Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guardian is publishing Russian Propaganda

309 replies

Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 15:45

AIBU to be very disappointed that the Guardian has resorted to publishing Russian propaganda. It was shocking to read, largely inaccurate and wholly from the Russian perspective. I am all for listening to all sides, but there was no effort to understand how Ukraine feels, Ukraine's objective is clearly to win the war and reclaim their nation, and blaming the western leaders for arming Ukraine and the bloodshed caused by the Russians is somewhat misleading, Ukraine have every right to defend themselves.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/apr/27/ukraine-war-end-putin-russia-talks

OP posts:
IVFNewbie · 06/05/2022 10:09

UK media in partial reporting shock.

Swayingpalmtrees · 06/05/2022 10:02

hawkins There is not a reason now for Ukraine to stop or to settle for less, so I agree strategically the loss now and even in the next few years, is better than the alternative. The west are largely following the lead of Ukraine (with the exception of Germany and France whom I believe for their own interests, were encouraging Ukraine to compromise very early on - that seems to have stopped)
The whole of Europe would be safer and more secure if Russia loses entirely.

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 06/05/2022 09:59

We are not privvy to what is happening in terms of supplies to Ukraine alex for security reasons we may never know what is being supplied. However, Ukraine are achieving great success due in large to the weapons and training they are receiving from the west - that and the motivation to save their country from the Kremlin.

What I would say is we can only see the Russian reaction, and Putin is furious and telling the west to stop supplying, and threatening all kinds of things - so certainly whatever we are sending is enough to make Putin feel very stressed and disturbed and concerned about any of his goals being met, for his reaction alone and nothing more I would say more than enough is being done to help Ukraine - we won't know the detail, but we can be sure it is helping them a great deal.

Look, we are now talking about Ukraine actually winning, that was not even a possibility in our earlier conversations was it alex? So we are now in a much stronger position than before.

I am hopeful now. I am hopeful for a resolution for Ukraine, I am hopeful potentially for wider stability in Europe in the medium term as a result.

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 06/05/2022 09:26

Swayingpalmtrees · 05/05/2022 18:51

I am not trying to be condescending at all - I am referring to your last post that stated:

i want the 'west to be looking at ways to shorten the war, whilst at the same time not giving an inch of ground to Putin, thats a Ukrainian decision only

You are implying in your post that there are ways to shorten the war, there are no ways to shorten the war with the exception of Putin withdrawing his troops from what I can see which might be a touch premature at this stage. I am wondering what other options and ways you think are available to Ukraine/West *alexandra201? Genuinely I am interested why security experts haven't considered different options already...and what they might be in your view?

I would say, if there were a raft of measures available that could be taken to prevent this terrible war and save the many thousands of innocent people dying, do you not think we would have taken them by now?

Sure but do you have to add in things like "You do realise alex...." anyway, moving on!

I'm not a security expert nor am i in the Biden Government, however, the US has spent the $3billion in aid announced recently, the planed $33 billion hasn't even been voted on...(end of May) the UK is sending 13 armoured vehicles and night vision googles, some radar and some shortrange anti ship missiles.... it all seems "jam tomorrow..."

Ukraine need heavy weapons now, they aren't getting them in sufficient numbers and i would like to see the Black Sea blockade challenged... i do not see how we can let Putin shut off international waters with impunity, appreciate the Turkey angle so perhaps the USA is pushing for Turkey to change its stance but if they are, its being done in total secret!

As a former air chief of staff said yesterday "Russia is pushing very hard atm and not achieving its aims, so will be forced to pause, Ukraine can then counter and push Russia back BUT atm they do not have the weapons to do this"

Are we in danger of believing the rhetoric western leaders are telling us but not looking at the detail?

Hawkins001 · 05/05/2022 21:56

"I would say, if there were a raft of measures available that could be taken to prevent this terrible war and save the many thousands of innocent people dying, do you not think we would have taken them by now ? "

that all depends on the philosophy of the individual or group and the long term strategy, and if they see the sacrifices made as worth the cost. I only say this analysis based on the warfare tactics of different leaders from history, e.g. Attila the hun, Alexander the great, Genghis Khan, Ivan the terrible, ect

Swayingpalmtrees · 05/05/2022 18:52

for Alexandra201

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 05/05/2022 18:51

I am not trying to be condescending at all - I am referring to your last post that stated:

i want the 'west to be looking at ways to shorten the war, whilst at the same time not giving an inch of ground to Putin, thats a Ukrainian decision only

You are implying in your post that there are ways to shorten the war, there are no ways to shorten the war with the exception of Putin withdrawing his troops from what I can see which might be a touch premature at this stage. I am wondering what other options and ways you think are available to Ukraine/West *alexandra201? Genuinely I am interested why security experts haven't considered different options already...and what they might be in your view?

I would say, if there were a raft of measures available that could be taken to prevent this terrible war and save the many thousands of innocent people dying, do you not think we would have taken them by now?

OP posts:
Hawkins001 · 05/05/2022 16:24

LuluBlakey1 · 04/05/2022 09:30

I think the writer is right. Russia followed this plan in Syria, he annihilated cities, ground them down with ongoing barrage assaults over months until they were decimated and helpless with every bit of infrastructure destroyed and hundreds of thousands killed. Putin has barely used his armed forces- his military power is vast and, if he unleashes it, it could be catastrophic.
I don't think Nato starting a huge war is the answer - Putin would use nuclear weapons if they did.
I don't know what the answer is but what is happening at the moment is pointless. Ukraine can not win. This is simply a stage in a plan of attack by Putin.

Johnson is determined to create an image of himself as some sort of international statesman/leader from this.Sending hundreds of millions in weapons, appearing in Kyiv. It is all pointless, jostling for a position of i portance on a world stage.

The truth is Britain is done- we are insignificant on the world stage. We are a tiny country, with no resources or significant industry or land or military reserves, whose time on the world stage was 100-200 years ago. Power now resides in China, Russia and the US. Europe and Britain are finished as big powers. If the US left Nato, Russia would be uninterested in Europe once we were no military threat.He is not interested in our culture and would not want most of Europe as part if Russia - although he might want some of o.d parys of the USSR back to give him a 'buffer'.

This is the source that states Russia's power

Alexandra2001 · 05/05/2022 15:20

Ummmmm Condescending or what!! So point me to where i said "shorten the war by diplomacy" or even anything that could be construed as such?

Shorten the war by military means, there is no other way.

Putin has never negotiated in good faith and lies constantly, either that or has no control at all over the military.

If i had the time, i could find the posts in the early 'invasion threads where i was ridiculed for stating the talks between Ukraine and Russia were pointless and waste of time or others (around the time of Brexit & under a different name) when i referred to Russia as the USSR or the Soviets... Putin always played the Tories like a fiddle.

Once he invaded, gloves off, the time for diplomacy and compromise had vanished.

Swayingpalmtrees · 05/05/2022 10:54

There are no ways to shorten the war that will be attractive to Putin Alex
He does not want to shorten the war, he only wants to win and move next to Moldova as soon as he can.

Putin's aim is to take as much as he can, as quickly as he can. The only way to stop him is to take away his army, his supply routes, the financial means to pay for the war and cripple him in every direction - at every level. That is how we shorten the war, by defeating him and doing so in such a way that Russia are extremely unlikely to do the same ever again.
In short, Russia needs a brutal kicking and it needs to be good if it is to work as a deterrent for their next leader's ambition. A shame and stain on Russia so deep that can span generations, that is the only way we can all prevent WW3. The only way. Anyone that says otherwise now, after all that we now know, is just kidding themselves.

The days of niceties and peace talks about what Ukraine is prepared to give away are truly over. Now it is a matter of just how long it takes to drive Russia out. You do know Russia can not be allowed to win, you do know that Alex? A win for Russia would see a huge escalation and spread of war, the security situation for all citizens including Russia would be at huge risk. There is no peaceful way out of this, that has credence now unless Putin does a total U turn and pulls out.

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 05/05/2022 10:42

@HardyBuckette Missed that, strange thing to say!
@Swayingpalmtrees Yes i listened to a Ch4 report yesterday, from near Donetsk, the heavily camouflaged soldier was saying that it is so easy to kill the Russian as they never change tactics and keep coming back for me.

The Syrian and Chechen so called elite forces, were little more than hired killers, slaughtering lightly armed civilians and its heart warming to know they have been killed by Ukrainian forces.

Yes the war lasting a long time is what i have been saying the danger is & i don't want that, i want the 'west to be looking at ways to shorten the war, whilst at the same time not giving an inch of ground to Putin, thats a Ukrainian decision only.

Swayingpalmtrees · 05/05/2022 10:42

**ISIS

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 05/05/2022 10:40

No one can rule it out pink and the biggest worry for defence experts has always been the 'room for an accident' in conflicts like this. Which is why the back channels are kept open, and communication even with the war raging in Ukraine continues between the West and Russia.

One would like to think there would be a reasoned conversation about the next steps before they happen (but not always) Intelligence is really key. Planning for all eventualities ditto. I would imagine this is the reason why Russia, despite having the capacity to inflict a biological or precision nuclear attack is in reality very reluctant to do so as this will be a step too far for the whole world, and not just those on the Ukrainian side. The fact that they have so far chosen not to do so indicates some reasoned thinking in the Kremlin.

I wouldn't bother with a bunker, it would be better to go out in style with the first flash as the world you would return to would probably not be one worth living and would be a living hell for many years to come.

Russia may have miscalculated this war, and have over played their hand but they are not stupid and are not IS - their lives have value as well, they all have skin in the game so to speak.

OP posts:
PinkestMoon · 05/05/2022 10:20

A conventional war fought by NATO in Eastern Europe or a WWII style conflict? Just googling to see how much Anderson shelters are going for before I move to bunkers. What a world.

Swayingpalmtrees · 05/05/2022 10:11

The threat from Belarus cannot be ignored by Ukraine, so it ties up forces that otherwise might be sent to the south

It is was my understanding that a percentage of troops from Belarus have been in Ukraine for a while in fact more or less from the second week of the invasion, and many have died a result.
It was a wake up call for Belarus when the much vaulted special forces from Chechnya didn't make it out alive. I understand Belarus have since brokered a deal with Russia to take all of the wounded Russians soldiers into their hospitals (which are overflowing according to reports) on the borders, and are assisting with logistics rather than ground forces. One would not expect Belarus to be able to offer more than this, as they have their own country and interests to defend. Chechnya have pulled back after they lost some of their best. Although I imagine both are present to some degree.

Ukraine are not alone either, it is worth noting. Many civilians from all around the world have joined the fight. I am always surprised to hear the number from Thailand and places you would not expect!

Where has anyone said Russia has a massive and terrifying military? they clearly don't, that has been very clear for many weeks but that doesn't mean they cannot make this war last a very long time

Then the war will have to last a long time. Ukraine are prepared for it, the West are prepared for it, and certainly NATO are ready. Have you seen the forces gathered in Poland and other surrounding countries?
Russia have traded heavily on their military capacity in the past, leading others to believe they are capable of far greater conflict than we have seen so far. The war has been a helpful insight into the true state of affairs.
If Russia want to drag this war out, that is a matter for them. I think they would be ill advised to do so, when the Russian population starts to truly understand the scale and huge cost and consequences to this war, Putin might find this will be his undoing.

pink It is possible for NATO and Russia to be involved in conventional war, it would not automatically mean a nuclear war. Things could escalate very quickly in a way that Russia would not be prepared for. I am not sure how keen they will be after the debacle in Ukraine to take on half the world - it would be suicidal to even consider it, and there are only so many times you can threaten the world that you will press the button before other nations just stop listening, and see you for what you are.

OP posts:
HardyBuckette · 05/05/2022 09:42

Alexandra2001 · 05/05/2022 08:11

The threat from Belarus cannot be ignored by Ukraine, so it ties up forces that otherwise might be sent to the south.
Same as the threat to Odesa is used to keep forces there too.

Where has anyone said Russia has a massive and terrifying military? they clearly don't, that has been very clear for many weeks but that doesn't mean they cannot make this war last a very long time.

Lulublakey at 930 yesterday. Vast and catastrophic, apparently.

Alexandra2001 · 05/05/2022 08:11

Hawkins001 · 04/05/2022 20:55

Possible cannon fodder, why use your troops when you can recruit others and use them for war ?

The threat from Belarus cannot be ignored by Ukraine, so it ties up forces that otherwise might be sent to the south.
Same as the threat to Odesa is used to keep forces there too.

Where has anyone said Russia has a massive and terrifying military? they clearly don't, that has been very clear for many weeks but that doesn't mean they cannot make this war last a very long time.

PinkestMoon · 04/05/2022 22:23

Excuse my ignorance but when you say "At some point the west will need to reconcile its wish to avoid war, with the reality that we may not have the choice if it comes to it" what do you mean @Swayingpalmtrees? My understanding is that that war (if, God forbid, it comes) would be a nuclear war and then it's all over. Or are you referring to some kind of conventional war? And what theatre would that play out in?

HardyBuckette · 04/05/2022 22:01

FatherBuzzCagney · 04/05/2022 20:32

Thank you @HardyBuckettebut not true - you've being doing a great job of explaining the situation.

Putin tried and failed to push Belarus and other Collective Security Treaty Organisation states into committing troops.

Having mentioned this earlier, thought I should say that Belarus seems to be showing possible signs of getting involved after all (sudden announcement of "combat readiness drills"). But hard to see them making a great deal of difference to the war in the long term.

Thank you that's kind.

Re Lukashenko, I think he's worried he won't survive dragging Belarus into Putin's war. Agree there would surely have to be huge pressure on him for him to take that risk.

Hawkins001 · 04/05/2022 21:22

FatherBuzzCagney · 04/05/2022 21:17

That's never been the Russian approach in this region (not since 1991, at least). Russia has generally preferred to conduct military operations in the former Soviet Union on its own and hasn't made an attempt to rope others in, except in a couple of cases in Central Asia (the Tajik civil war in the 90s and the recent CSTO "peacekeeping" operation in Kazakhstan), where the additional troops were largely window dressing.

Russia has been attempting to pressure the Belarusian president to get involved for weeks now - because of Russian army shortages and possibly to give a veneer of legitimacy by making it look like a regional action (though who that would fool I have no idea). Lukashenko has refused because he's already widely hated in Belarus after he stole the 2020 election, and involvement in the attack on Ukraine would be very unpopular. If he has cracked (and it may just be shit stirring - we'll have to wait and see) then Putin must have put a lot of pressure on him. Which would also suggest increased desperation in the Kremlin.

Fair points and analysis

FatherBuzzCagney · 04/05/2022 21:17

Hawkins001 · 04/05/2022 20:55

Possible cannon fodder, why use your troops when you can recruit others and use them for war ?

That's never been the Russian approach in this region (not since 1991, at least). Russia has generally preferred to conduct military operations in the former Soviet Union on its own and hasn't made an attempt to rope others in, except in a couple of cases in Central Asia (the Tajik civil war in the 90s and the recent CSTO "peacekeeping" operation in Kazakhstan), where the additional troops were largely window dressing.

Russia has been attempting to pressure the Belarusian president to get involved for weeks now - because of Russian army shortages and possibly to give a veneer of legitimacy by making it look like a regional action (though who that would fool I have no idea). Lukashenko has refused because he's already widely hated in Belarus after he stole the 2020 election, and involvement in the attack on Ukraine would be very unpopular. If he has cracked (and it may just be shit stirring - we'll have to wait and see) then Putin must have put a lot of pressure on him. Which would also suggest increased desperation in the Kremlin.

Hawkins001 · 04/05/2022 20:55

LemonDrizzleSlice · 04/05/2022 20:35

And if Russia was the terrifying, massive force that some PPs seem to think it is, why would they even need Belarus's troops?!

Possible cannon fodder, why use your troops when you can recruit others and use them for war ?

FatherBuzzCagney · 04/05/2022 20:41

Well, quite.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 04/05/2022 20:35

And if Russia was the terrifying, massive force that some PPs seem to think it is, why would they even need Belarus's troops?!

FatherBuzzCagney · 04/05/2022 20:32

Thank you @HardyBuckettebut not true - you've being doing a great job of explaining the situation.

Putin tried and failed to push Belarus and other Collective Security Treaty Organisation states into committing troops.

Having mentioned this earlier, thought I should say that Belarus seems to be showing possible signs of getting involved after all (sudden announcement of "combat readiness drills"). But hard to see them making a great deal of difference to the war in the long term.