Paragraphs like this:
"No day goes past without some senior western politician proclaiming that Ukraine will be “successful” and that Russia is “failing”. This is certainly morale-boosting. But it is clearly nonsense"
Why is this nonsense if the West continue to support Ukraine? It is not a done deal at all given Ukraine has 44 million people ready and willing to fight their cause, and they have literally nothing to lose now.
"If Russia’s aim was to exterminate the Ukrainian nation, then the west’s approach is helping to do just that"
That is not true, and it is a pretty despicable to say that the West are contributing to 'exterminate' Ukraine! It is clearly extremely offensive when most of the West are doing all they can to support Ukraine.
"Encouraging the Ukrainians to continue, however just their cause, is merely making their country uninhabitable"
So in other words Putin should be able to continue terrorising Ukraine and Ukraine should merely put down their arms. Does anyone seriously think this is an option for Ukraine? Ukraine would cease to exist overnight, and be absorbed into the motherland. They have no choice but to continue until the last.
"To get Putin to the negotiating table at all, everything would have to be up for discussion – including Ukraine’s borders"
And how would he propose to get Zelensky to the table given the mass genocide of his people. This is not all on Putin's terms, as much as he would like to imagine it is. Russia if nothing else have shown how weak they are.
"Putin will never accept defeat"
Well Putin might have to, if his army continue to struggle and die in their thousands. That apparently is not even an option according to this learned fellow - but many in the west now believe it to be a real possibility that Ukraine could win back all or most of their country. Russia are now fighting a three hundred mile war which is not for the faint hearted, the unrested and the unfed.