Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to resist the urge to say what I want to say…

316 replies

goinglow · 26/04/2022 04:05

I’ve just been through the most traumatic break-up. We had been together for a year and were planning for the future, when he completely blindsided me with a break-up. Within an hour of that, he did something so reckless, outrageous and insane that it felt like living through a nightmare (I wasn’t hurt, it was something he did that I witnessed). I prefer not to divulge the story but the phrase ‘what a disgusting c*’ is the reaction from most people when they hear the story.

He then blocked me on all mediums and left me an absolute shell of myself. Prior to the break-up we were (I thought) completely in love.

A few weeks later with no contact at all and I’m back on my feet and moving forward, and he’s just emailed me and asked me for half the money for something he paid on behalf of both of us.

I never thought he’d have the audacity to ask for it after the way he behaved. I assumed he’d consider it his arsehole tax. He can easily afford to swallow the cost.

I want to rip him a new one. I want to tell him if he wants his money he can face me and explain himself and his behaviour. I want to tell him the years of therapy I’ll need will far outweigh the cost. I want to tell him he should be so ashamed of his behaviour and the fact he would come to me for money is a disgrace.

I know I shouldn’t though. Moral high ground and all that.

However, he’s someone that wants a quiet life. He’ll want nothing more than to think his actions have had no consequences and to carry on guilt-free. On that basis, I can’t help but want to remind him this isn’t the case.

What would you do? Pay up, block and move on, or take the opportunity to remind him that actions have consequences and say some of the unsaid things he deserves to hear?

OP posts:
LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 26/04/2022 16:58

Before thinking of paying, please do charge him for any additional costs you faced!

LollyLol · 26/04/2022 16:58

It is a shame you already repaid him for the one specific thing he bought you.
I’d send him a reply, “After taking into account my cost overruns due to the unexpected outcome of our trip, less the amounts you paid on my behalf, you owe me £317.97. Please transfer the amount to my bank account today.”

if he replies with a “how did you come up with that?” reply or insists you still owe him money, I’d reply, “if you want to dispute this and prefer to dredge through all the sordid details of our trip in small claims court, we can go down that route. I don’t pretend to understand your behaviour, but surely even you can see some advantage to settling this privately between ourselves rather than airing everything in full sight of the public.”

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 26/04/2022 16:54

Do you have a friend or relation (one of those suitably revolted by his behaviour) who could stand-up to (and shame) him? You could tell him that since he is now dead to you, this person is holding the money ready for him and that they want 'a word' with him. :)

If he doesn't turn up for the 'chat' and the money before a certain date, it is being donated to his least favourite charitable/political/social cause.

It is sad to have lost the man you thought he was but it could have taken even longer for him to show his true colours.

Wishing you a much better future than the one he offers.

ExMachinaDeus · 26/04/2022 16:51

What on earth would he want a dialogue for?

Power. Manipulation.

To prove to himself that he's not the utter arsehole he clearly is.

ExMachinaDeus · 26/04/2022 16:50

I'd block and ignore.

AND DO NOT PAY HIM ANYTHING.

I wouldn't tell him how you feel at the moment.

Why make yourself vulnerable to him? Why give him that knowledge of you.

He does NOT deserve to know anything about you, and certainly NOTHING that could give him any kind of hold over you.

He's behaved like a sociopath (not that he is one, but sadly a lot of men cut off emotionally like this - it is almost psychopathic). Do not treat him as if he stll cares for you.

He doesn't.

Please, just walk away. Ignore, block, go on & have a fantastic life! Flowers

TigerLilyTail · 26/04/2022 16:36

Hhmmmm. I’m not sure I can process this. What on earth would he want a dialogue for?

Some possible reasons

  • He's broke and desperately needs the money (seems unlikely from what you've said).
  • It's doing it to fuck with your head.
  • He's bored/lonely/horny and thinking about you.
Probably the last one!
SpaceshiptoMars · 26/04/2022 16:34

Saracenia · 26/04/2022 16:27

Many years ago, I walked in on my boyfriend in bed with our flatmate, in my bed. I moved out that day. A month later he rang to ask me to pay a share of the bills that had come in. I laughed and hung up.

I expect the OP witnessed far worse! Probably walked in on a five way including a goat and a leprechaun in the bed she'd paid for....

Paddingtonthebear · 26/04/2022 16:34

Some people just have no class at all unfortunately.

Paddingtonthebear · 26/04/2022 16:30

He blocked you on all mediums so that you couldn’t contact him, then assumes it’s fine to contact you when it suits him. What a twat. I would act as though he is blocked. Add his email address to blocked/spam email, then delete and move on with your life. If he is that determined to get some money out of you then he can instruct a solicitor or something. In the meantime thank your lucky stars you didn’t waste any more of your life on him than you did

Krakenchorus · 26/04/2022 16:30

Do not respond in any way. Don't pay, don't acknowledge that you've read the message. Delete. Block. Ignore.

You have nothing at all to gain from any communication with this arsehole. Not closure (it won't be), not satisfaction in having spoken your mind.

Do not pay because that would be engaging in a form of communication. Just no.

Thank god you only wasted a year! Lucky escape, OP.

Saracenia · 26/04/2022 16:27

Many years ago, I walked in on my boyfriend in bed with our flatmate, in my bed. I moved out that day. A month later he rang to ask me to pay a share of the bills that had come in. I laughed and hung up.

tkwal · 26/04/2022 16:24

Block him after you've told him to whistle for the money. Then move on and give thanks you're rid of him

goinglow · 26/04/2022 16:21

BitOutOfPractice · 26/04/2022 12:47

I’m going to say it again because you haven’t clicked yet. He doesn’t want the money. He wants to open a dialogue with you. About anything.

whether you want that dialogue will influence your reply. I suspect you do. Answering him in any way or even acknowledging the message by paying the money back will, in his mind, reopen the dialogue between you.

My best advice? No answer. Of any kind.

Hhmmmm. I’m not sure I can process this. What on earth would he want a dialogue for?

OP posts:
Testina · 26/04/2022 16:21

I’d pay exactly what I owed with no comment, and block.

Ophanim · 26/04/2022 16:19

If you don’t pay I think it’ll always be in the back of your mind that he may contact you again at a later date asking for the money. You won’t be completely free of him.
Pay him back and never contact him again.

goinglow · 26/04/2022 16:19

tcjotm · 26/04/2022 12:20

Rant to yourself on a voice memo to yourself and you can feel like he’s cowering in meek silence while you tear strips off him. Win win, you say it all and he never hears it (face it, he wouldn’t truly hear you anyway) and so can’t use it against you.

I do this when I can’t stop dwelling on stuff. Works so well. And if I listen back I’m either super grateful it wasn’t a real voicemail as I sound unhinged or I’m pleasantly surprised how articulate I sound (rare, but quite satisfying).

If I really needed to I’d do it as a voicemail WhatsApp to my sister as she’d say all the right things 😂

This is genius! What a great idea!

OP posts:
stiritwithaknife · 26/04/2022 16:13

"They had an agreement so she should pay back. He'll have nothing to complain about as far as the OP's behaviour goes. The only questionable behaviour will be his." -@SammyScrounge

There are no medals given out for being the most upright and nicest after a breakup.

@goinglow why are you giving this so much headspace?? He doesn't deserve all this worry over what to do. He deserve any more of your time and attention.

Text him back: "😂and you owe me a significant amount of money for the hotel room / new travel tickets / taxi / train / [insert details here] I had to unexpectedly arrange because of you breaking up with me on holiday and putting on such a disgusting display. Never contact me again. If you have an ounce of decency you will transfer $[your total cost for changing your arrangements inserted here] to my bank account. Goodbye". And block him.

DO NOT PAY HIM HALFSIES FOR A HOLIDAY HE PLANNED TO BREAK UP WITH YOU ON! He should have had the decency to break up with you on native soil so you didn't waste your time and money on holiday with him.

Don't be a mouse, OP! Don't be so easily cowed by anticipating and catastrophising worst case scenarios of what he might do if you don't give him everything he wants.

Hana89 · 26/04/2022 16:12

goinglow · 26/04/2022 04:31

It was half of several meals and incidentals that he paid for on holiday (which is where we broke up), with an agreement to split the costs when we got home. We split it out of practicality, not out of necessity. We can both afford to cover the costs.

On the one hand you did agree to split the costs, but equally, that agreement came before he broke up with you and ruined your holiday and (from what you've said) he behaved completely inappropriately too! So I think on balance you're very justified in just ignoring his request.
Also if you want to send an email expressing your feelings, maybe write it in Word (so that you can't accidentally hit send too soon!) and sleep on it. Then you can read back what you've written in the morning and if you're still happy with it - hit send! And if you don't want to hear back from him: block! block! block! 😊

babyjellyfish · 26/04/2022 15:53

goinglow · 26/04/2022 09:50

A significant amount of money, yes! I will indeed add this in and offset against anything I owe him. He actually may end up owing me money in the end. A dialogue of sorts is unavoidable but I am keeping it very direct and formal.

In that case, don't pay him a penny.

pompei8309 · 26/04/2022 15:53

I have no doubt that you suffer as a consequence of his actions but “ several years” of therapy?? really ? and you still want to entertain him over some petty meal money .
Very dramatic in my opinion affter only one year of relationship

SammyScrounge · 26/04/2022 15:51

TigerLilyTail · 26/04/2022 05:58

I’m genuinely surprised how many people are saying to pay him back.

They had an agreement so she should pay back. He'll have nothing to complain about as far as the OP's behaviour goes. The only questionable behaviour will be his.
Once that loose end is tied off, the OP can go NC with a clear conscience and never speak to that jerk again.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 26/04/2022 15:41

goinglow · 26/04/2022 09:50

A significant amount of money, yes! I will indeed add this in and offset against anything I owe him. He actually may end up owing me money in the end. A dialogue of sorts is unavoidable but I am keeping it very direct and formal.

I think in that case I would just message him and say, ‘Unfortunately your unforeseen action on holiday cost me a significant amount of money in hotel/ transport etc costs. As such I consider us to be equally out of profit as a result of money spent on the trip and will not be paying anything to recoup any costs you feel you incurred during the holiday or during our relationship. I consider this matter closed. Please do not contact me again.’

I would then just block and delete on any and every platform he might use to contact him and refuse to engage in the conversation any further.

TigerLilyTail · 26/04/2022 15:28

Mariposista · 26/04/2022 15:24

Don't give him a penny. If he wants it, he can come and face you and explain himself. So sorry OP

Oh, fuck! Definitely don't meet up with him face to face!

This is 100% not about the money. Don't get sucked into any kind of drama with him. Pay or don't pay, but block him and move on.

SpindleInTheWind · 26/04/2022 15:27

goinglow · 26/04/2022 09:48

A significant amount of money, yes! I have been debating whether to add this in.

Well, that and he ruined the bloody holiday.

Mariposista · 26/04/2022 15:24

Don't give him a penny. If he wants it, he can come and face you and explain himself. So sorry OP

Swipe left for the next trending thread