Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for feeling resentful towards my brother about his easy life?

218 replies

MartinsSquirrel · 26/04/2022 14:38

I have a 35 year old brother who recently moved back to the UK after living in California for 13 years, he recently told me that he's just retired which completely shocked me. I knew him and his wife made great money while they were in the states (they paid for me and my parents to visit a few times) but I had no clue just how wealthy he is. He told me him and his wife have over £5m in investments and just live on that now! They have no children and no plans for any so their days basically just consist of gaming and watching Netflix and playing with their dog, that's in contrast to me who has 3 children and can barely pay the bills! I love my brother and he's never been anything but lovely to me and my parents but I just can't help feeling resentful about his incredibly easy life AIBU

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock1 · 27/04/2022 08:33

Having your own children is worth way more than £5m.
How condensing.
Dbro may or may not decide to have DC in the future with plenty more to offer or he might stay sensible without DC double his money in further investments and have a great life.

Nesbo · 27/04/2022 08:30

“5m is not huge money really, if they want to have a great life (holidays, Reno's, flying business class etc.)”

ahhhhh, you’ve got to love Mumsnet, a mere 5 million isn’t enough to give you a great life.

I mean, that might only bring them an income of a couple of hundred thousand a year - with no kids, no need to put any of that aside to save/make pension payments and (most likely) no mortgage to cover.

With complete freedom from the need to work how can anyone really expect to have a great life on that!

SofiaSoFar · 27/04/2022 08:29

Unless you're about to teak us how you having 3 kids and struggling to pay the bills is somehow your brother's fault, YABVU.

gannett · 27/04/2022 08:28

I don't understand feeling envious or resentful at someone else winning a game you weren't playing.

I have rich friends and I saw the kind of work they had to do and the kind of industries they had to go in to make that money. There was probably a moment in my life at university when I could have chosen to go down that route but it never seemed appealing as a life path. Would that amount of money be nice? Sure. But I'm not even a tiny bit envious because I didn't and still don't want that life.

I basically got the life I wanted - lots of freedom, not tied down by kids, lucky enough to have always worked in and around things I'm passionate about. I made all my choices with this in mind. Earning megabucks was something I knew I'd probably be passing up.

Occasionally parent acquaintances have made really weird digs about the freedom DP and I have to have a rich social and cultural life - like, beyond a light-hearted "ooh that must be nice, I wouldn't know". It's confusing more than anything. If you wanted that life for yourself why did you have children?

I save my resentment for people who've fallen upwards in life because of privilege - luckily I'm in a position in my industry where I can advocate for young people from less well-off backgrounds, and speak out against nepotism.

CounsellorTroi · 27/04/2022 08:28

So you are a multimillionaire and you still don’t feel like you have enough money? That’s sad. I think the OP’s brother has a healthier mindset tbh.

LuckySantangelo35 · 27/04/2022 08:28

FairyCakeWings · 26/04/2022 17:42

Having your own children is worth way more than £5m.

@FairyCakeWings

Correction-

having your own children is worth way more than £5m TO SOME PEOPLE

You simply cannot make that statement as a universal one. Sounds like OP’s bro and wife had the option of kids and they didn’t want it so clearly having kids isn’t of the same value/appeal to them. I have friends and you’d have to pay them £5m to even think about kids.

expand your mind a bit that not everyone has the same values, hopes, aspirations, aims in life. And that means that kids are not the be all and end for lots of people. And that is fine! To each their own.

Rachie1973 · 27/04/2022 08:25

Lockupyourbiscuits · 26/04/2022 18:35

apart from living off his investments
has he got a purpose in life now ?

Why must one have a ‘purpose’?

sammylady37 · 27/04/2022 08:21

This thread has shown a lot of posters in a bad light.
Such as those who appear to have so little imagination that they envisage a young, dynamic hard-working, wealthy couple will literally spend all their time watching Netflix and gaming. And those who really think having children is the only fulfilling path in life and others lives are missing something if they choose to be childfree. And the abhorrent few who view wealthy relatives as a potential source of money for their DC.
Eye-opening.

LuckySantangelo35 · 27/04/2022 08:20

FairyCakeWings · 26/04/2022 17:42

Having your own children is worth way more than £5m.

@FairyCakeWings

Correction-

having your own children is worth way more than £5m TO SOME PEOPLE

You simply cannot make that statement as a universal one. Sounds like OP’s bro and wife had the option of kids and they didn’t want it so clearly having kids isn’t of the same value/appeal to them. I have friends and you’d have to pay them £5m to even think about kids.

expand your mind a bit that not everyone has the same values, hopes, aspirations, aims in life. And that means that kids are not the be all and end for lots of people. And that is fine! To each their own.

LuckySantangelo35 · 27/04/2022 08:16

justanoldhack · 27/04/2022 07:30

Tbh his life sounds a bit boring to me

Haha

As pp has said, bet he feels like that about your life!

i don’t know why people on here are suddenly falling over themselves to say how exciting, thrilling, fun, etc etc life with children is when there are loads and loads of threads on here indicating the exact opposite! That child rearing is boring, relentless, drudge work etc etc and it’s absolutely fine to say that (and true) so why are people saying so much that a child free is incomparable to theirs, cannot be as good and the millionaire couple must be desperate to swap with them??!

I think not!

LuckySantangelo35 · 27/04/2022 08:12

Chaoslatte · 26/04/2022 17:34

YABU. It’s no secret that kids are expensive. You could have stopped at 1 or 2 (assuming you didn’t have triplets) but presumably you wanted the extra children more than the extra money. He opted for the extra money.

Exactly! Own your choices OP

wobytide · 27/04/2022 07:38

justanoldhack · 27/04/2022 07:30

Tbh his life sounds a bit boring to me

I imagine he thinks the same of some of the posters on here. But I doubt he's taking the time to post on here whilst he has Netflix and gaming as his only two priorities in life

justanoldhack · 27/04/2022 07:30

Tbh his life sounds a bit boring to me

imisscashmere · 27/04/2022 06:36

No, I wouldn’t be resentful, or even envious or jealous. My son is everything to me.

mind you, I’m stopping at 2 kids and I hope we’ll still be able to afford some luxuries. I also think that if my brother was that wealthy he would help us - or our DC - out financially. I certainly would if the tables were turned.

melcalfe · 27/04/2022 05:31

I think perhaps he shouldn't have told you exactly how successful he's been

he probably didn't.

I would never tell anyone our net worth, not even my mum

expat101 · 27/04/2022 05:10

Just stay in tune with your relationship with them and try not to worry about the rest.

As a niece I have benefited from having a wealthy (ish) Uncle and Aunt, not benefiting in a financial sense, but being able to enjoy staying with them at their very luxury home, always shouted breakfast/lunch/dinner at nice (not snobby, they won't go to those) places, lent a nice luxury car to drive around instead of hiring my own when visiting and been shown things I wouldn't have experienced otherwise.

If you get caught up in the differences between you, it won't make you a better or nicer person. Try to focus on other stuff. You might find what they are doing is a distraction from them not being able to have children and they are suffering great angst and pain that they don't show you.

tortadicarote · 27/04/2022 02:43

I think perhaps he shouldn't have told you exactly how successful he's been, but even if you didn't know how much he has, you'd know he was wealthy enough to retire, so maybe it wouldn't make any difference.

I can understand feeling envious, but you'll have to accept that different people have vastly different lives, even within the same family. He may do better than you do with money, but no-one is guaranteed a long and happy life, and we all have problems. When you feel envious, remember that you wouldn't actually want to trade places with your brother (would you?) and focus your energies on making your life and your children's lives the best they can be.

melcalfe · 27/04/2022 02:41

MartinsSquirrel · 26/04/2022 14:51

envious is a better way to describe it, I think with my own situation (I'm stable financially but absolutely no luxuries) it feels strange to see someone who I'm so close to living a life that I could only dream of.

But you had THREE children, did you not think that would massively impact you financially - for decades? I just don't get it. Sorry.

melcalfe · 27/04/2022 02:39

To add, if my sister 'barely paid her bills' I would prob help her out with a holiday here and there. BUT I would be ConfusedHmm that she had 3 kids, of course they're expensive and unless you're wealthy, you will struggle to bring them up. So maybe he doesn't have that much sympathy (esp as he's child free). sorry just being honest.

melcalfe · 27/04/2022 02:37

That's crazy because we have way more than triple of that and we wouldn't dream of retiring.

We're still building businesses, I'm studying to get more money, etc. We're similar age.

5m is not huge money really, if they want to have a great life (holidays, Reno's, flying business class etc.). What's the point sitting at home watching Netflix? Esp at their young age.

But it's an interesting look. I'd never have thought that my sister would be envious of me. Makes me feel sad.

whumpthereitis · 27/04/2022 02:26

claretblue79 · 27/04/2022 01:17

@whumpthereitis Completely stand by what I wrote. OP described them as gaming, watching Netflix and playing with their dog. Unless you have any special insider information I would call that a very shallow existence. If you find that pious then fine, I would call it realising that there is a world outside my front door and doing something to make that world better.

I think he’s aware there’s a world outside his front door, given that he’s just flown in from California and he’s shortly off to South Korea.

You have no idea what he does or doesn’t do for anyone else 🤷🏻‍♀️

I’d take the dogs, Netflix, wealth and freedom tbh. If that’s shallow then it’s an infinitely more attractive proposition than the alternative so far presented by those attacking him. He sounds happy, you on the other hand do not.

Bookescapeartist · 27/04/2022 01:37

Everything pays better in California- our neighbors are nurses and pull in 250-300 k a year with overtime, as nurses so it is easy to see how they would have built that kind of wealth in 13 years and they will have worked for it- no doubt they returned to the UK to avoid having to pay health insurance each month, no longer covered by an employer once you leave them.
I am sure they won't watch Netflix for ever but are recovering from years of hard work. He sounds like a generous person to me so I would be happy for him- in a sense he won the lottery of choosing well paid work in California and he has earned his retirement. The early retirement movement is big in the US and on all the FIRE forums everyone points out that America is the place to do it, much harder to do in the UK where only a small % of jobs pay very well I would say. He has made career choices that lead to building up wealth and he will have paid costs to do that in terms of the stress he will have been under.
be happy for him, his life is not typical and nor are his choices.

ashitghost · 27/04/2022 01:29

I would go mad just watching tv and gaming all day. And I’d hate not to have children. Genuinely would not envy them. It’s no life for me.

claretblue79 · 27/04/2022 01:17

@whumpthereitis Completely stand by what I wrote. OP described them as gaming, watching Netflix and playing with their dog. Unless you have any special insider information I would call that a very shallow existence. If you find that pious then fine, I would call it realising that there is a world outside my front door and doing something to make that world better.

707smile · 27/04/2022 00:58

I'm sure you worked just as hard as your brother. A lot of this will have been luck.

I don't think you're being unreasonable at all.

Also bear in mind that through most people's childhoods their parents try to keep things completely equal for each child- so you've grown up in a situation where you could expect the same things, now he's suddenly in a very different situation to yours and only in his 30s. His wealth is the kind that most people can never expect to have. It's completely natural and okay to feel jealous of him!