Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why having an elective C-Section is so frowned upon?

663 replies

Rosesandbutterflys · 27/04/2022 11:50

I am (hopefully) having an elective C-Section soon. First baby, don't want anymore children after.

I've always had a fear of child birth, which over the past 5 years has been compounded by a lot of people around me having children and the vast majority of these (though I appreciate I'm probably unlucky here) have been pretty traumatic births that have ended in severe tears, forceps and a lot of the time, an emergency section anyway. Granted their experiences have mostly been better on their second birth/ child.

Nothing and I truly mean nothing about natural childbirth/ labour appeals to me. Not the hours of pain, pushing, potential rips/ tears, forcep intervention, epidural (yes I appreciate I'd have one of these for a section), damage of my pelvic floor and the panic and stress of potentially having to be rushed to theatre because it just wasn't going to happen naturally and the baby is in distress or whatever.

Now don't get me wrong, nothing about a c-section appeals to me either, it's absolutely no walk in the park and I'm dreading it, but it has to come out some way and I am a person that likes to plan things and to somewhat be in control/ aware of the plan. I have also had abdominal surgery before (though not as severe as a C-section) and I know recovery is likely to be painful and slower than if I were to have a natural birth. But for me, this is the preferred/ lesser of the 2 evils option.

I have also spent hours pouring over research as to the benefits of a vaginal birth over a c-section and last night came across a NICE/ NHS study/ research that found that actually, for a planned/ elective c-section, the risk to the mother of a c-section compared to a vaginal birth is pretty much the same. It states that the risk of the baby ending up in NICU with a C-section is 13.9% compared to a vaginal birth which is 6.3%, so double the risk, BUT it says the research does not take into account the fact that most c-sections undertaken are for medical reasons and therefore the likelihood of the baby needing NICU attention after it's born is increased anyway.

It then went on to say that the risks of an unplanned, emergency C-Section are a lot higher than a natural birth/ elective/ planned C-Section. So I guess if each woman was guaranteed to have a straightforward, natural birth, then great, but a lot of women do end up needing an emergency c-section so, technically they are more at risk than someone who has chosen an elective.

This now seems like I am bashing natural delivery and I'm not at all I totally admire and respect women that chose that route, I only wish I were that brave.

However, the responses I have had from people my whole pregnancy when I have admitted I am opting for an elective C-section have been ridiculous. Not one person has responded positively, all I've had is 'Oh, really? Are you sure??' and 'Oh, why on earth would you elect to have that?' etc etc. Or just a stony faced, tight smile and 'oh right' making it clear they disapprove but not actually coming out and saying it.

I got told last night that the reason I'm getting these reactions is because a C-section is 'taking the easy way out '😕

If that's the case, why on earth wouldn't you? Why is it that it seems the prerequisite to being a good mother is seemingly having to martyr yourself all the time?

So many of my friends that have had children and also the women in my NCT class who are preparing for their births have all expressed dismay/ distress at having to have any pain relief, they all want it to be as natural as possible and I know my friends that haven't had 'textbook' births still harbour 'guilt' and sadness to this day. Why? If you need gas and air or an epidural, so what? What exactly am I missing? If they ended/end up with forceps or an emergency section, it's not their fault, it's just one of those things. Surely modern medicine has provided these things to make childbirth safer?

Anyway, gone off on a tangent now but if you disapprove of someone having an elective c-section, could you tell me why?

OP posts:
GirlSYML · 01/05/2022 07:04

@bigyellowTpot so your body wasn’t able to do what it’s supposed to do naturally so you couldn’t have a natural birth with either of your children - but all women should have a natural birth as it’s what their bodies do naturally. Ok then. Thanks for your valuable contribution to the thread 😂😂😂

EthelMerman · 01/05/2022 00:26

@bigyellowTpot my grandmother was one of 13 but so what? They were lucky to survive such big families.

Childbirth was a risky business for women, in the UK if you’re not Caucasian then the risks in the West are still too high. Elsewhere the statistics make for grim reading.

Women aren’t being weak or snowflakes, please do some research into childbirth through the ages. What our forebears endured was quite horrific and dangerous. And in all too many cases fatal for mother and child.

theodosiaburr · 30/04/2022 23:15

I don’t get the attitude of ‘well I wouldn’t want that so other women shouldn’t get to choose it!’ Isn’t the whole point of choice and options the fact we aren’t all going to pick the same things..

EthelMerman · 30/04/2022 22:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FFS @bigyellowTpot the more of your posts I read the more I despair. my grandmother was one of 13 but so what?

Childbirth was a risky business for women, if if you’re not Caucasian then the risks in the West are still too high. Elsewhere the statistics make for grim reading.

Women aren’t being weak or snowflakes, do some research into childbirth through the ages. What our forebears endured was quite horrific and dangerous. And in all too many cases fatal for mother and child.

ridemesideway · 30/04/2022 22:20

Go with what you want. Nobody else should care.

I really wanted a vaginal birth. Luckily it was a textbook delivery, no issues afterwards. Was up and about a couple of hours later, back running and at the gym within a few weeks. I was actually terrified of a C section because I had a fear of my uterus being sliced open and dealing with a wound.

EthelMerman · 30/04/2022 22:10

bigyellowTpot · 29/04/2022 13:40

Also does the fear of having your abdomen cut open and messed about with not put you off. I'd rather have a natural vaginal delivery any day. it's what your body is designed to do.

@bigyellowTpot My body didn’t do what it was supposed to. I didn’t dilate sufficiently, DS was wedged, shoulder presenting not head. Thankfully I had an EMCS. I’m grateful to be alive in the 21st century.

After that and with DS2 being transverse, I chose to have a C-section. Stop being judgey - we may have the same plumbing but it doesn’t necessarily work the same way for everyone.

Mysteryuser · 30/04/2022 22:04

You can now get this under NICE guidelines. afaik. Sorry if I was in any way offensive up thread. I just really hope all pregnant women these days check out all of the risks and benefits relating to all modes of delivery and fight for what is right for them. ( Although it shouldn't be a fight.)

lioncitygirl · 30/04/2022 21:43

i didn’t know you could get this in the NHS. I guess for it would be the cost associated with it - but if you’re paying for this privately then no one can and should judge you. My sister In law had three paid for privately - she didn’t want a natural birth.

LeeMucklowesCurtains · 30/04/2022 21:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I don’t know where to start.

Except that you don’t piss out of your vagina, ffs.

bigyellowTpot · 30/04/2022 21:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SpaghettiNotCourgetti · 30/04/2022 19:35

@MissChanandlerBong80 Thank you for such a lovely post! As I say, it took a while after an exhausting delivery for my milk to come in last time and it's reassuring to hear that my feeling - that the delivery and associated issues were related to the delay - is probably a fair one. Once we got started, DD breastfed beautifully and we kept it up for nearly 2 1/2 years so I'm cautiously optimistic that it can be good this time as well Smile

phoenixrosehere · 30/04/2022 15:50

theodosiaburr · 30/04/2022 11:26

Individual risk factors are a big part of it too. My last birth all odds were in my favour (age, weight, previous v birth, spontaneous onset of labour, no pregnancy complications and so on) and statistically chances were low enough for me to feel attempting vaginal birth was the best option and indeed I had a very good straightforward birth.
For other women that’s not the case eg first-time mums who undergo induction often have very high odds of ending up with an instrumental delivery or emergency Caesarean (as in that’s more likely to happen than a ‘normal’ birth!) ditto induced mums of a certain age etc. Often these women aren’t even told what the odds are and feel unlucky to end up with an emergency section despite there being a 50% chance that would be the outcome.

Yes. As I said upthread I was coerced into an induction. I questioned it for weeks because I wanted evidence for it it which all I received was stillbirth stats every time. I found out upon research later that this was a common tactic often used to coerce women into inductions and the stats themselves were outdated. By their logic and the stats they used, they should be inducing every pregnant woman in the population at 39 weeks. I was a healthy, 28 yo ftm, who the consultants thought my baby “looked” big. Every sonographers said they didn’t see it. I questioned if he was so big, why weren’t they offering me an ELCS? How is an induction safer? Once again, stillbirth stats. I was told that doctors knew best. A blue baby that wasn’t even 7lbs came out with two traumatised parents.

I would like to know how an ELCS would have been more expensive than a 3-day failed induction, emcs, therapy for ptsd, and possible life long special needs care for him.

BronwenFrideswide · 30/04/2022 15:50

@bigyellowTpot Silly for not even trying that takes the absolute biscuit. What other areas of health do you enforce that mantra? Your attitude is appalling and just shows the rank misogyny there is in women's healthcare especially maternity care.

Women should have the options regarding birth clearly explained to them and then be supported without judgement to make the choice they want that they feel suits them best, that is progressive women centred health care.

I myself needed an episiotomy and ventouse delivery with my first birth. How fucking ironic that someone who claims the female body is designed to just deliver babies naturally needed interventions to deliver their own - so not such a perfect design then and if you were in a place where those options were unavailable then you and/or baby would most likely have died.

MissChanandlerBong80 · 30/04/2022 13:37

SpaghettiNotCourgetti · 29/04/2022 11:44

I'm booked for a caesarean in just over a week after a pretty shocking first birth. If I'd known what that first birth was going to be like, I'd have had an ELCS that time, too!

I'm glad to hear that your breastfeeding was successful - it's the only thing that I'm a bit concerned about at the moment. But then, after the forceps and PPH with my 'better' natural delivery, it took days for my milk to come in anyway. I'm hoping that the lack of stress will help!

Anecdata of course, but I had the same concerns as you, and to my surprise and delight I had a far, far easier time breastfeeding after my ELCS than after my traumatic vaginal birth - my son latched on in recovery after my ELCS and it was more or less plain sailing apart from a tongue tie which was snipped at a week old (and of course was nothing to do with the ELCS).

Prior to having my ELCS I discussed my concerns with my midwife and she said that in her experience BFing difficulties after caesareans are more common with emergency sections where the mother has been in labour for age and is exhausted and traumatised.

Best of luck with your section. Mine was lovely and I have such happy memories. My one bit of advice is to take a camera into theatre and ask the midwife to take lots of pictures. I have beautiful pictures of the moment the surgeons lifted my son out of me and when they put him on me for skin to skin.

Mysteryuser · 30/04/2022 13:23

I did read an article in which a doctor was arguing for this. I think (although my statistics are probably way off- please could someone correct me) that he said a greater than one in one thousand risk in relation to surgery had to be discussed, but the odds of tearing with vaginal birth, especially over the age of 40, were something like one in three ( although may have been much higher or lower). Regardless, it was a far higher risk than the one in one thousand risk, or whatever the actual threshold is for discussion, in relation to surgery. And yet this certainly wasn't mentioned to me until I brought the subject up.

SunaksNutsack · 30/04/2022 12:40

Yes that’s a very good point. The odds of various scenarios should be clearly communicated to women who want this information. Birth injuries stopped me from doing proper aerobic exercise such as running for a long time because I was incontinent until they were fully sorted out and every bounce would make me leak a little. Not exactly good for my physical or mental health to be effectively prevented from doing the exercise I love. I used to compete in a sport pre children and it all stopped. And I’m having problems with the area where I tore now I’m at menopause. If I’d had proper information I’d have elected to have a CS.

SpaghettiNotCourgetti · 30/04/2022 11:53

Often these women aren’t even told what the odds are

Excellent and important point. At the antenatal classes we went to (NHS ones in the maternity centre) we were told about the possibilities of interventions, but not about the likelihoods. 1 in 3 women having their first baby will need an instrumental delivery! A third!

Source: https://www.rcog.org.uk/for-the-public/browse-all-patient-information-leaflets/assisted-vaginal-birth-ventouse-or-forceps//*

I mean, are women even able to give informed consent without these statistics? They are so careful to hammer home the risks of c sections and quietly never mention the odds with vaginal deliveries - the more I looked into it when making my decision for this birth, the more appalled I was, frankly.

Lampyshady · 30/04/2022 11:51

vivainsomnia · 27/04/2022 12:08

Of course because of the costs and availability of staff. An anaesthetic consultant doing a cesarian is one taken away from emergency, critical surgery.

So it is a selfish choice. I don't think it's the end of the world, but I'm surprised you didn't consider this.

i find this view ridiculous-how far do you take it? Is deciding to have more than 1 child selfish? Or deciding to have children at all for that matter as it is guaranteed to cost the NHS money? How about deciding to engage in high risk activities that might result in an accident that will cost the NHS money (such as skiing)-is that selfish? The NHS is there to be used and people are free to make choices that may result in costing the nhs more money. The consultants job is to provide both elective surgeries and emergency cover-this is factored in to the NHS staffing rota/budget. On an individual level, the cost of 1 operation to the nhs is negligible so surely shouldn’t need to be considered when making a big decision such as how to give birth. There’s nothing to feel guilty for-the nhs wouldn’t offer elective c sections if it wasn’t viable and in the best interests of patients.

theodosiaburr · 30/04/2022 11:26

Individual risk factors are a big part of it too. My last birth all odds were in my favour (age, weight, previous v birth, spontaneous onset of labour, no pregnancy complications and so on) and statistically chances were low enough for me to feel attempting vaginal birth was the best option and indeed I had a very good straightforward birth.
For other women that’s not the case eg first-time mums who undergo induction often have very high odds of ending up with an instrumental delivery or emergency Caesarean (as in that’s more likely to happen than a ‘normal’ birth!) ditto induced mums of a certain age etc. Often these women aren’t even told what the odds are and feel unlucky to end up with an emergency section despite there being a 50% chance that would be the outcome.

Fridafever · 30/04/2022 11:08

My thinking on this has shifted since I had DS. Shifted for me to be clear, I always believed people should be able to chose.

I did a very low intervention home birth which was an extremely positive experience. No tearing, not really very painful, it was an amazing day and I look back on it really joyfully. No pain relief needed, I had some techniques from the birth skills book that worked fantastically. If we’re reporting on our vaginas I’d like to report mine as still tight, thanks. I can also trampoline without pissing myself.

However the more studies that come out, the more I think I’d chose an ELCS if I had my time again. Although with hindsight I was right to go vaginal birth because it was great I do think the risks are much greater of injury. I think if I’d really understood the data at the time I’d have decided losing the chance of the optimum outcome of an easy vaginal birth was a reasonable payoff for reducing the chance of some awful outcomes.

Anyway sorry for the ramble!

Mysteryuser · 30/04/2022 10:57

Bigyellow, I personally think it's very 'silly' not to do your utmost to minimise risk to your future health, and to knowingly increase the chance of incontinence and prolapses etc.. But each to their own.

eatingapie · 30/04/2022 10:45

www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2022/feb/13/caesareans-or-vaginal-births-should-mothers-or-medics-have-the-final-say

apologies if this has been posted upthread - interesting article which references a study in which ELCS are shown to have fewer negative outcomes than planned vaginal births.

im like you OP. I’d rather have the given risks of an ELCS than the unpredictable risks of a natural birth. Similarly, I’ve yet to hear a positive vaginal birth story other than that of a friend who had home births- which are also frowned upon!

Rosesandbutterflys · 30/04/2022 10:27

bigyellowTpot · 30/04/2022 09:50

@BronwenFrideswide and @GirlSYML Obviously there are complications and interventions required in vaginal delivery's, I myself needed an episiotomy and ventouse delivery with my first birth. But the OP is talking about opting for a an elective
C-section by choice before even attempting a vaginal delivery. Obviously sections are often needed and the best option in many births as was the case with my friend in my post. but I think it is silly for a woman just to decide she wants a section due to fear of the unknown (unless it is extreme fear that has become an actual phobia) like I said I was also very scared but all turned out well in the end and I did it again with dc2. I just think it is silly for opting to have a section without even trying, like my friend said recovery from her section was far far worse than her 3 previous natural births. Do you think c-section is the way to go and all woman should opt for it? people die in the world every day doing all kinds of things that are natural eating is natural but people choke to death doing it sometimes? I myself definitely wouldn't want that major surgery if it could be avoided.

I couldn’t give a shiny ‘shit’ if you think I’m ‘silly’ for opting to do something without trying something else that is absolutely of no benefit to me and not mandatory.

I have a medical reason as to why I will probably need a c section but I would be opting for one anyway because why endure hours and hours of pain, possible forceps and other interventions when you don’t have to? All the women I know who have had c sections have had a good recovery. Yes there’s a chance I won’t but that’s a risk I’m prepared to take. I’d rather take that risk than risk a vaginal birth. I’ve only got one friend who had a half decent vaginal birth, the rest were awful, traumatic experiences and a few are now left with permanent injuries. Why, just why would I want to risk that when I don’t have to?! Would it just be for the pat on the backs Id get from women like you because I wasn’t ‘silly’ and ‘gave it a go’ yeh, no thanks.

OP posts:
bigyellowTpot · 30/04/2022 09:50

@BronwenFrideswide and @GirlSYML Obviously there are complications and interventions required in vaginal delivery's, I myself needed an episiotomy and ventouse delivery with my first birth. But the OP is talking about opting for a an elective
C-section by choice before even attempting a vaginal delivery. Obviously sections are often needed and the best option in many births as was the case with my friend in my post. but I think it is silly for a woman just to decide she wants a section due to fear of the unknown (unless it is extreme fear that has become an actual phobia) like I said I was also very scared but all turned out well in the end and I did it again with dc2. I just think it is silly for opting to have a section without even trying, like my friend said recovery from her section was far far worse than her 3 previous natural births. Do you think c-section is the way to go and all woman should opt for it? people die in the world every day doing all kinds of things that are natural eating is natural but people choke to death doing it sometimes? I myself definitely wouldn't want that major surgery if it could be avoided.

SW1amp · 29/04/2022 21:25

It's very naive to think you have any kind of agency once you're on the operating table - many things can and do go wrong.

when I was on the operating table, I was given plenty of choices


  • delayed clamping or not

  • immediate skin to skin or not

  • lights lowered at birth or left as normal

hell, I was even able to choose the music the nurse played through the speakers!

and let’s not forget that I had signed pages of consent pages beforehand, which gave me plenty of options in the event of things not going to plan…