Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cold Water Therapy Death

58 replies

StridTheKiller · 27/04/2022 07:29

www.thesun.co.uk/news/18383425/woman-dies-celebrity-cold-water-therapy-coleen-rooney/

This is so sad. Is this therapy safe?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Reallyreallyborednow · 28/04/2022 19:09

People have died after saunas- should we ban everyone from using them?

people aren’t generally too impaired to operate 2 ton machines at high speeds following a sauna and kill other people. Any risks from a sauna is to the individual making that choice.

the drink driving analogy is not a good one. If you choose to immerse yourself in cold water that’s your choice. Although if you get into trouble you may put others at risk if they attempt a rescue.

ParisNoir · 28/04/2022 18:25

Reallyreallyborednow · 28/04/2022 16:15

or the millions that are killed by drunk drivers - every single year, yet we dont ban alcohol do we?

yes. Drunk driving is banned.

My point is: we dont ban EVERYONE from drinking because one or two people cant cope with it and hurt others. This is the same. People have died after saunas- should we ban everyone from using them?

almondbran · 28/04/2022 16:25

StridTheKiller · 27/04/2022 08:52

Thankyou @DurhamDurham that is interesting and informative.
The death rate of this 'therapist' is 1 in 1100. Not sure of stats. re. skiing, exercising, sunbathing etc but this seems high?

That’s not how statistics work 🤦🏽‍♀️

Reallyreallyborednow · 28/04/2022 16:15

or the millions that are killed by drunk drivers - every single year, yet we dont ban alcohol do we?

yes. Drunk driving is banned.

Perime · 27/04/2022 21:00

meassociation.org.uk/2015/06/sam-cams-sister-stricken-with-m-e-for-a-year-daily-mail-27-june-2015/

This has always stuck in my mind as my DD has Issues with fatigue after having Glandular Fever. It was something she wanted to try so she could reset her symptoms. Long before I heard of the Wim Hof method.

ParisNoir · 27/04/2022 19:08

I booked a series of whole body cryotherapy chamber sessions (standing in an ice cold chamber for 4 minutes in only shorts and a bra). The benefits for me were immense. Firstly, it gives you a massive boost of seratonin- you feel wonderful afterwards. Secondly, Ive ramped up my exercise regime and was struggling with muscle strains and pain and it fixed that literally overnight. Thirdly, my skin complexion improved and I felt mentally sharper afterwards. They actually told a client just before me that he couldnt go into the chamber due to his blood pressure (too high) and he was really annoyed and started arguing with them but they remained firm so they do as many checks as they can to ensure safety. Living is a risk. I bet those people who went to work on 9/11 didnt expect to die either, or the millions that are killed by drunk drivers - every single year, yet we dont ban alcohol do we?

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/04/2022 14:40

@BoredZelda no one is being blasé about her death. It is tragic, as mentioned several times.

It is sensationalising her death by poor reporting that gives the impression it was the fault of the instructor or that celebrities are popularising a dangerous sport when by all accounts she collapsed after the swim.

I also suspect anyone doing an actual group like this has to read and sign waivers about potential danger.

Ski4130 · 27/04/2022 13:51

I cold water swim through autumn and winter in a lake and an unheated lido, and my mum and a friend have sent me this news story today. It's incredibly sad, and I feel so, so sorry for her children, family and friends.

Cold water swimming does carry risks, I'm not sure of the temperature of the lake this lady was swimming in, but the lake here has gone from 2.8 to 6.8 from the beginning of winter to now, and 2.8 was enough to take your breath away and would cause you to feel quite ill if you stayed in too long. At 2.8 degrees, 5 minutes is plenty for me swimming in a swimsuit, swim boots, swim gloves & bobble hat, and I'm not sure you could stay in too much longer in a wetsuit to be honest.

I absolutely get why people would think the idea of it is is horrible, but I genuinely feel invigorated, energised and ready for anything after a cold swim, and the friend and I who go together relish that time to ourselves, when you can think about nothing else but your breathing and keeping swimming as the cold water hits you.

UglyModernWindows · 27/04/2022 13:06

I am one of them Scandinavians and cold water swimming is not a new thing at all. Even the ancient Greeks were at it! There are many health benefits even though random over cautious mumsnetters try their best to discredit them.

Back home it's common to jump into a pile of snow after the sauna. Some folks go swimming in a frozen lake early mornings before they set off to the work (local councils make and maintain these holes in the lakes). No sauna or anything, just a cossie and a quick dip in the water.

This is a tragic accident, doesn't sound like the provider was at fault and there is no reason to ban the activity.

EdgeOfSeventeenAndThreeQuarter · 27/04/2022 12:39

@Testina 😂 it’s why the Scots are so good at swearing. Several millennia of entering icy waters cursing and squealing whilst attempting to beat off the cold by shielding our nipples with hands.

Testina · 27/04/2022 12:33

@EdgeOfSeventeenAndThreeQuarter for those of us that love the sting of the properly cold water, it’s you that has the luxury 😂

EdgeOfSeventeenAndThreeQuarter · 27/04/2022 12:27

I’m in Scotland so your talk of 13 degrees is pure luxury - even in the height of summer! 😂

despite swimming in water as low as 1 degree, I personally am not sure my body could take a plunge pool.

it’s well known for improving mental health and there was a bbc documentary on it a year or two ago. Might’ve been dr creepy Cristian.

ethelredonagoodday · 27/04/2022 12:22

It's very sad, and awful for the family of the lady who died.

As many have said upthread, this is a growing trend, probably with interest probably raised further due to the current Wim Hoff programme on BBC.

My husband and I (me less frequently than he) have started having cold showers over the last couple of years as a consequence of features in the media on the health benefits. It makes you feel good afterwards, even if at the time it takes your breath away. My DH went for an open water swim last week, for the first time, and managed really well, but he swam in a managed lake with a temp of 16 degrees. i think a gradual approach is needed for many people and risk factors need to be considered.

I think like others have suggested, many, many activities and sports carry risks. Some people sadly have undiagnosed or hidden health conditions which mean they are more at risk from certain activities. To suggest this activity should be banned is sensationalist and an overreaction I think, regardless of how very sad this incident is.

DurhamDurham · 27/04/2022 12:19

*I did one of those courses back in December (our instructor was called Emma I think), it was wall to wall hippies, and great fun!

I felt so good after the dip, it gave me a taste for it and I've been doing dips (not swims) in local spots since then*

@SageCardy We had Emma too! She was great, I even enjoyed the wild garlic soup despite my initial reservations.

waterlego · 27/04/2022 12:02

When you buy a treadmill or join a gym, there are warnings about safe exercising.

And these participants signed a waiver and completed a medical questionnaire before taking part in the cold water activity. She would have read about the possible risks before taking part.

it is a really sad thing to happen and my heart goes out to her family.

BoredZelda · 27/04/2022 11:59

So what? Intentionally taking part in cold water swimming or whatever is not the same as going into a lake expecting it to be warmer.

I am sorry for this woman and her family but this isn’t a new, dangerous thing. This was an unfortunate incident. My dad worked with a man who dropped dread on a treadmill, that doesn’t mean using one is dangerous.

When you buy a treadmill or join a gym, there are warnings about safe exercising. That people die doing other things, doesn’t mean we should be blasé about this woman’s death.

waterlego · 27/04/2022 11:40

BoredZelda · 27/04/2022 11:24

Cold water swimming/dipping/showering is all the rage at the moment. It’s apparently really good for you

And yet yesterday our local police force posted a warning on Facebook about swimming at this time of year because the water is colder than you think.

It’s good that your local force are raising awareness that it can be dangerous. I’ve heard that the sea is at its coldest at the moment because obviously such a large expanse of water takes time to respond to the air temp, which is why Sept/Oct is probably the best time to go sea swimming in the UK because the sea has been warming nicely all through the summer. It makes sense that the police have issued that warning now as we’ve had so much lovely weather recently (in my part of the UK at least), so more people are spending time on beaches. When people are at the beach on a sunny day, some of them will want to go in the sea and many will not know that the sea is particularly cold at the moment after a long winter.

The fact that swimming in cold water (and swimming full stop) can be dangerous doesn’t preclude it from also being a healthy thing to do for many people. Lots of things can be good for you but can also be dangerous in rare cases. Skiing was mentioned upthread. It’s excellent exercise and for those who enjoy it, it’s wonderful for your mental health. But sometimes people crash into trees or other skiers and get injured or worse. It’s for each individual to inform themselves about how to attempt the activity as safely as possible, and decide whether they find the risks proportionate to the benefits.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/04/2022 11:36

Yeah sorry the more I think about this the more irritating it gets.

This woman didn’t die because of negligence, she didn’t drown, it has nothing to do with the fact that Colleen Rooney has also done it. Saying the therapist now has a 1 in 1100 death rate is alarmist and quite frankly ridiculous.

Would you have the same reaction if it was a heart attack after just completing a sky dive? Because that’s about equivalent I would say.

Testina · 27/04/2022 11:29

Another person who swims outdoors year round. My English lake is 13° right now. The River Goyt wasn’t “ice cold”.
Poor, dramatic reporting.
A tragedy, but no-one can say why on the basis of that sensationalist twaddle.
Can you imagine reading that and thinking, my wife is DEAD and the focus here is clickbait mentions of “celebrities”?

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/04/2022 11:29

BoredZelda · 27/04/2022 11:24

Cold water swimming/dipping/showering is all the rage at the moment. It’s apparently really good for you

And yet yesterday our local police force posted a warning on Facebook about swimming at this time of year because the water is colder than you think.

So what? Intentionally taking part in cold water swimming or whatever is not the same as going into a lake expecting it to be warmer.

I am sorry for this woman and her family but this isn’t a new, dangerous thing. This was an unfortunate incident. My dad worked with a man who dropped dread on a treadmill, that doesn’t mean using one is dangerous.

BoredZelda · 27/04/2022 11:24

Cold water swimming/dipping/showering is all the rage at the moment. It’s apparently really good for you

And yet yesterday our local police force posted a warning on Facebook about swimming at this time of year because the water is colder than you think.

BoredZelda · 27/04/2022 11:20

I believe there is a tv series where contestants partake in this 'therapy'

I assume they do it with medical on standby and with rigorous health screening. They didn’t just put an advert on the local Facebook page offering it to anyone who rocks up with a hundred quid.

Manekinek0 · 27/04/2022 10:55

The headline is misleading. People die after doing all kinds of things, it is a shame but many people will have undiagnosed conditions.

waterlego · 27/04/2022 10:48

Actually, this article claims that studies have shown cold water swimming boosts the immune system by increasing white blood cell count. It doesn’t seem to cite the source of that research though.

www.iprshealth.com/news/8-benefits-of-cold-water-swimming/

waterlego · 27/04/2022 10:43

@Reallyreallyborednow I don’t disagree. It seems there isn’t enough research so far to declare definite health benefits (though plenty of anecdote, as you say). I agree with you that it is questionable to label it ‘therapy’.

But if people feel that it is helping them, even if only by placebo, then it’s a good thing for those people. Equally, people should be able to try it, provided they’ve been informed of the risks beforehand, and provided it hasn’t been labelled as therapy!

But then the word therapy gets used metaphorically at times doesn’t it? Retail therapy, for example! If someone finds a particular activity therapeutic, perhaps it is therapy to them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread