Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why having an elective C-Section is so frowned upon?

663 replies

Rosesandbutterflys · 27/04/2022 11:50

I am (hopefully) having an elective C-Section soon. First baby, don't want anymore children after.

I've always had a fear of child birth, which over the past 5 years has been compounded by a lot of people around me having children and the vast majority of these (though I appreciate I'm probably unlucky here) have been pretty traumatic births that have ended in severe tears, forceps and a lot of the time, an emergency section anyway. Granted their experiences have mostly been better on their second birth/ child.

Nothing and I truly mean nothing about natural childbirth/ labour appeals to me. Not the hours of pain, pushing, potential rips/ tears, forcep intervention, epidural (yes I appreciate I'd have one of these for a section), damage of my pelvic floor and the panic and stress of potentially having to be rushed to theatre because it just wasn't going to happen naturally and the baby is in distress or whatever.

Now don't get me wrong, nothing about a c-section appeals to me either, it's absolutely no walk in the park and I'm dreading it, but it has to come out some way and I am a person that likes to plan things and to somewhat be in control/ aware of the plan. I have also had abdominal surgery before (though not as severe as a C-section) and I know recovery is likely to be painful and slower than if I were to have a natural birth. But for me, this is the preferred/ lesser of the 2 evils option.

I have also spent hours pouring over research as to the benefits of a vaginal birth over a c-section and last night came across a NICE/ NHS study/ research that found that actually, for a planned/ elective c-section, the risk to the mother of a c-section compared to a vaginal birth is pretty much the same. It states that the risk of the baby ending up in NICU with a C-section is 13.9% compared to a vaginal birth which is 6.3%, so double the risk, BUT it says the research does not take into account the fact that most c-sections undertaken are for medical reasons and therefore the likelihood of the baby needing NICU attention after it's born is increased anyway.

It then went on to say that the risks of an unplanned, emergency C-Section are a lot higher than a natural birth/ elective/ planned C-Section. So I guess if each woman was guaranteed to have a straightforward, natural birth, then great, but a lot of women do end up needing an emergency c-section so, technically they are more at risk than someone who has chosen an elective.

This now seems like I am bashing natural delivery and I'm not at all I totally admire and respect women that chose that route, I only wish I were that brave.

However, the responses I have had from people my whole pregnancy when I have admitted I am opting for an elective C-section have been ridiculous. Not one person has responded positively, all I've had is 'Oh, really? Are you sure??' and 'Oh, why on earth would you elect to have that?' etc etc. Or just a stony faced, tight smile and 'oh right' making it clear they disapprove but not actually coming out and saying it.

I got told last night that the reason I'm getting these reactions is because a C-section is 'taking the easy way out '😕

If that's the case, why on earth wouldn't you? Why is it that it seems the prerequisite to being a good mother is seemingly having to martyr yourself all the time?

So many of my friends that have had children and also the women in my NCT class who are preparing for their births have all expressed dismay/ distress at having to have any pain relief, they all want it to be as natural as possible and I know my friends that haven't had 'textbook' births still harbour 'guilt' and sadness to this day. Why? If you need gas and air or an epidural, so what? What exactly am I missing? If they ended/end up with forceps or an emergency section, it's not their fault, it's just one of those things. Surely modern medicine has provided these things to make childbirth safer?

Anyway, gone off on a tangent now but if you disapprove of someone having an elective c-section, could you tell me why?

OP posts:
Here4theaibu · 29/04/2022 11:05

I lost a little boy at 18 weeks 2 days before lockdown. One thing I've really struggled with is the feeling of the lack of control I had while I was giving birth.
I really wanted an elective c section when I got pregnant again and ended up being talked out of it by various consultants. Baby ended up being an emergency C-section anyway after being induced and getting stuck.
Obviously recovery is no walk in the park and it is absolutely not the easy way out as some people seem to think. If we were to have another baby I would absolutely go for an elective c section.

I know you have to do what's best for your baby but I so strongly believe you have to do what is best for you as well. When i was talking to the well being midwife she said your mental health was as much a medical reason for requesting an elective c section as much as a physical one.

I will definitely be advocating for myself next time

LeeMucklowesCurtains · 29/04/2022 11:01

No, If men did it, there would have been a way to incubate a foetus outside the womb and sit on it like a chicken by now, or a way to teleport them out.

My bug bear is when you have a couple and it’s the man saying “we’ve decided against pain relief”.

Oh, we’ve decided! Do fuck off.

If I was with a man who said that, I’d chop his balls off and “we” would decide he didn’t need pain relief for the stitches.

BeatieBourke · 29/04/2022 10:52

Giving birth is dangerous and painful. If men did it, everyone would have elective sections. The idea that we are supposed to suffer, bleed, tear, endure and somehow ENJOY it is mental, and completely wrapped up in biblical/misogynist bullshit. If people want vaginal births, crack on. But the idea that having one is best just seems bonkers to me.

Ignore people telling you sections are expensive. If you compare a section to a straight forward birth with no long term impacts then yes. But how many of those exist? How much does incontinence cost the NHS? Or years of antidepressants? Or psychologists? It's bollocks.

A lot of women apparently like martyring themselves. Weirdos.

Mysteryuser · 29/04/2022 10:50

It's so true though, isn't it, that there's this strange rhetoric around natural being best when it comes to childbirth. (Although I'm in no way judging anyone who decides that that's right for them.) Surely this is the only area of medicine where this is a thing? I've never heard of anyone being judged for having a hip replacement, for example. That's hardly natural either!

Pumpkinjam · 29/04/2022 10:37

I didn’t realise elective c-sections were frowned upon? Who cares what anyone else thinks. I’m pretty sure if men had to give birth the culture around having a lovely natural, drug free labour involving dim lighting and aromatherapy would soon be over.

Fuck that…there’s a reason so many women and babies used to and still do sadly die during childbirth. Giving birth is a dangerous time for women and their babies…you should always have the right to choose whatever options modern medicine has to offer. We’re not living in the dark ages.

TheGoogleMum · 29/04/2022 10:23

Honestly if I was in your position and told you'll probably need an emergency section anyway I would definitely have an elective one. The procedure be better being planned for.
People are so judgemental of mothers

HardyBuckette · 29/04/2022 10:10

SpaghettiNotCourgetti · 29/04/2022 09:46

LOL at Ms Self Righteousness over here, electing for a further three caesareans after her first - even if they were medically necessary, your pregnancies weren't, were they? Top grade hypocrisy!

Lmao exactly. Four lots of maternity care, including three after a highly complex first delivery, obliging the NHS to continue incurring the costs of your increasingly complex obstetric career? Sit the fuck down!

Louise0701 · 29/04/2022 09:49

@SpaghettiNotCourgetti I’ve opted for all 3 csections!! They’re amazing births, very calm and lovely environment, super fast recovery, successful breastfeeding and no life long damage like some vaginal births lead to!
If I do have another child, which were still considering, I am 100% having another elective.
maybe I’m too posh to push 😂

SpaghettiNotCourgetti · 29/04/2022 09:46

Orcacrazy · 28/04/2022 21:44

I’ve had 4 c/s after my 1st at 28 weeks I wasn’t allowed to try a natural birth.
I would never have chosen a c/s .I personally think it’s selfish , cost and staff wise to the NHS.
In this post covid situation where staff levels are at an all time low an elective operation that could be avoided is selfish.
Wanting to have your body cut open layers of skin muscles (the uterus is a muscle) and tissue cut actually wanting to have the scar is incomprehensible to me.

LOL at Ms Self Righteousness over here, electing for a further three caesareans after her first - even if they were medically necessary, your pregnancies weren't, were they? Top grade hypocrisy!

missg00se · 29/04/2022 09:24

I had an emergency section after 2 days of vomiting and excruciating contractions during a failed induction. I was exhausted and in the end they had to do a section. The cord was around my daughter’s neck. It’s likely I would have died and so would my daughter had they not done the section, and I STILL have people telling me I had the easy option because I had a section.

I had such a fear of childbirth my whole life and it put me off conceiving for a long time. and then that absolutely put me off having any more. I wish I’d had the guts to push for an elective section, for my mental health.

Don’t worry about it, people are really weird when it comes to childbirth. Do what’s right for you.

Thejoyfulstar · 29/04/2022 09:19

@LunaLovegoodsNecklace those were my reasons for having an ELCS. However, some reasons that a woman might have for having an ELCS that I have dont have experience of (thankfully) is having been sexually abused or raped. I am sure that there are women who want to bypass a vaginal birth and all of its invasive procedures, in order to avoid triggering horrendous memories. These women aren't necessarily going to tell Brenda at the Post Office why they have opted for a CS. Nobody knows what is going on inside any woman mentally when she is preparing to give birth, nor the ordeals that she has faced in the past.

LuckySantangelo35 · 29/04/2022 08:36

@HoppingPavlova

Oh give over with your NHS virtue signalling! As I’ve said before, you can martyr yourself to save the NHS moneyyyy Hun, other woman can and do have the right to select an option which works for them and they are gonna take it! I think you are forgetting that we pay taxes to fund the nhs, it is not ‘free’. After years of womens health being overlooked, women are not going to sacrifice having choices to save the NHS money (crucially not that elective c sections do actually cost more money as loads of posters have explained to you)

LunaLovegoodsNecklace · 29/04/2022 08:35

For those who talk about the impact that elective sections have on the NHS should maybe çonsider the wider implications which traumatic births have on mothers, and, consequentially, babies. PTSD, difficulty bonding with the baby, difficulty establishing breastfeeding, postpartum depression/anxiety as well as some of the life-limiting physical changes which a complicated vaginal delivery may entail. Birth trauma can impact the entire family and have so many knock on effects.

This is such an important point made by @Thejoyfulstar. How depressing that good physical and mental health for women and their babies is not considered a big enough priority.

montysma1 · 29/04/2022 08:00

For heaven sake, having any kind of postnatal or antinatal care costs the NHS money. Maybe she shouldn't get pregnant at all.
Smokers cost the NHS money. Drinkers cost the NHS money. Cyclists cost the NHS money. Car drivers cost the NHS money. Everybody costs the NHS money.
If she wants a section she should have a section without the holier than thou shite.

liveforsummer · 29/04/2022 07:47

MrsJamin · 29/04/2022 07:44

I had an emergency Cs (went into labour with breech baby) and then vbac. The lasting thing about the Cs for me is the crappy not even symmetrical scar that will ensure I never have a flat or even nicely rounded belly. If I had the choice again I'd still try for a natural birth. Just speaking from personal experience.

I assume the scar is the result of emergency as my 2 scars from planned are neat and too low to affect my stomach at all. They are below any knicker/bikini line

MrsJamin · 29/04/2022 07:44

I had an emergency Cs (went into labour with breech baby) and then vbac. The lasting thing about the Cs for me is the crappy not even symmetrical scar that will ensure I never have a flat or even nicely rounded belly. If I had the choice again I'd still try for a natural birth. Just speaking from personal experience.

HardyBuckette · 29/04/2022 07:42

HoppingPavlova · 29/04/2022 03:08

The second reason is that costs persist after the births. Costs of treatment required after complications of vaginal birth and indeed of EMCS are both costs of attempted vaginal birth. They have to be part of the pot as well.

I don’t disagree with any of what you say - but you show complete ignorance in the way pots work. Everything you say is true. In an ideal world it would all work like that. Funding models though are all about people doing the best they can in the immediate term.

The analogy is funding via Govnt of the day. No Govnt pumps money into something that shows benefit down the track. They are in it for the here and now. They may not be in power down the track so why do they care what happens down the track, the MO is kick the can down the road and look as good as you can for today, so that’s spend on stuff in the immediate term to make themselves look good. In Health that translates to short sightedness. They don’t care that extra funding today will result in better outcomes down the track. All your stuff about benefits down the track is 100% correct. Well done, pat on the back, you are correct. You are not the Lone Ranger and only person to have figured this out, everyone actually knows this. The people responsible for funding don’t care though. So when budgets are handed down all that stuff for down the track doesn’t factor in. This often makes a complete mismatch with Guidelines and best practice, which do factor in a long term approach.

Then that woeful budget that lives for today is split up into buckets, those buckets are distributed out into pots. Some poor person peers over into a near empty pot and thinks how the fuck am I meant to run a department on that. This is not going to give patients the care they deserve but we will have to try and do our best to ensure the majority of people are treated adequately, recognising not all will necessarily be treated ideally because that funding does not match Guidelines etc.

Another analogy. A parent has a limited amount of cash to provide their kids food. They have 2 choices. They can buy nutritious food food that will have long term health benefits for their kids. Buying this food will mean their kids eat for 4 days. Or, they can buy cheaper crap that will feed their kids for 7 days and no doubt lead to poor outcomes down the track. If they go the nutritious food they know they will have kids crying for 3 days so they take the crap option. The parent is not proud of this and does not feel good about it but believe they have done the best they can with the choices they had. Medical care, including birth, is no different.

Lastly, a sad fact is, sometimes you know that in order to feed the child for 7 days, if something adverse results from this, then Legal has a pot they will use. Hang on, but what if you had of had the money that Legal has in their pot in your pot to begin with because ultimately it all leads back to the same bucket. You could have fed the child for 6 days at least, and there would be no need for someone to use that pot. No one who distributes buckets and pots has this common sense, so your pot will never be bigger and Legals pot smaller.

This is quite the goalpost move, and as an explanation for your views, isn't consistent with half of what you said.

Saying that ELCS costs the NHS more is not the same thing as saying it doesn't cost more and may even cost less over the longer term, but because of the way in which NHS funding works and the reality that people and institutions are generally short termist over costs for obvious reasons, people aren't receptive to that. They're two different points. There's actually a good argument to be made about NHS short termism here, speaking as someone who's actually had a bit of professional involvement on the subject as it happens (although the legal costs are concentrating their minds a bit on that one). But you didn't make it.

Additionally, even if we look solely at the costs while the woman is in hospital, that still doesn't tell us why you thought straightforward VB only was the appropriate comparison to ELCS. You talked of theatre time, anaesthetists, extra hospital stays etc as though those aren't also a risk of attempted VB. Basically, even taking an extremely short term approach, ELCS costs v straightforward VB costs are the wrong way to look at it, because attempting a straightforward VB doesn't mean you get one.

Thejoyfulstar · 29/04/2022 07:30

I had an elective c section a few months ago. When I told people I was having it, I was often met with either a sad or scornful 'why?'. It seemed strange that I had to produce my list of reasons (some of them being: forceps, severe tear, haemorrhage, blood transfusion, prolapse from previous vaginal delivery). It never ceased to amaze me when they would say 'ah ok', as if to give approval, as if it was their business.

For those who talk about the impact that elective sections have on the NHS should maybe çonsider the wider implications which traumatic births have on mothers, and, consequentially, babies. PTSD, difficulty bonding with the baby, difficulty establishing breastfeeding, postpartum depression/anxiety as well as some of the life-limiting physical changes which a complicated vaginal delivery may entail. Birth trauma can impact the entire family and have so many knock on effects.

My ELCS was nothing special. It was surgery and not the day spa experience that is so often espoused on Mumsnet. The recovery was long and quite brutal at times. However, it wasn't much worse than the recovery from my vaginal birth and I didn't have to endure hours and hours of suffering and unpredicted interventions to get the baby out. I would do it again.

My answer to anyone prying about why you're having an ELCS would be 'oh, lots of reasons but basically my doctor and I have decided that a c section is the best option'. End of story.

HoppingPavlova · 29/04/2022 03:14

Will add, that’s why people will also experience discrepancies in care across institutions and you will find policies differ as sometimes pots at some places are bigger than pots at others, or various factors mean you are luckier in spend and your pot tends to last longer than your counterparts corresponding pot at another institution so you have more of an ability for optimal treatment than your counterpart. It can be a lottery system at times.

HoppingPavlova · 29/04/2022 03:08

The second reason is that costs persist after the births. Costs of treatment required after complications of vaginal birth and indeed of EMCS are both costs of attempted vaginal birth. They have to be part of the pot as well.

I don’t disagree with any of what you say - but you show complete ignorance in the way pots work. Everything you say is true. In an ideal world it would all work like that. Funding models though are all about people doing the best they can in the immediate term.

The analogy is funding via Govnt of the day. No Govnt pumps money into something that shows benefit down the track. They are in it for the here and now. They may not be in power down the track so why do they care what happens down the track, the MO is kick the can down the road and look as good as you can for today, so that’s spend on stuff in the immediate term to make themselves look good. In Health that translates to short sightedness. They don’t care that extra funding today will result in better outcomes down the track. All your stuff about benefits down the track is 100% correct. Well done, pat on the back, you are correct. You are not the Lone Ranger and only person to have figured this out, everyone actually knows this. The people responsible for funding don’t care though. So when budgets are handed down all that stuff for down the track doesn’t factor in. This often makes a complete mismatch with Guidelines and best practice, which do factor in a long term approach.

Then that woeful budget that lives for today is split up into buckets, those buckets are distributed out into pots. Some poor person peers over into a near empty pot and thinks how the fuck am I meant to run a department on that. This is not going to give patients the care they deserve but we will have to try and do our best to ensure the majority of people are treated adequately, recognising not all will necessarily be treated ideally because that funding does not match Guidelines etc.

Another analogy. A parent has a limited amount of cash to provide their kids food. They have 2 choices. They can buy nutritious food food that will have long term health benefits for their kids. Buying this food will mean their kids eat for 4 days. Or, they can buy cheaper crap that will feed their kids for 7 days and no doubt lead to poor outcomes down the track. If they go the nutritious food they know they will have kids crying for 3 days so they take the crap option. The parent is not proud of this and does not feel good about it but believe they have done the best they can with the choices they had. Medical care, including birth, is no different.

Lastly, a sad fact is, sometimes you know that in order to feed the child for 7 days, if something adverse results from this, then Legal has a pot they will use. Hang on, but what if you had of had the money that Legal has in their pot in your pot to begin with because ultimately it all leads back to the same bucket. You could have fed the child for 6 days at least, and there would be no need for someone to use that pot. No one who distributes buckets and pots has this common sense, so your pot will never be bigger and Legals pot smaller.

EarlGreywithLemon · 29/04/2022 03:06

@Hmm1234 ”Plus the recovery time is longer and you’ll struggle to get up, move around, use the toilet and even feed the baby.”

I struggled to get up, move around and use the toilet after my vaginal birth, and continued to do so for months. In fact I couldn’t go to the bathroom at all because my bladder stopped working. I had to go back to hospital three times in the first two weeks for that, including one overnight readmission. Wonder how much that cost the NHS together with my transfusion, and 5 day hospital stay? A couple of weeks post birth trying to walk for 5 minutes felt like my pelvic floor was falling out (it was - I had a prolapse and my stitches were gaping and infected). A month after the birth I was walking the 10 minutes to a medical appointment when I started feeling urine pouring down my legs - I had no control over it whatsoever. None of that is even a slight exaggeration.

If you can come up with horror stories about c sections, I can do the same about vaginal births. Difference is, the latter is my own lived experience.

Oh, and I’m a C section baby - lucky enough to be naturally slim, no food allergies at all, no hay fever.

Dinneronmybfpillow · 29/04/2022 01:22

I can't get into a headspace where someone else's birth choices are anything to be 'judged' in the first place. I've had one home birth and one hospital birth (DTs so couldn't have another homebirth).

I couldn't give one shiny shit how other women choose to have their babies. Mind you, I don't care whether you BF or FF, spoon feed or baby-led wean, stay at home or go back to work... anything really (apart from car safety - that is the hill I will die on).

SunaksNutsack · 29/04/2022 01:00

It’s such a personal choice. I’m menopausal now and I had vaginal births but I’d have sections if I could do it again. No one explained when I was at the point of deciding, that scars from where I tore would be so troublesome in menopause. I didn’t anticipate the damage to my pelvic floor, the impact a weak one has on exercise and the knock on effect on my self esteem when I couldn’t exercise to lose the baby weight without peeing my pants.

EthelMerman · 29/04/2022 00:23

@Rosesandbutterflys I have had two c-sections, the first was an emergency after labour didn’t progress. The midwife didn’t spot DS had his shoulder presenting not his head. Whipped into theatre. I was soon up and about, no issues bonding with my baby, was able to breastfeed. Sore for a while but recovered well.

DS2 was transverse so I was booked in for a c-section. He then moved but I refused to opt for a natural birth. Turns out at 39 weeks he was 10lbs 5oz, so who knows how big he’d have been if I’d waited. Had a bit of a bleed but came through and again all well with me and DS.

My sister had all four naturally, she just popped them out.

Some people love the rigours of labour but you need to make the right choice for you. A fear of childbirth is a valid reason. Nature may intervene and you may have a swift natural birth, but it’s your body, so your choice to have a c-section.

Foggydayz · 29/04/2022 00:21

I had 3 CS . The first one was emergency as complications arose after I got to 9.5cm. I wanted to try again, naturally,, second time round- but nature intervened. Third time round - the choice was taken from me

I didnt have major complications with my C section, but I did hate being in hospital for 5 days afterwards, struggled with lactation and I have never regained any feeling in the scar area.

I think a natural birth that goes well is the easiest and safest option all round. And that is why first timers with no complications are guided to them. Saving the NHS precious resources is also part of it, and not to be sniffed at

The main thing is - this is a controversial issue, and you may wish to reconsider your attitudes on this basis. You may have planned a C Section at 39 weeks, but what if baby comes at 36/ 37 and you make too much progress before they can intervene. Ultimately, you can't control it all - but you can try and make the best choices at the time.

Presuming C Sectons are better than worse case Vaginal births is not a fair comparison

Swipe left for the next trending thread