Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guardian is publishing Russian Propaganda

309 replies

Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 15:45

AIBU to be very disappointed that the Guardian has resorted to publishing Russian propaganda. It was shocking to read, largely inaccurate and wholly from the Russian perspective. I am all for listening to all sides, but there was no effort to understand how Ukraine feels, Ukraine's objective is clearly to win the war and reclaim their nation, and blaming the western leaders for arming Ukraine and the bloodshed caused by the Russians is somewhat misleading, Ukraine have every right to defend themselves.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/apr/27/ukraine-war-end-putin-russia-talks

OP posts:
Fishwishy · 27/04/2022 19:37

I don't see why it cannot be published as an alternative viewpoint. But I am very free speech and believe in giving airtime to views I find challenging. Something people on here and Mumsnet should do well to respect with the censorship of daily mail articles and the stupid stuff Mumsnet bans as hate speech or not being supportive. Book burning does nothing to help anyone whether it is "far right" (which increasingly means anything the left don't like) both gender critical material and stuff some people consider misogyny to the far left and XR. Getting alternative viewpoint is good whether or not I think it's crap (hence why I come on here)

SpindleInTheWind · 27/04/2022 19:36

The actual foreign correspondents at the Guardian are excellent, but the non-specialist foreign affairs commentators are generally over-confident and under-informed.

Did you see Owen Jones on the French presidential election? Embarrassing. But he's Kath Viner's golden boy or something.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 27/04/2022 19:35

Aishah231 · 27/04/2022 19:32

I'm sick of people dismissing any chance of peace talks with Putin. Yes it might be futile - but it might not and unless the West is prepared to send serious forces in then they have a duty to at least attempt to set up peace talks. Anyone would think they just want a long drawn out war of attrition which we can all 'learn lessons from' in the future after 100s billions have been made by arms manufacturers.

So what happens in these peace talks? What do we give Putin? And what do we think Putin will do afterwards - just retire to his dacha?

Aishah231 · 27/04/2022 19:32

I'm sick of people dismissing any chance of peace talks with Putin. Yes it might be futile - but it might not and unless the West is prepared to send serious forces in then they have a duty to at least attempt to set up peace talks. Anyone would think they just want a long drawn out war of attrition which we can all 'learn lessons from' in the future after 100s billions have been made by arms manufacturers.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 27/04/2022 19:29

Aishah231 · 27/04/2022 19:26

It's not Russian propaganda its an educated informed commentator giving their opinion. They just happen to disagree with you.

And they just happen to want to appease Putin.

Do you see how it works yet?

LemonDrizzleSlice · 27/04/2022 19:26

We did... sort of negotiate with Hitler. Appeasement.

Exactly. But we didn't once he had invaded Poland. Churchill was clear on that, and right. Because any agreement could never be trusted. Hitler didn't want peace, he wanted lebensraum and victory. And Putin is the same. We let him save face in Ukraine? Somewhere else will be next. And then Ukraine again.

Aishah231 · 27/04/2022 19:26

It's not Russian propaganda its an educated informed commentator giving their opinion. They just happen to disagree with you.

FatherBuzzCagney · 27/04/2022 19:14

TheVanguardSix that piece by Seamus Milne is basically a cut-and-paste of 2014 Kremlin talking points. It's pretty much 100% bollocks. It's a far clearer example of a prominent Westerner siding with Putin than the Roxborough article. But then not a surprise from Putin's Valdai mate, and the man who would go on to push the Kremlin's line on the Skripal poisonings on poor, gormless Corbyn.

Guardian is publishing Russian Propaganda
Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 19:13

murdoch Pro peace and pro talks would be the preferred route with almost any other world leader, but we are talking about Putin here. He is not big on peace or talks, he wants Ukraine and the west to capitulate to his demands. The author is not an inspiring peace broker spreading goodwill, but a mouthpiece of the Kremlin.

OP posts:
TheVanguardSix · 27/04/2022 19:06

LemonDrizzleSlice · 27/04/2022 16:08

Exactly. More of a fellow traveller than a useful idiot, I suspect.

I mean, why on earth didn't we negotiate with Hitler to stop him being so beastly? All we had to do was give him a "win" when he invaded Poland, and then he would have settled down and never been beastly again!

We did... sort of negotiate with Hitler. Appeasement. It was weak and it didn't work and gave Hitler more leverage. But the point of these policies is to try and stem the tide of full-scale world war. This is 'rock and hard place' stuff. We're really sitting on the edge of full-scale war (with nukes! Yay!) at worst. At best, it's a decade-plus shock of utter economic and (it goes without saying) political woe for Russians, Ukrainians, Europeans, Middle Easterners & North Africans (who rely on Ukrainian grain and are feeling that pain in real-time), and even Americans to a lesser degree. Our economies are going to really suffer and who gets to feel the burn? You and me. As usual.
There are complexities to this war that are a lot to unpack.
If we return to 2014 and read this article, it sheds some light on where we're at now. It is still relevant.
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/apr/30/russia-ukraine-war-kiev-conflict
It's not an 'oh poor Russia' piece but a 'well, no wonder Russia is pissed!' insight into what was going on in the region (and how much it defines the current crisis).
Again... that 7-year-old Guardian piece is an opinion.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 27/04/2022 18:58

Pro-peace is appeasement, at this stage.

Maurepas · 27/04/2022 18:57

In his interview on Monday Trump told Piers Morgan he would forbid Putin from using the word 'nuclear' ever again and from threatening everybody with it. He says he would tell Putin America has much greater nuclear power than Russia - which it does. People are afraid of Putin because he is constantly threatening nuclear attack to any country he does not like, any he thinks will join NATO or supply Ukraine. So he can get whatever he wants by saying word 'nuclear'. But other countries have nuclear power too.

Murdoch1949 · 27/04/2022 18:57

The opinion piece is not pro Russian at all, more pro peace. The author rightly points out that Ukraine is being destroyed, it is. They say that talks are better, yes they are. We all want the war to end, the author is just putting their jaw jaw not war war perspective. I feel that Putin will not genuinely enter talks, he needs a big win, needs to grab Ukrainian territory back. He seems ill, maybe it’s his last hurrah.

Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 18:54

I have just cancelled my kindle subscription as a result. I don't want to be fed this bullshit and pay for the privilege.

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 18:53

It is written in a way that starts out reasonably, but the article to me felt like a veiled threat. The west need to be looking at appeasement or Russia will wipe Ukraine off the map. It was also alluding to world war three. It is to try and encourage people to think more moderately and less ambitiously - 'come on you know Russia will win so don't make this difficult for yourselves' tone - when indeed the facts on the ground indicate that Russia is losing, and it is losing badly. They haven't met a single target so far, and the war has already been raging for over two months. In fact their position becomes weaker by the day.

I find the dishonesty of this piece, the threatening under tones and the sheer audacity to try and convince the readers that it would be far better for all if Ukraine just stopped and the west stopped arming them, and the general insistence that the west is responsible for the 'extermination' of innocent civilians grossly misleading and inaccurate.

OP posts:
FatherBuzzCagney · 27/04/2022 18:36

That should have been: his addiction to publicity.

LemonDrizzleSlice · 27/04/2022 18:36

Hont1986 · 27/04/2022 17:26

The opening paragraph says "Ukraine is fighting a just war. Russia’s invasion was entirely unprovoked. ... Vladimir Putin launched a straightforward war of aggression and territorial conquest."

I'm not sure OP knows what propoganda means.

And I'm not sure that you know how propaganda works. You don't just come out and say "our side is right and your side is wrong". You muddy the waters. You seem reasonable. You work in metaphors and allusions. The most successful anti-Jewish films in the Nazi era were stories, not statements. They start off seeming reasonable, and they hook you in.

FatherBuzzCagney · 27/04/2022 18:35

Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 18:28

How can any academic seriously defend the mass murder of innocent people? Regardless of the history between the two countries, and is well understood if you are well read. Long standing views withstanding, surely what has actually happened in Ukraine overrides the academic case?

I don't know any that do. But I know a couple who placed most of the responsibility for the pre-war situation on Ukraine and NATO. One of them has gone very quiet since the war really kicked off; the other I haven't seen so much of, so not sure who he's saying. I don't share their views but I also don't doubt that they hold them in good faith. Then there's one very prominent academic who is not a specialist on Russia or Ukraine but who believes himself to be an expert on everything. He's taken a lot of criticism for his position on Ukraine (that it's NATO's fault). In his case, I think his position is a result of a refusal to admit that his crappy, reductive view of international relations might not be all it's cracked up to be (by him) and his addition publicity and to being provocative.

Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 18:28

How can any academic seriously defend the mass murder of innocent people? Regardless of the history between the two countries, and is well understood if you are well read. Long standing views withstanding, surely what has actually happened in Ukraine overrides the academic case?

OP posts:
FatherBuzzCagney · 27/04/2022 18:20

I wouldn't assume it would require anyone to be paid off, OP. I know a few people (academics, commentators) who take this or a similar line, and it's a product of very longstanding views about Russia, its neighbours, and NATO. But of course there are others whose position is harder to explain as an honest difference of opinion. For example, there's the person who worked for RT until the start of the war and then suddenly discovered they had a conscience about working for the propaganda mouthpiece of a murderous dictatorship and resigned, only to pop up at Stop the War Coalition, pushing lines about Western responsibility for the war.

Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 18:19

Paragraphs like this:

"No day goes past without some senior western politician proclaiming that Ukraine will be “successful” and that Russia is “failing”. This is certainly morale-boosting. But it is clearly nonsense"

Why is this nonsense if the West continue to support Ukraine? It is not a done deal at all given Ukraine has 44 million people ready and willing to fight their cause, and they have literally nothing to lose now.

"If Russia’s aim was to exterminate the Ukrainian nation, then the west’s approach is helping to do just that"

That is not true, and it is a pretty despicable to say that the West are contributing to 'exterminate' Ukraine! It is clearly extremely offensive when most of the West are doing all they can to support Ukraine.

"Encouraging the Ukrainians to continue, however just their cause, is merely making their country uninhabitable"

So in other words Putin should be able to continue terrorising Ukraine and Ukraine should merely put down their arms. Does anyone seriously think this is an option for Ukraine? Ukraine would cease to exist overnight, and be absorbed into the motherland. They have no choice but to continue until the last.

"To get Putin to the negotiating table at all, everything would have to be up for discussion – including Ukraine’s borders"

And how would he propose to get Zelensky to the table given the mass genocide of his people. This is not all on Putin's terms, as much as he would like to imagine it is. Russia if nothing else have shown how weak they are.

"Putin will never accept defeat"

Well Putin might have to, if his army continue to struggle and die in their thousands. That apparently is not even an option according to this learned fellow - but many in the west now believe it to be a real possibility that Ukraine could win back all or most of their country. Russia are now fighting a three hundred mile war which is not for the faint hearted, the unrested and the unfed.

OP posts:
ThePants999 · 27/04/2022 18:05

> article describes Putin as a "butcher"
> no justification for the invasion
> "Russian propaganda"
...okay.

I do disagree with the article, but for what it's missed, not for what it says. "Putin will never accept defeat" is absolutely true and Ukraine is stuffed, but the Western world is helping Ukraine to fight not just in the faint hope that it can win, but to make sure any Russian victory is so costly that Putin can't pull this shit again for the foreseeable future.

Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 18:00

I am working so couldn't check in before now. Thank you for your posts, they make for interesting reading.

I am more than well aware of the different global views - I have just come back from a stint in the middle east and India, and the reporting there is very very different, and so are the positions of the people, who believe Ukraine poisoned Abramovich (and their own negotiators) and fake news circles widely that somehow Ukraine is Russia's to take back.

This piece was such a naked piece of pro Kremlin appeasement, I was shocked it made the final cut and wondered who exactly has been paid off - including the author. Like most people I get my news from different sources, but it is obvious to all you can not negotiate with a mad man that is trying to erase your entire nation and is certainly not looking for peace. Ukraine have the only option available to them which is to fight to the last for freedom. I disagree that Russia are a dead cert to win, and I haven't been wrong so far. A quick solution it won't be however, with loss of life on both sides.

The two countries most looking for appeasement and a quick solution are Russia and Germany as far as I can tell, and I feel this article was offensive, particularly to the Ukrainian people who are losing their lives and trying to hold the front line.

OP posts:
LetitiaLeghorn · 27/04/2022 17:46

Hont1986 · 27/04/2022 17:26

The opening paragraph says "Ukraine is fighting a just war. Russia’s invasion was entirely unprovoked. ... Vladimir Putin launched a straightforward war of aggression and territorial conquest."

I'm not sure OP knows what propoganda means.

I disagree with the premise that because an opening paragraph says Putin was wrong to start the war, the rest of the article must therefore be anti Russian.
The article as far as I can see is an urging for the rest of the world to sit down to peace talks to discuss yet again putins wants, such as renegotiating countries borders. They've had peace talks and ceasefire and Putin has ignored them all. Even if he suspended hostilities while talks happen, countries aren't just going to roll over to Putin's diktat, so it would be merely asuspension not a cessation.
Of course we all want a peaceful and quick solution. It appears as if Roxburgh's is to give Putin what he wants.

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 27/04/2022 17:38

Russian Peace Talks = Let me invade your country, displace your peoples and install our own government. No compromise. We kill you otherwise.

Ukrainians = Okay guv, we'll put the kettle on for the new president.

Ffs 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread