Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider telling others about dd's condition?

65 replies

Madreamigajefa · 26/04/2022 00:47

Dd is 4. She has one good friend at school so far, but she doesn't always reply when people speak to her (including the friend) and already other children have stopped bothering with her or can do things which are a bit mean to her. She has a rare chromosome disorder which means it's highly likely her not responding is a result of associated high social anxiety levels, plus on-off hearing issues, and she has an extremely high likelihood of future learning difficulties. We agreed before to keep her condition on a need to know basis, thinking of it as her information to share as she gets older, but I am worried now that she might end up socially excluded and even bullied because of how it comes across as blanking everyone. She seems to get on a lot better one on one with other children, but more than one and she's looking for an escape. AIBU to think about telling a few more people and thinking it might help, or am I setting up my child to be more isolated and for things that she should have the right to disclose about herself to be spread throughout her peers' parents before she's even old enough to understand it herself?

OP posts:
CatsandDogs22 · 26/04/2022 08:43

I would. My DD has a friend who is being assessed for ASD and knowing this has meant we have encouraged her to persist.

The friendship is good for both of them, that DD learns not everyone thinks the same way and that some people need a little more time/patience/understanding. But she isn’t always easy to be friends with. So having that knowledge of “why” can be helpful.

ParisLondonTokyoSlough · 26/04/2022 08:39

I’m not sure as parents we should be disclosing private medical information to everyone our child goes to school with. The only people that need to know our those people responsible for the child (whether it’s teachers, school nurses, babysitters, grandparents etc). Otherwise, I take the view that the information is my child’s private information to disclose as and when they see fit.

Needmorelego · 26/04/2022 08:38

Of course you should tell people - in age appropriate ways of course. To her friends "she can't always hear what you say so she needs a little help". Does she use Makadon? Children would be very keen to learn some to 'talk' to her. They probably know some already from watching Mr Tumble on TV.
Children are so accepting and just take everything as a fact so knowing that Child A can't hear properly so 'hears' with hands, or Child B has legs that aren't strong so they use a wheelchair. That's just a fact about that child which to them is as accepting as Child C always wears dinosaur t-shirts because she loves dinosaurs.

picklemewalnuts · 26/04/2022 08:30

Instead of announcing a 'condition' that has many varied symptoms, why not just disclose about the specific symptoms?

'Amelia has auditory processing difficulties. Sometimes she simply doesn't understand what she's hearing. Can you smile at her and her say it again, that might help.'

'Amelia gets overwhelmed by groups, but she does really well one to one'

FloorWipes · 26/04/2022 08:29

If my child wasn’t responding because English was her second language or something I would tell people without hesitation. I don’t feel like this should be any different because it’s a medical condition. It’s not something to be ashamed of. It’s just a fact. Like “we are from Italy” is a fact. Lots of kids have a condition of some kind, from autism to cystic fibrosis. It’s not right giving them the added burden of feeling like it’s a big secret.

Bpdqueen · 26/04/2022 08:25

Yes tell people so they can understand otherwise their just going to think she's rude and that's not fair on your daughter

CatSpeakForDummies · 26/04/2022 08:19

My DD has ASD, but not diagnosed until around 8. I found that a lot of 4yo children are not as a socially aware as we project onto them. She can likely join in if she wants and will have others join her if she's doing something fun. I also found that there are a lot of kind children and they are very accepting. Once she settles into friendships, I'd tell the mums if they are nice.

TBH there are so many quirks in little children, I think people are just as accepting with or without knowing an official diagnosis. Unless she's actually mean, she'll be fine.

It sounds like you are a great mum, I'd continue to play it by ear.

x2boys · 26/04/2022 08:19

You could just say your daughter has a genetic condition,which can explain some of her traits etc
Honestly if I said my son has 16p13.11 microdeletion syndrome most people would have no idea what I was talking about particularly if his symptoms where not as pronounced as they are.

WildCoasts · 26/04/2022 08:17

I've been through this dilemma but with an older child. I agree it is their information to share if they want to and they have a right to privacy, but after my experience with not sharing, when the issue is so obvious, I've found it better to quietly tell people beforehand. It makes a big difference to the way people respond to my child for the positive, which is better for her. My child isn't aware I tell people.

KloppsTeeth · 26/04/2022 08:15

I didn’t share my son’s autism diagnosis, for the same reasons, and with hindsight it was a mistake. People will form opinions about your child no matter what, but if they are informed they have a chance to correct / change the way they interact with your daughter.

Greatoutdoors · 26/04/2022 08:13

At 4 I’d tell people to allow them to help her, definitely. You can be selective about it but I don’t think you need to be. It’s just a part of her, nothing to be ashamed of, like with ND kids. It just helps others to understand if they know.
If there are a couple of children she enjoys playing with, how about arranging play dates with their mums and if they seem kind, mention it to them. Most nice mums would listen and help their child understand how best to include DD.

Thehop · 26/04/2022 08:12

I don’t see the need for secrecy here. There’s nothing to be ashamed of. She has a unique profile and people will understand for better when they know why she behaves a little differently socially surely?

IcedOatLatte · 26/04/2022 08:09

Madreamigajefa · 26/04/2022 08:04

Yes I am, and another group as hers is the most common of the rare ones. It sounds very similar, although they may be experiencing different aspects

It will understanding much easier if you use the quote function

One of my dc had a classmate with similar difficulties and I don't know if the parents didn't want to acknowledge them or didn't want to share but the child ended up with no friends as the other children didn't know to make allowances and the last time I heard was on their 3rd primary school

Mybestyear · 26/04/2022 08:07

Pinklimey · 26/04/2022 07:27

Okay, that was very final. Why ask?

@Pinklimey do you mean the “no” post? I think OP was answering the question “is it Turner syndrome” - could be wrong

Madreamigajefa · 26/04/2022 08:04

Yes I am, and another group as hers is the most common of the rare ones. It sounds very similar, although they may be experiencing different aspects

OP posts:
DolphinaPD · 26/04/2022 08:02

Why wouldn't you tell people if it will make her life easier.

To a pp above, she wont be able to identify her way out of a condition she has.

I personally wouldn't be all cloak and dagger about it. Accept her as she is and stop trying to keep it shameful secret.

DolphinaPD · 26/04/2022 08:00

Madreamigajefa · 26/04/2022 07:48

Because it is a condition that we are told "some people are fine and don't know they have it, others have multiple medical complications, but these are the 183 most common things associated." and so if she wasn't to show any of them except medical ones that get handled outside of school then it would feel like gossiping about my own child. Yes I told the school, and I made a decision to communicate with them daily, but they haven't raised concerns about any of this, its from what I have observed myself. Last parents evening they mentioned that she plays alone but seems happy if best friend is not there, the term before all the children were still identifying those core social skills and she just doesn't seem to have followed along as much. Also because of my experience early on when sharing anything, people who would assume that she was not smart or capable. One grandmother has even given the "are you sure she really has it? “ because her challenges aren't as pronounced.

But she's showing issues now Confused

I find this a bit ridiculous tbh.

Knittingchamp · 26/04/2022 07:59

You definitely need to share this. It isn't shameful or gossiping, it's your unique DD and she has a unique profile, and knowing what you know puts her at a distinct advantage to having never gotten the diagnosis. Knowledge and information is power, and enables other kids and teachers to understand her better. It makes for a more understanding and compassionate environment all round. There's nothing worse for a kid than being misunderstood and sharing her neurodiversity will stop that happening. I can't see the benefit of keeping it quiet and you'll find as the years tick by, she might face much bigger challenges and it'd help her to be supported through it by people who know and understand her situation

SleeplessInEngland · 26/04/2022 07:52

Ok, so what advice do you want if you already made your mind up?

Madreamigajefa · 26/04/2022 07:48

Because it is a condition that we are told "some people are fine and don't know they have it, others have multiple medical complications, but these are the 183 most common things associated." and so if she wasn't to show any of them except medical ones that get handled outside of school then it would feel like gossiping about my own child. Yes I told the school, and I made a decision to communicate with them daily, but they haven't raised concerns about any of this, its from what I have observed myself. Last parents evening they mentioned that she plays alone but seems happy if best friend is not there, the term before all the children were still identifying those core social skills and she just doesn't seem to have followed along as much. Also because of my experience early on when sharing anything, people who would assume that she was not smart or capable. One grandmother has even given the "are you sure she really has it? “ because her challenges aren't as pronounced.

OP posts:
InvincibleInvisibility · 26/04/2022 07:31

An interesting story about Ds1 (with Adhd and dyspraxia). He's been in the same class with the same large (14!) Group of friends since he was 3 (not UK). He's popular cos he loves playing any physical game and will happily follow someone else's lead (and hes a nice kid, never insults anyone).

Before his diagnosis , he went through a difficult patch age 7-8 where he would get extremely angry (particularly if something was unfair).

His friends all knew how to "manage" him - stepping back to leave him space or stepping in to get him out of the situation when he was angry (he never totally lost it at school thanks to his friends intervening).

When talking about it, his best friend just shrugged and said its DS1. He's my friend. We love him as he is. Amazing from an 8 year old.

DS1 is now 10 and still friends with them all.

ENoeuf · 26/04/2022 07:29

EmeraldShamrock1 · 26/04/2022 07:25

@ENoeuf Great advice some parents are more immature than their 4 y.o's my Ds doesn't know he has ASD, all his peers know because their parents told them.

Yes I’ve learned the hard way. See also: anything else you confide in someone about re your child may not be treated in confidence.
its not shameful obviously to have any condition but some are prejudged and it’s ultimately your child’s information.

Pinklimey · 26/04/2022 07:27

Okay, that was very final. Why ask?

x2boys · 26/04/2022 07:27

My son has a rare chromosome disorder,the thing is how it affects a person varies massively ,my son has severe autism and learning disabilities,the chromosome deletion is thought to be the underlying cause,however some people are only affected very mildly if at ,all some also have health issues ( which thankfully my son does not )
I think I would continue to explain on a need to know basis,are you a member of Unique ?

EmeraldShamrock1 · 26/04/2022 07:25

@ENoeuf Great advice some parents are more immature than their 4 y.o's my Ds doesn't know he has ASD, all his peers know because their parents told them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread