Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that Amber Heard is not representative of the BPD community

61 replies

MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 11:53

Waking up to dozens of armchair psychologists on social media gleefully announcing that A.H's recent BPD diagnosis explains her abuse of Johnny Depp.

I have BPD. I have never hit my partners, current or past. I have never caused anybody to lose a finger. I have never shit on an exs bed, or encouraged my friends to do so. I'm not a nasty person and I don't belittle people. I'm nothing like A.H.

Nobody is talking about the histrionic personality disorder she has been diagnosed with, just the BPD. Apparently the BPD is the reason for all of this and that's case closed.

So now an already stigmatised condition is going to be even more stigmatised, and those of us with BPD that stems from childhood trauma are going to be further demonised for just existing.

Lovely.

We do not claim A.H and she is not representative of the BPD community.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheSillyMastiff · 27/04/2022 18:27

I work with service users who have a array of mental health diagnosis.

Some with BPD are non violent offenders some with BPD are violent offenders.

BPD is a sliding scale in my experience.

She does fit a BPD diagnosis, but I wouldn't then shoe horn everyone who has BPD in to the same "behaviours" because that isn't how BPD works, and it's definitely not my experience of working with people who have BPD.

Past trauma also effects how people with BPD frame/exhibit their behaviours so again it's not a one shoe fits all whatsoever.

But I agree OP many people don't understand the condition and are pretending it's now "proof". It's proof of nothing in my opinion.

User280905 · 27/04/2022 18:21

It's just so frustrating to see so many people saying it's a clear cut case of her being abusive because she has BPD and the BPD explains it perfectly when it doesn't, not at all

I hear you op. Sorry if this has upset you. I can understand why.

MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 18:15

Has Amber took to the stand at all? I haven't been following the case closely but every clip I see it's either Johnny or other witnesses. I haven't seen her speak yet?

OP posts:
Teddah · 27/04/2022 17:56

Allthecheeseplease · 27/04/2022 16:13

@beachcitygirl

Histrionic Personality Disorder is in the DSM 5.

Are you a mental health professional?

Women are also perpetrators of abuse.

I find the anti-psychiatry crowd to be unwilling to listen to any other opinions. They’re after an echo chamber.
There certainly is a problem with the psychiatric approach, especially to women and some other minorities. Black men, for example, are disproportionately diagnosed with psychotic disorders. I do not believe anyone would ruin their own career - a prestigious one at that - for Johnny Depp.

MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 17:23

gogohm · 27/04/2022 16:54

Mental health conditions and autism are never an excuse for bad behaviour, end of. My dd has autism and bpd I've never allowed her to use them as a reason for being bad

You're right, they're not excuses for bad behaviour.

They're also not exclusively the reason for bad behaviour, in those who have the conditions.

OP posts:
gogohm · 27/04/2022 16:54

Mental health conditions and autism are never an excuse for bad behaviour, end of. My dd has autism and bpd I've never allowed her to use them as a reason for being bad

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 27/04/2022 16:44

Women are also perpetrators of abuse.

This is fundamental for people to acknowledge. It's not just women who are victims. Men can be also.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 27/04/2022 16:42

Well of course it's obvious why. But it's bizarre to be angry at someone causing stigma because their ex's therapist has diagnosed them with it!

Oh I completely understand you now! I thought you meant you couldn't understand why the legal team have asked for her to evaluate AH, sorry I've seen many comments on other forums/medias saying that and misunderstood your comment.

Emmelina · 27/04/2022 16:17

Of course not. But bear in mind she was diagnosed after her relationship with Johnny ended, therefore she wasn’t on medication or having therapy with BPD in mind. From what I can tell, she was self-medicating with alcohol.

Allthecheeseplease · 27/04/2022 16:13

beachcitygirl · 27/04/2022 12:06

Psychiatry is just patriarchy with a prescription pad.

This doctor for rent isn't even board certified, has "diagnosed" heard with bpd & the made up disease "histrionic disorder" and she met her once by zoom for 15 mins.

Depp's lawyers paid her to say what she's saying.

I don't believe a word of it.

Amber heard is being punished by media & experts for daring to criticise a beloved male.

The misogyny on display makes me want to vomit.

@beachcitygirl

Histrionic Personality Disorder is in the DSM 5.

Are you a mental health professional?

Women are also perpetrators of abuse.

countofmontecrispo · 27/04/2022 16:00

I think there’s a lack of understanding of the expert witness role here.

Whilst Depp’s legal team instructed Dr Curry, her responsibilities are ultimately to assist the court. She will receive payment whatever the outcome of the case. Whilst it’s possible for there to be bias depending on what side instructs you, if there’s clear evidence of this, an expert could themselves find themselves with a custodial sentence and their professional reputation trashed. It’s really not something many professionals would risk.

Dr Curry met with Heard for many hours for interview and conducted many psychometric tests. She would also have had access to all Heard’s medical and therapy records before even meeting her, so it is perfectly possible that she had a provisional opinion that Heard had a personality disorder before they met (& btw Histrionic Personality Disorder is a formal diagnosis, not a ‘made up thing’). Personality Disorders are also sometimes referred to as ‘Complex Trauma’ in the UK, as most people with these symptoms / attributes have abusive / traumatic histories.

I don’t agree with much of what Dr Curry said, but I think she did a very good job as an expert witness.

ArianaDumbledore · 27/04/2022 16:00

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 27/04/2022 15:56

Well of course his legal team would hire someone to dispute that. That's just common sense from their side.

Well of course it's obvious why. But it's bizarre to be angry at someone causing stigma because their ex's therapist has diagnosed them with it!

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 27/04/2022 15:56

ArianaDumbledore · 27/04/2022 15:22

But you're just going to ignore the fact it's a therapist engaged by her ex-husband to dispute the claim they're relationship caused her to develop PTSD?

Well of course his legal team would hire someone to dispute that. That's just common sense from their side.

MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 15:55

Coincidentally substance misuse is also recognised as a symptom of BPD and its Johnny with the substance misuse issues. It would be interesting to see that raised in cross examination.

If a woman has previous trauma and has problems with interpersonal relationships = BPD

If a man has previous trauma and engages in self harming behaviours in the shape of drug and alcohol abuse = ???

It is a bit of a misogynistic diagnosis to throw about, and it is thrown about.

Anyway, I don't know whether she has BPD or not but it's so offensive to see (not necessarily here, but on other social media) that the diagnosis is the reason for the abuse.

I asked my OH today whether he thinks I'm in any way abusive or intimidating, he said categorically not. He added that the only woman he has ever felt intimidated by, was his ex, who hit him and did not have BPD.

I, a woman with BPD, am less of a risk to my partner and children than his ex who had no mental health issues.

Similarly with my ex, he abused me and he didn't have BPD.

Some will have you believe, because they believe, that you should run for the hills if somebody you're dating has BPD (now that is something I have seen on mumsnet!) and it's such a cruel generalisation.

This vilification of Amber that has suddenly gone down the BPD route is perpetuating the alienation of the thousands of us, pretty nice people, with BPD.

Hate her behaviour, dislike her as a person, just please don't claim its because of that condition.

Autism, schizophrenia etc are also massively stigmatised and that has to stop too.

Judge people on an individual basis, not on a diagnosis.

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 27/04/2022 15:41

Autumndays123 · 27/04/2022 14:19

Have you read anything about Dr Curry? She's hardly a person they've dragged off the streets 😂 she's a well respected professional in her circle, sits on advisory boards and conducts related research in top academic institutions

I’m sure she is. She’s also hired by Johnny Depp 🤷🏻‍♀️

Not entirely sure to what degree it matters whether Amber Heard has BPD or not. The trial isn’t to determine whether she’s an abuser, it’s to determine whether he is. She may indeed be an abuser, but that doesn’t mean he isn’t also one.

CareBearsCare · 27/04/2022 15:36

Yanbu to be angry that many people stereotype people with ND or MH issues based on their knowledge of one person. For example not all people with autism lack empathy.

AH will have an expert come up with a diagnosis for Depp too.

ArianaDumbledore · 27/04/2022 15:22

But you're just going to ignore the fact it's a therapist engaged by her ex-husband to dispute the claim they're relationship caused her to develop PTSD?

ApertureGLaDOS · 27/04/2022 15:20

@MissCrowley I can understand the mix up. This case is already really confusing.

I agree with OP as it should happen about the vilification of mental health disorders and if anything, I'm not sure why more anger isn't directed at JD's legal team. They will be very aware the stigma certain personality disorders/ mental health conditions still hold and I can only assume they are taking the angle that a) it can't be PTSD because it's actually 2 personality disorders and b) because she has those personality disorders it's almost 'pre-destined' that she would be abusive. I think it's disgusting that they are trying to use personality disorders to discredit her and exploiting that stigma to make their case.

MissCrowley · 27/04/2022 15:06

@ApertureGLaDOS my fault for not reading the full thread in its entirety. I assumed it was her psychiatrist giving the diagnosis not JDs.
Next time I'll RTFT

MoreStigma · 27/04/2022 14:51

What a strange thread. Are you saying that some of the potential symptoms of BPD are not that which have been outlined in the trial?

Strange, really?

Anyway no. That's not what I'm saying.

What I'm saying is, having BPD doesn't mean somebody is going to abuse their spouse and Amber's alleged BPD isn't the reason she has been abusive towards people.

You can be a shitty person and not have BPD. BPD doesn't make you a shitty person as is implied by alot of people in general.

I spent 10 minutes scrolling through social media this morning and came across multiple posts from people very gleefully announcing that:

  • They could tell she had BPD from how abusive she has been.
  • The BPD diagnosis explains her being abusive

^ just two examples among many.

Such statements and attitudes are harmful and having BPD given as the reason somebody is abusive is completely out of order.

The stigma stinks. There are so many of us that don't behave in an abusive way, yet are assumed to, because of the stigma.

Her BPD is being trumpeted as the reason she has been abusive and that's not on.

OP posts:
Newrunner29 · 27/04/2022 14:42

beachcitygirl · 27/04/2022 13:18

@Newrunner29 Dr Curry gave depps lawyers the diagnosis after one 15 minute zoom call. PRE- meeting heard. It's in the transcripts.

The statements that ah lawyer was referring to wasn't written by the witness but lawyers if that's what u r referring to. In her testimony she stated she had video/witness to come to conclusions as well as seeing her for I think 10 hours and done extensive testing. She clearly meet her as she gave her a muffin so no idea where u are getting 15 mins zoom call from

TheKeatingFive · 27/04/2022 14:39

What relationship? He employed her as an expert witness in a trial

he knew her.

I mean, why would anyone find a diagnosis from a doctor of their ex husbands choosing to be a preferable approach? When there are many other options out there.

Autumndays123 · 27/04/2022 14:36

TheKeatingFive · 27/04/2022 14:30

She's hardly a person they've dragged off the streets 😂 she's a well respected professional in her circle, sits on advisory boards and conducts related research in top academic institutions

I don't know why that would negate the PP points. She's the choice of/has a relationship with Amber's ex husband. No one would find that an ideal set up for a neutral diagnosis I don't think.

What relationship? He employed her as an expert witness in a trial, that happens in practically every trial. It's embarrassing what a limited understanding of court cases the general public have

TheKeatingFive · 27/04/2022 14:30

She's hardly a person they've dragged off the streets 😂 she's a well respected professional in her circle, sits on advisory boards and conducts related research in top academic institutions

I don't know why that would negate the PP points. She's the choice of/has a relationship with Amber's ex husband. No one would find that an ideal set up for a neutral diagnosis I don't think.

Autumndays123 · 27/04/2022 14:19

whumpthereitis · 27/04/2022 14:15

Wonder what Johnny Depp’s diagnosis would be.

Amber Heard may or may not have BPD. I’m not sure a diagnosis by a psychiatrist hired by her ex husband is necessarily going to be particularly trustworthy, however.

Have you read anything about Dr Curry? She's hardly a person they've dragged off the streets 😂 she's a well respected professional in her circle, sits on advisory boards and conducts related research in top academic institutions

Swipe left for the next trending thread