Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think surely the CIA etc must have looked at assassinating Putin?

59 replies

Sortilege · 26/04/2022 14:47

That must have been one possibility they’ve explored since he invaded Ukraine, right? Even if it’s been judged impossible.

Now Russia is notching up talk of nuclear war. It must be something they’re scoping out, or have I read and watched too many thrillers?

I just keep wondering what twist will come next,

YANBU = Could happen
YABU = State sponsored assassination is not something any power or agency would resort to.

OP posts:
meditrina · 26/04/2022 16:35

fallfallfall · 26/04/2022 15:10

Can I ask why the CIA? Why not MI6, Why not the secret military of a dozen other countries?

Not MI6 because the British line is consistently that we don't do assassinations.

CIA and Mossad seems to have different rules, and I'm sure there will be others.

Not least the various Russian services, so I assume that Putin is very well protected, so no-one from within can get it. Which must make it hard/impossible for a foreign agency to carry out (and get operatives safely away from)

Plus of course there's no telling what would happed next and its likely potential to make things even worse. All those in positions of power are Putin proteges, and so will be likeminded. And would see it as an act of aggression, then heaven knows what. Especially if their retaliatory strike was against the wrong actor

ancientgran · 26/04/2022 16:30

Blossomtoes · 26/04/2022 16:24

They can’t nuke the Kremlin, it’s so pretty!

I thought that!

Blossomtoes · 26/04/2022 16:24

They can’t nuke the Kremlin, it’s so pretty!

Sortilege · 26/04/2022 16:15

UrslaB · 26/04/2022 16:00

Okay there is so much to unpack here. Do security agencies employ espionage and even outright assasination? Hell yes.

Do they however consider the assasination of one of the most powerful leader's of a nuclear armed nation? No. Not just no. Heck no.

Firstly, Putin is one of the most well protected leader's in the world. If he was killed it would likley be from an internal coup rather than a foreign force. He is known for his paranoia and his distrust for even his own fellow govt. ministers and supposed allies. Assasinating him would be difficult.

In the intelligence community the idea of a devil you know being better than the devil you don't is also another huge issue. If Putin was disposed of then this would create a power vaccum as the line of succession is murky. For all of Putin's terrible crimes he has kept Russia stable. Think back to when the USSR fell. The number of drug and weapon dealers which were spawned and used state resources was a huge issue and the effects are still plain to see internationally today. Just the thought of all the rogue elements given free rein if Putin disapeared is a nightmare for intelligence agenices.

Then is the issue of power struggles. An internall squabbling Russia sounds like a great idea in theory but would have huge international consequences (uncertainty over economic issues, food production, manufacturing, military, treaties,internal population management) and would make the likelyhood of a more extreme leader rising to power by a show of strength more likely. That would be bad...so bad.

All the intelligence on what motivates Putin and what works against him would be useless. The intelligence on his allies would suddenly become potentially worthless as intelligence communites scamble to figure out the new leader, their personality, quirks, goals and who their allies are. Also, the assumption taht Rssia would just quietly leave Ukraine if Putin died is naive. Putin has a number of supporters and backers who may take over if he died and assasinating him may allow a similarly like minded but potentially even more ruthless individual to take over. No government is just one man, no matter what it looks like from outside.

Anyway, all those issues are a headache if an assasination or a coup worked. Then you consider the disaster of if it failed. And that is a real possibility. Assasinations of high valued leaders in history have been seen to fail in the past e.g Castro. Heck, even when they succeed they can have horrible consequences like with Lumumbra sinne despite succeeding everyone knew who to point the finger at. If intelligence agencies try to assasinate Putin but fail then this would cause massive issues. Huge geo political and economic repercussions at the least, an excuse for more miliray actions and possibly even all out war in Europe.

Heck, even if it succeeded, if the intelligence agency was even suspected (as unless it was covered up perfectly Nato countries would be...een if it was covered up perfectly as a death by natural causes conspiracy theories and propoganda would likely thrive) of it this could turn Putin into a martyr and harden Russian attitudes. Cause a more hard line leader to rise, while giving an excuse for more retalitatory war and geo-political or economic repercussions.

Just...no. The intern or the new guy in the meeting suggests wacking Putin and then everyone else tells him to sod off and go get their coffee order while they have a real discussion. This isn't a Bond film.

Interesting. Thanks.

OP posts:
Libertaire · 26/04/2022 16:07

I’m sure the Americans would love to take Putin out but he is so paranoid and so well protected that, short of nuking the Kremlin, it would be impossible to get to him. And if they did that, the Russians might be a bit cross, which given their nuclear arsenal probably wouldn’t end well…

3luckystars · 26/04/2022 16:00

I know!!!!!!!!!

I have watched the Bourne films and James Bond and thought there was a grain of truth in them. But there can’t be.

(Unless someone has actually gotten close and instead of just shooting him, they had an elaborate rotating saw that was going to cut him in half or a laser beam that was going to blast him slowly over the course of 20 minutes and he managed to escape.)

I don’t know what to believe anymore.

UrslaB · 26/04/2022 16:00

Okay there is so much to unpack here. Do security agencies employ espionage and even outright assasination? Hell yes.

Do they however consider the assasination of one of the most powerful leader's of a nuclear armed nation? No. Not just no. Heck no.

Firstly, Putin is one of the most well protected leader's in the world. If he was killed it would likley be from an internal coup rather than a foreign force. He is known for his paranoia and his distrust for even his own fellow govt. ministers and supposed allies. Assasinating him would be difficult.

In the intelligence community the idea of a devil you know being better than the devil you don't is also another huge issue. If Putin was disposed of then this would create a power vaccum as the line of succession is murky. For all of Putin's terrible crimes he has kept Russia stable. Think back to when the USSR fell. The number of drug and weapon dealers which were spawned and used state resources was a huge issue and the effects are still plain to see internationally today. Just the thought of all the rogue elements given free rein if Putin disapeared is a nightmare for intelligence agenices.

Then is the issue of power struggles. An internall squabbling Russia sounds like a great idea in theory but would have huge international consequences (uncertainty over economic issues, food production, manufacturing, military, treaties,internal population management) and would make the likelyhood of a more extreme leader rising to power by a show of strength more likely. That would be bad...so bad.

All the intelligence on what motivates Putin and what works against him would be useless. The intelligence on his allies would suddenly become potentially worthless as intelligence communites scamble to figure out the new leader, their personality, quirks, goals and who their allies are. Also, the assumption taht Rssia would just quietly leave Ukraine if Putin died is naive. Putin has a number of supporters and backers who may take over if he died and assasinating him may allow a similarly like minded but potentially even more ruthless individual to take over. No government is just one man, no matter what it looks like from outside.

Anyway, all those issues are a headache if an assasination or a coup worked. Then you consider the disaster of if it failed. And that is a real possibility. Assasinations of high valued leaders in history have been seen to fail in the past e.g Castro. Heck, even when they succeed they can have horrible consequences like with Lumumbra sinne despite succeeding everyone knew who to point the finger at. If intelligence agencies try to assasinate Putin but fail then this would cause massive issues. Huge geo political and economic repercussions at the least, an excuse for more miliray actions and possibly even all out war in Europe.

Heck, even if it succeeded, if the intelligence agency was even suspected (as unless it was covered up perfectly Nato countries would be...een if it was covered up perfectly as a death by natural causes conspiracy theories and propoganda would likely thrive) of it this could turn Putin into a martyr and harden Russian attitudes. Cause a more hard line leader to rise, while giving an excuse for more retalitatory war and geo-political or economic repercussions.

Just...no. The intern or the new guy in the meeting suggests wacking Putin and then everyone else tells him to sod off and go get their coffee order while they have a real discussion. This isn't a Bond film.

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 26/04/2022 15:55

I thought Elon Musk was going to duff him up. I'd pay to see that 😃

I don't like that Sergei Lavrov. He can go as well.

girlmom21 · 26/04/2022 15:54

Blossomtoes · 26/04/2022 15:48

I’m astonished that Trump survived for four years and he’d have been a lot easier for a rogue CIA agent to take out.

I don't think he was dangerous enough for anyone to waste their time on to be honest.

Blossomtoes · 26/04/2022 15:48

I’m astonished that Trump survived for four years and he’d have been a lot easier for a rogue CIA agent to take out.

Sortilege · 26/04/2022 15:43

justasking111 · 26/04/2022 15:37

I thought an agreement was made many years ago not to do this to heads of countries h. Arafat was a tempting target and the order was given to leave him be

I hadn’t heard about that.

Although since the whole Guantanamo bay and extraordinary rendition business, I’m quite sceptical about international agreements or even international law being adhered to, especially by the Americans.

OP posts:
CPL593H · 26/04/2022 15:42

That ridiculously long table he is so fond of is less about Covid and more about keeping potentially disaffected minions far enough away that his bodyguards would get to him before they did, IMO. These (apparently frequently changed, every few days) bodyguards are realistically the only people who could get close enough, I think, at least for the foreseeable.

Pity, as there would be extensive queues of volunteers.

MrsTerryPratchett · 26/04/2022 15:42

justasking111 · 26/04/2022 15:37

I thought an agreement was made many years ago not to do this to heads of countries h. Arafat was a tempting target and the order was given to leave him be

There were attempts on Arafat's life though.

lalahotpants · 26/04/2022 15:37

I think it will be one of his own who will eventually take him out, probably only ones who could close enough

justasking111 · 26/04/2022 15:37

I thought an agreement was made many years ago not to do this to heads of countries h. Arafat was a tempting target and the order was given to leave him be

Sortilege · 26/04/2022 15:36

Alexandra2001 · 26/04/2022 15:22

@Sortilege You watched "Anna" the other night didn't you?

I doubt it even crossed their minds, what do you think would happen if it got back to Russia that the CIA etc killed Putin?

No. I didn’t. What is it? Sounds like I should. 😄

OP posts:
bellinisurge · 26/04/2022 15:35

And achieve what? Who would replace him? The Russians need to sort this out themselves. He's not going to live forever.

MrsTerryPratchett · 26/04/2022 15:33

Can I ask why the CIA? Why not MI6, Why not the secret military of a dozen other countries?

Because they have very well-documented form for it. And the US has been the most recently successful in buggering around with other people's countries in recent years.

They took it from the UK's example but the student surpassed the teacher decades ago.

SisterAgatha · 26/04/2022 15:28

I expect my laced radioactive burger to arrive any day now for this comments.

SisterAgatha · 26/04/2022 15:28

I feel like he is a robot already. He reminds me Yul Brynner in Westworld, that robot that KEEPS GOING.

No wonder he’s not afraid of nuclear war, underneath his latex skin layer, he is made of scrapped vintage Lada’s (a shit 80’s car for the young un’s)

whumpthereitis · 26/04/2022 15:23

They probably have. Same as Russia has probably looked at assassinating western figureheads. It’s easier said than done though, and the short and long term ramifications have to be considered. Take out Putin, the head of a nuclear state, but who replaces him? What does it mean for international relations? You think China, India etc are going to be particularly happy? What’s the payback likely to be? What of the safety of diplomats and intelligence agents abroad?

It’s never as simple as just killing one man.

Putin himself is ex KGB. He knows precautions for take, and you can be sure he’s got the FSB and SVR looking at even the smallest threat against him.

Alexandra2001 · 26/04/2022 15:22

@Sortilege You watched "Anna" the other night didn't you?

I doubt it even crossed their minds, what do you think would happen if it got back to Russia that the CIA etc killed Putin?

Sortilege · 26/04/2022 15:21

NightmareSlashDelightful · 26/04/2022 15:12

This is why Bond films etc are total fantasy.

Setting aside the moral argument, I would imagine doing something like that would be unacceptably risky in global stability and political terms. Not only in how it is done, but also what comes after. The power vacuum created by something like that would be unpredictable and highly unstable.

I don't think that supposedly civilised countries should be contemplating 'whacking' other heads of state, even if those heads of state are warmongers.

Yes, that’s what’s concerning about it. I keep thinking there might be an attempt - I can’t imagine it hasn’t at least been looked at - and then wondering how seriously any agency would try, and how likely that they’d succeed, and what would come next….

I don’t imagine it’s that likely, but I wondered what everyone else thought.

Unfortunately, it’s looking like rocky times ahead whatever happens.

OP posts:
Sortilege · 26/04/2022 15:17

girlmom21 · 26/04/2022 15:12

Official agencies simply can't kill him. It would need to be a citizen gone rogue and they'd have to get to him first.

Although I must admit I'm surprised Zelensky is still alive.

I was imagining the CIA helping someone close to him to do it, I think. They must always recruit or work with locals for the dark stuff?

I’m obviously far too vague for espionage!

OP posts:
Sortilege · 26/04/2022 15:14

fallfallfall · 26/04/2022 15:10

Can I ask why the CIA? Why not MI6, Why not the secret military of a dozen other countries?

I did put “etc” in to cover everyone but I think of the CIA as the most ruthless, I suppose, maybe because quite a lot has come out about some of their previous activities, such as their repeated attempts on Castro’s life, as PP referenced.

Haven’t MI6 managed to keep their activities darker? I know either 5 or 6 did admit to extra-judicial killing at one point, but no specifics. (I didn’t dream that, did I?)

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread