Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that introverts don't need "bringing out their shell!" 🙄

228 replies

MrsVillanelle · 27/04/2022 13:50

Hi,

So this is something that has really irritated me recently. I don't really see myself as an extrovert or introvert tbh. Maybe somewhere in between. However, my dp is definitely an introvert, but a confident and successful one, which shouldn't really be seen as surprising or contradictive, but in our society, loud and extroverted characters, seem to be viewed as the ones who make it to the top.

I was watching an episode of Four in a Bed the other day and a couple of the contestants were dancing around and singing. One of the women looked happy enough, but didn't want to dance....which should be fine, but this other couple were saying quite seriously, as though she really needed their help "she's lovely, but we need to bring her out her shell a bit". I just thought, erm..why?! You actually hear that sort of thing all the time, but when you step back and think about it, how rude is that?! People don't need to be shouting, doing karaoke and dancing around to be "out their shell". These people may very well be out their shell and perfectly happy as they are.

Not sure I'm explaining very well why this annoys me so much 😂 but does anyone know what I mean?

It's such a bizarre way of thinking.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fairisleflora · 01/05/2022 01:25

I had some social anxiety until late teens when someone introduced me to the concept of ‘fake it until you make it’. Make up a list of 10 or so conversational starters that would suit the event you are attending, put on a mask of someone super confident at this sort of thing and plough on in. It sounds a bit deceptive, like you are not being true to yourself, but actually it was a lot of fun.

XenoBitch · 30/04/2022 23:35

ErinTingey · 30/04/2022 17:25

Because social events are literally for socialising! How is that so hard for you to grasp? If you go along and sit there saying nothing, you're basically expecting other people to do all the hard work while you reap the rewards of the nice atmosphere and entertainment. It's so incredibly self centred and rude.

Totally agree. I had one woman attend a dinner party at my house and said almost nothing all evening. It was painful. She shocked me while leaving by suddenly smiling brightly saying what a great time she'd had. She'd contributed sweet fa all night and just been an emotional hoover.

Really... did she put a huge downer on the night? Did anyone try to actually engage her in conversation?

I was invited to a gathering where I only knew the host. Everyone else already knew each other, and it was nigh on impossible to make any conversation with them. At one point, I made eye contact with one person and smiled. He had a go at me and asked why I was smiling when I didn't know what he was talking about. Now, that was fucking rude.

I also hosted a party, and a friend came who did exactly as what the person you described did. Spoke about 4 words the entire evening, but said told me she had a lovely time. She was in the middle of a mental health crisis (was under home treatment team), and she pretty much goes mute then. I would have looked very poorly on people who would have judged her for that.

Loopytiles · 30/04/2022 17:28

wanting to dance or not isn’t anything to do with introversion/extroversion.

ErinTingey · 30/04/2022 17:25

Because social events are literally for socialising! How is that so hard for you to grasp? If you go along and sit there saying nothing, you're basically expecting other people to do all the hard work while you reap the rewards of the nice atmosphere and entertainment. It's so incredibly self centred and rude.

Totally agree. I had one woman attend a dinner party at my house and said almost nothing all evening. It was painful. She shocked me while leaving by suddenly smiling brightly saying what a great time she'd had. She'd contributed sweet fa all night and just been an emotional hoover.

pixie5121 · 30/04/2022 15:13

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

pixie5121 · 30/04/2022 15:05

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Badbadbunny · 30/04/2022 11:00

ParsleyRosemarySage · 30/04/2022 07:43

Where I am living at the moment, it is not enough to be civil and polite. I think as usual we are all talking at cross-purposes determined by the one-in-millions individual circumstances and experiences we are faced with.

The prejudice I am talking about, against quiet people, is not about people who do not respond in any way to civilities and small talk. It is operating against those who are not party animals and do not want to be dragged out on social engagements outside work, and who are not really interested in participating in loud raucous conversations that seem more suitable for hen parties most of the time.

As I said, the odd thing is that I can exchange civilities and needed information far more effectively than such people, who seem to take one look at you and refuse to engage in work-related conversations with you if you’re not the sort who will gossip ten-to-the-dozen about what someone did while pissed out of the head to a member of the opposite sex on the latest night out.

Yes I agree with that. There's a massive difference between someone at work who is generally quiet but gets the job done and communicates efficiently for work purposes, as opposed to someone at work who not only is generally quiet but also doesn't contribute at all in meetings, doesn't communicate on work related matters, etc. The former is absolutely fine, whereas it's really a disciplinary matter for the latter. Unfortunately, I think too many people don't understand the difference.

Badbadbunny · 30/04/2022 10:57

@PlasticineMeg

You may not technically owe anyone but is it worth being a dick for the sake of a righteous crusade to show how special you are?

Exactly the same could be turned around for you too! Why do you think other people owe you to be uncomfortable in engaging with random strangers like yourself? Why should you be a dick by bullying and virtually abusing quieter people?

PlasticineMeg · 30/04/2022 09:15

TheOriginalEmu · 29/04/2022 13:10

But why do you think you are owed conversation? You aren’t. If a person can’t/doesn’t want to engage in small talk, there is nothing wrong with that. You’re just conditioned by society that that’s what people do. I’m quite happy to sit quietly and watch people, watch the wedding, whatever the thing is.

Because I haven’t forced that person to come to a social event - the key word here being social - they’ve come of their own volition. Why do you think we owe you your misery unchecked? Imagine if we all sat in silence at wedding or events, how shit that would be. Yes you should have conversations at social events, you should contribute to the group. Otherwise go home as it’s pointless you being there.

I do sometimes wonder if we’ve gone too far with the “you don’t owe anyone” spiel - I’ve seen a few threads this week where people are horrified as their children being spoken to by strangers, or having to make conversation. You may not technically owe anyone but is it worth being a dick for the sake of a righteous crusade to show how special you are?

DangerouslyBored · 30/04/2022 08:17

Grrr shyness / introversion are NOT the same thing.

I’m an introvert. I am a good conversationalist, a ‘can talk to anyone’ type, not remotely shy, happily gave a speech at my wedding (and enjoyed all the attention that being a bride for the day brings), enjoy socialising / a party. Love hosting friends at my home (one of my favourite things in the world). I have a high profile career.

But leave my shell the hell alone. My shell is my sanctuary. Without it I’m a drained, lifeless, exhausted husk. I need my shell to recharge, to contemplate. I bloody love my shell.

ParsleyRosemarySage · 30/04/2022 07:43

Where I am living at the moment, it is not enough to be civil and polite. I think as usual we are all talking at cross-purposes determined by the one-in-millions individual circumstances and experiences we are faced with.

The prejudice I am talking about, against quiet people, is not about people who do not respond in any way to civilities and small talk. It is operating against those who are not party animals and do not want to be dragged out on social engagements outside work, and who are not really interested in participating in loud raucous conversations that seem more suitable for hen parties most of the time.

As I said, the odd thing is that I can exchange civilities and needed information far more effectively than such people, who seem to take one look at you and refuse to engage in work-related conversations with you if you’re not the sort who will gossip ten-to-the-dozen about what someone did while pissed out of the head to a member of the opposite sex on the latest night out.

Speakingmymind · 30/04/2022 06:22

Waxonwaxoff0 · 27/04/2022 15:08

Ah, another thread slagging off extroverts.

Yes, they are all loud, brash buffoons who barge through life without a care for others 🙄

TuftyBum · 30/04/2022 06:19

Mummyratbag · 27/04/2022 15:03

I had a recent parents evening for my (secondary school) son. EVERY teacher said he was well behaved, doing well, but needed to speak up. It was like reading my own school reports from 30-40 years ago. Husband is the same. Why after all these years can't people understand that some people are happy to listen and learn quietly??

Because being able to articulate well in front of others is a key skill.

I was assessing at a graduate assessment centre and one of the candidates said almost nothing all day. This is a role where teamwork and people interaction is almost constant so the ability to talk through a problem and communicate well verbally is important. She emailed for feedback and I told her she didn't score highly as she didn't say hardly anything. She came back genuinely shocked and was all 'In my mind on the first challenge...' and 'I thought about the second exercise...' It's all very well 'thinking' but if you don't say it out loud in that type of environment you won't get anywhere.

pixie5121 · 29/04/2022 22:39

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

pixie5121 · 29/04/2022 22:36

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

GinnysGin · 29/04/2022 22:22

I was meant to write parents 'should encourage' their children and I stand by that as someone who was a very introverted child. My mother would often make me speak to relatives and thank them for cards, ask for the bill in restaurants (life skills) and one time I ordered something and I was given the wrong thing and my father made me go back and tell them. At the time I was mortified, but as an adult I am now assertive as a result. I believe that my mother and father helped me to become less introverted and shy which has benefited me in my career and relationships as an adult.

Wringingourhands · 29/04/2022 20:53

YANBU

To think that introverts don't need "bringing out their shell!" 🙄
To think that introverts don't need "bringing out their shell!" 🙄
XenoBitch · 29/04/2022 20:37

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at poster's request.

I don't get upset, but my eyes stream like they would if I was. I have had years of therapy, and it has never helped. It is frustrating because I can be talking about something mundane, and my face is crying.

I have never been rude to someone at an event for trying to talk to me.
I get invited to social events because the host values my company. They don't expect me to mingle with strangers.... they always say they wont be offended if I don't go, but they would love it if I did. I push myself to attend weddings, because the couple want their nearest and dearest there. It would be more rude to turn down the invites tbh.

I am not sure why you think someone who struggles with small talk is "snubbing people".

Jonny1265 · 29/04/2022 20:36

StorminNorma · 27/04/2022 14:13

YABU because there's no such thing as introversion or extraversion. The whole thing is nonsense dreamt up by marketing eejits. People saying we all need to do karaoke are tedious. So are people who adopt an identity based on a marketing campaign from 70 years ago.

Not true.

OutsideLookingOut · 29/04/2022 20:35

user1497207191 · 29/04/2022 20:29

@XenoBitch

Some the comments about people who struggle with small talk being rude (and gossiped about) make for a depressing read. Some people really do struggle. If someone persists in engaging me in small talk, I burst into tears. I can't help it. That does not mean I think I "am superior" to other people.

Same here. I retreat under pressure, but if I can go slowly and in my own time I can actually be quite sociable. If under pressure, I dry up and withdraw. I just need time rather than being bombarded. I also need small numbers of people, 1 or 2 is fine but in any larger group, I retreat into my shell.

This I can understand. I don’t understand why there has to be a wedge between introverts and extroverts or in this case shy/socially anxious people and social people (who can be introverted or extroverted).

Perhaps we would not need so many labels if people could just be accepted for who they are.

That person who only managed to say one sentence at a party may have pushed themselves and overcome such a personal struggle. Telling those who struggle not even to try if they can’t conform feels so wrong to me.

OutsideLookingOut · 29/04/2022 20:30

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Ugh I find your judgement over the GF to be a little gross. And I think making small talk is important. You have no clue why she may have acted that way and why assume she felt above you? Perhaps she was shy, perhaps she is ND, perhaps social anxiety etc etc. I just can’t imagine reacting so strongly to someone saying so very little!

user1497207191 · 29/04/2022 20:29

@XenoBitch

Some the comments about people who struggle with small talk being rude (and gossiped about) make for a depressing read. Some people really do struggle. If someone persists in engaging me in small talk, I burst into tears. I can't help it. That does not mean I think I "am superior" to other people.

Same here. I retreat under pressure, but if I can go slowly and in my own time I can actually be quite sociable. If under pressure, I dry up and withdraw. I just need time rather than being bombarded. I also need small numbers of people, 1 or 2 is fine but in any larger group, I retreat into my shell.

pixie5121 · 29/04/2022 20:25

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

user1497207191 · 29/04/2022 20:25

GinnysGin · 29/04/2022 18:53

I think it is important that children are brought out of their shell by their parents, as they shouldn't live a life full of crippling anxiety due to a fear of socialising/speaking aloud etc. However, an adult who has made a conscious decision can live the life they wish to lead and if that is a more introverted one, then fine.

Nope, it was pressure to come out of my shell that caused my social anxiety. I wouldn’t be as bad if people had just let me be myself and take things slowly. It was trying to confirm that led me to doing wrong things that made me more self conscious.

XenoBitch · 29/04/2022 19:57

Like many on this thread, my school reports also said about me being very quiet. The feedback from the work experience I did (do schools do that anymore?) was that I should sign up for drama classes to "get me out my shell".
I am not in a shell, there is no shell surrounding me. This is just me, and is who I am.

As an introvert, I am drained by social things, and recharge by spending time alone. That is the opposite to extrovert. It has nothing to do with small talk, shyness, dancing, being the centre of attention or hiding away. You could be the life and soul of a party as an introvert. You can be shy and quiet as an extrovert.

Some the comments about people who struggle with small talk being rude (and gossiped about) make for a depressing read. Some people really do struggle. If someone persists in engaging me in small talk, I burst into tears. I can't help it. That does not mean I think I "am superior" to other people.

A particular pet hate of mine is people who psychically drag you onto dance floors. Please, just stop.