Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

English Baccalaureate - worth it for the child?

29 replies

Pennypinch · 27/04/2022 13:37

Second eldest is now having to decide on GCSE options. They are Year 8 at a Comprehensive that is very heavily performing arts based (older sibling at a grammar didn’t’ have to decide until Year 9).

We had the meeting yesterday and from what I can make out, much like the assembly they gave to the pupils prior to the Easter holidays they really pushed the Eng Bacc.

The phrases “red brick university” and “makes you stand out” were used. In the booklet the phrases “the potential it unlocks four our pupils” and “empowers our pupils” are marked in bold on the Eng Bacc page.

Now the older sibling, has chosen Eng Bacc subjects as they are were an easy fit - all subjects they enjoy so it was an easy decision without much thought as to what the Eng Bacc meant.

However for this child, whilst a humanities subject is an enthusiastic choice for them, a language isn’t. (Although, in saying that, it does worry me that they lose their learning of a MFL by the end of Year 8 if they don’t pick one. But ultimately, their choice.)

This child has four options to take and the school allows three performing arts subjects to be chosen if any child would like to do them (they really pushed this point at the open evenings we went to).

Although I will say, whilst they showed the option blocks on the presentation slides yesterday evening, and whilst they are similarly set out in the leaflet given to us, there was no verbal reminder that taking three performing arts is allowed.

Not that I mean they should hand hold, but that it almost felt like they didn’t want to encourage it. (They became part of an academy about 2 years ago and the other school within this academy is an academic school, so I do wonder if they are moving away from the performing arts. At the open evening we went to in 2019, the school talked about how their Progress 8 was below average but this was because the government had initially said some subjects could be counted in the figures but then changed their mind a little later on and rather than making the kids change course, they ploughed on with those subjects/courses not caring what effect it had on the Progress 8; in other words, it gave the impression that they didn’t care about league tables etc but cared for the individual children more which hugely appealed to us. Now with all this talk about Eng Bacc etc, I suppose I’m worried that this mindset has changed.)

I should add they do offer a mixture of GCSE and BTEC, Cambridge Institute etc.

My AIBU, is about whether

YABU and the Eng Bacc is a worth while string to their bow regardless

or

YANBU - it is pushed for the single benefit of the school.

Thank you.

OP posts:
Pennypinch · 27/04/2022 14:22

Testina · 27/04/2022 14:19

Curious what the 3 performing arts subjects are? Drama and Music and….?

I do want my children to take a humanity and a language - but for their own breadth of learning, not a measure for the school. Couldn’t give two hoots about that!

Dance is the third

OP posts:
Testina · 27/04/2022 14:19

Curious what the 3 performing arts subjects are? Drama and Music and….?

I do want my children to take a humanity and a language - but for their own breadth of learning, not a measure for the school. Couldn’t give two hoots about that!

TeenPlusCat · 27/04/2022 14:11

I don't think it is helpful for universities, but it does cover a broad range of subjects which is what GCSEs should be about.
However for some reason RE doesn't count as a humanity and to my mind that is as useful if not more so than History or Geography.
Furthermore, because our MFL tuition is so woeful at primary level, many children don't want to continue it for GCSE.

For an able child it gives a good balance of academic subjects, but there is no benefit to EBacc as such.

I'm not convinced that 3 performing arts subjects is a great idea when selecting age 13 as that seems unnecessarily narrow, unless a child is either super talented or is really not capable of doing other subjects.

cecilthehungryspider · 27/04/2022 13:59

It's a good way to show a broad range of academic subjects, which will be seen as a good thing by some universities. I don't think it's that important though. If a different choice of subjects is a better fit for the child I would go with that. I certainly didn't see EBacc mentioned on any entry criteria for university applications.

Swipe left for the next trending thread