Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guardian is publishing Russian Propaganda

309 replies

Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 15:45

AIBU to be very disappointed that the Guardian has resorted to publishing Russian propaganda. It was shocking to read, largely inaccurate and wholly from the Russian perspective. I am all for listening to all sides, but there was no effort to understand how Ukraine feels, Ukraine's objective is clearly to win the war and reclaim their nation, and blaming the western leaders for arming Ukraine and the bloodshed caused by the Russians is somewhat misleading, Ukraine have every right to defend themselves.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/apr/27/ukraine-war-end-putin-russia-talks

OP posts:
FatherBuzzCagney · 27/04/2022 17:33

Staffy1 · 27/04/2022 17:06

Russia is a lot bigger than Ukraine. I would think Ukraine have lost a lot of people too. Putin is not the type to back down, his type never do. I can’t see it ending in a good way the way it is going now. As the author of the article said, it either needs NATO to step in properly, or to persuade Putin to negotiate, which is easier said than done and Ukraine isn’t want to give him everything he wants, especially not at this stage after all they have lost.

Yes Ukraine have undoubtedly lost a lot of soldiers, as well as civilians. But short of a general mobilisation of Russian men of fighting age, the pool of Ukrainians willing to fight is a lot bigger than the available Russians. And the motivation of Ukrainian fighters is much greater.

The US government have estimated that the Russian forces in Ukraine are down to 75% combat effectiveness. It seems as if over 15,000 Russian soldiers have been killed. Assuming a traditional wounded-to-killed ratio of 3-1, that would be 45,000 wounded - so, 60,000 wounded + killed out of an original force of 190K. Plus prisoners, plus deserters. And that's just in two months. I can't remember a major military power suffering anything close to these levels of losses in a comparable time period in a war of choice in recent history.

Who replaces these lost troops? Russia can't afford to put all its armed forces personnel into Ukraine - it has other things going on that it needs troops for, not least the defence of Russia itself. Belarus, theoretically in a military union with Russia, has declined to send troops to Ukraine. Other security partners in the Collective Security Treaty Organisation (Russia's pitiful attempt to replicate NATO) have backed off even further than Belarus.

So once the remaining available Russian forces are redeployed to Ukraine and then killed and wounded in their turn, where do the next wave of Russian troops come from? This year's conscripts, the teenagers (the ones too poor to have bribed their way out of conscription) with a few weeks' training? General mobilisation - an army of the poorly trained, poorly equipped and hugely pissed off?

And all this is before you get to the issue of how Russia can carry on arming its troops given the scale of equipment losses, the effects of sanctions and the time it take to build new tanks, helicopters, warships. Meanwhile, Ukraine is receiving seemingly limitless aid from the world's only military superpower.

Putin cannot win in Ukraine so he needs to decide which loss he can plausibly try to frame as a win.

Btw, the one pretty certain way for it to end badly would be if NATO stepped in properly.

Hont1986 · 27/04/2022 17:26

The opening paragraph says "Ukraine is fighting a just war. Russia’s invasion was entirely unprovoked. ... Vladimir Putin launched a straightforward war of aggression and territorial conquest."

I'm not sure OP knows what propoganda means.

littlegreenheart · 27/04/2022 17:15

I wish he'd been more specific.There HAVE been/are negotiations. Ukraine says Russia has acted in bad faith, broken promises such as humanitarian corridors, etc. Is he suggesting that NATO make it crystal clear to Ukraine that they must trust Russia. and they must accept Russia's preconditions such as Ukraine's ceding Crimea and giving up claims to Donetsk and Luhansk?

As for the Dayton agreement - NATO DID have to intervene directly and militarily in ex-Yugoslavia (despite none of the fighting being on NATO member territory) to get all of those parties to the table, the Bosnian Serbs and Croatia perhaps more so than Milošević. To me, this looks like a mistake the US/NATO have made before: they think they can force the hands of their beneficiaries, but in some cases they're misunderstanding that people really WILL fight on even without US/NATO/international support, even if it's suicidal. When does that ethically cease to be Ukraine's choice, if ever?

I don't think NATO leaders think Putin will back down, I think some of them believe that international pressure of various types (mostly, but not all, economic) will isolate Russia far enough to drive a coup or similar. However, I think the US (and probably the UK and Canada) have likely overestimated the commitment of real, practical support internationally.

Staffy1 · 27/04/2022 17:13

@LemonDrizzleSlice there is probably no point in negotiating unless there is compromise and Ukraine shouldn’t have to give anything away to keep Russia happy, but how long can Ukraine keep going on it’s own against a much bigger country and army lead by an arsehole who won’t back down? Anyway, regardless of your opinion or mine, the authors opinion is not Russian propaganda or in any way pro-Russian.

Staffy1 · 27/04/2022 17:06

Russia is a lot bigger than Ukraine. I would think Ukraine have lost a lot of people too. Putin is not the type to back down, his type never do. I can’t see it ending in a good way the way it is going now. As the author of the article said, it either needs NATO to step in properly, or to persuade Putin to negotiate, which is easier said than done and Ukraine isn’t want to give him everything he wants, especially not at this stage after all they have lost.

FatherBuzzCagney · 27/04/2022 16:57

True enough as dictators like Putin aren’t going to back down or retreat.

They do if they're beaten. The Russian army has already retreated from the Kyiv region, having had its arse handed to it.

If Ukraine continues to get the necessary weapons - both the necessary volume and the right sort - they can (a) continue to degrade Russia's ability to fight in Ukraine and (b) potentially push Russian forces back to at least their pre-February 2022 positions.

Russia is losing men and weapons at a staggering rate and they don't have the means to keep replacing them. They simply don't have the resources to keep going indefinitely, whatever Putin wants.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 27/04/2022 16:51

Staffy1 · 27/04/2022 16:49

I don’t see how that’s Russian propaganda at all. He says it’s clear that they started it and shouldn’t have and he has a point that it’s just going to prolong it with the West backing Ukraine and supplying weapons but not getting involved in the fighting. True enough as dictators like Putin aren’t going to back down or retreat.

And they're not going to stop if they're allowed a "win" or we negotiate some sort of phony peace!

Putin lied and lied before invading Ukraine, gave people like Macron the runaround, just like Hitler did before Poland. There is no point negotiating, because they don't want peace.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 27/04/2022 16:49

@FatherBuzzCagney and @LetitiaLeghorn speak a lot of sense.

Staffy1 · 27/04/2022 16:49

I don’t see how that’s Russian propaganda at all. He says it’s clear that they started it and shouldn’t have and he has a point that it’s just going to prolong it with the West backing Ukraine and supplying weapons but not getting involved in the fighting. True enough as dictators like Putin aren’t going to back down or retreat.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 27/04/2022 16:46

zaffa · 27/04/2022 16:42

@LemonDrizzleSlice we will her to agree to disagree on our interpretation of 'helping' I think.

Maybe you are not aware of what the UK and its forces have been doing in Ukraine over the last 8 years? And why Ukraine praises us, and the US, over all other countries?

LetitiaLeghorn · 27/04/2022 16:46

Not initially though. Europe let Germany annex Austria which was breaking the Versailles treaty. Then they actually gave Hitler Sudetenland to appease him, thinking it would avert war because Hitler said that's all he wanted and he would stop then. But of course, he didn't. He interpreted the rest of Europe negotiating peace and not standing up to him as a sign he could do what he liked.
Putin has done exactly the same thing. We stood back when he attacked Georgia and annexed the Crimea. He was emboldened by it. Like Hitler it made him look strong at home.
At what point do we stop him. When he's sat on the Isle of Wight? I'm not supporting us going to war. The world is trying to not let it escalate. Roxburgh wants a ceasefire and peace talks. There have alteasy been ceasefires that Russia just ignored and bombed fleeing people. They've been in prace talks since day one. Putin is as unreliable as Hitler was. Remember his treaty with Stalin promising nor to invade Russia which he broke 2 years later? I wouldn't trust Putin not to do the same.
I disagree that people can't write opinion pieces in newspapers but I do think that in important matters such as this, there should be an accompanying piece giving the alternative pov.

FatherBuzzCagney · 27/04/2022 16:46

Well, the opening paragraph would get you 15 years in jail in Russia, but otherwise it's certainly pushing a line that strongly favours the Kremlin. He's hardly he only one, though - there are a number of western commentators with varying degrees of historical closeness to the Russian government who are taking this approach.

He's badly wrong on several counts. Russia is absolutely failing in Ukraine, judged against any of its aims and looking at the performance of the Russian armed forces. Operationally and strategically, it's been a self-inflicted military disaster on a scale I haven't seen before in my adult lifetime. They've absolutely fucked themselves. The only way that's going to change is if Western states stop arming NATO.

It also never seems to occur to these people that it's not our fucking call. If Ukraine wants to carry on fighting for their survival, that's up to them. If states decide it's not in their self-interest to support that, that's their choice (though I'd say they were wrong) but it's grossly paternalistic to suggest that Ukraine doesn't know what's best for itself and so the grown-ups in the West need to decide for them.

Of course, not surprising that Seamus Milne's old paper is publishing this kind of take in the opinion section (his old fiefdom). Milne, who chaired a discussion panel with Putin at the Russian government's Valdai Conference in 2014 - the year Russia illegally occupied Crimea and started a proxy war in the Donbas - and who was responsible for Corbyn's Kremlin-tastic line on the Skripal poisonings, is/was very close to Kath Viner and seems to have been one of the main forces behind her becoming editor. The actual foreign correspondents at the Guardian are excellent, but the non-specialist foreign affairs commentators are generally over-confident and under-informed.

zaffa · 27/04/2022 16:42

@LemonDrizzleSlice we will her to agree to disagree on our interpretation of 'helping' I think.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 27/04/2022 16:24

So it's more like Hitler's annexation of Sudetenland, in that sense. Except this time we are doing the right thing.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 27/04/2022 16:22

zaffa · 27/04/2022 16:19

@LemonDrizzleSlice we fought hitler though. We aren't fighting Putin here, just watching the Ukrainians do it....

Helping the Ukrainians do it. We've been helping them since Russia invaded Crimea. And more help is coming.

zaffa · 27/04/2022 16:19

@LemonDrizzleSlice we fought hitler though. We aren't fighting Putin here, just watching the Ukrainians do it....

Birdy78 · 27/04/2022 16:16

Everything is escalating and unless some diplomatic solution is found soon things could get completely out of hand. Pouring more weapons in to a conflict zone is not going to have a peaceful outcome. If you think this is the correct strategy are you willing to bet your children’s lives on it ? If this ends up nuclear that’s what you’re doing.

Scianel · 27/04/2022 16:09

It's an opinion piece. People are still entitled to have those, for now.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 27/04/2022 16:08

LetitiaLeghorn · 27/04/2022 16:05

The writer of that article was Angus Roxburgh who was a PR advisor to Putin. Of course he's advising to accept Putin's peace terms! 😂😂

Exactly. More of a fellow traveller than a useful idiot, I suspect.

I mean, why on earth didn't we negotiate with Hitler to stop him being so beastly? All we had to do was give him a "win" when he invaded Poland, and then he would have settled down and never been beastly again!

10HailMarys · 27/04/2022 16:07

It's not even close to being pro-Russian propaganda! Have you actually even read it?

At no point does it praise Russia or suggest that Ukraine shouldn't be an independent nation. The whole point of the article is that Putin is a monster who needs to be stopped from razing Ukraine to the ground and driving its people from their homeland, and that some form of compromise and negotiation might be the safest way to save Ukraine in some form or another.

I'm not saying I agree with everything in the article - I don't. But it's a perfectly valid point of view and certainly not 'Russian propaganda' in any shape or form.

leadmeaway · 27/04/2022 16:07

That article is complete bollocks and coming from a very unrealistic position of a naïve perspective. So basically the author is saying its easier and less destructive to just bend over and say to Putin okay if you have a cease fire, we will grit our teeth and discuss the possibility of Russia taking any thing they want as long as the oppressed guaranteed to stop defending it.

May be people would rather fight to the end to keep their freedom with nothing, rather than live their entire life under a dictatorship just so they can have a house over their head.

So what happens after that, why should Putin stop there? Do you just give him where ever and what ever he likes in case he threatens to destroy it other wise.

StoneofDestiny · 27/04/2022 16:07

It's an opinion piece - there is a huge difference between that and propaganda.

Oddessafile · 27/04/2022 16:06

@LemonDrizzleSlice it was an opinion piece, very different from the nazi propaganda in the 30s spouted by the mail under lord Rothermere.

Raquelos · 27/04/2022 16:06

95% of war realted news in times of war is propaganda. It's fascinating to realise that most people don't realise that.

In this case you ABVU indeed, it is an opinion piece in a paper that has had some very good coverage of events in Ukraine and certainly hasn't taken a pro-Russian position. Also having read that article I am having a hard time seeing how you read it as pro-Russian anyway.

If you go to countries outside of Europe you will see the war being reported differently, in so far as there is some interesting analysis of why Putin felt this was the right course of action to take to protect Russia's interest, I'm not suggesting that is cast Iron truth either (what is after all) but it is a better explanation than the line of "he's gorn mad" that most of our press seems content with.

LetitiaLeghorn · 27/04/2022 16:05

The writer of that article was Angus Roxburgh who was a PR advisor to Putin. Of course he's advising to accept Putin's peace terms! 😂😂