Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why having an elective C-Section is so frowned upon?

663 replies

Rosesandbutterflys · 27/04/2022 11:50

I am (hopefully) having an elective C-Section soon. First baby, don't want anymore children after.

I've always had a fear of child birth, which over the past 5 years has been compounded by a lot of people around me having children and the vast majority of these (though I appreciate I'm probably unlucky here) have been pretty traumatic births that have ended in severe tears, forceps and a lot of the time, an emergency section anyway. Granted their experiences have mostly been better on their second birth/ child.

Nothing and I truly mean nothing about natural childbirth/ labour appeals to me. Not the hours of pain, pushing, potential rips/ tears, forcep intervention, epidural (yes I appreciate I'd have one of these for a section), damage of my pelvic floor and the panic and stress of potentially having to be rushed to theatre because it just wasn't going to happen naturally and the baby is in distress or whatever.

Now don't get me wrong, nothing about a c-section appeals to me either, it's absolutely no walk in the park and I'm dreading it, but it has to come out some way and I am a person that likes to plan things and to somewhat be in control/ aware of the plan. I have also had abdominal surgery before (though not as severe as a C-section) and I know recovery is likely to be painful and slower than if I were to have a natural birth. But for me, this is the preferred/ lesser of the 2 evils option.

I have also spent hours pouring over research as to the benefits of a vaginal birth over a c-section and last night came across a NICE/ NHS study/ research that found that actually, for a planned/ elective c-section, the risk to the mother of a c-section compared to a vaginal birth is pretty much the same. It states that the risk of the baby ending up in NICU with a C-section is 13.9% compared to a vaginal birth which is 6.3%, so double the risk, BUT it says the research does not take into account the fact that most c-sections undertaken are for medical reasons and therefore the likelihood of the baby needing NICU attention after it's born is increased anyway.

It then went on to say that the risks of an unplanned, emergency C-Section are a lot higher than a natural birth/ elective/ planned C-Section. So I guess if each woman was guaranteed to have a straightforward, natural birth, then great, but a lot of women do end up needing an emergency c-section so, technically they are more at risk than someone who has chosen an elective.

This now seems like I am bashing natural delivery and I'm not at all I totally admire and respect women that chose that route, I only wish I were that brave.

However, the responses I have had from people my whole pregnancy when I have admitted I am opting for an elective C-section have been ridiculous. Not one person has responded positively, all I've had is 'Oh, really? Are you sure??' and 'Oh, why on earth would you elect to have that?' etc etc. Or just a stony faced, tight smile and 'oh right' making it clear they disapprove but not actually coming out and saying it.

I got told last night that the reason I'm getting these reactions is because a C-section is 'taking the easy way out '😕

If that's the case, why on earth wouldn't you? Why is it that it seems the prerequisite to being a good mother is seemingly having to martyr yourself all the time?

So many of my friends that have had children and also the women in my NCT class who are preparing for their births have all expressed dismay/ distress at having to have any pain relief, they all want it to be as natural as possible and I know my friends that haven't had 'textbook' births still harbour 'guilt' and sadness to this day. Why? If you need gas and air or an epidural, so what? What exactly am I missing? If they ended/end up with forceps or an emergency section, it's not their fault, it's just one of those things. Surely modern medicine has provided these things to make childbirth safer?

Anyway, gone off on a tangent now but if you disapprove of someone having an elective c-section, could you tell me why?

OP posts:
SexyPortugese · 27/04/2022 16:56

I wonder if the people spouting how our bodies are 'made for childbirth' apply their ridiculous creationist theory to everything else in their lives. Who made your bodies, btw? I was under the impression we'd evolved, and that our current rates of mortality when birthing without adequate care were down to the obstetric dilemma.

Utter tosh to believe some magic person 'made' our body and designed it for a purpose. Says everything about your worldview.

Incredibly insulting and downright cruel to say that when so many women die in childbirth every single day. Guessing their bodies were faulty, or maybe whoever build your body (god i'm guessing) was half asleep at the wheel.

notanotherbloodystreetparty · 27/04/2022 16:54

I feel like some people's c-sections are from a different planet to mine. Having one at 9 am and allowed to go home at 9am the next.

I couldn't easily get out of bed at 9am the next day, let alone walk to the car and get in and out of it, and the rest of the ward were not much better. Sorry to be blunt, but it did really feel exactly like it was, like someone had cut a great hole across my middle.

Anyway, I am glad I had it because other breech DC wouldn't necessarily be here (despite NCT crap about turning babies (not this baby was not for turning, though neither of us benefited from 2 rough hours of trying)). Just a making a counter point to people saying my body was designed to safely birth a breech baby and a 'natural' birth would have been better for my DC's lungs and those saying they skipped out of hospital a day later and were back at the gym after 14.

Do what will give your baby and you the best chance of survival and good health, not what the NCT tell you. And don't think an 'elective' C-section is a choice and and 'emergency' C-section is not. Usually an 'elective' C-section is just as necessary as an 'emergency' C-section, it is just the some has seen the emergency coming and planned properly for it.

SpaghettiNotCourgetti · 27/04/2022 16:54

This. Imagine if everyone having a baby had elective caesareans? This would leave a shortage of surgeons etc for emergency situations/sections.

Yes! Imagine all those poor neurosurgeons unable to operate on stroke patients because they've been forced down to maternity again. The corridors will be full of thwarted orthopods and cardiothoracic surgeons who're just doing caesarean after caesarean instead of the surgery they're trained for Hmm

Our (large) hospital has two theatres for caesareans - one for elective and one for emergency - which are staffed as you'd expect.

I'm booked for a caesarean in a couple of weeks because I'm not keen to repeat my no pain relief shitshow of a vaginal birth experience. I can't wait for it. I'm sure that a straightforward vaginal birth is no more than a couple of hours of discomfort, but I haven't experienced this personally and so have decided to try again a different way this time. It's been really interesting, actually, to see how many women have had c sections and don't mention it - I feel like I'm joining this clandestine society. Half of the women I know had a vaginal delivery first, and then a caesarean subsequently because their 'natural', 'normal' births were so traumatic and / or debilitating. The only person I've had comments from is MIL, who basically breathed four babies out and thinks that pain relief in labour means you don't get the full experience and so shouldn't be used. She's also full of what I won't be able to do after a c section, conveniently overlooking that after pushing for four hours, having an episiotomy and instrumental delivery and then a PPH, I wasn't in a fit state to do much more than exist in shell shock for a while after DD was born. At least this time round I'll have had a night's sleep beforehand.

LuckySantangelo35 · 27/04/2022 16:54

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 27/04/2022 12:41

So you’re opting for it because it’s seen as the easier of the two options but then argue it’s not easier.
I don’t care how anyone has their baby or how they feed them but I will say the fears of others do have a knock on effect and that’s the issue I have. Making women scared, compounding issues of breastfeeding which ultimately give more money to the formula companies.

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

so what if she is picking it because it’s the easiest? What’s the problem with that?
will she go on to be a better mother if she picks the easier/less painful option?

Hospedia · 27/04/2022 16:50

Snowflakes1122 · 27/04/2022 13:57

This. Imagine if everyone having a baby had elective caesareans? This would leave a shortage of surgeons etc for emergency situations/sections.

Don't be ridiculous, 100% caesarean deliveries would never happen as some women will always choose Option A and others will always choose Option B with some having to accept the alternative to whichever they wanted due to unforseen circumstances. However all women should have the choice for which method of delivery they want.

If it ever did come down to 100% caesarean rate then staffing levels would adapt to accommodate it, the surgeries would not be taking staff away from emergencies and other services because the NHS would allocate staff based on the fore-knowledge that all deliveries would be caesareans.

lanthanum · 27/04/2022 16:49

Do what's right for you, and never mind what other people think.

HOWEVER, just bear in mind the possibility that it doesn't happen as planned. If the baby decides to arrive early, it might be best to be open to the possibility of natural birth - prem babies are often both quicker and easier; if the baby is well on its way by the time you turn up at hospital, it may not make sense to try and get you into theatre as an emergency.

CorneliusVetch · 27/04/2022 16:46

Okaaaay · 27/04/2022 15:02

  • It’s (significantly) more expensive (anaesthetic time, obstetric time, drugs, longer recovery as an inpatient).
  • It’s major surgery (few surgeries these days are as invasive) and comes with the risk of infection and all the risks of any major healthcare intervention (the risks are comparably greater to a vaginal birth)
  • Recovery is comparably long and tricky (driving, bending, picking up etc)

That said, given your anxiety around childbirth, it’s a perfect valid (and safe) way to deliver your baby. Work with your MW / obstetrician - perhaps write down as you have here why this is the option you wish to take. Your birth preferences (you can never truly ‘plan’) are your business. Please stop sharing them - everyone has an opinion when a baby is in the mix.

just on your point about risk:

a. It’s true the risks of surgery don’t apply to vaginal birth but if you try for a vaginal birth, there is a significant risk of needing an emergency section which is riskier than an elective one

b. There are risks to vaginal birth which don’t apply to sections, like tearing though your clitoris, or up through your anal sphincter. The damage to women’s genitals is avoided by caesarean.

c. Some increased risks to baby of caesareans, eg needing NICU, not having the microbiome etc. These are more likely but less damaging than the risk to the baby of hypoxic brain injury in vaginal birth. That is far less likely but catastrophic if it does happen. There are babies who died at birth, or have significant brain injury, that would be alive if they had been born by caesarean. That gets skipped over a lot. So which is riskier for baby depends on how you evaluate risks. I know someone who was low risk and this happened to her so I have a bit of a bug near about this!

d. C-sections are invasive in that it is open rather than laparoscopic. Not sure I agree “few” operations are as invasive though but in any case, for women without contra-indications for surgery, sections are very safe. I personally consider a caesarean less invasive than having my vagina cut open with scissors and someone shoving forceps up me to yank my baby out but I quite genuinely can see why people would rather a vaginal birth and that plenty of vaginal births go smoothly and give women an experience they are pleased with.

e. Lots of women have far easier recoveries from caesareans than vaginas births. It just depends.

I know from your post that you agree that vaginal birth and caesareans and both valid birth choices, but i am just responding on the risk point.

Hospedia · 27/04/2022 16:42

notanotherbloodystreetparty · 27/04/2022 13:14

Just as a counterpoint to this…
I was out of hospital within 24 hours of both my c-sections, driving within 2 weeks and back exercising before 6 weeks
yes the first 48 hours were difficult, but not painful if you take the tablets and don’t try and over do it

Sorry this is not a typical experience. 48 hours after my C-section I was still having strong painkillers given to me as suppositories in hospital.

The hospital would not even let C-section mothers leave hospital until 3-4 days. I was begging to go home (couldn't sleep in hospital, so was deranged with sleep deprivation after 2 days) and they refused.

I don't know what hospital would let you go home after 2 days.

Exercise with a 12-inch abdominal incision still healing after 2 weeks - you are superwoman!

Not sure what the medical advice about that would be though. I doubt a doctor would support that.

With my first elective section (second section overall) I had my baby at 9am and was allowed to be discharged at 9am the following morning although I opted to stay another night as DC wasnt great at feeding. I was up and walking roughly five hours after delivery once the spinal wore off and staff were insistent on this as its better for your recovery to be mobile and a shuffle around the room is preferable to lying in bed, I had a shower 8hrs post-delivery and it was heavenly. The only painkillers given by the hospital were paracetamol and ibuprofen (same as when I had a different abdominal surgery a few years ago) and this was enough. This was fairly common as almost all the caesarean mums in my MN baby bus had similar experiences. I went for a pub lunch the day after being discharged, slow walk from the passenger door to the pub door while DH carried the car seat then sitting at the table was no more strenuous than a slow walk from my living room to my dining room and sitting at my own table. I had a very careful walk around the shopping centre at day five because DS had a party to go to at the softplay there. Obviously no one should be overexerting themselves post-surgery or pushing their body beyond its limits but being in immense pain, a lengthy hospital stay, and heavy duty painkillers aren't a universal caesarean experience.

I don't know about 12 inch incisions either, a typical incision fir a caesarean is roughly four to six inches - even my 9lb transverse baby was able to exit via a four inch incision.

pentagone · 27/04/2022 16:32

milawops · 27/04/2022 15:48

I had a vaginal birth and having watched my sister recover from 2 C sections I will take my 2nd degree tear all day every day.
Anyone who thinks it's the easy option is wrong.

I've had two c-sections and they were easy. Pain killers meant I had no pain. I wasn't tired or exhausted after giving birth. I recovered quickly. I genuinely found them positive experiences.

Lovemypeaceandquiet · 27/04/2022 16:32

The way you deliver your baby into this world is between you & your doctors @Rosesandbutterflys .

Honestly, I’ve never asked any pregnant woman how are they planning on doing it, are people really having these conversations and then give you their opinions ??

I can only imagine that they are either coming from a place of having super easy VB or the opposite, they suffered complications and they don’t think it’s fair you’ve got a different, “easier” options.

Id just stop discussing it with anyone but your doctors OP, it’s not their vaginas and baby’s health/life at stake.

momonpurpose · 27/04/2022 16:24

I was offered an elective . I turned it down because I wanted to go natural. Ended up having complications and an emergency section I wasn't awake for. I wish I'd done the elective. This is your birthing experience don't let anyone shame you

pentagone · 27/04/2022 16:23

SW1amp · 27/04/2022 15:59

Exactly. I think the maternal mortality rate for those times is around 1 in 8

that pretty much proves they were clearly not ‘literally designed’ for having babies, unless you don’t understand the meaning of “literal” or “designed”

Countries where large sections of the female population have no or limited access to modern health care still have very high rates of maternal death and death of babies due to childbirth.

We are not designed to have babies, we are evolved. And its an evolutionary trade off between the advantages of large brain in human babies and the risk this creates to the mother (and child) at birth. We've evolved to the point where the high death rates are 'justified' by the benefits of a large brain.

LuckySantangelo35 · 27/04/2022 16:20

jellybeansandthings · 27/04/2022 12:21

I would just say this. Are we as a society ready for this to be available to every single pregnant woman who gives birth? Sometimes things can have minimal effect on society when there are relatively small numbers, but if think about it, what would happen if overnight every woman wanted an elective section? Would we be ok with allocating money and resources for this and taking them away from other needs? That's part of how society judges actions. There's nothing wrong with your decision but if you get into it, it's about priorities

Yup and what’s more of a priority than female health?

Some women are left with birth injuries that stops them from being fully continent, being able to enjoy sex, being able to run and exercise.

Honestly, what could be more of a priority??

whumpthereitis · 27/04/2022 16:13

Marvellousmadness · 27/04/2022 15:28

Because why choose medical intervention when your body literally is made for having babies.

Because the human body is also ‘made’ to be pretty shite at it.

Lots of things are natural, from using leaves instead of toilet paper, to dying in childbirth. Luckily we live in a modern world that affords us more choices.

As far as what’s better for the baby, the baby is being born at term either way (all things going well). The woman is the one that’s gone through pregnancy and is the one that has to go through birth. If she decides to make a choice prioritising her own needs over working exactly to the baby’s timetable, she should absolutely go the fuck ahead. Women matter too.

sparechange · 27/04/2022 16:05

OfstedOffred · 27/04/2022 15:03

I think doing it because its easier without it being medically recommended for you is fine but remember it costs the taxpayer money.

It's a bit like how I'd like to lose a stone in weight. I'm not obese but I'd look better thinner. I don't expect the NHS to give me free liposuction to achieve that, when I could opt for the 6 month long grind of a diet and achieve the same.

There has been some bollocks on this thread but this has to take the biscuit 🍪

pentagone · 27/04/2022 16:02

Vaginal birth is not the horror show you think
It certainly can be. That's why birth trauma is a real thing.

SW1amp · 27/04/2022 15:59

LeeMucklowesCurtains · 27/04/2022 15:40

Yes it was - but actually, it’s quite badly made for it, if you look at mortality rates pre modem healthcare.

Some very frightening statistics from the middle ages for childbirth for the mother and baby in this country, just a small example.

Exactly. I think the maternal mortality rate for those times is around 1 in 8

that pretty much proves they were clearly not ‘literally designed’ for having babies, unless you don’t understand the meaning of “literal” or “designed”

milawops · 27/04/2022 15:48

I had a vaginal birth and having watched my sister recover from 2 C sections I will take my 2nd degree tear all day every day.
Anyone who thinks it's the easy option is wrong.

Topseyt123 · 27/04/2022 15:47

Marvellousmadness · 27/04/2022 15:28

Because why choose medical intervention when your body literally is made for having babies.

What complete and utter bollocks! Was I designed to put up with the traumatic birth injuries I sustained during "natural" childbirth? The severe tearing and the lifelong pelvic floor damage? There was much more too.

In large parts of the world women still die in fairly significant numbers having babies. Many could be saved if caesareans were a realistic option and more readily available I should think.

But no, you say their bodies are made for it. Dangerous bullshit. There are many flaws in our design and some can prove catastrophic.

DomesticatedZombie · 27/04/2022 15:47

BogRollBOGOF · 27/04/2022 15:06

People shouldn't be putting others down for very personal, medical choices either way round.

Unless you're in the tiny, tiny minority who's free-birthing, how a baby exits the mother's body is pretty much always agreed with medical professionals anyway and managed by them.

how a baby exits the mother's body is pretty much always agreed with medical professionals anyway and managed by them.

Medical professionals will offer information and their advice. Consent rests with the patient.

MrsToothyBitch · 27/04/2022 15:43

I have considered this for a while and I'm on a similar page to you OP. People can do as they please but personally I'd like an ELCS. I have GAD which leans really strongly towards an intolerance to uncertainty. Labour scares me.

I also struggle with a very low pain threshold, hypermobility and fatigue. I really don't know how I'd cope with late pregnancy and labour either mentally or physically- for me, these risks are worse and much larger than the medical risk of ELCS. The whole thing puts me off getting pregnant tbh.

LeeMucklowesCurtains · 27/04/2022 15:40

Marvellousmadness · 27/04/2022 15:28

Because why choose medical intervention when your body literally is made for having babies.

Yes it was - but actually, it’s quite badly made for it, if you look at mortality rates pre modem healthcare.

Some very frightening statistics from the middle ages for childbirth for the mother and baby in this country, just a small example.

ZenNudist · 27/04/2022 15:39

It's not the easy way out. It's major surgery for something that could be avoided at less risk to baby and altogether better recovery for mum.

You do you and don't tell people your birth plan. Literally no one asks if you're planning a natural birth or if they do they're odd. The probably mean are you planning on drugs or no drugs not are you planning and going straight to section without labour.

You're probably worrying more than you need to what people think. Don't. Birth is just the first of many choices you get to make as a parent. Own your decisions.

If you told me your birth plan I'd think you were very neurotic. Vaginal birth is not the horror show you think. You seem to have your head screwed on about what an ELCS involves. If your doctors are letting you have one they know best and you don't need anyone else second guessing you or sneering. I hope it goes well.

GirlSYML · 27/04/2022 15:33

Marvellousmadness · 27/04/2022 15:28

Because why choose medical intervention when your body literally is made for having babies.

See this is dangerous nonsense. If you could take a minute not to parrot twaddle the facts are as follows @Marvellousmadness

If we look at long-term trends in maternal mortality – the likelihood a woman will die from pregnancy-related causes – we see that every 100th to 200th birth led to the mother’s death.

Improvements in healthcare, nutrition, and hygienemean maternal deaths are much rarer today. But women are still dying from pregnancy-related causes that are preventable.

The World Health Organization estimates that almost 300,000 women died from pregnancy-related causes in 2017. That’s 808 women every day

whatuser · 27/04/2022 15:33

I think peoples first reaction is that it's a bit of a wussy thing to do, which is wrong of course. I tried to get a c section for the same reasons but they weren't convinced I was scared enough

I think VB is harder during the actual birth, CS is harder after the birth (recovery)