Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To understand the attitudes

41 replies

OrlaOrka · 26/04/2022 21:28

I hope I manage to articulate this enough so it makes sense! I have been watching the series on tv Yorkshire midwives on call, and have had a bit of a realisation with language we use around birth
The women having normal deliveries have been told things like ‘well done you’, ‘you’ve done amazing’ etc etc
The women who had a caesarean never had any such thing said to them. I myself have had 2 sections and never had anything like this said to me, and I spoke to a midwife friend who actually confirmed she agrees, women who push babies out often get this kind of praise where as women who have sections don’t often. I don’t know where I’m trying to go with this really but I think it’s going to make me definitely make an effort to any of my friends who have sections in the future tell them how amazing they have done!

I think what I’m interested to know is have any of you found the same? Or I am alone in this? (I really hope I am tbh).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OrlaOrka · 30/04/2022 19:31

@PortalooSunset absolutely love this! This is what I was trying to get across is that all birth is birth and should get the same recognition, not that women who have sections end up with a feeling like they haven’t done it properly! That midwife sounds brill

OP posts:
PortalooSunset · 30/04/2022 19:14

I have experience of both tbh! Emergency section for dc1 and I was treated appallingly. Very traumatic. Dc2 we'd moved so I birthed (planned section due to breech) in a different hospital and the staff were amazing. Really supportive and full of praise. I got a massive (gentle) bollocking from my community midwife when pregnant for saying (before I knew how things would turn out) that I wanted to give birth 'properly'. She told me I'd already done that when I had dc1. I bloody love that woman, totally changed my outlook. I was able to free myself from the shame of failure I'd felt for years.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/04/2022 18:30

PinkSyCo · 29/04/2022 22:02

Good to see ageism is alive and well on Mumsnet. Confused
That aside, your experience might make you deserving of sympathy, just like one might expect after any painful surgery. Any effort, however, was provided by the medical team, so if there’s praise to be had, it should all goes to them surely. Let’s just be thankful that, in this day and age, abdominal deliveries are on the whole a safe option and result in providing us with healthy babies. That’s all that matters surely?

Oh, hi, Iain.

Do you not think that a bloke with four adult children hanging around on a site to talk about vaginal deliveries, domestic abuse and feminism with women when his own children are in their twenties and his wife certainly hasn't been on here for at least a decade sounds just a tad creepy?

😀

Vikinga · 29/04/2022 22:36

I've had both. Vb was by far easier and quick to recover. No intervention just some gas and air. Next day I was back to normal. My CS was major surgery and having to be on drugs and the first week of being sore.

But carrying a baby, giving birth to it (however you do it) and then nurturing it, does deserve acknowledgement!

Fairislefandango · 29/04/2022 22:30

Cross-posted. I've no doubt a c-section is traumatic and that recovery is really tough when looking after a new baby. I'm just not that surprised that people would be inclined to congratulate you on the birth of your baby and be very sympathetic and solicitous about how you are feeling and your recovery etc (as they would after any major surgery), rather than saying you did it great.

Fairislefandango · 29/04/2022 22:26

Tbh I can understand why. A c-section causes trauma to the body etc, but it's not a process the mother actively takes part in. I had two pretty horrendous vaginal births. I have no idea if anyone congratulated me on how well I'd done - it is a pretty hazy memory for me, thank goodness.

OrlaOrka · 29/04/2022 22:21

@PinkSyCo I am actually amazed that you can think it is as black and white as this. You seem to have the bizarre opinion that women are purely vessels and that we can just lie on an operating table and have a baby sliced out of us and it is as robotic as that. No effort? Are you deluded? Or just an arsehole?

How about the mental and physical effort it took to get to that point? A woman might have already gone through numerous hours of labour. Maybe she’s had a pregnancy where the baby might have conditions that require a delivery by c section. Maybe she’s had a cord prolapse. Or maybe it’s just her choice on how she wants to birth her baby, it’s certainly not no effort on her behalf let me tell you that.
You are disregarding the experience, the being in an environment with a team full of medical professionals, having a spinal put in, lying on the table waiting for it to work all the while you are shivering and shaking from a combination of adrenaline and anaesthetic. The feeling of a surgeons hands inside your actual body. Your body being cut open in 7 layers and all the healing that you have to do. What other major surgery are you expected to not only recover from but care for a tiny baby?

I think you are both disrespectful and inconsiderate and I feel sorry for any of your friends or relatives that may have had caesareans as you consider them to have put in no effort and are undeserving of any appreciation. Wow.

If you are a woman I think you should be ashamed of yourself, no wonder so many women have such a sense of failure after a c section with people like you perpetuating this bullshit

OP posts:
PinkSyCo · 29/04/2022 22:02

NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/04/2022 14:04

Well, assuming you aren't my ex in which case fuck off out of Mumsnet, you're 52 years old and your children are all adults now the actual process of a section means that there is significant damage done to muscles, fascia/connective tissue and even if you discount such experiences such as mine where the epidural didn't take properly and I felt the incision and manual tearing of the muscles before they acted, it can be both a physically painful (in terms of post operative pain) and scary (in terms of having abdominal surgery whilst awake) experience. And then women have to recover physically from these injuries whilst simultaneously working 24 hours a day on limited sleep in terms of looking after a baby.

I found the difference between the two - a section and a forceps delivery - like night and day. One I still experienced pain from decades later, the other, all I had to do was be a little careful when sitting down for a couple of weeks. It seems completely illogical to me to dismiss major abdominal surgery as nothing emotionally and physically but treat a normal process as worthy of respect.

There are reasons why other surgeries aren't performed under local anaesthesia. These include the response of the patient during surgery. Perhaps you could campaign for six year olds to only have surgery under epidural? Or ban sick leave for men who have only gone to sleep and woken up again minus their gallbladder?

It doesn't hurt to say nice things to somebody who is in pain and feeling vulnerable or even traumatised. Simple reassurance costs nothing but can make a huge difference emotionally to somebody who is simultaneously dealing with pain, lack of strength in the damaged muscles, severed connective tissue which also has nerve endings, adhesions, uterine contractions whilst also being cut and major hormonal and life changes.

Good to see ageism is alive and well on Mumsnet. Confused
That aside, your experience might make you deserving of sympathy, just like one might expect after any painful surgery. Any effort, however, was provided by the medical team, so if there’s praise to be had, it should all goes to them surely. Let’s just be thankful that, in this day and age, abdominal deliveries are on the whole a safe option and result in providing us with healthy babies. That’s all that matters surely?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/04/2022 14:04

PinkSyCo · 29/04/2022 03:53

Probably because when you have a C-section you just have to lie there. Unless you were 5 years old, why would you expect praise for that?

Well, assuming you aren't my ex in which case fuck off out of Mumsnet, you're 52 years old and your children are all adults now the actual process of a section means that there is significant damage done to muscles, fascia/connective tissue and even if you discount such experiences such as mine where the epidural didn't take properly and I felt the incision and manual tearing of the muscles before they acted, it can be both a physically painful (in terms of post operative pain) and scary (in terms of having abdominal surgery whilst awake) experience. And then women have to recover physically from these injuries whilst simultaneously working 24 hours a day on limited sleep in terms of looking after a baby.

I found the difference between the two - a section and a forceps delivery - like night and day. One I still experienced pain from decades later, the other, all I had to do was be a little careful when sitting down for a couple of weeks. It seems completely illogical to me to dismiss major abdominal surgery as nothing emotionally and physically but treat a normal process as worthy of respect.

There are reasons why other surgeries aren't performed under local anaesthesia. These include the response of the patient during surgery. Perhaps you could campaign for six year olds to only have surgery under epidural? Or ban sick leave for men who have only gone to sleep and woken up again minus their gallbladder?

It doesn't hurt to say nice things to somebody who is in pain and feeling vulnerable or even traumatised. Simple reassurance costs nothing but can make a huge difference emotionally to somebody who is simultaneously dealing with pain, lack of strength in the damaged muscles, severed connective tissue which also has nerve endings, adhesions, uterine contractions whilst also being cut and major hormonal and life changes.

OrlaOrka · 29/04/2022 12:40

ShirleyPhallus · 29/04/2022 09:59

Do 5 year olds routinely get c-sections?

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

OP posts:
ShirleyPhallus · 29/04/2022 09:59

PinkSyCo · 29/04/2022 03:53

Probably because when you have a C-section you just have to lie there. Unless you were 5 years old, why would you expect praise for that?

Do 5 year olds routinely get c-sections?

Howaboutnope · 29/04/2022 09:53

UsernameInTheTown · 26/04/2022 21:50

Who gives a fuck? My elective c section was ace and I don't have any post birth horror stories or injuries unlike many who give birth naturally. The last these poor fuckers deserve is a well done and a pat on the back.

All of this!!

I've had one emergency section and one planned. I did get praise as it goes (only remember it with the planned one- dont remember much about the emergency one as i was so tired and high!) but i didn't give a toss either way to be honest! Just happy everything went well.

LittleMG · 29/04/2022 09:22

I had an elective c section with my son and have another booked for 4 weeks time. If people find out they always have a lot to say about it 🤷‍♀️ but honestly I know it’s the best thing for me.

OrlaOrka · 29/04/2022 08:22

PinkSyCo · 29/04/2022 03:53

Probably because when you have a C-section you just have to lie there. Unless you were 5 years old, why would you expect praise for that?

Wow what a nice person you are

OP posts:
PinkSyCo · 29/04/2022 03:53

Probably because when you have a C-section you just have to lie there. Unless you were 5 years old, why would you expect praise for that?

Suzi888 · 29/04/2022 03:02

I had an elective c sec for a breech baby, I do feel I had it easy compared to mum’s who had vb/emergency c secs. It didn’t cross my mind to be congratulated, just felt like I was having the easy option (and that’s how the doctor made me feel too!)

I did get a ‘well done’ for being first c sec mum getting up out of bed, catheter out and showered!

xxcatcatcatxx · 29/04/2022 02:52

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Womeninblack · 26/04/2022 22:39

I pushed identical dds out and I was classed as a “hero” on the maternity ward. Everyone was talking about me apparently, I was very pleased with myself 😌 But women having c sections are just as amazing in my opinion

Choopi · 26/04/2022 22:37

I can't remember if anyone said we'll done or not but I had 2 very easy vaginally births less than 10mins pushing, no tears, up and about like normal the next day(I had both of mine late at night). I never really talk about my births because they were a breeze and I feel kind of guilty about it. I would definitely think being sliced open is the scarier, braver option than what I went through.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/04/2022 22:30

I agree - I was told I didn't do anything by a number of people when DD1 was delivered. OK, I didn't move, but I think the epidural not having taken when they made the incision was a pretty fucking big deal, along with the post op infection, wound reopening, adhesions and general ongoing pain.

DD2 was a VBAC and was by forceps after over 24 hours in labour. I was up by the morning, showering, obviously very tender, tired and I'd lost a fair amount of blood - but I was fine to get on with everyday stuff after the weekend like the school run (walking a little gingerly, mind). but I was treated like I'd done something far harder, when, from my perspective, I was feeling invincible, if a little battered and tired.

What I needed from the section was reassurance that I'd done something major (ie, surgery) and was doing great. Not being told that when I'd done something far easier physically and mentally than by first experience.

Ducksinthebath · 26/04/2022 22:19

I find the whole thing utterly bizarre. If your friend/sister/colleague announced they planned to have a tooth pulled with no pain relief you’d be appalled. Push a baby out with nothing but breathing and they’re heroic, brave, a warrior. The whole language and attitude around childbirth is just odd.

JenniferBarkley · 26/04/2022 22:17

This wasn't my experience at all. Two sections, no vaginal deliveries. I had excellent care, and was certainly told more than once that I was doing well, and told to take care of myself and that I'd been through an ordeal etc.

I do think there is an issue with the conversation around natural birth, but I think it is more of an issue before the birth than after. In my very limited personal experience.

OrlaOrka · 26/04/2022 22:15

MozzarellaMonster · 26/04/2022 22:12

I've had both, first a C section and second vaginal. Luckily I never felt like I failed after my C section I just felt relieved to have had help and for the bloody thing to be done with.
I suppose I see both versions as hard work and traumatic. A Section is so painful, our bodies are amazing that we can heal up and be on our feet running around after a baby in a matter of weeks that I guess just a bit more praise for how hard recovery is.
I had a cut with my vaginal birth and forceps so that took just as long to heal although I could get up and about a lot quicker. Just think women need more credit for what a shit show birth is and that we are legends for getting through it regardless 😁

this ^

OP posts:
FairyPolkadot · 26/04/2022 22:13

Both mine were emm cs deliveries and I definitely felt that I was treated differently on the post natal ward on both occasions by some of the midwives. A couple made me cry. I didn’t particularly expect to be told well done but I also didn’t expect to be made to feel like that. I spoke to my community midwife about one of them in particular when I returned home. Turned out, this midwife was known for being extremely unkind. She visited me on the ward with another midwife and I was (and still am) amazed that they both sat there, reduced me to sobs and gave no comfort, only said ‘you should feel guilty’ and walked away. I despised being on those postnatal wards and was very pleased when they discharged me fairly quickly after dc2 birth.

MozzarellaMonster · 26/04/2022 22:12

I've had both, first a C section and second vaginal. Luckily I never felt like I failed after my C section I just felt relieved to have had help and for the bloody thing to be done with.
I suppose I see both versions as hard work and traumatic. A Section is so painful, our bodies are amazing that we can heal up and be on our feet running around after a baby in a matter of weeks that I guess just a bit more praise for how hard recovery is.
I had a cut with my vaginal birth and forceps so that took just as long to heal although I could get up and about a lot quicker. Just think women need more credit for what a shit show birth is and that we are legends for getting through it regardless 😁