Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Transfered all our money into wrong account

188 replies

swimmer55 · 26/04/2022 10:58

First time poster, just had a panicked call from my husband, he has transferred all of our savings in to a new account at a new bank (its been sitting in a current account for a couple of years gaining no interest so now interest rates are rising slightly we decided to transfer), by transposing 2 numbers it has gone to a strangers account, the bank are on it but have said it will take up to 24 days and there's a possibilitythey won't be able to return it, has this happened to anyone else and what was the outcome ? Its all of our savings so we are panicking!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CrankyFrankie · 30/04/2022 14:37

What sort of person would refuse to return someone else’s money?! Disgusting.

opensunflower · 30/04/2022 11:22

if anyone else is worried about making this
mistake, the thing to do is transfer a nominal amount, check it works ok then transfer the bulk of cash

my boss taught me this and ill always do it

ancientgran · 30/04/2022 10:33

Just checked MSE and they now have a bank offering 1.5% for instant access. None of the rates they are showing are with one of the big high st banks.

ancientgran · 30/04/2022 10:32

The problem with changing to one of the big name banks is their interest rates are rubbish. Apart from the ones for small amount of savings (like £50 a month for a year or something) my bank was paying 0.1% interest. I switched to a less well known bank, recommended by MSE, and I'm getting 1.25%. That is for instant access (money I don't want to tie up as possibly moving house) I could get a higher interest rate if I tied my money up for a year or two.

So my new saving account is with a bank that doesn't provide the facility to check the name and account number so when I sent the money over my high st bank couldn't confirm the account. I sent £10, then £100 to make sure and then transferred all our savings. With inflation the way it is 1.25% isn't keep up with inflation but 0.1% is a joke.

daisychain01 · 30/04/2022 08:38

ChanceNorman · 30/04/2022 07:59

As someone who works in a bank, involved in fraudulent and missing payments and CRM there is SO much incorrect and outdated advice on this thread. People are also maintaining 'this is how it works' when they're actually talking about bank specific processes - for example just because one bank physically stops you sending a payment if there's a name mismatch does NOT mean that's a catch-all industry policy and all will.

I'm not going to add another voice saying 'this is correct, look at my advice!' 😂 but for anyone in a similar situation to the op, please ignore most of the well meaning but flat out wrong advice on this thread! You'll get far more accurate info just googling. I believe the Financial Ombudsman website also has a helpful consumer article about payment issues.

In fairness @ChanceNorman i specified the name of my bank and asked the OP which bank they were with, for that very reason, because the main banks do have all the checks and balances in place but not all. People have also suggested to the OP that they would do well to switch to one of the main banks that give all those safeguards.

i can say 100% that 2weeks ago, I couldn't pay for a service because the person hadn't given me the exact name of their company as it appeared on their account, so it didn't match their account no and sort code and I had to ring them up and verify it, to be able to pay them online. It does work well.

UnicornPooPoo · 30/04/2022 08:17

Years ago, I was on benefits as a single parent. I had £33k transferred into my account one day. All I can say is I was very surprised to see it there! I didn't use online banking at the time so didn't even notice it was there for at least a week and had no notification from the bank, that poor person must have been frantic thinking I'd nicked it. Anyway, I called the bank secretly hoping I'd won the lottery and not been told 😆 They looked into it which seemed to take ages and the money was returned about two months later!!

It was actually quite a faff for me as I had to get proof for the DWP that I wasn't hiding money from them and was almost taken off benefits at one point 😢

ChanceNorman · 30/04/2022 07:59

As someone who works in a bank, involved in fraudulent and missing payments and CRM there is SO much incorrect and outdated advice on this thread. People are also maintaining 'this is how it works' when they're actually talking about bank specific processes - for example just because one bank physically stops you sending a payment if there's a name mismatch does NOT mean that's a catch-all industry policy and all will.

I'm not going to add another voice saying 'this is correct, look at my advice!' 😂 but for anyone in a similar situation to the op, please ignore most of the well meaning but flat out wrong advice on this thread! You'll get far more accurate info just googling. I believe the Financial Ombudsman website also has a helpful consumer article about payment issues.

Indoctro · 30/04/2022 07:45

My friend did it with £600 and the person refused to give it back so she lost it

Some people are very dishonest. It was a serious amount of money to her at the time and left her extremely broke.

I always wonder if karma caught up with the horrid individual who kept her money Angry

Crystalb8ll421 · 30/04/2022 07:21

I just want to add that this happened to us. My husband's aunt died and left us £83 000 and my husband transferred it to our mortgage provider. Luckily I checked with the mortgage provider a week later and found out they hadn't received it so we went back to the bank and it turned out the counter person had put the wrong number on the slip and my husband had signed it without checking... luckily the incorrect bank account number didn't belong to anyone so essentially the money was floating about in the ether for a few days. Rest assured my husband is not trusted to do anything like this now! It's left to me because I am the triple checker. We even got £100 in compo from the building society. But it was a frightening time for me. Imagine losing that much.money.

Rtruth · 30/04/2022 06:10

The bank can only request it back, receiver doesn’t have to give it back(you can take them to court if they don’t).

However, I’d have serious questions:

  1. how did it happen? Banks have so many checks in place before a transfer, so it would have warned him accounts don’t match.
  2. have you seen the Account number it was transferred to?
  3. have you spoken to bank about the timescales directly?
me109f · 30/04/2022 02:25

Difficult to do as transferring money has double checks these days. You are most likely to get all your money back.
It would be illegal if an undeserving recipient tried to transfer the money to hide it without knowing where it came from. If it is a genuine mistake the bank will just get it returned straight away without the recipient being involved. I used to work for a bank and this happens a great deal. Twice I have had large sums appearing into my account; I never touched the money and it soon disappeared back to where it came from.

ThanksForAllTheFish · 30/04/2022 01:55

I used to work for a bank and worked the in
’internal accounts department’ for a while. This very thing happens a lot more than you could imagine- hundreds of thousands of pounds each and every day.

The money is in an account belonging to the bank - all the money transferred to accounts that don’t exist bounce into the catch all internal account for that sort code.

People who work in the bank go through these accounts every day and try to clear them back to zero. Each type of transaction has its own protocols to return or move on the funds. As it’s from one bank to another they might have to return it which can take a few days, or what might happen is they will move it into your OH’s new account if they have been given the new account details. It’s much easier to move the money into the correct account with the same bank that it is to send it back.

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 30/04/2022 01:30

You can click through and choose to ignore the warnings if the name is mismatched. You can't click through if the account details don't exist. The OP said the numbers were incorrect and didn't match any account so they hoped it was in holding. None of the banks signed up to the Confirmation of Payee system will let you put a transfer through if the numbers don't match an existing account. If the account doesn't exist then you can't transfer money to it.

This scheme was introduced in the last two years. So yy in the past you might have been able to send money into limbo if you used details that didn't exist but most banks don't let you do that any more. And if anyone has a bank that does let you send money into the ether then you should switch to one of the others.

dottypencilcase · 30/04/2022 01:15

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 26/04/2022 15:19

The solicitor handling my grandparents estate entered incorrect bank details and almost lost my parents' inheritance. They manages to sort it but, when it happened I was snooping around trying to find out what they could do and came across this story.

amp.theguardian.com/money/2019/dec/07/i-lost-my-193000-inheritance-with-one-wrong-digit-on-my-sort-code

Absolute madness that it isn't counted as theft!

He got it back: https://www.theguardian.com/money/2019/dec/14/man-handed-193000-in-sort-code-error-says-he-tried-to-give-it-back?CMP=ShareiOSAppp_Other

VanGoghsDog · 30/04/2022 01:14

Sooziewoozie · 28/04/2022 13:27

I think you may find the bank is liable. They do checks these days to make sure the account number matches the name don't they? If this is the case the transaction should have failed. You may find the money is in a holding account. Fingers crossed you get it back.

It doesn't "fail" just due to not matching. It warns you and you can sidestep it - I've just done it this evening because an account I send money to has a slightly different name to the one I typed in, but I know it's the right account. You just click "continue anyway".

The odd thing though is that a) if he got the sort code right there wouldn't be another bank in the mix, b) he'd just opened the account he was transferring to, how could he not notice the name didn't match, it should have been his own name.

Harmonypuss · 30/04/2022 00:40

In September 2016 my son's student loans were put into someone else's account. Student Finance said we'd provided wrong account details. They tried to recall the money but the account holder had moved/spent it. They said because we'd given the wrong account info it was our fault and that they wouldn't be sending replacement funds but he'd still have to repay the loan.
We proved that we'd given the correct information as I'd kept screen shots of everything we'd submitted.
An investigation was opened in November 2016 and eventually, 8 months after he should have had the funds, they eventually found in our favour and sent him the cash to the correct account.
This was a MAJOR ball-ache coz I don't work and he really needed those funds in the September, not the following May when his university year was practically over.
It was lucky that we were able to get a loan to cover his expenses. We applied to Student Finance for them to pay the interest we'd had to pay on the loan due to their mistake, we've only just got that back from them after over 5yrs.

Spectre8 · 29/04/2022 23:43

My bank is like so on it its crazy. I had to pay my landscaper £8k and because they are using a third party provider that wasnt listed they couldn't verify the name and account. I sent £200 through to test it worked and it did. Then I tried to said the remaining amount and as it was large I had to call the scam preventation team and talk to them and verify it was legit. I had to call my lanscaper to had it on record that he confirmed the details are legit. Then I finally put it through via my banking app and then the fraud team stopped the payment and I had to talk to them.

alltheteeshirts · 29/04/2022 22:38

If your bank didn't have the newish measure where it checks the name on the account matches... I'd be getting a new bank after this. No reason to keep a dinosaur bank.

IsabelHerna · 29/04/2022 22:09

Thank god your story had a happy ending. I'd hope that even if the account existed, the owner would happily return your money, it's the right thing to do. I couldn't be able to live with myself if random money appeared into my account...

midsomermurderess · 29/04/2022 22:04

It could give rise to a claim for unjustified enrichment, on the grounds that the payee has been enriched at the payer's expense, the payee's retention of the enrichment being unjust. You'd have to know who the payee is, and raise a court action though.

Mollymoostoo · 29/04/2022 22:03

GingerFigs · 26/04/2022 11:40

I still don't understand how your husband can have transferred a large sum of money to an account that did not match. Bank transfers now have to match the name and account number to validate the payee plus there are limits on first time transactions.

This. My bank tells me the name on the account and warns me if the name I have typed and the name on the account do not match.

FangsForTheMemory · 29/04/2022 22:02

When someone was transferring a large amount of money to me I said 'For god's sake send me £1 first, then send the rest once I've confirmed it has arrived safely.' I mean you take care but there are ways of minimising errors.

VivX · 29/04/2022 21:57

swimmer55 · 28/04/2022 11:46

Apologies for delay in updating,its my first post so completely lost the thread. 100 per cent sure this is whats happened, I've witnessed the calls back and forth between the 2 banks, still not resolved but it does still seem that it hasn't gone into an actual account, each bank is asking for the other to recall/send it so hopefully it will be sorted.Just such a stressful few days, its a lot of money.

I have done this to a non-existent International bank account. It eventually bounced back - it took a week - and that was without a recall request.

For those saying that there is a check that the payee name and account matches - as not all banks have signed up for this, depending on who you bank with and where the recipient account is. Both banks need to have signed up for the service for it fully work.

And as others have said, it is not the banks fault if the customer has made the error (as in this case).

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 29/04/2022 21:53

The six largest banks are all signed up to Confirmation of Payee and some of the internet banks are signed up to it too.
If OP's DH has managed to find a bank that doesn't use that system, then OP should be moving their accounts to a bank that does use it.

Louise2092 · 29/04/2022 21:51

This happened to us but with our rent payment. Our landlord changed banks and dp wanted to pay rent from his account this time but he mixed up 2 numbers. We had no clue until the landlord called me.

It took a month to sort with constant chasing of the bank. We were told that it would take 2-3 working days for days bank to contact the bank of the person the money went to who then had 2-3 working days to contact their customer.

We were also told that if the person who got the money said it was a genuine transaction/transfer then they had 21 days to prove it. We were then told that if that person had spent our money, we had to wait til there was money in their account as their bank couldn't put them into debt which I think is shocking if they've spent money they know isn't theirs. That was the most stressful part. We were lucky that we put the reference for the payment as rent and our street name so unless that person rented out a property on our street, they didn't really have a leg to stand on.

My partner has transferred money to me on a few occasions since with the same bank and we've had to go through the process a few times and they couldn't tell us why dp's money was being transferred to random accounts/going missing.

He's now changed banks but it's a horrible situation to be in... hope you get it back ASAP. As long as you used a good reference for the transfer, hopefully the person who got the money isn't able to convince their bank the payment to them is genuine.

Also... sorry if this has been sorted now. Only read so far then dog went nuts at the door.