Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why having an elective C-Section is so frowned upon?

663 replies

Rosesandbutterflys · 27/04/2022 11:50

I am (hopefully) having an elective C-Section soon. First baby, don't want anymore children after.

I've always had a fear of child birth, which over the past 5 years has been compounded by a lot of people around me having children and the vast majority of these (though I appreciate I'm probably unlucky here) have been pretty traumatic births that have ended in severe tears, forceps and a lot of the time, an emergency section anyway. Granted their experiences have mostly been better on their second birth/ child.

Nothing and I truly mean nothing about natural childbirth/ labour appeals to me. Not the hours of pain, pushing, potential rips/ tears, forcep intervention, epidural (yes I appreciate I'd have one of these for a section), damage of my pelvic floor and the panic and stress of potentially having to be rushed to theatre because it just wasn't going to happen naturally and the baby is in distress or whatever.

Now don't get me wrong, nothing about a c-section appeals to me either, it's absolutely no walk in the park and I'm dreading it, but it has to come out some way and I am a person that likes to plan things and to somewhat be in control/ aware of the plan. I have also had abdominal surgery before (though not as severe as a C-section) and I know recovery is likely to be painful and slower than if I were to have a natural birth. But for me, this is the preferred/ lesser of the 2 evils option.

I have also spent hours pouring over research as to the benefits of a vaginal birth over a c-section and last night came across a NICE/ NHS study/ research that found that actually, for a planned/ elective c-section, the risk to the mother of a c-section compared to a vaginal birth is pretty much the same. It states that the risk of the baby ending up in NICU with a C-section is 13.9% compared to a vaginal birth which is 6.3%, so double the risk, BUT it says the research does not take into account the fact that most c-sections undertaken are for medical reasons and therefore the likelihood of the baby needing NICU attention after it's born is increased anyway.

It then went on to say that the risks of an unplanned, emergency C-Section are a lot higher than a natural birth/ elective/ planned C-Section. So I guess if each woman was guaranteed to have a straightforward, natural birth, then great, but a lot of women do end up needing an emergency c-section so, technically they are more at risk than someone who has chosen an elective.

This now seems like I am bashing natural delivery and I'm not at all I totally admire and respect women that chose that route, I only wish I were that brave.

However, the responses I have had from people my whole pregnancy when I have admitted I am opting for an elective C-section have been ridiculous. Not one person has responded positively, all I've had is 'Oh, really? Are you sure??' and 'Oh, why on earth would you elect to have that?' etc etc. Or just a stony faced, tight smile and 'oh right' making it clear they disapprove but not actually coming out and saying it.

I got told last night that the reason I'm getting these reactions is because a C-section is 'taking the easy way out '😕

If that's the case, why on earth wouldn't you? Why is it that it seems the prerequisite to being a good mother is seemingly having to martyr yourself all the time?

So many of my friends that have had children and also the women in my NCT class who are preparing for their births have all expressed dismay/ distress at having to have any pain relief, they all want it to be as natural as possible and I know my friends that haven't had 'textbook' births still harbour 'guilt' and sadness to this day. Why? If you need gas and air or an epidural, so what? What exactly am I missing? If they ended/end up with forceps or an emergency section, it's not their fault, it's just one of those things. Surely modern medicine has provided these things to make childbirth safer?

Anyway, gone off on a tangent now but if you disapprove of someone having an elective c-section, could you tell me why?

OP posts:
HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 14:13

HoppingPavlova · 28/04/2022 14:08

To those that don’t, please explain how forcing a woman to give birth vaginally against her wishes is reasonable. And then please explain how that is different to forcing a woman to give birth against her wishes by denying her safe access to abortion.

Everyone should be able to make informed choices about their health and bodies. However, a more reasonable analogy would be why don’t we give an MRI to everyone who comes along and demands it, which is pretty much every second person these days. Ultimately, would more people benefit from an MRI, yes. Can this be justified with cost/resource, no. Why can’t people make informed choices and have the medicine they want? Why can’t they just demand a 2nd or 3rd line agent as first line rather than waiting to see if first line does the trick or fails? Why can’t they have an informed choice? Because while it may benefit an individual, cost/benefit it doesn’t stack up in the greater model.

The harsh reality is there is no bottomless pot for health. It’s a finite pot and you have to make it stretch to cover everyone, and often that means most people have something that, while not ideal is adequate as opposed to a few having something ideal and leaving the pot empty to cover everyone else.

Again, why are you still maintaining that providing ELCS is more expensive for the NHS? If you're going to claim the cost/benefit doesn't stack up, especially if for some reason you think it can be compared to giving MRIs to 50% of the population, the onus is on you to prove that.

HoppingPavlova · 28/04/2022 14:08

To those that don’t, please explain how forcing a woman to give birth vaginally against her wishes is reasonable. And then please explain how that is different to forcing a woman to give birth against her wishes by denying her safe access to abortion.

Everyone should be able to make informed choices about their health and bodies. However, a more reasonable analogy would be why don’t we give an MRI to everyone who comes along and demands it, which is pretty much every second person these days. Ultimately, would more people benefit from an MRI, yes. Can this be justified with cost/resource, no. Why can’t people make informed choices and have the medicine they want? Why can’t they just demand a 2nd or 3rd line agent as first line rather than waiting to see if first line does the trick or fails? Why can’t they have an informed choice? Because while it may benefit an individual, cost/benefit it doesn’t stack up in the greater model.

The harsh reality is there is no bottomless pot for health. It’s a finite pot and you have to make it stretch to cover everyone, and often that means most people have something that, while not ideal is adequate as opposed to a few having something ideal and leaving the pot empty to cover everyone else.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 28/04/2022 12:14

I firmly believe that women should have an informed choice about their health, their bodies and giving birth.

To those that don’t, please explain how forcing a woman to give birth vaginally against her wishes is reasonable.

And then please explain how that is different to forcing a woman to give birth against her wishes by denying her safe access to abortion.

Bingbangbongbash · 28/04/2022 11:56

@vivainsomnia there is nothing selfish about exercising your rights, and as people have explained, there is nothing ‘obvious’ about the cost implications of either birth choice. Is popping a kid out at home with a community midwife cheaper than a team of surgeons performing a CS? Yes. But when you factor in blue lighting to hospital, NICU care, repairs to the mother and all the other frequent traumas birthing mums face, the equation isn’t so simple.

And that’s even before you start factoring in any mental health costs - which we all know aren’t taken seriously enough at any level.

I can’t work out if the women castigating others for choosing CS are dim or just extremely misogynistic.

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/04/2022 11:28

Genuinely don’t know how anyone could argue with @LunaLovegoodsNecklace post

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/04/2022 11:27

LunaLovegoodsNecklace · 28/04/2022 10:44

So much misogyny on this thread, made even more hideous by the fact that it's coming from other women.

I've had two ELCS and they were fantastic experiences. Couldn't really give a toss what anyone thinks about it, and I never did when my children were babies either. I was happy and confident that I'd had the births that were best for me and my babies. No lasting health effects, which I am grateful for. I think it's a lottery as to whether you will recover well and be left with ongoing health problems, whether a vaginal birth or a C-section. And the chances of problems are less for ELCS than EMCS for obvious reasons.

Women should be supported to make the choice that is right for them without judgement, be that a vaginal or CS birth. All this nonsense about cost as well- PP's have correctly pointed out the costs around inductions, instrumental deliveries, the support needed for a woman choosing to have a VB when a CS may be safer in that instance, and also the care required after for those who have suffered traumatic injuries. All of these things probably cost similar or more than an ELCS. What about number of children as well? I have had two ELCS on the NHS- what about women who have 3,4,5+ VB's? Does anyone criticise them in the same way for the cost to the NHS of their births?

Here, here 🙌

Louise0701 · 28/04/2022 11:18

@JustDanceAddict that’s your experience. I’ve had 3 and never had any problems whatsoever establishing breastfeeding and it certainly didn’t take me 3 weeks to feel “normal” I was up and about normally by the end of the first week each time and drove after about 10 days

Yerroblemom1923 · 28/04/2022 10:59

I think the key word is "elective", you've chosen this route. Many don't have a choice. And yes, natural is always seen as best just as breast feeding is viewed better than bottle feeding. There will always be judgement but an Emergency C section is viewed v differently than if you choose to have one iyswim.

LunaLovegoodsNecklace · 28/04/2022 10:57

vivainsomnia · 28/04/2022 10:50

Don’t try and make this poor woman feel bad for exercising her rights - rights that have been put in place by medical experts and policy makers with far more information and knowledge than you. Shame on you
That's ridiculous. It is a selfish choice, but that doesn't mean anyone should feel ashamed. Everyone make selfish decisions at one point in their lives. As I said clearly, it's not the end of the world!

I would have thought though it was obvious that it was more expensive.

It's more than a uncomplicated, non instrumental, no induction required and no traumatic injury sustained vaginal delivery but honestly, how many of those actually happen?

The costs around the VB's that are not entirely straightforward are never scrutinised in the same way as ELCS. It's all misogyny against women- how dare a women make a choice of something that may cost more but that in all likelihood benefits her. The costs of dealing with traumatic injuries are ok, because at least she's suffered! Disgusting but that really seems to be the attitude of many.

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 10:55

vivainsomnia · 28/04/2022 10:50

Don’t try and make this poor woman feel bad for exercising her rights - rights that have been put in place by medical experts and policy makers with far more information and knowledge than you. Shame on you
That's ridiculous. It is a selfish choice, but that doesn't mean anyone should feel ashamed. Everyone make selfish decisions at one point in their lives. As I said clearly, it's not the end of the world!

I would have thought though it was obvious that it was more expensive.

It's not at all obvious, no.

Is that your way of saying that you just made an assumption about cost and didn't look into it at all?

vivainsomnia · 28/04/2022 10:50

Don’t try and make this poor woman feel bad for exercising her rights - rights that have been put in place by medical experts and policy makers with far more information and knowledge than you. Shame on you
That's ridiculous. It is a selfish choice, but that doesn't mean anyone should feel ashamed. Everyone make selfish decisions at one point in their lives. As I said clearly, it's not the end of the world!

I would have thought though it was obvious that it was more expensive.

LunaLovegoodsNecklace · 28/04/2022 10:44

So much misogyny on this thread, made even more hideous by the fact that it's coming from other women.

I've had two ELCS and they were fantastic experiences. Couldn't really give a toss what anyone thinks about it, and I never did when my children were babies either. I was happy and confident that I'd had the births that were best for me and my babies. No lasting health effects, which I am grateful for. I think it's a lottery as to whether you will recover well and be left with ongoing health problems, whether a vaginal birth or a C-section. And the chances of problems are less for ELCS than EMCS for obvious reasons.

Women should be supported to make the choice that is right for them without judgement, be that a vaginal or CS birth. All this nonsense about cost as well- PP's have correctly pointed out the costs around inductions, instrumental deliveries, the support needed for a woman choosing to have a VB when a CS may be safer in that instance, and also the care required after for those who have suffered traumatic injuries. All of these things probably cost similar or more than an ELCS. What about number of children as well? I have had two ELCS on the NHS- what about women who have 3,4,5+ VB's? Does anyone criticise them in the same way for the cost to the NHS of their births?

Rosesandbutterflys · 28/04/2022 10:20

Comefromaway · 28/04/2022 09:57

It's "frowned upon" because it is surgery and with any surgery there comes increased costs to the NHS but more importantly, risk to mum & baby.

However, saying that c sections are often necessary. The decision whether or not to have one should be a clinical decision which includes effects on mental health.

Have you actually read any of the thread?! And any of the supporting evidence/ statistics re risk and cost? It's NOT true that it's riskier and it's NOT true that it's more costly. You've literally just come on and arrogantly and smugly said the sky is green and then trotted off all self-satisfied.

OP posts:
LittlemissMama67 · 28/04/2022 10:06

If baffles me that in this day and age women can be so unsupportive and rude to other women, does it cost you personally a penny if Jane down the street has an elective section? And if the answer it is “YeS I pAy TaXeS”

don’t we all? And I’m sure I’ve inadvertently paid for something for you in the same way, unless you’ve never been to the doctors, had an operation, called the police the list goes on. Put a sock in it seriously.

it’s honestly just jealousy that they get the option to have a calm and pain free birth while you had to go through labour, if it isn’t that then why not just live and let live.

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 10:02

It's "frowned upon" because it is surgery and with any surgery there comes increased costs to the NHS but more importantly, risk to mum & baby

This just isn't true.

WishingWell5 · 28/04/2022 10:01

Our bodies are not designed to give birth naturally in many cases. If we were to truly give birth naturally with NO medical intervention there would be a very high level of deaths, mother and baby. To put it simply, we have evolved to max capacity where the child's head is so large it puts huge strain on the mother to give birth and in some cases it is simply not possible. And it is undoubtedly a fact that many babies who die in childbirth would have survived in an elective c section. You can never know what is best or 'right' until you are in the thick of it, but I am a strong believer of following your instincts and what you feel to be right for you.

Comefromaway · 28/04/2022 09:57

It's "frowned upon" because it is surgery and with any surgery there comes increased costs to the NHS but more importantly, risk to mum & baby.

However, saying that c sections are often necessary. The decision whether or not to have one should be a clinical decision which includes effects on mental health.

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 09:55

Those deaths, of course, often giving rise to compensation payments as well. This too is a cost that has to be factored into maternity budgets.

Honestly, the failure of the money money money brigade to actually cost this properly is really stark. If you want to argue that the NHS can't afford a particular option, do so on the basis of what it actually costs. It's incredibly telling how many people can't look beyond straightforward vaginal birth is cheaper for the NHS than anything else at the delivery stage.

Hospedia · 28/04/2022 09:50

Here's a novel idea: why doesn't the NHS impartially state the pros/advantages and cons/risks of vaginal birth and caesarean birth and then allow women to make an informed choice for themselves? We're not infants. We don't need a pat on the head and a lollypop for being brave and doing it right. It's our bodies so it should be our choice and if a woman sees a greater benefit vs risk analysis in caesarean birth over vaginal birth (and visa versa) then she should absolutely be able to make that choice for herself.

Agree also that problems with the NHS are down to poor funding and management not women requesting caesareans - only around 3% of the NHS budget is spent on maternity services, a tiny amount in overall spending. The cost differences between vaginal births and caesarean births are minimal, particularly when looking at long term postnatal issues, the difference is that caesarean births have that spending up front and vaginal births have it over a longer period. Breastfeeding can be impacted by caesarean birth but that's more to do with lack of support than lack of post-birth oxytocin, there will always be women who can't breastfeed or who don't want to breastfeed and that's their choice, they shouldn't be pressured either way, but for those who do want to attempt it post-caesarean then proper support and advice on establishing it can help but again this is lacking due to lack of funding (and that's also true for women who have had vaginal births).

Maybe instead of getting twisted up about caesareans bleeding the NHS coffers dry, you should instead get angry about the pittance spent on maternity care that means outcomes are frequently compromised, partners have to stay overnight in what should be a female patient only space to provide care that should be carried out by staff, and the fetishisation of natural birth that has actively contributed to maternal and neonatal deaths?

AgnesWestern · 28/04/2022 09:41

I had an elective c-section and it was the best option for me. I was extremely anxious about it, but they gave me morphine and diazepam into my arm and I felt fine, literally the calmest I’ve ever felt, which is crazy as they were cutting me open!

They put him to my breast straight away and I fed him myself for just over a year in the end, so having a c section didn’t affect that at all.

I was in pain after for about 10 days, but I didn’t need to take all the painkillers they gave me to take home.
The worst part was the trapped wind and when they removed the catheter. But overall it wasn’t a bad experience at all.
He was a big baby, over 9lbs. So I’m pretty sure I’d have ended up with some sort of intervention like forceps or even an emergency c-section if I’d had him naturally.

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/04/2022 09:38

@SweetPetrichor

misogony is alive and well in you isn’t it? Loads of bollocks you’ve said

Bingbangbongbash · 28/04/2022 09:33

@Franklyfrost absolute bullshit. I had no medical concerns prior to birth at all, but my baby got stuck and I ended up with an EMCS. For my second I tried again for a natural birth - again, no complications. But again the baby was stuck. This time I stayed the course with my ‘natural’ birth and ended up with a full team of emergency medics ripping me open. Turns out I’m one of the women who would have died in childbirth had I not lived in one of the most developed countries in the world. Since then I’ve had endless tests and procedures to try and fix me up. My natural birth has definitely cost the NHS a packet - and that’s not even counting the many, many appointments and tests I had before my second birth to see if I should go VBAC or ELCS.

Your ignorance is appalling. The NHS is on its knees because of chronic underfunding and piss poor management, not women choosing CS.

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 09:24

Where is this NHS that offers all women enough drugs to not feel any pain during their vaginal delivery, out of interest? I must've delivered my vaginally birthed offspring in a different one.

Franklyfrost · 28/04/2022 09:17

@Squillerman Squillerman · 28/04/2022 08:50
Some people say a natural delivery is more cost effective for the NHS but it really isn’t, there’s barely anything in it especially if it’s a traumatic delivery with spinal, forceps etc.

I had ELCS with my last two DC after traumatic vaginal births. There’s no way the ELCS cost the NHS more than me being rushed into theatre with a retained placenta and then a couple of blood transfusions. I was also in hospital recovering for 3 days, out the next morning after my ELCS.

If you have complications, during a natural or c-section birth, it’s going to cost more. If you have a medical need then a c-section is obviously right. However the majority of births could be successful with just a clean room, basic equipment and the occasional presence of a midwife. Not that that extreme should be forced upon people but it’s worth remembering that it exists as an option for most births.

The NHS paying for lifestyle surgery when it is struggling to find vital surgery is morally wrong. Individuals with no health concerns should pay for an elective c-section themselves or take all the drugs on offer from the NHS and not feel any pain or even be particularly aware of their vaginal delivery.

Bingbangbongbash · 28/04/2022 09:00

@vivainsomnia its not a selfish choice at all. The NHS is set up to treat everyone, regardless of their personal choices. We don’t refuse to treat rugby players’ broken bones because they are ‘selfish’ for playing a dangerous sport. We don’t refuse to treat smokers or alcoholics or drug addicts because of some sort of misplaced value judgements on their lives. Don’t try and make this poor woman feel bad for exercising her rights - rights that have been put in place by medical experts and policy makers with far more information and knowledge than you. Shame on you.

Every women should have the right to choose their own birth method. Having had both a ‘natural’ birth and an EMCS, I would choose an ELCS next time (there won’t be a next time, largely because of the trauma of my ‘natural’ birth).

OP - the only people who should feel shame are those who are judging your choice. If men gave birth this wouldn’t even be a debate.