Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that Amber Heard is not representative of the BPD community

61 replies

MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 11:53

Waking up to dozens of armchair psychologists on social media gleefully announcing that A.H's recent BPD diagnosis explains her abuse of Johnny Depp.

I have BPD. I have never hit my partners, current or past. I have never caused anybody to lose a finger. I have never shit on an exs bed, or encouraged my friends to do so. I'm not a nasty person and I don't belittle people. I'm nothing like A.H.

Nobody is talking about the histrionic personality disorder she has been diagnosed with, just the BPD. Apparently the BPD is the reason for all of this and that's case closed.

So now an already stigmatised condition is going to be even more stigmatised, and those of us with BPD that stems from childhood trauma are going to be further demonised for just existing.

Lovely.

We do not claim A.H and she is not representative of the BPD community.

OP posts:
MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 12:22

I've heard the recordings of Amber admitting to hitting Johnny, belittling him afterwards and saying he's being a baby about it, downplaying it as just a "hit" and not a punch etc. That itself is pretty concrete evidence that she has been an aggressor but then those recordings were very tactical, as were the ones she made of him slamming cabinets etc and who knows what goes on when the recordings stop.

I don't think any of what went on between them is due to any supposed BPD.

It's just so frustrating to see so many people saying it's a clear cut case of her being abusive because she has BPD and the BPD explains it perfectly when it doesn't, not at all.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 27/04/2022 12:20

Heard has nothing been officially diagnosed with anything. Is that not correct?

50ShadesOfCatholic · 27/04/2022 12:16

MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 11:53

Waking up to dozens of armchair psychologists on social media gleefully announcing that A.H's recent BPD diagnosis explains her abuse of Johnny Depp.

I have BPD. I have never hit my partners, current or past. I have never caused anybody to lose a finger. I have never shit on an exs bed, or encouraged my friends to do so. I'm not a nasty person and I don't belittle people. I'm nothing like A.H.

Nobody is talking about the histrionic personality disorder she has been diagnosed with, just the BPD. Apparently the BPD is the reason for all of this and that's case closed.

So now an already stigmatised condition is going to be even more stigmatised, and those of us with BPD that stems from childhood trauma are going to be further demonised for just existing.

Lovely.

We do not claim A.H and she is not representative of the BPD community.

To be fair, there is no proof that AH has done any of these things either.

KitBumbleB · 27/04/2022 12:14

The Dr also spent 4 hours having dinner with Depp before we even met Heard. She can't possibly claim to be completely impartial.

MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 12:14

beachcitygirl · 27/04/2022 12:13

Exactly. It's a horrific shit show. I've been reading Dr Jess Taylor's take on twitter. You know the author of "why women get Blamed for everything"
She's analysing everything said through a feminist lens.
Worth reading .
She's on twitter @drjesstaylor

Thanks I'll take a look now

OP posts:
beachcitygirl · 27/04/2022 12:13

Exactly. It's a horrific shit show. I've been reading Dr Jess Taylor's take on twitter. You know the author of "why women get Blamed for everything"
She's analysing everything said through a feminist lens.
Worth reading .
She's on twitter @drjesstaylor

MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 12:08

beachcitygirl · 27/04/2022 12:06

Psychiatry is just patriarchy with a prescription pad.

This doctor for rent isn't even board certified, has "diagnosed" heard with bpd & the made up disease "histrionic disorder" and she met her once by zoom for 15 mins.

Depp's lawyers paid her to say what she's saying.

I don't believe a word of it.

Amber heard is being punished by media & experts for daring to criticise a beloved male.

The misogyny on display makes me want to vomit.

15 minutes on zoom?

Well that undermines everything she has said then, you can't diagnose somebody you've never met based on 15 minutes of a video call. What the hell

OP posts:
beachcitygirl · 27/04/2022 12:06

Psychiatry is just patriarchy with a prescription pad.

This doctor for rent isn't even board certified, has "diagnosed" heard with bpd & the made up disease "histrionic disorder" and she met her once by zoom for 15 mins.

Depp's lawyers paid her to say what she's saying.

I don't believe a word of it.

Amber heard is being punished by media & experts for daring to criticise a beloved male.

The misogyny on display makes me want to vomit.

MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 12:04

LaingsAcidTab · 27/04/2022 12:00

I agree with you that violence isn't an indicated behaviour with BPD, and I agree that many people are going to jump to the wrong generalisations about those with BPD.

But Amber Heard does have BPD and shouldn't be further alienated by barring her from a diagnosis that now has a very good record of treatment thanks to DBT and other interventions.

I'm not barring her from a diagnosis, just (perhaps in a clumsy way) saying that those of us with BPD do not associate ourselves to the sort of behaviour she has displayed in her relationship with Johnny Depp.

I don't like how her diagnosis is being used to explain the behaviour, almost a case of "well she has BPD and that's why she's done all of these horrible things and abused her husband"

I hope she does get the help she needs, it's just a shame it comes at the expense of everybody else with the condition who now have to deal with being compared to her - alot of whom don't have the funds or connections to access the therapy they desperately need.

OP posts:
LaingsAcidTab · 27/04/2022 12:00

I agree with you that violence isn't an indicated behaviour with BPD, and I agree that many people are going to jump to the wrong generalisations about those with BPD.

But Amber Heard does have BPD and shouldn't be further alienated by barring her from a diagnosis that now has a very good record of treatment thanks to DBT and other interventions.

Kat1953 · 27/04/2022 11:56

Although I don't have BPD, I know people who do and I agree with you wholeheartedly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread