Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To basically demand super-flexible working hours

482 replies

Flatbrokefornow · 25/04/2022 22:52

I am very privileged in that I don’t have to work to pay the bills (although only just, and not for much longer at the rate things are increasing!), but less privileged in that I’m widowed with no family close by. I’m completely on my own.

Now my DD is in secondary school, I’d like to think about going back to work, to fund a few treats and get my pension and DD’s education fund back on track, and also for my own fulfilment.

BUT, I won’t consider working school holidays. I know people do, and all power to them, but it won’t work for us, yet. (My DD has been diagnosed with anxiety, is being assessed for ADHD and has also lost her father. She’s got enough to cope with) We’ve tried holiday clubs in the past, and the effects on her anxiety are just not worth it for our family. She’s just 11, and while she (probably) won’t set fire to the house, and I’m happy to leave her for short periods occasionally, I can’t really just expect her to stay home alone all day everyday. There really isn’t anyone I can ask. Lone parenting makes forming friendships difficult, I’m an only child and my parents live abroad. I have lovely neighbours, who will do the odd favour, but that’s not exactly a solid plan going forward.

is it a non starter? I was thinking of retraining, but given the restrictions I can work, I’m not sure it’s worth bothering. Who’s going to want to employ me? Especially if any of the interview panel are blokes who never even think about childcare (and it’s common, let’s face it) and just think I’m either coddling her, or a spoilt princess that wants holidays off. I have considered working in a school, but in all honestly I don’t think I could spend all day managing children’s behaviour and then come home and manage DD (who can be very rigid and oppositional) with the level of patience I’d need and enough energy to hold boundaries with her. I don’t think that would be fair on her, or sustainable for me.

I’m currently looking at careers with flex time, working from home, or short term/part time contracts. I wouldn’t mind buying extra leave, or taking a pay cut, but my family will come first and I would leave a position which didn’t allow or follow through on me not working school holidays (in the main. The odd day will probably be doable) without hesitation. Is this even possible? How can I phrase it so that my boundaries are clear, but not sound entitled? How can I reassure an employer that I’ll do my damndest for them in my working hours, but that’s all of the time they are buying from me, and it’s not about money for me. Are my only options very casual, or leaving a job every July?

OP posts:
latetothefisting · 26/04/2022 20:05

tinkerbellvspredator · 25/04/2022 23:01

I'd concentrate on WFH jobs / hybrid jobs where you're not expected into the office every day. Come the school holidays you take 2 weeks annual leave and have a few weeks solely working from home. It wouldn't be a problem where I am (public sector).

This. I moved from local govt to civil service in 2021. both my old and new job are now completely flexible - can work from home every day, office every day or hybrid, work your hours within whatever timescale you like, ask to do condensed hours/4 day week or 9 day fortnight, and can take leave whenever you want (and build up 2 extra days flexi leave per month if you want).
I wouldn't go in demanding those things exactly but realistically it takes months to go through the hiring process in a lot of places. If you aim to start this September you'll have a good 10 months of opportunity to show you're a good worker, so if you do need to then ask for some leniency (although obviously not as drastic as completely changing your hours) you're in a better place, plus they will probably not want to lose you and train someone else if you're halfway decent. Once you get next school holidays (2023) under your belt, your dd will be 13/14 by the following ones and you might feel happier leaving her alone for longer.

rainbowmilk · 26/04/2022 19:55

LegMeChicken · 26/04/2022 16:42

What area is this roughly (education, healthcare, social service) and why do they keep hiring people who can’t do the job? Does nobody else want to work there? V curious.

This actually sets women’s advances back several years. Sustainable flexible working means good work practices etc.
Not ‘shove it onto others’. I’d be inventing fake children and taking summers off too, or looking for others jobs if I worked there.

I’m guessing because the best candidates for the recruitments they’ve done have been people with kids and they can’t refuse to hire them because they have childcare commitments as that’d be discriminatory. I’m sure people without are applying but they aren’t getting the jobs, which is frustrating (for me, anyway).

I agree though that flexibility is not working where I am (or working brilliantly, depending on who you ask).

Sorry op for derailing the thread!

LondonJax · 26/04/2022 19:38

I work in admin in a local school. A lot of people assume all the school holidays are free for term time only staff. They're not. We do get most of the holidays off but, as someone who works 5 days a week (even though they are part time days) I have to commit to 5 days work during the holidays. Yes, that is spread over the Easter/Summer/Christmas breaks and half terms but I don't always get a say about which of those holidays I have to come in on. So I may have to do a couple of days at the end of the summer break to get our area ready for the kids return. Or I may be asked to come in for a day or two over Easter to do the same. Otherwise the days are up to me but I have to give five days during the holidays - non negotiable it's part of the contract.

Last year we were also asked if we could help out in another department in the school summer holidays as they had staff sick with Covid and work needed to get done for the new term. We could say no and we were paid for the extra hours - but that sort of thing can be common for admin staff when the school is shut. I've also been asked if I can help with a summer school activity. Again, it's extra pay and there's no forcing but, as everyone works as a team, it's sometimes hard to say no...after all it may be you needing the help next time and it takes some front to ask for it if you've never been prepared to roll up your sleeves.

You also have to balance the potential time off in the holidays against the fact that it's not easy to get time off during term time. My manager is very good but I get school holidays off so she needs to see me at some point. It's what I'm paid for and school jobs are like gold dust!

In addition we have to come in for INSET days. Again, it's non negotiable. It's part of the contract and you have to work them. Of course if you're then working and your child's school has an INSET day you have to make your own arrangements - you work in term time and that's it.

Also, don't forget that like most other jobs, admin in a school don't start and stop when the school is open to the kids. My hours are 8am to 4.15pm. Better than some but I still need to leave the house before DS and I get home after him.

So school jobs look cushy and, in some respects they are. But most school jobs aren't 9am to 3pm - far from it.

And, of course, OP you can ask employers for term time work. But you do have to understand that others needs have to be balanced too. For example, our DS has a heart condition, he has a friend who has a brain tumour and another who has severe autism. Who gets first bite of the cherry during the holidays if we all worked together. Because, as a parent, I also want to spend time with my child, whether he had a heart condition or not.

unknownorigins · 26/04/2022 19:36

I know you said not working with children by the way, but these jobs are only a few hours a day, even agency work you can just do mornings or afternoons, as little or often as you like.

unknownorigins · 26/04/2022 19:35

Haven't read the whole thread sorry so not sure if you are suitably qualified but there are agencies who arrange cover in schools and you can block out whenever you aren't available to work. A range of roles from TA to cover supervisor.
Cleaner or dinner lady in a school would also work.
After school or breakfast club term time only would be a few hours a day.

lottiegarbanzo · 26/04/2022 19:26

You need to find jobs to apply for that match your needs / what you can offer.

What you cannot do is apply for FT roles with five weeks holiday and 'demand' 13 weeks holiday.

Those employers won't have an opinion on your childcare needs or priorities, they will simply discard your application.

So there thoughts are quite irrelevant, unless you have very specialist skills, so are operating in a seller's market:

Especially if any of the interview panel are blokes who never even think about childcare (and it’s common, let’s face it) and just think I’m either coddling her, or a spoilt princess that wants holidays off.

How can I phrase it so that my boundaries are clear, but not sound entitled?

Job-hunting is a bit like dating - but based on skills, attitude, availability etc. It's about matching the right person with the right job. You don't look for an unsuitable person then demand that they change / accept their demands that you change. You find someone suitable first, then work through the details.

YANBU to think you can find something suitable, if you assess yourself realistically and search diligently. But YABU to imagine you don't need to do the work of assessing, searching and testing how good your perceived 'matches' are by applying, listening to feedback and honing your search and applications accordingly.

Voerendaal · 26/04/2022 19:15

I totally sympathise OP. I am in same situation, widowed with a daughter in year 8 who is struggling with bereavement and turning into a teenager. I have no parents and family live over an hour away. I have to be self sufficient as there is no one to help. And to be frank unless you are in that position you can’t understand how hard it is. I had to leave my substantive job as a nurse because I couldn’t do the shifts etc. However I am able to do bank work and I don’t work school holidays. I won’t say I am lucky because I am not but I am fortunate that I can do this. But the work is not guaranteed and shifts can be cancelled at short notice which is hard. It is of course a 0 hours contract.
I do think you will struggle to get a job that is term time - your best bet is locum/ agency depending on your skill set. But I am also pretty sure that in a few years your daughter will be more independent and you will be able to be more flexible. Could you use the next few years to study/ retrain??

tootiredtoocare · 26/04/2022 19:11

School admin staff - you don't have to face the kids if you don't want to, when it gets too much hide away in the office. They don't come up very often but as you seem to be able to afford to wait, just keep an eye out for them.

middleeasternpromise · 26/04/2022 19:11

Term time only jobs are a definite thing - but you should look on govt websites/local authorities/councils etc as they are familiar with this term. If you are flexible about what you are willing to do there will be opportunities. They may not be the best paid and you may be competing with others who for also good reasons, cannot commit to working a whole year (many many families cannot afford child care even with subsidies so compete for term time only posts). I think the focus should be I can only work term time but when I am here I can be very dedicated.

I am sorry you and your daughter have been through bereavement, it really is a painful experience. Good luck with your search.

Morph22010 · 26/04/2022 19:09

Copperpottle · 26/04/2022 18:51

I mean, I was gonna recommend some super flexible roles in tech, but even they don't let you just take all the school holidays. You'd need something in a school, or you'd need to freelance and be so highly skilled and in-demand that you could just clock off and tell your clients you're off for weeks.

Holiday day camps don't hurt, even for the most sensitive kids.

But not all holiday day camps can cope with all children especially if they have additional needs.

PukkaP · 26/04/2022 19:06

I'm civil service and loads of people work term time only

Bunnycat101 · 26/04/2022 19:02

The other thing you could consider is applying for unpaid parental leave. You cld get up to 4 weeks max a year (total max over lifetime of the child is 18 weeks) and in addition to annual leave, it might be enough to ride the worst of it for a few years. I suspect applying for the parental leave would be easier to manage than negotiating a term time contract.

godmum56 · 26/04/2022 18:58

AryaStarkWolf · 26/04/2022 15:23

Interesting

There can be reasons. When my husband died I had a very wobbley few months until his private pension and other income kicked in.

Copperpottle · 26/04/2022 18:51

I mean, I was gonna recommend some super flexible roles in tech, but even they don't let you just take all the school holidays. You'd need something in a school, or you'd need to freelance and be so highly skilled and in-demand that you could just clock off and tell your clients you're off for weeks.

Holiday day camps don't hurt, even for the most sensitive kids.

youlightupmyday · 26/04/2022 18:47

Temping would be ideal

godmum56 · 26/04/2022 18:46

Shgytfgtf111 · 26/04/2022 18:11

And Op you have come equipped across as very entitled because lots of parents are in a similar position to you in terms of childcare, through bereavement, divorce with no other family around or a multitude of other things. Unfortunately unless term time is advertised as part of the job you have no more of a right to spend the holidays with your child than others do with theirs. I'm sorry if that's really harsh.

And every single one of them can raise it at interview. Honestly too much crab bucket on this thread

godmum56 · 26/04/2022 18:44

BoredZelda · 26/04/2022 18:34

However your attitude would worry me, to be honest - I'd be looking for someone open and willing to talk about possibilities and strategies, not someone who's going to say on the one hand "I've heard there are people who work all the time, but I just can't imagine it" and on the other hand "well obviously it's not worth trying". And I would be put off by someone who demanded rather than started a conversation, it doesn't bode well for their relationship management skills

I disagree. OP knows it won’t work for her and has a boundary to set. Any employer who is going to start making silly assumptions about her “relationship management skills”

I needed flexible working long before it became more common. At every job interview I said I needed to be able to work from home a day or two a week. I had my reasons and it was non negotiable. I wasn’t about to “have a conversation” with someone who didn’t walk in my shoes and have them tell me I could manage if I only tried. I told them what they would get if they hired me was a dedicated, hard working, highly experienced member of staff and what I needed in return was flexibility. They had a choice to hire me or not, I was offered every job I interviewed for. My employer is very happy with the situation and my ability to manage relationships is just fine.

This absolutely

LouLou198 · 26/04/2022 18:42

Dinner lady in a school? Most work 10-2 term time only.

BoredZelda · 26/04/2022 18:38

Unfortunately unless term time is advertised as part of the job you have no more of a right to spend the holidays with your child than others do with theirs. I'm sorry if that's really harsh.

OP has every right to negotiate her working terms at interview with her employer. Everyone else can do the same if they wish. There are people in my office who are paid less than me for doing the same job. For all I know, they might be struggling financially, that’s not my fault. I negotiated my salary and they can do the same.

WonderingWanda · 26/04/2022 18:38

I doubt demanding will get you any where but you are entitled to ask. Unfortunatly it won't get you anywhere as I'd imagine there are numerous staff in every organisation who would like to do the same. No employer is going to set the precedent that employees can chose this as an option....they'd have no staff left. School holiday childcare is so hard for families and it's the main reason I chose teaching.

There are other jobs in schools such as admin that don't involve as much co tact with students. What's your career history? Do you have any particular expertise?

Walkingthedog46 · 26/04/2022 18:36

What about temping? We had a temp who only worked term-time as her husband worked abroad and her son was at boarding school, so she needed to be at home during the long school holidays. She said it worked well as she could pick and choose when she was available for work.

alltheteeshirts · 26/04/2022 18:36

Honestly, I think the answer is temping, i.e. a normal job, but on a very short fixed-term contract. If you're good at what you do, you can keep getting sent to back-to-back jobs as long as you're available. There's more security in it than people think - I've met contractors who do this as a lifestyle to suit them and would never accept a permanent full-time gig. It sounds like it would be ideal for your circumstances.

BoredZelda · 26/04/2022 18:36

**Any employer who is going to start making silly assumptions about her “relationship management skills” is one she doesn’t want to work with.

Shgytfgtf111 · 26/04/2022 18:35

BungleandGeorge · 26/04/2022 18:22

Lots of parents aren’t dealing with a traumatised child with mental health problems caused by losing a parent. It’s really not the same as just requiring childcare. I imagine it’s very difficult. There’s no harm in asking for any job that you fancy but it would probably be better to contact them before interview so you aren’t wasting each other’s time. I’m not sure how many takers you’ll get but who knows it might suit some employers

No but she doesn't know what any of her colleagues children's issues are and that was my point, there shouldn't be an automatic assumption that the needs of her child are greater than the needs of another when she can't possibly know. It's an assumption.

BoredZelda · 26/04/2022 18:34

However your attitude would worry me, to be honest - I'd be looking for someone open and willing to talk about possibilities and strategies, not someone who's going to say on the one hand "I've heard there are people who work all the time, but I just can't imagine it" and on the other hand "well obviously it's not worth trying". And I would be put off by someone who demanded rather than started a conversation, it doesn't bode well for their relationship management skills

I disagree. OP knows it won’t work for her and has a boundary to set. Any employer who is going to start making silly assumptions about her “relationship management skills”

I needed flexible working long before it became more common. At every job interview I said I needed to be able to work from home a day or two a week. I had my reasons and it was non negotiable. I wasn’t about to “have a conversation” with someone who didn’t walk in my shoes and have them tell me I could manage if I only tried. I told them what they would get if they hired me was a dedicated, hard working, highly experienced member of staff and what I needed in return was flexibility. They had a choice to hire me or not, I was offered every job I interviewed for. My employer is very happy with the situation and my ability to manage relationships is just fine.

Swipe left for the next trending thread