Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Transfered all our money into wrong account

188 replies

swimmer55 · 26/04/2022 10:58

First time poster, just had a panicked call from my husband, he has transferred all of our savings in to a new account at a new bank (its been sitting in a current account for a couple of years gaining no interest so now interest rates are rising slightly we decided to transfer), by transposing 2 numbers it has gone to a strangers account, the bank are on it but have said it will take up to 24 days and there's a possibilitythey won't be able to return it, has this happened to anyone else and what was the outcome ? Its all of our savings so we are panicking!

OP posts:
ToffeeNotCoffee · 28/04/2022 18:00

.

Echobelly · 28/04/2022 17:45

I had a similar thing when my inheritance came through from my granddad - it was a huge sum, enough to pay off our mortgage. And I somehow gave my dad my savings account number with two digits transposed and realised this on a Friday afternoon.

My brother didn't help matters by ringing me and saying he'd heard if it goes to a real account you can't compel them to return it to you and he'd heard about all these cases where people lost their money forever because the other person didn't want to give it back. This was literally about 3 months before name checks came in... fortunately my dad told me that the solicitor said usually the money bounces back as it's rare for a bank to have two such similar account numbers and the majority of the time the money reappears, which set my mind at rest a bit. Luckily it bounced back on the Monday. All my accounts now check the name! But yeah, that was a sharp intake of breath right there.

DontKeepTheFaith · 28/04/2022 17:33

I have a fairly new savings account which doesn’t have the electronic check thing set up with my bank. My bank warns me to triple check because of this so I sent a little, then a little more and basically transferred my savings in installments. I still check the number on the account before sending anymore money even now. It’s stressful but the interest rate is good!

ProfessorSlocombe · 28/04/2022 17:23

If someone mistakenly pays money into your account it is theft to keep it. The crime is "dishonestly retaining a wrongful credit," from the Theft Act 1968.

You really shouldn't dabble in areas that aren't your forte. You end up missing the important bits (or is that why you didn't post the link ?) which is:

Wrongful
A credit is wrongful if it derives from theft, blackmail, fraud or stolen goods.

www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/theft-act-offences

Just mixing up numbers or accounts does not make a payment wrongful. And as we have already decided, the original payment into the recipients account doesn't have the intent necessary for theft.

Superhanz · 28/04/2022 17:00

Similar happened to me. I had set up an account on our credit union account and 1 number was incorrect. I transferred £1000 and when it didn't show in our account I realised the mistake. As there was no account with that name the money came back into the account, I think it took around a week.

CellophaneFlower · 28/04/2022 16:56

tomatoandherbs · 28/04/2022 16:24

They allow you to overide. I too am with NatWest
but you have to explicitly confirm that the details you have match what is in the screen and has not been identified at matching

but this account didn’t even exist. So that would have been flagged

I was mainly replying to the earlier posters who were saying if the details didn't match then the bank would block the transfer. But if non-existent account I'm sure it would flag!

Seaography · 28/04/2022 16:51

If someone mistakenly pays money into your account it is theft to keep it. The crime is "dishonestly retaining a wrongful credit," from the Theft Act 1968. The dishonest element comes from whether it would be reasonable for the recipient to notice this money appear and believe they had no right to it. I once had money paid into an account I no longer used so it was reasonable that I didn't notice. Getting £10k paid into the account I use regularly would be hard to prove I acted reasonably.

However, that doesn't mean it will be simple getting it back. The police are unlikely to be interested and you don't have the persons details. You would probably have to deal with it on a civil basis and start by taking the bank to court to establish who the other account holder is.

In this case if it has not gone to a person it should be in a holding account at the other bank and returned soon. Still nail biting to wait though!

ProfessorSlocombe · 28/04/2022 16:43

maybe because we all use internet banking and all know you actively have to confirm when setting up an entirely new payee at least twice that you definitely have details correct and matches XYZ as being be account they have identified as being the one the details input relate to

"All" of us ?

Maybe not "all" of us who deal with bank transfers daily and know that not all banks are able to verify payee details.

Loobyloo68 · 28/04/2022 16:40

I once tried to pay a builder £9k via online banking. Even though his name and account number etc matched, I had to ring my bank and ask them to put the payment through, bit embarrassing in front of the builder saying the money wont go through to your account, but good really that the bank were sort off checking a large amount leaving my account

tomatoandherbs · 28/04/2022 16:25

Soontobe60 · 28/04/2022 16:24

I always do this even though my banking app now verifies if the account name, sort code and account number match!!

You always transfer all your life savings into accounts that don’t exist?

Soontobe60 · 28/04/2022 16:24

I always do this even though my banking app now verifies if the account name, sort code and account number match!!

tomatoandherbs · 28/04/2022 16:24

They allow you to overide. I too am with NatWest
but you have to explicitly confirm that the details you have match what is in the screen and has not been identified at matching

but this account didn’t even exist. So that would have been flagged

CellophaneFlower · 28/04/2022 16:20

I started another thread the other day as I thought money I'd transferred to my mortgage account had gone missing.

Nationwide just give you an account number and sort code to transfer, not a name. I've tried "nationwide" and it always comes up as an unconfirmed account and do I still want to proceed at my own risk? So some banks do let you override this (Natwest). I panicked so much the first time I transferred, thinking it was somehow dodgy or I'd got some numbers muddled up!

tomatoandherbs · 28/04/2022 16:19

Why do I think the husband is being a little shady?

maybe because we all use internet banking and all know you actively have to confirm when setting up an entirely new payee at least twice that you definitely have details correct and matches XYZ as being be account they have identified as being the one the details input relate to

so either the husband was transferring ALL their savings whilst also performing brain surgery and was understandably a little distracted or….

tryingtosettle · 28/04/2022 16:15

thecatsarecrazy · 28/04/2022 16:13

I don't believe this post is true. Saying now the account doesn't exist and it will bounce back.. if that was the case it would happen straight away. I paid someone £140 I had to put his full name in. He gave me the wrong account number and it bounced straight away. More going on here for sure

I've seen it happen at work and its taken 2 weeks to bounce back.

Autumnwater · 28/04/2022 16:13

We lost about £800 doing the same. Only realised when my partners friend messaged and said that he hadn’t received the money and it was a while down the line. Bank was pretty useless and never got it back. Someone had a nice treat though

thecatsarecrazy · 28/04/2022 16:13

GingerFigs · 26/04/2022 11:40

I still don't understand how your husband can have transferred a large sum of money to an account that did not match. Bank transfers now have to match the name and account number to validate the payee plus there are limits on first time transactions.

I don't believe this post is true. Saying now the account doesn't exist and it will bounce back.. if that was the case it would happen straight away. I paid someone £140 I had to put his full name in. He gave me the wrong account number and it bounced straight away. More going on here for sure

Shiloh139 · 28/04/2022 16:03

BorgQueen · 28/04/2022 15:25

I’m assuming it’s first direct given that their ( from today) regular saver account now pays 3.5% ?
I’ve just opened a current account with them but I can’t open a regular saver with them until I’ve had the account details through the post.
Presumably your DH already has a FD current account? If so then why couldn’t he transfer between the 2 accounts?
If not FD then apologies, heads up to everyone else though, the regular saver is fixed for a year at 3.5% and you can pay in £300 a month - so a couple can open separate accounts and pay in £600 😉

Oooh, great to know, thanks BorgQueen. Also, for others interested in this, it's probably worth knowing that you can't withdraw from their regular saver accounts for a minimum 12 month period, without closing the Regular Saver altogether. 3.5% is worth doing though, if you know you won't need the money in that 12 month period.

Right, I'm going to get on to FD to see about opening a new Regular Saver account with them.

thecatsarecrazy · 28/04/2022 16:02

I did a bank transfer a couple of weeks ago and you have to put the full name of the person in so this doesn't happen. I put the wrong number in to start with because he gave me the wrong last digit, and it bounced.

Rosehugger · 28/04/2022 15:56

I did it years ago in the very early days of online banking, paying my Barclaycard bill in 2000- I had actually put in the right numbers but apparently it had been going to someone's business Barclaycard! It wasn't possible to pay for a personal Barclaycard bill that way and I had clicked on the only but wrong option when I set it up. Only realised when my statement said I hadn't been paying for two months. I cried a bit then contacted Barclaycard, who to their credit (fnar) sorted it out quickly and it was all good.

pentagone · 28/04/2022 15:45

Thanks BorgQueen - handy tip!

BorgQueen · 28/04/2022 15:25

I’m assuming it’s first direct given that their ( from today) regular saver account now pays 3.5% ?
I’ve just opened a current account with them but I can’t open a regular saver with them until I’ve had the account details through the post.
Presumably your DH already has a FD current account? If so then why couldn’t he transfer between the 2 accounts?
If not FD then apologies, heads up to everyone else though, the regular saver is fixed for a year at 3.5% and you can pay in £300 a month - so a couple can open separate accounts and pay in £600 😉

totallybonafido · 28/04/2022 15:18

DH once transferred a few thousand into the wrong account, fortunately the account number that he used didn't exist and so it took a few days for the bank to return the money. He learned his lesson that day and always double checks and triple checks now!

pentagone · 28/04/2022 15:13

RestingPandaFace · 26/04/2022 11:26

It’s a bit late now but if you are making a large transfer to a new recipient (one that you have just set up) it’s a good idea to send £1 first and check it gets there OK.

This! Your husband is an absolute tool for transferring all of your savings to a new account and where presumably the bank checking system didn't verify it was the right account ( not all banks have this service so if I am sending money to a bank that is not verified I transfer just £1 first).
Not to mention being an absolute tool for not checking and double and triple checking he had put the right numbers in.

CharlieLo · 28/04/2022 15:09

People saying it can’t be possible because banks check the name etc now.
Currently Chase is being pushed as the best easy access savings account by moneysavingexpert, lots of people opening an account. It does not verify the name of the bank account holder when you transfer to it as Chase don’t do that. So it is still possible to do.