Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move my child from a achieving school which she enjoys because of the travel time?

39 replies

Cozytoesandtoast00 · 26/04/2022 16:47

Please help. This problem is going round and round my head.
My eldest son is in year 7 of his secondary school. We chose the school because of its outstanding reputation and results. Our local school was in the "Requires Improvement" category.
He enjoys school. Although says it is hard work and has made friends. The school is in a town centre and we live in a small village. It takes him about 1.5 hrs to get home and by then he's shattered. He leaves very early at 7:15am.
We live in a very 1970's kind of environment. The kids all play on the green outside at stay up later. They all go to the local school which has now improved to a good category. My son has expressed that he feels like he is missing out when he doesn't have time to play outside an be with his local friends.
I feel like quality of life is really important in children's lives and his energy levels are also suffering due to the early starts. I feel that exam time in the future will also be difficult due to the limited time for revision.
My youngest son is in year 5 and I'm reluctant to send him there as he enjoys outdoor time.
One potential option is that I could pick them up to and from school when my youngest starts there and manage my job around that. Although there are no guarantees that I would be able to do this in the future.
Does anyone have any thoughts or opinions that would help? I'm seriously considering moving him. Should I move him?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Abraxan · 27/04/2022 19:03

Does the local school have a space?
Have you been able to have a tour round the school before you decide?

Hallyup89 · 27/04/2022 09:54

Poor kid. If he was in his GCSE years then I may be reluctant to move him but I absolutely wouldn't hesitate to move a year 7.

Just goes to show you shouldn't read too much into Ofsted reports. We're looking to move and so I've been looking at schools recently. There were outstanding schools that were inadequate a few years back, and vice versa. My daughter's 'outstanding' school hasn't been Ofsted inspected for 14 years. I'd much rather go on my gut feeling than a snapshot of a couple of days of inspection.

Lesser performing schools often get a cash boost and new leadership as well.

InDubiousBattle · 27/04/2022 09:36

I had a pretty much identical commute to my secondary school, I used to finish at 3.30 and get home at 5. I got driven into school 3 days a week and that made a difference. I absolutely loved my school though, I absolutely thrived there so the long commute was worth it for me.
I did lose local friends. As I got older my life became very focused on my school town rather than my home town so from 13/14 ish age my parents hardly saw me.

BusyMum47 · 27/04/2022 09:17

RedskyThisNight · 26/04/2022 17:25

Move him now. That's a ridiculous amount of travel time. Think of all the other things he could achieve if he wasn't travelling for 3 hours a day.

(I also had a long commute for school and missed out on local friendships and was permanently shattered. The supposedly better school was not worth it).

I agree! I was in the same boat & hated it! All those pointless hours on a bus while my local friends grew up without me. And I couldn't socialise with my school friends as they all lived miles away - it was a lose:lose situation for me. Moving your son in time for the start of year 8 would be fine & won't impact his education. He'll thank you for it.

Lalliella · 27/04/2022 08:08

There’s a lot more to life than an outstanding Ofsted rating! With a better quality of life he’ll probably achieve more at school anyway. I’d move him.

RedskyThisNight · 27/04/2022 07:56

mycatisannoying · 27/04/2022 05:13

I'm not sure. My feeling - based on nothing admittedly! - is that the dynamic with the local children could change if he were with them all the time.
Personally I would let your son make the decision.

Having local friends is only a small part of the benefit. The not having to spend 3 hours a day travelling, being the main part!

I'd agree that friendships with specific local friends might change (as all friendships do) but it's far more likely that new friends will live significantly closer than his current friends do now - he must never see his friends out of school at the moment; or only if he gets lifts. Being able to be more independent and socialise freely is a big part of being a teenager.

mycatisannoying · 27/04/2022 05:13

I'm not sure. My feeling - based on nothing admittedly! - is that the dynamic with the local children could change if he were with them all the time.
Personally I would let your son make the decision.

PinkSyCo · 27/04/2022 05:03

Ultimately it should be his decision, but if he’s waiting for you to decide for him then I would definitely chose the local school.

kateandme · 27/04/2022 04:51

That level of commute is going to get and feel worse and worse.for friends,social and all your lives.
I think u need to be firm and help him by making a decision as the adult.it might feel nervous to move and he might backtrack on his initial.wamt to but that's quite normal.once back and settled I think he will be so relieved.

Landlubber2019 · 27/04/2022 04:37

We had a similar dilemma and of course you want your child to do well. Have you looked at the local school or did you dismiss it on the back of its reputation?

We chose the local option which although offered a much poorer Ofsted report would facilitate independence and local friends. Good mental health is as important as the education and it seems this is what is being sacrificed.

You need to either move house to reduce the commute or move his school and sooner rather than later

OutlookStalking · 27/04/2022 03:29

Ooops posted early -

They must be exhausted. I would asap move to picking them up and then try and sort a move.

OutlookStalking · 27/04/2022 03:29

I dont think that amount of commuting is at all sustainable or fair to the child.

You will need to put youngest in before/after sgcool clubs so you can pick up your eldest or move him.

Its very hard for a child to make this decision as the school is all they know.

Can you visit the local school again (and is there definitely a space?) . Long term that commute wont leave time for homework or friends or anything. Thats such a lot for a child re

Cozytoesandtoast00 · 26/04/2022 20:12

iRun2eatCake · 26/04/2022 20:09

Could younger child walk home alone or go to after school club so you can collect DC1?

That is a good idea but I'm not sure how happy I'd be with my youngest doing that. I'll give it some thought though. Good point. Thank you.

OP posts:
iRun2eatCake · 26/04/2022 20:09

Cozytoesandtoast00 · 26/04/2022 20:04

He keeps on changing his mind. I think he just wants me to decide so I'm trying to do what's best for him overall.
I already pick him up from a bus stop which is about a 10 min drive away. Picking him up from school is not an option at the moment as I have a younger child who I have to collect.
He already gets there for 8am.
Thanks for your suggestions though.

Could younger child walk home alone or go to after school club so you can collect DC1?

Cozytoesandtoast00 · 26/04/2022 20:04

sickofthisnonsense · 26/04/2022 20:04

Ofsted isn't everything

You're completely right.

OP posts:
Cozytoesandtoast00 · 26/04/2022 20:04

BungleandGeorge · 26/04/2022 19:48

What does he want to do? Did he choose his current school? If he likes it and has settled well I’d look into the option of driving him at least part of the time. can he go to a club or library after school and you pick him up later? They can also usually go in for breakfast. In some ways it’s quite nice to have local friends who don’t go to your school as kids quite often fall out. What happens if he’s not happy at the other school?

He keeps on changing his mind. I think he just wants me to decide so I'm trying to do what's best for him overall.
I already pick him up from a bus stop which is about a 10 min drive away. Picking him up from school is not an option at the moment as I have a younger child who I have to collect.
He already gets there for 8am.
Thanks for your suggestions though.

OP posts:
sickofthisnonsense · 26/04/2022 20:04

Ofsted isn't everything

BungleandGeorge · 26/04/2022 19:48

What does he want to do? Did he choose his current school? If he likes it and has settled well I’d look into the option of driving him at least part of the time. can he go to a club or library after school and you pick him up later? They can also usually go in for breakfast. In some ways it’s quite nice to have local friends who don’t go to your school as kids quite often fall out. What happens if he’s not happy at the other school?

Cozytoesandtoast00 · 26/04/2022 19:38

KarmaStar · 26/04/2022 18:31

Go with your gut feeling and move him if he is happy to do so.🌈life's too short to waste 15 hours a week travelling.

Thank you. I think we need to move him.

OP posts:
Cozytoesandtoast00 · 26/04/2022 19:22

MysteriousMonkey · 26/04/2022 18:58

I'd move him and actually have moved one of my children from a Grammar school which involved a similar commute for similar reasons and they're much happier. Another of my children is still there but that's their choice.

Great to hear.

OP posts:
Cozytoesandtoast00 · 26/04/2022 19:21

VioletLemon · 26/04/2022 18:49

I'd definately move him. Speaking as a teacher there's alot to say for the impact of good well being, comes from having a bonded friendship group and lots of time to play. Forget the travel to current school. Honestly, in 10 years he'll have friends for life, good experiences, skills, qualifications and happiness BUT there is no substitute for belonging and good mental health. He will always be the outsider in the group otherwise and could resent you for that. Unless there is a serious problem with the local school then go for it. By serious, I mean violence, fights, bullying, terrible HT etc. League tables totally meaningless.

Thank you for this. That's reassuring.

OP posts:
Cozytoesandtoast00 · 26/04/2022 19:21

SeemsSoUnfair · 26/04/2022 18:45

Madness to make a child go to a school 1.5 hrs away in the first place.

ds is in exam years now and that length of day and commute would have been so detrimental during this critical phase.

To be fair I didn't realise it would be that long. The delay in bus departure makes the commute longer.
I think I may have to move him after taking in consideration the future work pressures

OP posts:
Cozytoesandtoast00 · 26/04/2022 19:18

Mumdiva99 · 26/04/2022 18:37

Well I wouldn't have sent him in the first place. But given you did just because ofnthe RI judgement - what will you do in the future if it gets another RI? Would you want to move him again?

What does your son say about moving?
Would he like to change?

We have kids locally that travel over an hour for school. I wouldn't send mine, but they enjoy it. The kids I know wouldn't want to stop doing it as they think it worthwhile.

You're right of course and I made a huge mistake. No I wouldn't move him again for that reason.
He keeps on changing his mind

OP posts:
Cozytoesandtoast00 · 26/04/2022 19:15

Comedycook · 26/04/2022 18:36

I'd move him...that commute sounds exhausting. And in winter, all in the dark. I wouldn't like that

Actually it's worse in the spring/summer as she can't fall asleep early.

OP posts:
MysteriousMonkey · 26/04/2022 18:58

I'd move him and actually have moved one of my children from a Grammar school which involved a similar commute for similar reasons and they're much happier. Another of my children is still there but that's their choice.