Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that Amber Heard is not representative of the BPD community

61 replies

MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 11:53

Waking up to dozens of armchair psychologists on social media gleefully announcing that A.H's recent BPD diagnosis explains her abuse of Johnny Depp.

I have BPD. I have never hit my partners, current or past. I have never caused anybody to lose a finger. I have never shit on an exs bed, or encouraged my friends to do so. I'm not a nasty person and I don't belittle people. I'm nothing like A.H.

Nobody is talking about the histrionic personality disorder she has been diagnosed with, just the BPD. Apparently the BPD is the reason for all of this and that's case closed.

So now an already stigmatised condition is going to be even more stigmatised, and those of us with BPD that stems from childhood trauma are going to be further demonised for just existing.

Lovely.

We do not claim A.H and she is not representative of the BPD community.

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 27/04/2022 14:15

Wonder what Johnny Depp’s diagnosis would be.

Amber Heard may or may not have BPD. I’m not sure a diagnosis by a psychiatrist hired by her ex husband is necessarily going to be particularly trustworthy, however.

Autumndays123 · 27/04/2022 14:15

What a strange thread. Are you saying that some of the potential symptoms of BPD are not that which have been outlined in the trial? Violence, aggression, attention seeking etc? I think you'd have to be quite naive to think that every single person experiences every single symptom of every single illness. BPD manifests in a number of ways and in AH's case, she abuses partners and those closest to her - I need not remind you that JD is not the only partner she has abused and if my memory serves me correctly, she has once been caught in a lie where she claimed to have been raped but actually told someone else's story?

It's difficult to decipher whether JD is an abuser because unfortunately, AH has told so many lies that it is now difficult to separate the lies from the truth and that is a real shame.

What is unquestionable however is that AH is an abuser, in her relationship with JD, in her earlier relationships and almost certainly will be in her later relationships.

Also echo a PPs comment about Dr Curry not be certified, the people that are using this as an argument really are embarrassing themselves with their ignorance.

ArianaDumbledore · 27/04/2022 13:45

MissCrowley · 27/04/2022 13:31

A-fucking-Men OP.
That woman's is vile and I feel this is a way to get her off the hook. I have friends with BPD and they'd never do anything that AH has done.

It's to dispute AHs claim of PTSD following the relationship, not to "get her off the hook".

ApertureGLaDOS · 27/04/2022 13:41

MissCrowley · 27/04/2022 13:31

A-fucking-Men OP.
That woman's is vile and I feel this is a way to get her off the hook. I have friends with BPD and they'd never do anything that AH has done.

Why would Depp's paid-for psychiatrist make up a diagnosis of BPD to 'get her off the hook'?

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 27/04/2022 13:40

MissCrowley · 27/04/2022 13:31

A-fucking-Men OP.
That woman's is vile and I feel this is a way to get her off the hook. I have friends with BPD and they'd never do anything that AH has done.

I agree. There's tapes of her abusing JD and people still try and paint her as the victim. She isn't an abuser because of her mental disorder, she's just an abuser.

TigerLilyTail · 27/04/2022 13:32

Having looked up Borderline Personality Disorder a lot of it does seem to ring true for Amber, especially the intense fear of abandonment and inappropriate, intense anger and difficulty controling anger.

I get that not all people with BPD act this way, but it doesn’t seem unusual.

MissCrowley · 27/04/2022 13:31

A-fucking-Men OP.
That woman's is vile and I feel this is a way to get her off the hook. I have friends with BPD and they'd never do anything that AH has done.

LaingsAcidTab · 27/04/2022 13:30

MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 12:45

I have an ex who was terribly abusive, he definitely didn't have BPD.

Years later when DV came up in conversation the person I was talking to suggested that he probably had BPD, as though having the condition explains somebody terrorising their partner.

I'm gutted that people will think of me that way, based on my condition alone, when I have never hurt anybody in my life.

I agree I think it's important to make a clear distinction between a diagnosis, and then where the responsibility lies for that person's behaviour. You can have BPD and be abusive; you can have BPD and not be abusive. You can also end up damaging people because of a personality disorder or your psychopathology in the same way that a wounded dog will tend to attack those who approach it. It doesn't excuse inexcusable behaviour, but it does explain it.

LaingsAcidTab · 27/04/2022 13:25

beachcitygirl · 27/04/2022 12:06

Psychiatry is just patriarchy with a prescription pad.

This doctor for rent isn't even board certified, has "diagnosed" heard with bpd & the made up disease "histrionic disorder" and she met her once by zoom for 15 mins.

Depp's lawyers paid her to say what she's saying.

I don't believe a word of it.

Amber heard is being punished by media & experts for daring to criticise a beloved male.

The misogyny on display makes me want to vomit.

I'll disagree here because I find that women are often declared faultless in cases like this when the unpalatable truth is that both parties bear the weight of different responsibilities.

beachcitygirl · 27/04/2022 13:18

@Newrunner29 Dr Curry gave depps lawyers the diagnosis after one 15 minute zoom call. PRE- meeting heard. It's in the transcripts.

BabyofMine · 27/04/2022 13:07

I have no opinion on the topic BUT I have to point out “not board certified” is a ridiculous criticism and the lawyers were embarrassing marking a big deal of that.
Less than 4% of psychologists in the USA are board certified, it’s not standard or a requirement. The psychologist is qualified, licensed, and very experienced. To be casting doubt on her qualification is horrible.

This is her website: currypsychology.com/therapist/dr-shannon-curry/

Newrunner29 · 27/04/2022 13:02

Muffin gate I'm referring to a point when AD lawyer kept trying to say the witness told her husband who her Client was , as she mentioned her husband brought her some muffins , she explains that she buys muffins for the office regularly and he picked them up that morning as she was running late, but was picked up because she said something like ill explain so u can stop asking about the muffins .

Newrunner29 · 27/04/2022 12:57

beachcitygirl · 27/04/2022 12:06

Psychiatry is just patriarchy with a prescription pad.

This doctor for rent isn't even board certified, has "diagnosed" heard with bpd & the made up disease "histrionic disorder" and she met her once by zoom for 15 mins.

Depp's lawyers paid her to say what she's saying.

I don't believe a word of it.

Amber heard is being punished by media & experts for daring to criticise a beloved male.

The misogyny on display makes me want to vomit.

In the case she said she interviewed her for 10/12 hours cannot remember exact number! And she was definitely not in zoom call because of the while muffingate, she can hardly give her muffins while on a zoom call !

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 27/04/2022 12:53

What bugs me is how people are attributing all of her negative behaviour to the BPD

If that's what some people are doing, then yes, that's not what I would view as entirely objective, but then, you have to ask yourself if her behaviours are typical of a normal, healthy, well-adjusted individual, and if not, wonder if perhaps there is an underlying reason for them.

From what I know of her, she has not had a happy or straightforward life to this point. This is something that is also common in people with an actual BPD diagnosis, so, combined with her documented behaviours, I think it's reasonable to conclude that perhaps the psychiatrist isn't far off in her(?) conclusion.

To say that ALL of her behaviours are undoubtedly due to BPD I don't think is entirely reasonable, because she's a damaged individual who absolutely has been the victim of abuse in her past, so there will be behaviours typical of traumatised individuals. Living with Depp and his substance issues will not have been a walk in the park, so there will be parts of her behaviour that would be similar to any individual who found themselves in that particular situation, but then there are the really odd, and I mean really, really odd behaviours that aren't easily explained by anything other than one or more pre-existing personality disorders, so I also think it's fair if people want to explore and discuss that.

ArianaDumbledore · 27/04/2022 12:49

YABU

Whatever you feelings on Amber Heard are, it was Johnny Depp that engaged the therapist and there is nothing to suggest Amber Heard agrees with the diagnosis. Quite likely not as AH had allegedly said she had PTSD, but this therapist disagrees and instead says BPD and Histrionics Disorder.

I can't imagine I'd feel too great at having a diagnosis made by a therapist engaged by an ex partner., so she is probably less pleased than you.

MissusMaisel · 27/04/2022 12:46

Your point is invalid anyway. NOONE is representative of the BPD community, otr any community. The idea that you can make any judgement about a person based on knowing some slight thing about another person who may or may not have the same named condition as another person is bizarre and ridiculous.

Why would you feel the need to arbitrarily align yourself with this person only to so rudely distrance yourself, when you know nothing about her or her life?

MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 12:45

I have an ex who was terribly abusive, he definitely didn't have BPD.

Years later when DV came up in conversation the person I was talking to suggested that he probably had BPD, as though having the condition explains somebody terrorising their partner.

I'm gutted that people will think of me that way, based on my condition alone, when I have never hurt anybody in my life.

OP posts:
Thatswhyimacat · 27/04/2022 12:44

Unless Heard has a diagnosis from her own doctors, not one being paid by the legal team of her ex-husband, then anything said about her should be treated with extreme skepticism.

MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 12:40

I know what you're saying about the autistic stereotyping and I agree, my partner and son are both autistic and the stereotyping drives OH up the wall.

I do appreciate that some individuals with BPD can be abusive and manipulative, as can people without the diagnosis. What bugs me is how people are attributing all of her negative behaviour to the BPD.

OP posts:
ManAlive24 · 27/04/2022 12:34

I know someone with BPD who is exactly like Amber Heard. Lies through her teeth, manipulative, obsessive, needs to be the centre of attention, violent to partners. Not everyone is like that, but some are.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 27/04/2022 12:34

I don't think anyone is claiming she's 'representative of the BPD community', first of all because there's no such thing, being that individuals with this diagnosis are just that, individuals, and as distinct from each other as any other group of random individuals, but also because this is a back-to-front representation of the points they are making.

I happen to know a couple of friends with BPD, and both have, from time to time, indulged in behaviours that are eerily similar to what has emerged about Amber Heard. Am I surprised by the psychiatrists' conclusions? Not in the slightest, because my familiarity with my BPD friends led to me immediately seeing similarities in Amber Heard. That doesn't mean that I have concluded that ALL people with a BPD diagnosis are abusive and manipulative, and I don't believe anyone else has suggested this or come to that conclusion either. Can people with a BPD diagnosis be abusive and manipulative? Yes, absolutely, I've been on the receiving end of it and have first-hand experience of it. That is not ALL they are though, and it's not something that is perpetual or constant.

I understand the frustration about stigma and stereotyping. As an autistic individual I see it frequently when it comes to my own condition. Where I differ though, is that I also frequently see autistic people becoming irate when it's suggested that a specific behaviour might be down to autism, and railing against a completely misguided notion that the person suggesting this is implying that this is what defines Autism. I've had to step in and point out to some autistic people that yes, we absolutely can be obnoxious, rude, heartless, unthinking, lacking in empathy, and a downright nightmare to be around. Why do I do this? Mainly because I can be like this because of my autism, but also because it's just as stigmatising and incorrect to see other autistic people utterly denying that some of us can be like this.

People without autism are perfectly capable of acting like twats, so it's nonsense to suggest that autistic people are somehow incapable of it. Some BPD people are also perfectly capable of behaving horrendously, but that doesn't mean all of them are, or that it's inevitably the case when someone has that diagnosis.

EdgeOfSeventeenAndThreeQuarter · 27/04/2022 12:34

Not sure where this 15 minute idea came from. The expert witness met with AH twice in December of last year for “several hours”. She stated as much in her testimony.

TheKeatingFive · 27/04/2022 12:28

All I know is that she has been labelled as having BPD and now social media is up in arms slagging off people with BPD.

SM is an absolute dumpster fire with regards to this whole trial. All we can hope to do is ignore its fuckwittery.

TheKeatingFive · 27/04/2022 12:26

Apparently she has, by Curry.

I really doubt that would have any legitimacy whatsoever

MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 12:23

TheKeatingFive · 27/04/2022 12:20

Heard has nothing been officially diagnosed with anything. Is that not correct?

Apparently she has, by Curry.

I don't know how legitimate that diagnosis is or whether she's even able to make it given that she's not board certified as noted by PP.

All I know is that she has been labelled as having BPD and now social media is up in arms slagging off people with BPD.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread