Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To blame my Dad for a lot of issues..

81 replies

roseii · 27/04/2022 13:04

So my parents are still together, I had a stable upbringing (99.9% of the time) and I felt happy as a child.

My mum is very loving and was always there for me when I was young, gave lots of affection and support whenever needed.

My dad on the other hand, was always kind to me, never shouted at me or did anything really 'wrong'. But he was very absent in terms of emotional support, he didn't really hug me or tell me he loves me very much. He rarely called me 'beautiful' or 'amazing' the words I'd 100% expect my dp to use with our daughter. He made it difficult sometimes to feel relaxed at home as he used to be unimpressed with mess or noise (just general things that happen in everyday life).

I left home young and have always sort affection from men and did a lot of things in my teenage life that I hope my dd won't. I struggle with giving or receiving affection from anyone except my dd. I find it awkward if my partner calls me beautiful and I find displaying affection to my dp really difficult.

There's a million more things to this story, but the older I get the more I wonder whether my dad played a big part in my struggle now.. or whether it's just me as a person!

Can anyone relate?

OP posts:
GlamorousHeifer · 28/04/2022 13:59

Wow, your childhood was good by your own admission.
The only thing you could dredge up to taint it was your father's lack of physical affection whilst being a little over indulgent with gifts.
Please get a grip OP. Navel gazing to this degree is unusual.

Oblomov22 · 28/04/2022 13:39

I find your post odd. It sounds like a really good upbringing, And the fact that you don't view it that way it's very strange. Your father sounds fine.

"He rarely called me 'beautiful' or 'amazing' the words I'd 100% expect my dp to use with our daughter." I find this statement quite freaky. No one has ever called me beautiful or amazing. I'm not particularly. I'm good at loads of things.

Do you think you have chronic self-esteem that you're laying blame for on your dad when in actual fact it's not his fault?

Plus blame is a very strange thing, what does it actually achieve? Have you had counselling to address all these issues and accept yourself for what you are now and to move on because blame is fruitless.

Ferntastical · 28/04/2022 13:03

grapewines · 27/04/2022 14:18

"They fuck you up, your mum and dad"...

Try to get over it. My parents have never called me amazing. I don't know anyone's parents who did that. I think you have unreasonable expectations there. I agree with PP that we get too caught up in introspection sometimes.

This is true. For me, the more important question (about my own parents) is: did they do the best job they could, with the skills and knowledge and reosurces they had at the time?

I think they did. My parents tried very hard to do a good job. In many areas, they got it right, in some they got it wrong. Probably some of the wrongs led to greater struggles for me in life (the "it don't hurt" attitude to pain means I struggle to express any form of physical or mental pain now, for e.g.). But they are the parents I had and they did the best they could with what they had.

OP, do you feel like your Dad was capable (at the time) of greater affection and chose to withold it, or that he was giving you everything he could, at the time?

prettyteapotsplease · 28/04/2022 12:50

I can relate to this in a way. Neither parent was terribly affectionate though mum was a little more so. Dad was either emotionally absent or very critical - nothing was ever good enough (too much praise would result in us getting a 'swelled head' - too pleased with ourselves) and it has affected all my siblings in one way or another.

Mum may have been glad to have met dad and had a family but ultimately it was an unhappy family. Eventually we all have to try to 'get out from under' as it were and make our own way but it can't help but cast a shadow.

Poplob · 28/04/2022 12:44

Maybe I've been spending too much time on TikTok but there is a lot of navel gazing going on at the moment WRT one's parents and how they affected you. It is literally impossible to be a perfect parent. Completely impossible. Life shapes us. Families shape us. Parents are people like anyone else. 99% of the time they're doing the best they can with the tools they have. My parents have faults like anyone else but they're people. It's normal.

I think there's such a thing as too much therapy nowadays. It doesn't do to constantly look inwards and for reasons why you're like X, Y or Z. If you don't like the way you are then look for ways you can change that. Focusing on "my parents did X" is not going to be very helpful in the long run.

Hiphopfrogger · 28/04/2022 12:40

I find the idea of dads calling their daughters beautiful and amazing almost a bit….creepy? I don’t know if that’s the right word but it just gives me the ick.

Carrotmum · 27/04/2022 14:19

I’m in my 60’s and my dad would never have said I was beautiful or amazing he said I was smart and not to let boys mess me arround and encouraged me to go to university , not so common as now. He showed his love by fixing things and decorating top to bottom the first flat I ever had. He worked long hours at a physical job when I was a kid my mum was a SAHM which was how it usually worked back in the 60’s. We didn’t have loads of money but I had everything that I needed even if my parents had to go without. When I had children he was retired and was an amazing grandad half the kids in the area would get him to fix their bikes. My dad loved me to bits I didn’t need him to tell me that and I adored him my dad died 10 years ago and I miss him lots. He would have been an amazing great grandad.

grapewines · 27/04/2022 14:18

"They fuck you up, your mum and dad"...

Try to get over it. My parents have never called me amazing. I don't know anyone's parents who did that. I think you have unreasonable expectations there. I agree with PP that we get too caught up in introspection sometimes.

mycatisannoying · 27/04/2022 14:08

With respect, I think you should try and get over it.
Most of us are fucked up in one way or another by our parents.
All we can do is make it better for our own kids!

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 27/04/2022 14:05

We were quite poor growing up, so never got showered with gifts. So my experience of being shown love by my dad is very different to yours. My dads way was slogging his guts out so we could have a camping holiday every year.

Not that I'm complaining. Some of my fondest childhood memories are from those times.

But it does seem like you are doing too much navel gazing about this. I really think you are giving this too much headspace.

Porcupineintherough · 27/04/2022 13:44

Testina · 27/04/2022 13:18

Sounds like you’re blaming your dad rather than taking ownership of your own personality / issues.

^This.

Testina · 27/04/2022 13:39

@XDownwiththissortofthingX
”I honestly think that we're guilty of an inordinately pompous amount of introspection as a species, and many people spend far too much time invested in psychobabble, get caught up in touchy-feely nonsense, and would be far better if they just stopped it and got on with their lives.”

SO MUCH THIS 👏🏻

Watchkeys · 27/04/2022 13:34

Blame him, yes, if you want to. We can all find someone to blame for why we are who we are. But blame looks backwards. Whilst you are blaming, you are essentially allowing the person you are blaming to be in control of your today.

Who/what you blame is an irrelevance to how you move forward. Make the definition between blame, which looks backwards, and responsibility, which looks forwards. Who is responsible for your next action/feeling? Is it you, or is it your dad? Once you get to grips with this, you'll step into being responsible for yourself, and you'll step into all the joys of being in charge of your own life.

steff13 · 27/04/2022 13:34

roseii · 27/04/2022 13:23

I 100% appreciate that there's going to be loads of people thinking 'he sounds great compared to mine' and this wasn't me coming on here to make it seem like I've had a hard time at all! I'm just interested to see if anyone in a similar family can relate or not.

I resent the fact he spoilt me rotten to show me love (I forgot this in the original post which is annoying) I openly admit I expect too much from my partner in terms of money as this was drilled into me from young that mum says she loves you and dad buys you everything you want. It's made me spoilt and has made adult life tougher as I know it's wrong to expect anything from anyone and will be sure to try my best to teach dd that daddy loves her without buying gifts.

I have a similar issue with being spoiled. I've never blamed my dad, though. I'm an adult, have been for a long time. My spoiled-ness is 100% my problem to solve at this point.

Gowithme · 27/04/2022 13:33

I don't think it sounds particularly unusual unfortunately. That doesn't mean it's not at the root of your issue though, people put their experiences together in all sorts of different ways and are all affected differently. My father never complimented me and I'm uncomfortable with compliments from men too, but I'm very affectionate (he never was). I think more important though is to work on the things you want to change, if you want to be more affectionate to your partner than perhaps start with some very small steps, the more you do it the more natural it will become. If he compliments you then tell yourself you deserve it!

steff13 · 27/04/2022 13:30

I think it sounds like a fairly typical upbringing of the time. Your dad showed you love in the way he felt comfortable or the best way he knew how.

As far as your daughter goes, that's how it is with grandparents, isn't it? Being a parent is rewarding but it's a job, too. A grandparent's only responsibility is to love the child. He probably is finding it easier or less stressful than being a parent.

Comedycook · 27/04/2022 13:30

Your dad obviously showed that he loved you by buying you material things. A lot of older men I think saw their role as fathers as providing and bringing home the bacon. Mum's did the rest!

roseii · 27/04/2022 13:25

Also just to say, I love my dad dearly and this isn't a post to attack him. I'm just curious.

Thank you everyone for your helpful replies. It all helps for me to put into perspective.

OP posts:
roseii · 27/04/2022 13:23

I 100% appreciate that there's going to be loads of people thinking 'he sounds great compared to mine' and this wasn't me coming on here to make it seem like I've had a hard time at all! I'm just interested to see if anyone in a similar family can relate or not.

I resent the fact he spoilt me rotten to show me love (I forgot this in the original post which is annoying) I openly admit I expect too much from my partner in terms of money as this was drilled into me from young that mum says she loves you and dad buys you everything you want. It's made me spoilt and has made adult life tougher as I know it's wrong to expect anything from anyone and will be sure to try my best to teach dd that daddy loves her without buying gifts.

OP posts:
Toloveandtowork · 27/04/2022 13:22

Doesn't this sort of thing get passed down the generations? So maybe, while lacking in some way (like most of us) your father did his best in his own way.
I'm just not sure blaming our parents, pinning it on them, is the healthiest way to see this, for you and for him.
Maybe therapy where you can talk about it would help you.

axolotlfloof · 27/04/2022 13:22

It sounds like you had a positive upbringing and your Dad did his best, by the standards of the time.
If you need to work on your self esteem that's a good idea, but I think it's a bit unfair to blame your Dad for being a very normal Dad.
Parenting standards, and life, are very different now, so it's not surprising your DP is closer to your DD, than your Dad was with you.

Donkeyinamanger · 27/04/2022 13:20

Your Dad doesn't sound like a perfect parent, but honestly, are any of us? He doesn't sound like he has done anything massively damaging.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 27/04/2022 13:20

I can, kinda...

My mother was an absolute horror. Cold, emotionally distant, quick to anger, looked for any excuse to berate me, couldn't bring herself to show any interest in me, never praised me for achievements but was never shy in voicing her opinion when she thought I was falling short, and wasn't slow to raise her hands to me either.

Father was far warmer and more balanced, but wasn't a hugger and never stood up to my mother even when it was apparent he disagreed and believed she was being unreasonable.

For that reason I never really had all that close a relationship with either of them. I have a far more sympathetic view of my father than my mother, but the fact he stood by and watched her act like a tyrant, play blatant favourites, and repeatedly fail at being a human being still makes me stop short of feeling anything like genuine affection for him.

As an adult I don't have any time at all for emotionality and spirituality. I just see them as needless human folly. Things like romance, open declarations of affection, people who feel the need to profess their love and expect the same back, all of it just makes me roll my eyes as I honestly can't see the point of it or understand the apparent need for it. If any of that is down to my parents I don't know, but I suspect it's just who I am in all honesty. I have been accused in the past of 'not being able to express my emotions', whatever that means, but I honestly don't see it like that at all. I find most other people ridiculously overly emotional and fickle, and I don't understand at all why some people endlessly want to talk about 'feelings' and 'emotions'. I don't feel any need whatsoever to do that, and yet I'm still a reasonably happy, functional, and fulfilled adult.

I honestly think that we're guilty of an inordinately pompous amount of introspection as a species, and many people spend far too much time invested in psychobabble, get caught up in touchy-feely nonsense, and would be far better if they just stopped it and got on with their lives.

WildCoasts · 27/04/2022 13:19

I've never been called beautiful or amazing by my father. My mother made sure I knew my sister was the pretty one. I don't know anyone who was, to my knowledge. It sounds like your father was fine to me. Maybe not as physically affectionate as you'd have liked but that might be just who how he is. Honestly, your father sounds a lot easier than mine.

roseii · 27/04/2022 13:18

@Fairyliz thanks for your reply, I think this is it. That it was so 'normal' for the affection to be left to the mums. My dad is very much from this generation and I think he never felt it necessary to give me affection. (His own parents weren't affectionate, mum or dad) so he never learnt this either.

He used to shower me in presents and money as his way of showing me he cared. After I turned 18 this all stopped and he still helped out if I needed help with money but stopped 'showering' me in gifts. I think this was a hit because the only way he showed me love was by buying me things and that stopped! (This isn't me being spoilt just explaining why it felt strange to no longer be bought gifts) I see this as a way of men showing love which I know is wrong.

Maybe its been bought up recently as he is much more affectionate to my dd than he ever was me. Maybe he's just changing with the times!

OP posts: