Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why having an elective C-Section is so frowned upon?

663 replies

Rosesandbutterflys · 27/04/2022 11:50

I am (hopefully) having an elective C-Section soon. First baby, don't want anymore children after.

I've always had a fear of child birth, which over the past 5 years has been compounded by a lot of people around me having children and the vast majority of these (though I appreciate I'm probably unlucky here) have been pretty traumatic births that have ended in severe tears, forceps and a lot of the time, an emergency section anyway. Granted their experiences have mostly been better on their second birth/ child.

Nothing and I truly mean nothing about natural childbirth/ labour appeals to me. Not the hours of pain, pushing, potential rips/ tears, forcep intervention, epidural (yes I appreciate I'd have one of these for a section), damage of my pelvic floor and the panic and stress of potentially having to be rushed to theatre because it just wasn't going to happen naturally and the baby is in distress or whatever.

Now don't get me wrong, nothing about a c-section appeals to me either, it's absolutely no walk in the park and I'm dreading it, but it has to come out some way and I am a person that likes to plan things and to somewhat be in control/ aware of the plan. I have also had abdominal surgery before (though not as severe as a C-section) and I know recovery is likely to be painful and slower than if I were to have a natural birth. But for me, this is the preferred/ lesser of the 2 evils option.

I have also spent hours pouring over research as to the benefits of a vaginal birth over a c-section and last night came across a NICE/ NHS study/ research that found that actually, for a planned/ elective c-section, the risk to the mother of a c-section compared to a vaginal birth is pretty much the same. It states that the risk of the baby ending up in NICU with a C-section is 13.9% compared to a vaginal birth which is 6.3%, so double the risk, BUT it says the research does not take into account the fact that most c-sections undertaken are for medical reasons and therefore the likelihood of the baby needing NICU attention after it's born is increased anyway.

It then went on to say that the risks of an unplanned, emergency C-Section are a lot higher than a natural birth/ elective/ planned C-Section. So I guess if each woman was guaranteed to have a straightforward, natural birth, then great, but a lot of women do end up needing an emergency c-section so, technically they are more at risk than someone who has chosen an elective.

This now seems like I am bashing natural delivery and I'm not at all I totally admire and respect women that chose that route, I only wish I were that brave.

However, the responses I have had from people my whole pregnancy when I have admitted I am opting for an elective C-section have been ridiculous. Not one person has responded positively, all I've had is 'Oh, really? Are you sure??' and 'Oh, why on earth would you elect to have that?' etc etc. Or just a stony faced, tight smile and 'oh right' making it clear they disapprove but not actually coming out and saying it.

I got told last night that the reason I'm getting these reactions is because a C-section is 'taking the easy way out '😕

If that's the case, why on earth wouldn't you? Why is it that it seems the prerequisite to being a good mother is seemingly having to martyr yourself all the time?

So many of my friends that have had children and also the women in my NCT class who are preparing for their births have all expressed dismay/ distress at having to have any pain relief, they all want it to be as natural as possible and I know my friends that haven't had 'textbook' births still harbour 'guilt' and sadness to this day. Why? If you need gas and air or an epidural, so what? What exactly am I missing? If they ended/end up with forceps or an emergency section, it's not their fault, it's just one of those things. Surely modern medicine has provided these things to make childbirth safer?

Anyway, gone off on a tangent now but if you disapprove of someone having an elective c-section, could you tell me why?

OP posts:
pinkappleorpineapple · 28/04/2022 15:17

Who are these people asking about how you plan to give birth? It's no one's business.
Even with an ELCS planned there is a chance you could have a vaginal birth of things were to happen very quickly so if you don't want to tell them just say you aren't sure.

No one apart from my husbandand medical staff knows that I had an ELCS booked. I suppose I could foresee a lot of the negative responses here and just decided to avoid listening to a load of crap.

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 15:17

LunaLovegoodsNecklace · 28/04/2022 15:03

@HardyBuckette you said what I wanted to, much more articulately 😂

Thanks!

MissChanandlerBong80 · 28/04/2022 15:10

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 15:04

And if anything the relative costs probably look more favourable to ELCS now than they did in 2011, for two reasons.

One, because the birthing population has only got older, heavier and with a higher percentage of first timers since then, so the chances of the sort of vaginal birth that's cheaper than an ELCS is probably lower now than it was in the 00s. If I were being totally cynical, I'd speculate that this is part of the reason why we've seen the move from NICE and in clinical practice.

And two, because the case law in clinical negligence has developed since then. At the time NICE made that calculation, the Montgomery v Lanarkshire Supreme Court decision was still a few years away.

Yes - I wonder if those figures take into account the whopping amount the NHS pays out every year in negligence claims relating to botched vaginal births? If it doesn’t, I suspect the true financial balance would be vastly in favour of ELCSs.

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 15:04

LunaLovegoodsNecklace · 28/04/2022 15:00

Why are you so wrapped up in incorrect assumptions on cost, @HoppingPavlova?

Did you not read the very first line of the article @EarlGreywithLemon posted?

According to a 2011 Nice analysis, the expense of MRCs [Maternal Request C Sections] is only marginally higher than that of planned vaginal births, if treatment for related issues such as incontinence is taken into account.

Marginally higher. Clearly not much of an issue. Cost is much more complicated than the upfront cost of an ELCS vs VB. Clearly the cost of a VB can vary massively from being a lot cheaper than ELCS to much more expensive if lots of follow up treatment etc is required.

And never mind the human cost- of a woman being able to live comfortably, without incontinence and awful injuries, probably exacerbating PND, that's just a few things off the top of my head.

And if anything the relative costs probably look more favourable to ELCS now than they did in 2011, for two reasons.

One, because the birthing population has only got older, heavier and with a higher percentage of first timers since then, so the chances of the sort of vaginal birth that's cheaper than an ELCS is probably lower now than it was in the 00s. If I were being totally cynical, I'd speculate that this is part of the reason why we've seen the move from NICE and in clinical practice.

And two, because the case law in clinical negligence has developed since then. At the time NICE made that calculation, the Montgomery v Lanarkshire Supreme Court decision was still a few years away.

Allthe4s · 28/04/2022 15:04

*right word

LunaLovegoodsNecklace · 28/04/2022 15:03

@HardyBuckette you said what I wanted to, much more articulately 😂

Allthe4s · 28/04/2022 15:03

I confess to not having RTFT - because back in the real world no one I know has ever made comments to me or each other about people’s choice of labour or feeding. It’s such an non-issue it’s not discussed.

That’s probably because I don’t hang around with bellends who are judgy, nor do I judge other people. In fact judge isn’t even the right in this scenario.

When your child is older you’ll realise this is all just nonsense and blown way out of proportion, both in your head and what sounds like others around you. If you want an ELCS go for it.

LunaLovegoodsNecklace · 28/04/2022 15:02

Yep exactly! People like @HoppingPavlova can be a martyr all they like and kid themselves that they are such a good person for saving the NHS all that moneyyyy (even though they actually aren’t). You do you girl. But I and plenty of other women will do what is best for them when it comes to how they give birth and rightly so. Times have moved on.

Agree 100% @LuckySantangelo35

LunaLovegoodsNecklace · 28/04/2022 15:00

Why are you so wrapped up in incorrect assumptions on cost, @HoppingPavlova?

Did you not read the very first line of the article @EarlGreywithLemon posted?

According to a 2011 Nice analysis, the expense of MRCs [Maternal Request C Sections] is only marginally higher than that of planned vaginal births, if treatment for related issues such as incontinence is taken into account.

Marginally higher. Clearly not much of an issue. Cost is much more complicated than the upfront cost of an ELCS vs VB. Clearly the cost of a VB can vary massively from being a lot cheaper than ELCS to much more expensive if lots of follow up treatment etc is required.

And never mind the human cost- of a woman being able to live comfortably, without incontinence and awful injuries, probably exacerbating PND, that's just a few things off the top of my head.

EarlGreywithLemon · 28/04/2022 14:59

@MassiveSalad22 yep, I wish that too. Especially as I asked that question in my NCT class and was assured that it was never too late in labour for an EMCS...

MassiveSalad22 · 28/04/2022 14:57

‘In reality, that's not true. When labour gets to the point where forceps is needed, it's often too late to have an EMCS without significant risks to both mother and baby, because the baby is often low in the birth canal and would need to be pushed back up for the EMCS. I know, because I was in exactly that situation myself. I said on my birth plan that I would want an EMCS over forceps. ‘

I could have written that! Wish that was common knowledge.

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/04/2022 14:55

Thatcountrymum · 28/04/2022 14:52

At the end of the day it's your body and your choice, I had an elective c section, I was meant to have a home birth but baby was breach, they would have tryed to turn him but the risk and complications that went with it wasn't worth it, I had the c section and was out the next day, recovery is different for everyone, you do what you think is best for you and baby that's main and the most important thing, the fact you have a high risk pregnancy, if I was in your shoes I would do the exact same thing, x

Yep exactly! People like @HoppingPavlova can be a martyr all they like and kid themselves that they are such a good person for saving the NHS all that moneyyyy (even though they actually aren’t). You do you girl. But I and plenty of other women will do what is best for them when it comes to how they give birth and rightly so. Times have moved on.

EarlGreywithLemon · 28/04/2022 14:54

"Trial of labour" is such a misleading term. It gives the impression that the "trial" can stop at any point if it's not working. It can't. What I mean is: women are often told that they have the option to decline forceps and move on the ELCS if the labour isn't going to plan. In reality, that's not true. When labour gets to the point where forceps is needed, it's often too late to have an EMCS without significant risks to both mother and baby, because the baby is often low in the birth canal and would need to be pushed back up for the EMCS. I know, because I was in exactly that situation myself. I said on my birth plan that I would want an EMCS over forceps. The team were ready to offer me one, but explained very clearly why this would be risky for both the baby and me. Obviously I went for forceps; I would always avoid putting my baby in danger, whatever the cost to me. So would most women.

Also- the ventouse. Everyone knows the risks of forceps, but the ventouse is less talked about, and is brutal. Two people were holding me back on the operating table whilst they were pulling with it. The damage to me (3b tear) was done by the ventouse.

From the RCOG "Caesarean in the late stage of labour is a more complex operation than a planned caesarean and in some circumstances may increase the risk of harm to both you and your baby.
Decision making in labour can be difficult which is why it is important to explore any concerns you may have with your healthcare professional before you go into labour.
If you are certain you would not want an assisted vaginal birth, one option is to choose a planned caesarean birth before you go into labour."

Thatcountrymum · 28/04/2022 14:52

At the end of the day it's your body and your choice, I had an elective c section, I was meant to have a home birth but baby was breach, they would have tryed to turn him but the risk and complications that went with it wasn't worth it, I had the c section and was out the next day, recovery is different for everyone, you do what you think is best for you and baby that's main and the most important thing, the fact you have a high risk pregnancy, if I was in your shoes I would do the exact same thing, x

MassiveSalad22 · 28/04/2022 14:48

I needed a year of physio after my vaginal birth so I’m sure that was costly 😄

HoppingPavlova · 28/04/2022 14:48

That’s fine but where are you then clawing back money. Are you going to take it from oncology services, paeds? Who’s going without or being left with less than adequate? Things would be great in an ideal world where there was an adequate pot of money for everyone to have every choice they want and everyone to get ideal treatment. We don’t live in such a world.

It can only be solved by increasing the spend on health and god knows that’s needed. But where does that come from, education, defence? Hang on, here’s an idea, people pay more tax so the pot is bigger and they get what they want. What, they don’t want to pay more tax because they are being squeezed with increasing cost of living?

What’s your solution so that all of this is funded so that this utopia can be enacted?

HardyBuckette · 28/04/2022 14:45

HoppingPavlova · 28/04/2022 14:35

Again, why are you still maintaining that providing ELCS is more expensive for the NHS? If you're going to claim the cost/benefit doesn't stack up, especially if for some reason you think it can be compared to giving MRIs to 50% of the population, the onus is on you to prove that.

You want me to justify that a bed for a standard vaginal birth is not more cost effective than a bed for a C-sec? And this is why trial of labour is standard unless otherwise indicated (and of course there are reasons why it wouldn’t be).

Nope. Although the fact that you think that's what it actually comes down to says a lot.

I want you to justify your claim that offering maternal request ELCS doesn't stack up on a cost benefit level and can't be justified due to resources. This is very, very different to comparing the costs between an ELCS and a straightforward vaginal birth.

The first reason for this is because attempting a straightforward vaginal birth doesn't mean you get one. Instrumental births and emergency sections are both consequences of attempting vaginal birth rather than having an ELCS. They're both obviously more expensive than a straightforward vaginal birth. They go into the costs of attempted VB not the costs of ELCS column.

The second reason is that costs persist after the births. Costs of treatment required after complications of vaginal birth and indeed of EMCS are both costs of attempted vaginal birth. They have to be part of the pot as well.

There is also the issue of legal costs, which are part of the NHS maternity care budget. You're going to have to factor those into your cost benefit analysis.

Lastly, it's also wrong that trial of labour is standard unless indicated. NICE guidance is that women can request elective section without any medical indication other than their preference and while that's not observed across the board, it happens enough that trials of labour unless indicated most certainly are not standard.

HoppingPavlova · 28/04/2022 14:41

A bed for a vaginal birth is missing, at minimum, required theatre staff including but not limited to ob and anaesthetist, recovery staff, duration of stay is longer on average so add in ward support, additional pharmacy spend.

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/04/2022 14:39

@HoppingPavlova

”a trial of labour” is the same as forcing a woman to give birth naturally, it’s abhorrent and misogynistic.

A woman may seek a c section to avoid the possible complications of a natural birth like incontinence or tearing… is that really so weird and deviant??

LunaLovegoodsNecklace · 28/04/2022 14:38

@HoppingPavlova so are you suggesting that NICE guidelines aren't important then?

@EarlGreywithLemon that's a very interesting article and shows clearly why NICE changed their guidelines. Actually based on evidence rather than blatant misogyny and an apparent desire to want women to suffer/be punished, which has frequently been expressed on this thread.

HoppingPavlova · 28/04/2022 14:35

Again, why are you still maintaining that providing ELCS is more expensive for the NHS? If you're going to claim the cost/benefit doesn't stack up, especially if for some reason you think it can be compared to giving MRIs to 50% of the population, the onus is on you to prove that.

You want me to justify that a bed for a standard vaginal birth is not more cost effective than a bed for a C-sec? And this is why trial of labour is standard unless otherwise indicated (and of course there are reasons why it wouldn’t be).

EarlGreywithLemon · 28/04/2022 14:35

Sorry that the link pasted in a really funny place in the above. It wasn't like that in the preview!

EarlGreywithLemon · 28/04/2022 14:32

A very interesting article here on this:

A few relevant points:

Cost - "According to a 2011 Nice analysis, the expense of MRCs [Maternal Request C Sections] is only marginally higher than that of planned vaginal births, if treatment for related issues such as incontinence is taken into account. El-Chaâr thinks this might be especially true for parents over 40, who are often induced early but then sit around for a long time, waiting for active labour to start. “I would not be surprised if it’s cheaper to have a planned elective in that group,” she says." - and that is whilst the NHS provides next to no care for birth injuries, as all sufferers know. If it did, Caesareans or vaginal births: should mothers or medics have the final say?the costs would easily tip the other way.

Risks- "The risk of vaginal birth is often underestimated, so the comparison is skewed. This is because researchers do not always account for emergency caesareans as an outcome of attempted vaginal births. In fact, many older studies lump in the emergency C-section risk with the risk of all other caesareans, despite the fact that they are clearly more dangerous and almost always the result of a vaginal birth not going to plan. As Nice makes clear, ideally, studies would compare people planning a C-section with those planning a vaginal birth, but this information is rarely available.
These factors make it very tricky to estimate the risk of choosing a C-section versus planning a vaginal birth, but not impossible. In 2021, a team of Canadian researchers found a hospital database in Ontario that, unusually, had logged MRCs. This allowed them to compare MRCs to other low-risk pregnancies where the plan, but not necessarily the outcome, was a vaginal birth. The data shocked the study’s head author, Darine El-Chaâr, a perinatal researcher at the Ottawa hospital. In the planned vaginal birth group, there was a higher percentage of negative outcomes compared with the MRC group, driven by serious vaginal tears and babies admitted to intensive care."

HoppingPavlova · 28/04/2022 14:29

And nor do they have to juggle with making a pot stretch.

LunaLovegoodsNecklace · 28/04/2022 14:22

@HoppingPavlova you mention 'harsh realities' about no bottomless pit for health- you are aware that the 'reality' is that women are able to request ELCS and have been able to do so since the NICE guidelines changed in 2011? And whilst not perfect, most trusts are following this- indeed even trusts like John Radcliffe in Oxford have changed their stance having been awful over ELCS in the fairly recent past. So you can say all you want that ELCS isn't justified- NICE don't agree with you however.