Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cold Water Therapy Death

58 replies

StridTheKiller · 27/04/2022 07:29

www.thesun.co.uk/news/18383425/woman-dies-celebrity-cold-water-therapy-coleen-rooney/

This is so sad. Is this therapy safe?

OP posts:
Rosehugger · 27/04/2022 10:22

I just think it's crazy and doesn't suit some people at all. I hate HATE cold water, and wouldn't touch it with a bargepole. Swmming in the sea and in lakes is wonderful, but I don't do it unless I know the water will be a reasonable termperature. Some people love it, my MIL swam in a cool pool once and enjoyed it and I got in the same pool and couldn't warm up at all and felt like I was going to die if I didn't get out and get warm quickly. It's horrible.

SageCardy · 27/04/2022 10:16

DurhamDurham · 27/04/2022 08:25

I did a Wim Hof training course with work a few weeks back in the Lake District, it was mainly indoors with lots of breathing exercises and information on how to warm up quickly after cold water therapy. Towards the end of the day we did all go into the river, it was v cold but we all felt brilliant. We were warmed up quickly afterwards with soup and blankets.
We did have to complete health questionnaires and one of the party was advised not to get in due to a heart condition.
I really enjoyed the training, the breathing exercises were brilliant and I'd definitely go river swimming again.
Very upsetting and sad about the woman who died, she may have had an underlying health condition she wasn't aware of.
I don't think it's fair to say ALL these therapists/instructors are charlatans. Our instructor worked with Wim Hof for five years, she knew her stuff.

I did one of those courses back in December (our instructor was called Emma I think), it was wall to wall hippies, and great fun!

I felt so good after the dip, it gave me a taste for it and I've been doing dips (not swims) in local spots since then.

PierresPotato · 27/04/2022 10:13

I knew a man in his thirties who collapsed on a golf course and died as a result despite an immediate, trained response.
Such things do happen out of the blue sadly.

Snoken · 27/04/2022 10:10

I do ice swimming in Sweden and it's great for my arthiritis. I have been doing it for the last 5 years or so whenever I went to visit my family, now I live there and do it every morning. Although the ice is starting to melt on my lake, but it is still cold enough to have the desired effect for another couple of months.

It has therapeutic quilities, at least for me. I feel so good afterwards mentally, and my joints can tell if I haven't been doing it in a while.

Reallyreallyborednow · 27/04/2022 10:10

if you Google it, there are quite a few articles about it. Improved circulation is one supposed benefit, but I think the biggest one might be mental health benefits

i did google it. There is ongoing research, but currently it’s either proposed or theoretical benefits, or anecdotal.

there’s a couple of studies linking cold water immersion to a stress response, but then how do we know whether the stress response is a good thing?

nothing to show actual real positive effects on health. It may be mental, but how much of it is placebo- in which case it seems an awfully risky think to do to make yourself think you feel better.

there was the death of a mum in front of her kids recently too when she jumped into a plunge pool. It’s bloody terrifying.

we have so many drownings every year with people swimming in open water. It seems mad to be selling doing it in freezing water as “therapy”

reeeeeeee · 27/04/2022 09:44

Well what can you do? If you're sensible you look into things thoroughly before you do them. If not you suffer the consequences.

Cornettoninja · 27/04/2022 09:42

Hasn’t this been done for ages in Scandinavian countries? Sauna followed by a cold plunge?

I’m leaning towards this being a tragic event rather than something reasonably preventable. I can’t see anyone participating being subject to a full cardiac check up beforehand being workable.

Ylvamoon · 27/04/2022 09:31

Cold water therapy isn't a new thing at all...
But it is important to climatise and do it in a safe way by adhering to water safety rules.

ChampagneLassie · 27/04/2022 09:20

Cambridge University are currently doing research into the benefits of cold water exposure on delaying dementia. Anedotly I know several women who sea swim and believe it helps with their menopause symptoms. I live near a, lido and kniw lots of people who outdoor swim and find it exhilarating but aware it is risky

Ahgoonyegirlye · 27/04/2022 09:14

It’s awful, but someone dying of cold water shock like this is very rare. I swim in temps of as little as 0c all year round without a wetsuit but have acclimatised to doing so and done bit by bit, it’s incredibly beneficial.

Leftbutcameback · 27/04/2022 09:12

Presenting a death rate of 1 in 1100 as a useful statistic is completely disingenuous. It might be factually accurate but is one of those examples of being able to show anything with statistics.

A more useful measure would be the number of people who have died in similar situations, cold water swimming, similar therapy groups etc. if you read the article there was no “plunging” and it sounds very similar to slowly getting into cold water for swimming, albeit it it seems this was very cold for this country from what a PP says. I would be interested to hear that.

waterlego · 27/04/2022 09:06

And that feeling where you can’t catch your breath for a moment- yes, that’s what I got. I found that quite exhilarating but I guess some people would find it alarming.

waterlego · 27/04/2022 09:05

@Reallyreallyborednow , if you Google it, there are quite a few articles about it. Improved circulation is one supposed benefit, but I think the biggest one might be mental health benefits.

I’ve only ever immersed myself in very cold water a couple of times. Once was when I jumped into a pool under a waterfall in Spain. Another time was at the thermal spa in Bath where you are invited to pour a load of freezing cold water on your head straight after you’ve been in the steam room.

Both times I definitely got a sort of ‘high’. Just felt really alive and refreshed. Endorphins, I guess.

Reallyreallyborednow · 27/04/2022 08:53

Cold water swimming/dipping/showering is all the rage at the moment. It’s apparently really good for you

I’ve seen it too. Many people claiming “it’s good for you” but I haven’t seen any evidence for those claims. What exactly does getting into freezing cold water do and how does it benefit you?

i was a swimmer in my youth and unheated pools were relatively common, including outdoor. I remember getting into some so cold you couldn’t breathe for a few seconds. I don’t think it did me any good though!

StridTheKiller · 27/04/2022 08:52

Thankyou @DurhamDurham that is interesting and informative.
The death rate of this 'therapist' is 1 in 1100. Not sure of stats. re. skiing, exercising, sunbathing etc but this seems high?

OP posts:
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/04/2022 08:52

Isn’t this similar to the Scandinavians getting into ice cold water after they’ve been in a sauna? It’s not new.

everything can carry a risk, I’m not sure this is any riskier than anything else? Tragic yes.

Heracles1000 · 27/04/2022 08:47

WhereIsMyBrain · 27/04/2022 08:35

I'm a cold water swimmer and I find the way this is reported very confusing. Initially they say she plunged into ice cold water (incredibly dangerous). Later on they say she gradually got into a river in late April.

There's a huge difference in the risks of these two things. Plunging (which I take to mean jumping or diving) into cold water is dangerous even for experienced swimmers. Ice cold water (just above freezing) is a very different prospect from a river in April. Where I swim it's currently around 12 degrees, which is really cold if you're not used to cold water but a completely different level of risk to freezing water.

All cold water swimming carries risks. But the article does a really bad job of presenting how risky the thing this woman did was. Suspect it's only in the paper because of the Coleen Rooney connection.

I'm not a cold water swimmer and noted this as well.

ParisNoir · 27/04/2022 08:47

This is devastatingly tragic, my thoughts are with her family, but its very possible she may have had an unknown genetic heart issue. There have been a few footballers who have collapsed mid game and also died- are we going to ban football aswell? What about Natasha Richardson who died after hitting her head skiing?- ban that too? People have also died of heat stoke after spending the day in the hot sun on the beach- should we also ban sunbathing?

Where does it end?

Momicrone · 27/04/2022 08:42

Skiing is dangerous too

WhereIsMyBrain · 27/04/2022 08:35

I'm a cold water swimmer and I find the way this is reported very confusing. Initially they say she plunged into ice cold water (incredibly dangerous). Later on they say she gradually got into a river in late April.

There's a huge difference in the risks of these two things. Plunging (which I take to mean jumping or diving) into cold water is dangerous even for experienced swimmers. Ice cold water (just above freezing) is a very different prospect from a river in April. Where I swim it's currently around 12 degrees, which is really cold if you're not used to cold water but a completely different level of risk to freezing water.

All cold water swimming carries risks. But the article does a really bad job of presenting how risky the thing this woman did was. Suspect it's only in the paper because of the Coleen Rooney connection.

DurhamDurham · 27/04/2022 08:25

I did a Wim Hof training course with work a few weeks back in the Lake District, it was mainly indoors with lots of breathing exercises and information on how to warm up quickly after cold water therapy. Towards the end of the day we did all go into the river, it was v cold but we all felt brilliant. We were warmed up quickly afterwards with soup and blankets.
We did have to complete health questionnaires and one of the party was advised not to get in due to a heart condition.
I really enjoyed the training, the breathing exercises were brilliant and I'd definitely go river swimming again.
Very upsetting and sad about the woman who died, she may have had an underlying health condition she wasn't aware of.
I don't think it's fair to say ALL these therapists/instructors are charlatans. Our instructor worked with Wim Hof for five years, she knew her stuff.

EgonSpengler2020 · 27/04/2022 08:19

Some people can have undiagnosed heart arrhythmias (long QT syndrome) that predispose them to cardiac arrests in cold water shock, and other situations. Interestingly long QT syndrome is also one of the heart problems associated with COVID vaccines.

Whereas the vast majority people are fine but cold. Whatever floats your boat!!

Georgeskitchen · 27/04/2022 08:18

Isn't it a well known fact that suddenly plunging into very cold water can be dangerous? I've been aware of this for years and I'm no doctor!!

Sickoffamilydrama · 27/04/2022 08:16

Loads of people I know swim in the sea or lakes all year round, some that I know of are at least 60 years old. Like any exercise or water sport you need to be sensible but I hardly think we need to ban it. Youngish people can and do die of undiagnosed/unknown heart conditions.

Studies have found lots of benefits www.healthline.com/health/cold-water-therapy#how-to-use

I'm not taking away that this is an absolute tragedy for the woman and her family.

waterlego · 27/04/2022 08:11

Cold water swimming/dipping/showering is all the rage at the moment. I live by the beach and there is a group of women here who go in the sea every day of the year. It’s apparently really good for you and I’d like to try it but I’m not brave enough.

There is always a risk when getting into very cold water and it sounds as though participants had been informed of this and signed a waiver accordingly.

I’m not sure the owner should refer to himself as a therapist though as PP said.