Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guardian is publishing Russian Propaganda

309 replies

Swayingpalmtrees · 27/04/2022 15:45

AIBU to be very disappointed that the Guardian has resorted to publishing Russian propaganda. It was shocking to read, largely inaccurate and wholly from the Russian perspective. I am all for listening to all sides, but there was no effort to understand how Ukraine feels, Ukraine's objective is clearly to win the war and reclaim their nation, and blaming the western leaders for arming Ukraine and the bloodshed caused by the Russians is somewhat misleading, Ukraine have every right to defend themselves.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/apr/27/ukraine-war-end-putin-russia-talks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cheeserton · 07/05/2022 09:34

It's an opinion piece... Their reporting on Ukraine, published all day every day, bears little resemblance to your description.

HardyBuckette · 07/05/2022 09:31

it is cleverly written to coral the reader down the line of negotiate with Russia or risk world war 3. Of course the options presented in the article aren’t the only ways forward (despite being presented as such, psychological research indicates that giving people a choice of two things will usually result in them making a choice, here this is basically saying choose between negotiation or potential Armageddon).

Exactly.

I don't really care about whether this does or doesn't meet people's definitions of propaganda. But it's quite obviously a piece that reflects Russian interests and the war as they would wish it to be rather than as it is in reality. Coincidentally or otherwise. The Ukrainian journalist whose viewpoint I linked to upthread made a very good point that the first paragraph is simply what you have to say in the UK now if you want anyone to listen to your don't arm Ukraine arguments.

OMG12 · 07/05/2022 08:57
  • corral not coral😂
OMG12 · 07/05/2022 08:56

Well I think seeing the author of the should immediately cause people to question the intentions of the piece.

it is cleverly written to coral the reader down the line of negotiate with Russia or risk world war 3. Of course the options presented in the article aren’t the only ways forward (despite being presented as such, psychological research indicates that giving people a choice of two things will usually result in them making a choice, here this is basically saying choose between negotiation or potential Armageddon).

it might not be strictly propaganda, but a well written piece of persuasive writing
with a very obvious intention (especially given the source). But it’s The Guardian so about par for the course really.

Alexandra2001 · 07/05/2022 07:52

@Justanotherlurker No Cameron didn't, neither did May or Johnson, yes training given but no actually weapons given or even sold to Ukraine... its all there in the public record.

The first time the UK looked at supply missile systems was in October 2021.

Again, no hawk, i don't believe in NATO troops on the ground of even a NFZ, i did argue that both would be needed if UN troops sent to Mariupol or to Power stations.
But if Ukraine is to defeat Russia, then the Black Sea blockade needs lifting and far more offensive weapons sent.

As for your allegations, you tried this tack before and it ll get the same response as before too.

Hawkins001 · 07/05/2022 01:37

Or would you prefer historical inaccuracies ?

Hawkins001 · 07/05/2022 01:36

Tillsforthrills · 07/05/2022 01:12

It’s worrying that you cannot see, no amount of analysis or understanding a Russian point of view could detract from the fact that yes, he is a villain.

Ok say we agree that based on current intelligence that the public know, Putin is the villian, for historical context and our recording of history, we still need detail events, contexts, understanding of different perspectives, to record how putin became the villain.

Tillsforthrills · 07/05/2022 01:12

Hawkins001 · 06/05/2022 22:12

so basically then in your view, we are just ment to accept putin is the villian without any analysis or understanding from the russian perspectives ?

It’s worrying that you cannot see, no amount of analysis or understanding a Russian point of view could detract from the fact that yes, he is a villain.

Hawkins001 · 06/05/2022 23:52
Not sure what they are singing but it's a catchy tune. Ukraine one of the euro vision songs.
Justanotherlurker · 06/05/2022 22:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Hawkins001 · 06/05/2022 22:12

Tillsforthrills · 06/05/2022 19:32

Surprised at how awfully considerate some people regarding free speech of a veiled pro Kremlin article and of giving in to Putin.

These are not usual times, this is not a conflict that can be solved easily. He has plans to rule over other countries, slaughtering his way there.

Putin is another Hitler and shame on anyone wanting to defend him with ‘free speech’ in mainstream media.

so basically then in your view, we are just ment to accept putin is the villian without any analysis or understanding from the russian perspectives ?

Alexandra2001 · 06/05/2022 21:50

So because i see things differently from you, i ve twisted what Zelenskyys spokes person said and i ve "skewed thinking" i know exactly what i heard and if i thought you'd take the blindest bit of notice i could link you to the limited amounts of heavy weapons Ukraine has received so far...

I try to be respectful to your views but the reality is Ukraine is taking back almost no territory & has lost significant tracts of land... they are however halting any further advances... but now need heavy weapons to succeed in pushing back Russian forces.

Cameron, May and then Johnson blocked UK arms sales to Ukraine, it was the US that sold them some equipment.... we didn't want to upset Putin who was funding the UK Govts party, only in October '21 did we enter talks into supplying missiles.

We supplied non lethal arms and training until then.

Its all public knowledge but listening to BJ its easy to think we not only rearmed Ukr but trained them too ... all by ourselves.

HardyBuckette · 06/05/2022 20:43

AnuSTart · 06/05/2022 20:16

Do you actually know what propaganda is?

This is not it.

And what is written there is not far from the truth as many see it.

Those people are wrong. The article grossly overestimates Russian military abilities and so does anyone who agrees with it. I've no particular interest in whether it constitutes propaganda, but it's a disingenuous attempt to argue for ceasing to arm Ukraine without the guts to admit that's what he's actually doing.

AnuSTart · 06/05/2022 20:16

Do you actually know what propaganda is?

This is not it.

And what is written there is not far from the truth as many see it.

Tillsforthrills · 06/05/2022 19:32

Surprised at how awfully considerate some people regarding free speech of a veiled pro Kremlin article and of giving in to Putin.

These are not usual times, this is not a conflict that can be solved easily. He has plans to rule over other countries, slaughtering his way there.

Putin is another Hitler and shame on anyone wanting to defend him with ‘free speech’ in mainstream media.

PinkestMoon · 06/05/2022 18:55

What do you reckon will happen on the 9th? I feel sick with worry. Thanks for your previous replies OP, found them really informative

Swayingpalmtrees · 06/05/2022 18:28

Hang Alex, this is simply not true. The UK have been delivering arms since the invasion of Crimea, and training. There are plenty of arms being delivered as we speak. I listened to the same news, and what Ukraine have said is that they understand why NATO can't be involved, and were criticising mainly German inaction! Not all of the west! You also missed the part where they thanked the states. I feel like you take the information and twist it to fit in with your skewed thinking.

If anyone is running out of time here, it is most certainly Russia! No food, no supplies, fuel shortages, lack of modern weapons, medical supplies are very low or non existent, exhausted depleted soldiers, tanks stuck in the mud, and no advances anywhere of note. Ukraine on the other hand have all the time in the world, and will see this through as long as it takes.

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 06/05/2022 14:01

Was either Sky or Ch4 yesterday, a spokesman for Zelenskyy said he is a: disappointed that NATO hasn't got more involved (did understand why though) and b: not enough heavy weapons.

I think there is a bit of gap between the pledge and the delivery... understandable as Europe has been cutting back defence spending and there is lag due to training... but Ukraine has not got time on its side.

Swayingpalmtrees · 06/05/2022 12:15

Ukraine was demanding more weapons a few weeks ago, since then Zelensky seems to be thanking the west and I don't see the same demands now. In fact I think beyond his criticism of Germany it seems his requests have been met.
Maybe you are watching different sources to me, but everything I have seen indicates to me that the west are more than meeting the requests of Ukraine.

It is too early to see the endgame agreed, but there is no reason to think Ukraine won't win, they have the time, resources and the support of the world. Russia are lacking in all three, but most of all - motivation and will to succeed. We can not underestimate the will to win.

It looks to me like Ukraine is fast becoming a Vietnam for Russia.

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 06/05/2022 11:58

Swayingpalmtrees · 06/05/2022 10:02

hawkins There is not a reason now for Ukraine to stop or to settle for less, so I agree strategically the loss now and even in the next few years, is better than the alternative. The west are largely following the lead of Ukraine (with the exception of Germany and France whom I believe for their own interests, were encouraging Ukraine to compromise very early on - that seems to have stopped)
The whole of Europe would be safer and more secure if Russia loses entirely.

Yes absolutely!
Russia gaining a foothold in Ukraine by acting illegally and committing terrible war crimes, would be folly and they'd be back for more.. just as they did after ceasing Crimea, though far less violence then.

Alexandra2001 · 06/05/2022 11:54

@Swayingpalmtrees Ukraine are holding back the Russians at this moment in time and its the Ukrainians who are say they aren't getting the longer range weapons but of course it would be madness if the supply routes were made public.
Talk of Russian defeat (i.e pre 24th feb borders) is premature, if they get the weapons, then they can counter and maybe that will happen but to get back the Southern & Azov Sea ports and to then push them out of Donbass is going to be a huge task & one that require a lot more and far quicker supplies from the West... Russia being able to attack from the Black Sea (with Ukraine unable to counter this) is very problematic too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread