Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Transfered all our money into wrong account

188 replies

swimmer55 · 26/04/2022 10:58

First time poster, just had a panicked call from my husband, he has transferred all of our savings in to a new account at a new bank (its been sitting in a current account for a couple of years gaining no interest so now interest rates are rising slightly we decided to transfer), by transposing 2 numbers it has gone to a strangers account, the bank are on it but have said it will take up to 24 days and there's a possibilitythey won't be able to return it, has this happened to anyone else and what was the outcome ? Its all of our savings so we are panicking!

OP posts:
Ellie56 · 28/04/2022 14:59

RestingPandaFace · 26/04/2022 11:26

It’s a bit late now but if you are making a large transfer to a new recipient (one that you have just set up) it’s a good idea to send £1 first and check it gets there OK.

I always do that as I am paranoid about it going to the wrong account!

JudgeJ · 28/04/2022 14:55

tomatoandherbs · 28/04/2022 13:02

I’m getting a whiff here of something odd

either the entire thread but actually
more like the husband

Yet lots of posters, me included, have said they've made an error and I can assure you that I wasn't gambling, crack-buying etc., when a man does it it must be suspect! Such misandry.

ProfessorSlocombe · 28/04/2022 14:32

I think you may find the bank is liable.

Why ? There is a fundamental premise in English law that goes something like "I am not my siblings keeper".

I can guarantee that if banks were to insist on additional checks, there would be a flurry of MN posts about banks "not allowing" people to have access to their money when they wanted it.

HoppingPavlova · 28/04/2022 14:28

At least you haven’t inconvenienced someone else. I once had a large sum that was not mine appear in my account. It was not as simple as a phone call to the bank and the money disappears. I spent a lot of precious time I just didn’t have trying to sort it out. The right thing to do would have been compensation for my time to have been deducted from the amount and worn by either the person or institution that made the mistake. If this ever happens again I will remove the portion I estimate I will be owed, and work with the bank on the remainder. If less of my time is involved than estimated based on previous experience, I will give a refund to be passed on. I would also provide the invoice that accounted for payment for my time as the justification that the amount retained accordingly is not theft.

nearlyspringyay · 28/04/2022 14:10

Can you name the bank op, we're all assuming this is a uk transfer?

Franklin12 · 28/04/2022 14:04

Coastal. I was doing something similar for DDad. It was a huge amount and Nationwide (his bank) let me do it on my own - at home... Lloyds (my own bank) said that they wouldnt have allowed that and would expect me to get them to do it. And dont get me started on these people who try and scam the elderly often from abroad which makes them virtually untouchable.

babyjellyfish · 28/04/2022 13:57

I received five thousand pounds into my bank account by mistake once. I notified the bank and they took it out again without me doing anything further.

Shiloh139 · 28/04/2022 13:56

It happened to me about 7 years ago. I didn't realise I'd transferred £6k of savings into the wrong bank account, for about a month. I checked on the ISA and found it was still emptied. I was in tears. My bank and the bank it had gone to worked on it and I got it back in 9 days. The longest 9 days of my life. If they hadn't been able to get it back, I would have lost the money as it was my error.

If you look online there are mostly horror stories of how people don't get their money back and the Police aren't interested but there are people who do get it back, like me, who probably just never put their good news story online. Try not to get disheartened, keep hope, stay polite with the banks when you contact them for updates. I'll keep my fingers crossed that you get your money back soon.

IcedOatLatte · 28/04/2022 13:53

Newmum110 · 28/04/2022 13:46

This happened me last year, transferred thousands to the wrong person. Stressed for weeks but eventually bank sorted it. Keep the faith & keep the pressure on. It will eventually be returned.

How will faith help Confused Do you not know about the many well publicised cases of people who have lost huge sums from this kind of thing? You getting your money back doesn't mean that everyone else has/will

IcedOatLatte · 28/04/2022 13:51

Alondra · 28/04/2022 12:53

There are many people who still fret about transferring large amount of money online to another account.

You can always go to the bank and for a small fee, they will do it themselves which takes the responsibility out of your hands.

You need to change your bank to one that doesn't charge for such a basic service. Which bank charges for transfers? That's very poor ime

Newmum110 · 28/04/2022 13:46

This happened me last year, transferred thousands to the wrong person. Stressed for weeks but eventually bank sorted it. Keep the faith & keep the pressure on. It will eventually be returned.

Eeksteek · 28/04/2022 13:30

In my experience, it depends on the the bank. I’ve done it twice with a mistake in a payment over the last few years. The first time, it wasn’t my fault and it cost thousands and has taken years to correct, (I’m still dealing with it). The second it WAS my fault, and the bank corrected as soon as I contacted them. There could have been consequences (credit rating) but they didn’t apply them, because the money was paid at the right time in good faith.

WeAllHaveWings · 28/04/2022 13:29

I nearly screwed up a transfer lately (only a tenner), but it told me the account name and number didn't match. Same for my brother last year when he tried to transfer money to me and I had a typo in the account number 😳

Thought they all did this now?

Sooziewoozie · 28/04/2022 13:27

I think you may find the bank is liable. They do checks these days to make sure the account number matches the name don't they? If this is the case the transaction should have failed. You may find the money is in a holding account. Fingers crossed you get it back.

JudgeJ · 28/04/2022 13:23

if it were me then I would go to the Financial Ombudsman stating the bank had a reasonable duty of care to spot an obvious error in record matching.
The bank was not wrong here, people really do need to accept their own carelessness. The trite phrase 'duty of care' is trotted out so regularly to try and palm one's own responsibility to someone else.

Manekinek0 · 28/04/2022 13:18

Fingers crossed this all works out. I recently got a chase bank account and it came up with a warning about it not being able to be verified on the first transfer. I am so paranoid I always do a £1 transfer the first time and then once it's gone through the details are saved on my main account.

JudgeJ · 28/04/2022 13:17

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 26/04/2022 11:36

If they keep it, isn't it theft as it wasn't intended for them?

There used to be a crime called 'taking pecuniary advantage' which covered this situation but I don't think it still exists and I'm not sure if there is a replacement.
I did something similar when I was cashing in about £10,000 on the phone, I mis-read a 3 for 8 or v.v.. I went down to the bank, Nationwide, and they looked into it, having calmed me down with a cup of coffee, luckily in my case it had gone into a dormant or non-existant account and they were able to recover it immediately but she did say that had it gone into someone's account it could have been very difficult to recover.
Good luck with it.

muddyford · 28/04/2022 13:14

My normally careful DH transferred £500 in the same way, transposed the last two digits. This was in the days, relatively recently like last year, that matching by the bank wasn't happening. It wasn't an account but it still took three weeks for the money to be refunded.

ProfessorSlocombe · 28/04/2022 13:10

Why do some people think they have a right to steal someone else’s hard earned money?

Who said anything about stealing ?

People pearl clutching on here saying mistakes are virtually impossible to make are not being realistic. Mistakes do happen

Daily, given my experiences. I'm quite surprised by the number of posters who think the UK banking sector is somehow free from error.

ParisNoir · 28/04/2022 13:09

BuanoKubiamVej · 28/04/2022 13:07

This seems pretty likely. Unless the bank is really crap there should be loads of warnings and safeguards to stop people making these kinds of mistakes now. It used to happen quite a lot but all the banks I know about have changed their procedures to make it much more difficult to make mistakes like this. On the other hand it makes a good story to tell for why thousands of pounds of savings aren't there.

Exactly- and the reason banks now put those checks and warnings in is because if YOU then still get scammed, legally they have done everything they possibly can and arent obliged to cover your mistake, its to cover their own backs.

BuanoKubiamVej · 28/04/2022 13:07

SandrasAnnoyingFriend · 26/04/2022 11:30

Are you sure he's telling you the truth?
When transferring ay significant amount of money you get asked over and over again if the details don't match.
Is there any way he could he be using it for gambling?

This seems pretty likely. Unless the bank is really crap there should be loads of warnings and safeguards to stop people making these kinds of mistakes now. It used to happen quite a lot but all the banks I know about have changed their procedures to make it much more difficult to make mistakes like this. On the other hand it makes a good story to tell for why thousands of pounds of savings aren't there.

Alondra · 28/04/2022 13:06

Also, one thing that should make us all to breathe a bit easier is that banks these days take a minimum of 2-3 business days to clear transfers to another bank or new account. If we make a mistake and provided we realise we made the mistake in that time frame, it's easy for the bank to stop the transferring of the funds.

ParisNoir · 28/04/2022 13:05

scoobydoo1971 · 28/04/2022 13:03

Mistakes and negligent actions by banks do happen. I had money placed in my account once by mistake. I told the bank and they told me to keep it (small sum) until it was claimed. It was claimed, and they rang me for permission to retract it. A high street bank removed over £5k from my mother's account without her knowledge and consent. They claimed it was a dormant account (it was not, and she had added money in the year they closed it and phoned for interest statements). It took nearly two years of fighting the bank and then passing to the Ombudsman to get her money back. Errors do happen. Online banking checks the name of the intended recipient, as do over the counter transactions. I have recently moved money around between various accounts in my name and it is HARD, very HARD to get money moved without a little chat with the fraud team at the bank. I did a bank transfer this week over the counter of HSBC and they wanted all sorts of ID, and had me sign a document against the transfer. They even wanted me to volunteer a finger print for their system. If this is a legitimate error, you may struggle to get your money back but if it were me then I would go to the Financial Ombudsman stating the bank had a reasonable duty of care to spot an obvious error in record matching.

It wasnt the bank's mistake though- it was the husband transferring to the wrong account number which makes no sense because you get warnings first that the number doesnt match the account name. You also THEN get a message asking if you are sure it isnt a scam etc I agree with PP- there is something very fishy going on here....

Badger1970 · 28/04/2022 13:03

I would be a little cautious here, OP. Have you spoken to the bank yourself?

A family friend's DP supposedly did the same....... only he cleared the account and was long gone by the time she realised that it wasn't a banking error. He and his shiny new OW had a great life on her savings and she didn't get a penny back as the account was in both their names.

scoobydoo1971 · 28/04/2022 13:03

Mistakes and negligent actions by banks do happen. I had money placed in my account once by mistake. I told the bank and they told me to keep it (small sum) until it was claimed. It was claimed, and they rang me for permission to retract it. A high street bank removed over £5k from my mother's account without her knowledge and consent. They claimed it was a dormant account (it was not, and she had added money in the year they closed it and phoned for interest statements). It took nearly two years of fighting the bank and then passing to the Ombudsman to get her money back. Errors do happen. Online banking checks the name of the intended recipient, as do over the counter transactions. I have recently moved money around between various accounts in my name and it is HARD, very HARD to get money moved without a little chat with the fraud team at the bank. I did a bank transfer this week over the counter of HSBC and they wanted all sorts of ID, and had me sign a document against the transfer. They even wanted me to volunteer a finger print for their system. If this is a legitimate error, you may struggle to get your money back but if it were me then I would go to the Financial Ombudsman stating the bank had a reasonable duty of care to spot an obvious error in record matching.