Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Transfered all our money into wrong account

188 replies

swimmer55 · 26/04/2022 10:58

First time poster, just had a panicked call from my husband, he has transferred all of our savings in to a new account at a new bank (its been sitting in a current account for a couple of years gaining no interest so now interest rates are rising slightly we decided to transfer), by transposing 2 numbers it has gone to a strangers account, the bank are on it but have said it will take up to 24 days and there's a possibilitythey won't be able to return it, has this happened to anyone else and what was the outcome ? Its all of our savings so we are panicking!

OP posts:
BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 26/04/2022 12:33

Online banking now has several checks and pop ups/warning.

When your husband put the details in, the name and account number wont have matched. He would have had the warning telling him that the names and account number dont match. He would have had to click that he understood and that it was OK, he still wanted to transfer.

So... you wouldnt get a refund from the bank. He knowingly transferred to an account which didnt match.

If the account doesnt exist and it bounces back then that's great. But if it does and is gone, then you cant blame the bank and ask for them to reimburse you.

He'll need to pay more attention.

yellowsuninthesky · 26/04/2022 12:30

RestingPandaFace · 26/04/2022 11:26

It’s a bit late now but if you are making a large transfer to a new recipient (one that you have just set up) it’s a good idea to send £1 first and check it gets there OK.

Yes I do this. Most of the time it checks the name matches the account but not always (Metro bank doesn't seem to work) so it's a useful extra step. The tradesmen never mind as long as you transfer the rest quickly once they've said the £1 (I usually do £10) has arrived safely.

Georgeskitchen · 26/04/2022 12:29

Hope your money is recovered. My bank ( the red one with a Spanish name) will ot transfer any money if the account number and name don't match

Antarcticant · 26/04/2022 12:28

springtimeishereagain · 26/04/2022 12:25

Did the online banking not warn him that the number and the name of the account didn’t match? The online banking system checks that the bank sort code is correct then searches for the correct account name. It says if there is a discrepancy and asks if you want to go ahead. That should have been a red flag to your h...

Not all banks have this technology.

springtimeishereagain · 26/04/2022 12:25

Did the online banking not warn him that the number and the name of the account didn’t match? The online banking system checks that the bank sort code is correct then searches for the correct account name. It says if there is a discrepancy and asks if you want to go ahead. That should have been a red flag to your h...

woodhill · 26/04/2022 12:05

When I'm doing this I only ever do £1 to start with then I can check the transfer has gone through correctly as I am paranoid about making a mistake

ProfessorSlocombe · 26/04/2022 12:02

Theft requires dishonest intent on the part of the person (now) holding the property. And that intent must have been formed before they acquired the property. That's why in these cases the recipient can't be treated as a criminal.

Moreover, unless the person making the transfer was the victim of fraud or other criminal activity in making it, the bank can't do much.

In such cases the only recourse would be to sue the person who received the money on the basis you made a mistake. And there's no guarantee a court would order restitution. After all, this isn't as if the account holder accidentally dropped the money and the recipient found it. This is much more as if the account holder deliberately posted the money through the recipients letterbox.

WoodenClock · 26/04/2022 11:49

swimmer55 · 26/04/2022 11:23

Thanks for your replies, it a brand new account we opened, had an update from the bank and it seems all may not be lost, it looks like there's no such account as the number he used so hopefully will bounce back/ be returned, as I understand it the only time there would be issues is if it went into a persons account and they refuse to return it, honestly the most stressful morning!

Yes that's what I'd expect to happen. It's incredibly rare that a mistake in typing the account number would result in an actual account. It's very clever!

Money only usually goes to the wrong account when someone uses an actual wrong account number, I.e. when they pay the wrong known person, not because of a mistake in the account number.

WhipperWhirlBat · 26/04/2022 11:47

No, it isn’t theft apparently. Someone sadly at my workplace transferred about £24k to the wrong account, we knew who received the money, they acknowledged receipt but they wouldn’t return it!

Not much we could do, even with taking legal advice (which, ironically was in house).

We tried to recoup it over a few years then accounts had to write it off. Maybe the law has changed now (this was 5ish years ago) but it’s just shit and makes me very wary of bank transfer payments of any sort.

GingerFigs · 26/04/2022 11:43

And I guess to those saying that the bank should reimburse...the bank is a business and if it's your mistake then it's your responsibility.

I did a payment recently and you have to click numerous checks to say you are happy. There is some self responsibility here.

HappyCup · 26/04/2022 11:43

Coastalcreeksider · 26/04/2022 11:40

I recently transfered a huge sum from a house sale on behalf of my dad after selling his house.

I transferred £20 to start and then £1000 to make doubly sure it was going in correctly.

I was sweating over that new account but because it wasn't my money it was even worse.

I've still go to do another new account transfer soon for the rest of the money and I know I will be sweating on that too!

I had to do something similar and was so stressed I rang the bank helpline and made them stay on the phone with me for moral support while I did it. The person said I was their favourite call of the day. 😂

StrawberryPot · 26/04/2022 11:42

Who do you bank with op? We're with First Direct and it's quite a struggle to transfer money if there's the slightest discrepancy in details. When paying bills we often have to go back and check someone's account details to make sure the name exactly matches the account number.

Fingers crossed you get your money back soon.

MurmuratingStarling · 26/04/2022 11:40

swimmer55 · 26/04/2022 11:23

Thanks for your replies, it a brand new account we opened, had an update from the bank and it seems all may not be lost, it looks like there's no such account as the number he used so hopefully will bounce back/ be returned, as I understand it the only time there would be issues is if it went into a persons account and they refuse to return it, honestly the most stressful morning!

I missed this post!

Sounds like you should get the money back soon!

GingerFigs · 26/04/2022 11:40

I still don't understand how your husband can have transferred a large sum of money to an account that did not match. Bank transfers now have to match the name and account number to validate the payee plus there are limits on first time transactions.

Coastalcreeksider · 26/04/2022 11:40

I recently transfered a huge sum from a house sale on behalf of my dad after selling his house.

I transferred £20 to start and then £1000 to make doubly sure it was going in correctly.

I was sweating over that new account but because it wasn't my money it was even worse.

I've still go to do another new account transfer soon for the rest of the money and I know I will be sweating on that too!

MurmuratingStarling · 26/04/2022 11:38

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 26/04/2022 11:36

If they keep it, isn't it theft as it wasn't intended for them?

It should be theft but apparently it isn't.

Like if someone scammed you over the phone (or internet,) and it was because you willingly gave them your bank or credit card details, there is a strong chance that you will lose everything, because you willingly GAVE it to them. Awful loophole in the law.

BarbaraofSeville · 26/04/2022 11:38

Surely it can't be a case of 'nothing' can be done if the money is in the wrong account?

For that amount of money I wouldn't give up making a nuisance of myself with the bank's complaints procedure, financial ombudsman, financial columns in the papers etc.

ParisHarris · 26/04/2022 11:37

swimmer55 · 26/04/2022 11:23

Thanks for your replies, it a brand new account we opened, had an update from the bank and it seems all may not be lost, it looks like there's no such account as the number he used so hopefully will bounce back/ be returned, as I understand it the only time there would be issues is if it went into a persons account and they refuse to return it, honestly the most stressful morning!

Oh thank goodness for that. What a fright. Hope you get it back quickly.

I always do a small transfer (£1 or something) before moving a large sum just to check I have the details right- too paranoid not to!

MurmuratingStarling · 26/04/2022 11:36

tangledzebra · 26/04/2022 11:27

This happened to my partner and the person refused to return the money, the bank were useless and just said ‘we have written to the customer and he hasn’t responded’, they couldn’t share the customers details and so we couldn’t take them to court etc. It was about £2k so a lot of money.

Outrageous! Hmm How can anyone DO this?! How is it even allowed?

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 26/04/2022 11:36

If they keep it, isn't it theft as it wasn't intended for them?

MurmuratingStarling · 26/04/2022 11:34

I hope you get your money back, but I don't think the person whose account it has gone into HAS to give it back.

I saw something similar on a BBC consumer rights programme once, (around 2013.) A woman had paid £1750 into what she thought was her new landlord's account, for 2 month's rent, and the deposit/bond. The woman put ONE digit wrong, so it went into a stranger's account.

If they had both been with the same bank, it could have been sorted/dealt with, but because she was with Nat West and he was with Lloyds, nothing could be done, and she lost the money, because the recipient refused to give it back...

Pretty awful really, as the recipient should have been done for theft! But as the money was technically given to them, it was not classed as theft. Personally I couldn't live with myself if I kept someone's money like that. But some people are pure scum.

Hope this doesn't happen to you! Hope it's sorted soon!

swimmer55 · 26/04/2022 11:33

Wow how can someone do that to a person who has made a mistake I couldn't live with myself.

OP posts:
SandrasAnnoyingFriend · 26/04/2022 11:30

Are you sure he's telling you the truth?
When transferring ay significant amount of money you get asked over and over again if the details don't match.
Is there any way he could he be using it for gambling?

tangledzebra · 26/04/2022 11:27

This happened to my partner and the person refused to return the money, the bank were useless and just said ‘we have written to the customer and he hasn’t responded’, they couldn’t share the customers details and so we couldn’t take them to court etc. It was about £2k so a lot of money.

AnotherTroyforHertoBurn · 26/04/2022 11:27

When I paid my gardener the first time and I had transposed two figures, it went into banking la la land, I paid him correctly and the other sum eventually bounced back to me as the other account did not exist.

To this day on my banking app, it still say John Smith CORRECT. Grin