next few days, which has caused fury in Russia but what did they expect? All countries have now pledged to pay much more for defence now this has happened, emboldening NATO even more. Every country can now see clearly as we watch the terrible genocide unfold in Bucha the importance of deterrence and NATO. Russia have in fact served up the most perfect visually compelling reason why the post war alliances are so very important. Every single person in the west has witnessed the horror of the unfolding war in Ukraine, and as a result the invigoration of commitment to defend democracy at all costs now replaces the lethargic indifference we felt before. At no other time has a civilisation been woken up from their cosy feelings of stability to understand the threat we are all now living with, were living with all along ....and we can no longer sit idly by and assume our free world will stay free. We can't afford another moment of complacency.

That does not stop at Russia, a full reassessment will be taking place regarding China, Iran and NK and all the rest. Our eyes were forced open when we watched the blood bath in Ukraine, and Russia will not recover from this terrible act of evil for generations, if ever.

To say this has backfired for Russia is an understatement. There is no coming back from this, no matter what they do next. There is no way to win this war.

The very best thing they can do now, is gently pull back and return to Russia, Putin should retire and the next leader will have to move heaven and earth to convince the rest of the world that changes, real changes can and will be made. Compensation paid to Ukraine and peace agreements made between the two countries. There is a peaceful exit, but I expect Putin is too proud and full of ego to take it.

OP posts:
HardyBuckette · 04/05/2022 10:23

Swayingpalmtrees · 04/05/2022 09:48

it's no wonder the Chinese aren't up for doing much to help Russia

China does not need any further PR disasters after covid. I am sure Russia is not the attractive junior partner it once was...its all rather tarnished now with incompetence.

Oh yeah, there's having to be a rethink now. The mighty Russian war machine was supposed to leave NATO on the back foot and be another blow to the West. Instead they've managed to strengthen Western interests and unity, probably enlarge NATO, get Europe and North America closer to singing from the same hymn sheet than they have been in yonks and the Chinese have been obliged to observe sanctions in return for a quiet life. To say nothing of what the Taiwanese are going to think of all this. President Xi Jinping must be equal parts embarrassed and furious.

Swayingpalmtrees · 04/05/2022 09:48

it's no wonder the Chinese aren't up for doing much to help Russia

China does not need any further PR disasters after covid. I am sure Russia is not the attractive junior partner it once was...its all rather tarnished now with incompetence.

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 04/05/2022 09:46

Putin has barely used his armed forces- his military power is vast and, if he unleashes it, it could be catastrophic

So are you honestly saying Putin is suffering the terrible humiliation of his army being forced out and to the East, tens of thousands of deaths of young Russians if he has some mighty power yet to be unleashed?? Pull the other one! It might have bells on.

OP posts:
LuluBlakey1 · 04/05/2022 09:30

I think the writer is right. Russia followed this plan in Syria, he annihilated cities, ground them down with ongoing barrage assaults over months until they were decimated and helpless with every bit of infrastructure destroyed and hundreds of thousands killed. Putin has barely used his armed forces- his military power is vast and, if he unleashes it, it could be catastrophic.
I don't think Nato starting a huge war is the answer - Putin would use nuclear weapons if they did.
I don't know what the answer is but what is happening at the moment is pointless. Ukraine can not win. This is simply a stage in a plan of attack by Putin.

Johnson is determined to create an image of himself as some sort of international statesman/leader from this.Sending hundreds of millions in weapons, appearing in Kyiv. It is all pointless, jostling for a position of i portance on a world stage.

The truth is Britain is done- we are insignificant on the world stage. We are a tiny country, with no resources or significant industry or land or military reserves, whose time on the world stage was 100-200 years ago. Power now resides in China, Russia and the US. Europe and Britain are finished as big powers. If the US left Nato, Russia would be uninterested in Europe once we were no military threat.He is not interested in our culture and would not want most of Europe as part if Russia - although he might want some of o.d parys of the USSR back to give him a 'buffer'.

HardyBuckette · 04/05/2022 09:27

Putin has totally overplayed his hand (and some) and is now in deep shit, in a lose lose situation, worse still the world can now see that the second rate Russian army is twenty years out of date of very limited means and capability and certainly no match for NATO. On reflection this has now taken the 'fear' factor out of the equation about any future conflict

Yup. Relatedly, it's no wonder the Chinese aren't up for doing much to help Russia get out of the hole they've dug themselves.

Swayingpalmtrees · 04/05/2022 09:22

I am sorry to say but the worst is yet to come for Russia, in terms of the economical hit that is coming.

Putin has badly miscalculated the global response to his illegal invasion, he assumed he would be in Kyiv by day three, and it would be 'lightening quick' invasion and the west would have no time to respond.
Betting on a sloth like response from the EU, a weak Nato hands off approach and the same lack of interest when he did the dummy run with Crimea - he did not foresee or plan for a stalemate war that would last for years, maybe decades with the whole world sanctioning the shit out of Russia and a rush to supply world class weapons from around the world, along with military, financial and humanitarian aid for Ukraine.
Putin has totally overplayed his hand (and some) and is now in deep shit, in a lose lose situation, worse still the world can now see that the second rate Russian army is twenty years out of date of very limited means and capability and certainly no match for NATO. On reflection this has now taken the 'fear' factor out of the equation about any future conflict, hence we now see Putin playing his last card - nuclear threats. It is very telling he has resorted so quickly to that....it is a pure acknowledgment that he can't win any other way....

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 04/05/2022 09:21

I am sorry to say but the worst is yet to come for Russia, in terms of the economical hit that is coming.

Putin has badly miscalculated the global response to his illegal invasion, he assumed he would be in Kyiv by day three, and it would be 'lightening quick' invasion and the west would have no time to respond.
Betting on a sloth like response from the EU, a weak Nato hands off approach and the same lack of interest when he did the dummy run with Crimea - he did not foresee or plan for a stalemate war that would last for years, maybe decades with the whole world sanctioning the shit out of Russia and a rush to supply world class weapons from around the world, along with military, financial and humanitarian aid for Ukraine.
Putin has totally overplayed his hand (and some) and is now in deep shit, in a lose lose situation, worse still the world can now see that the second rate Russian army is twenty years out of date of very limited means and capability and certainly no match for NATO. On reflection this has now taken the 'fear' factor out of the equation about any future conflict, hence we now see Putin playing his last card - nuclear threats. It is very telling he has resorted so quickly to that....it is a pure acknowledgment that he can't win any other way....

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 04/05/2022 09:12

There is an excellent assessment of the war to date in the Telegraph this morning alex which basically sums up the situation that Russia are failing to make any headway whatsoever in the East or South. The military have issues with supply of weapons, food, tanks that are stranded in the mud so are having to use roads which is dangerous. Soldiers that were not rested are now appearing very fatigued, morale has hit rock bottom and there is no end in sight.

My guess is that Russia may try and reinvigorate their efforts on Victory day - but it is unlikely to change anything on the ground.

Most experts do believe Russia's invasion efforts are certainly on the brink of collapse - yes. They did not plan for a war to last for months. All bets are off.
The economy in Russia is on life support, they just made the repayments to avoid a default, but without access to their reserves due to sanctions it is a matter of time.
This is going to worsen for Russia by the day - medical supplies have run out/running out, many areas of Russia do not have basic supplies or access to banking and this is just the start....

OP posts:
HardyBuckette · 04/05/2022 09:08

Alexandra2001 · 04/05/2022 08:37

@HardyBuckette ...you like to put words in my mouth, i'll concede that!

Quote where i said Russia will import hi tech weapons? i was referring to the Hi Tech you claimed Russia needed to access these raw materials.... Do you really think Russia has no industry of it 's own?

No, i don't think the 'West or anyone else will put its own economic instability ahead of trade with Russia, we never have done that before with any other country...
Even now, we keep buying Russian oil and gas... our economies matter more to us and the RoW will buy their raw materials and in return sell them the imports they need, as they are doing so at present.

The UK and EU are saying oil imports will stop by the end of the year... gas? yet to be decided on.... not great is it? no word on the range of other raw materials the 'west import from Russia.

On evidence, neither of us can supply that, we can only look at the situation on the ground, its fluid, has and will change but most military experts do not believe Russia is on the brink of collapse as you appear to do.

This is still all very vague. I'd like to avoid putting words into your mouth, so tell me if I'm being clear here: you think Russia will be able to domestically manufacture all the necessary high teach weaponry to achieve a stalemate with a country currently being supplied with Western arms, by themselves? If that's not what you mean and I've misunderstood, I'd appreciate clarification, and if it is what you mean then how?

Re Russia having their own industry: you're conflating the existence of industry with the ability to obtain or create the necessary technology to get at very difficult to access raw materials. Russia is currently reliant on the West for this expertise and tech, we know that. Are you saying this is going to change, and if so, how will that happen?

In terms of the economy, around 60% of the global economy currently belongs to the countries sanctioning Russia, and a good chunk of the rest is the Chinese who are observant of sanctions. Nobody thinks some of the rest of the planet, who aren't a monolithic bloc, won't trade with them at all, particularly not the sort of trade that doesn't involve going against the US and Europe on sanctions. The question is how Russia are going to be able to weather the economic damage we know has happened and is still happening, whilst also being able to continue this very damaging war. You argue that sanctions will eventually be seen as damaging to the West, but that completely ignores the fact that energy and economic security are both part of that picture and both threatened by reliance on Russia. It's also simply a prediction, so again doesn't tell us why you're using the term 'fact'.

As for putting words into mouths, who said anything about Russia being on the brink of collapse? That's a strawman. There's a vast gulf between ceasing to function and being able to sustain a lengthy and costly stalemate war. You claimed the latter to be a fact, and you've still not evidenced this.

Alexandra2001 · 04/05/2022 08:37

@HardyBuckette ...you like to put words in my mouth, i'll concede that!

Quote where i said Russia will import hi tech weapons? i was referring to the Hi Tech you claimed Russia needed to access these raw materials.... Do you really think Russia has no industry of it 's own?

No, i don't think the 'West or anyone else will put its own economic instability ahead of trade with Russia, we never have done that before with any other country...
Even now, we keep buying Russian oil and gas... our economies matter more to us and the RoW will buy their raw materials and in return sell them the imports they need, as they are doing so at present.

The UK and EU are saying oil imports will stop by the end of the year... gas? yet to be decided on.... not great is it? no word on the range of other raw materials the 'west import from Russia.

On evidence, neither of us can supply that, we can only look at the situation on the ground, its fluid, has and will change but most military experts do not believe Russia is on the brink of collapse as you appear to do.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 04/05/2022 08:20

FatherBuzzCagney · 03/05/2022 23:14

Not sure how high your tolerance is for nerdy war stuff, but Michael Kofman's War on the Rocks podcast of a couple of days ago is excellent on the multiple challenges to the Russian army and why he thinks the Donbas offensive is Russia's last chance for an offensive operation in this war - but one they are currently failing to make work. Everything he says is very sensible.

Sounds interesting! I'll have a listen. Thanks.

HardyBuckette · 04/05/2022 08:16

Alexandra2001 · 04/05/2022 07:59

@HardyBuckette I never said Russia would be successful! what i am saying is Russia has the means to continue this war for years to come & will replace the military that it it has lost.

Russia doesn't need hi tech precision weapons either but i strongly suspect they will find a way to produce these, probably in lower numbers but they do have the means to make unlimited numbers of non smart weapons.

The 'West isn't the only supplier of hi tech and no one really knows what China/RoW will do in the future or if Western countries will continue sanctions as the cost of living continues to spiral, to meet the 2030 target etc of no more fossil fueled cars, we need raw materials from Russia or pay far more as prices rise, taking the tech even further out of reach.

I want nothing more than Putin/Russia to be defeated and the rebuilding of Ukraine but right now, i just don't see that happening ... maybe in the future the signs will be more positive but i think we are heading for a long war of attrition/stalemate.... all this assumes Putin doesn't die/replaced.

I know what you said, and that's what we're discussing. If you think Russia is going to be able to continue the war for years to come, to the extent that anything short of full NATO involvement is unhelpful, as the article argues, that's a very big claim. It requires very big evidence.

In terms of the West not being the only supplier of high tech weaponry, who else will do it to the quality and extent necessary? China are the only big supplier outside the West currently. They've been compliant with sanctions so far and they're showing no evidence at all of wanting to provide substantial Russian assistance. Which is quite understandable. Xi has his own position to think of. He's already backed the wrong horse. He isn't likely to be very pleased about the impact Russia's botched invasion has had on the NATO and the West. Where's their incentive?

WRT the West still staying onside with sanctions, what you've left out is the general realisation that there are security concerns to being so reliant on a despotic regime run by an inept fuckwit. Sure, much of the West would like to return to the pre February 2022 status quo, where it was viable to ignore the occasional land war on the fringes of Europe in return for Putin playing ball... but that has gone. It's been torched. There's no longer an option available where we can turn a blind eye in return for energy and security.

Basically, you're still not backing anything up. It's fine to have a hunch or whatever, but in that case call it that. Don't refer to your suspicions as fact.

Alexandra2001 · 04/05/2022 07:59

@HardyBuckette I never said Russia would be successful! what i am saying is Russia has the means to continue this war for years to come & will replace the military that it it has lost.

Russia doesn't need hi tech precision weapons either but i strongly suspect they will find a way to produce these, probably in lower numbers but they do have the means to make unlimited numbers of non smart weapons.

The 'West isn't the only supplier of hi tech and no one really knows what China/RoW will do in the future or if Western countries will continue sanctions as the cost of living continues to spiral, to meet the 2030 target etc of no more fossil fueled cars, we need raw materials from Russia or pay far more as prices rise, taking the tech even further out of reach.

I want nothing more than Putin/Russia to be defeated and the rebuilding of Ukraine but right now, i just don't see that happening ... maybe in the future the signs will be more positive but i think we are heading for a long war of attrition/stalemate.... all this assumes Putin doesn't die/replaced.