Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be gobsmacked about my salary increase

187 replies

Clementinemist · 25/04/2022 21:14

I started a new job a month ago, which came with a £15k payrise. 'Lucky me!' I thought when I was offered the role. It should have meant a bit more more disposable income. But in reality my disposable income has now actually decreased by £150 a month, mostly due to recent rent and bill increases.

Just wow.

I'm well qualified and experienced in my profession, and worked really hard for this role. It's quite senior too with more responsibility than my last job. Yes, I'd have been even worse off financially if I was still in my old job, but still a kick in the teeth. The concept of career and life progression now seems to be dead?

OP posts:
diamondsf · 26/04/2022 17:10

either way - I am concerned that the Op seems utterly financially ignorant despite being “professional”.

🤔

tomatoandherbs · 26/04/2022 17:08

Everyone assuming op very well paid

she could have been on £15k and then made a jump to £30k

either way - I am concerned that the Op seems utterly financially ignorant despite being “professional”.

who accepts a job without working out additional expenditure, tax etc against any increase in salary and is then “gov smacked”

Lockheart · 26/04/2022 16:59

I think you need to ignore a lot of the replies OP. Yes, you're very lucky to get such a good pay rise, but you're also not unreasonable to be disappointed that cost of living increases mean overall you're still worse off despite that.

As I said upthread, if the world made any sense a payrise of that magnitude should mean you have more discretionary spending power, not less.

It's a damning indictment of how messed up things are that such a big payrise still doesn't actually improve your life and it's scary what that means for people in the UK, most of whom won't be getting any pay rises!

diamondsf · 26/04/2022 16:49

Should I have gone down the mines at 12?

Basically yes according to some.

diamondsf · 26/04/2022 16:47

Do a quick google of PAYE tax calculator and you will see that you cannot have an increase in wages and take home less money.

The same thing has happened to me as it's taken me into the higher tax band & higher pension contribution.

Clementinemist · 26/04/2022 16:47

Eggshelly · 26/04/2022 09:17

That's your fault for going to uni not your employers.

There's a slight misunderstanding from a lot of people here.
I'm not angry about my salary. I'm just disappointed that a payrise is now worthless in the current cost of living situation.

And if I didn't go to uni haha. Should I have gone down the mines at 12? I work for the NHS, and last time I checked a solid majority of medical jobs require a degree.

OP posts:
beastiev · 26/04/2022 16:39

@Ohwellnevermindthen the pandemic has heaped on the woes but this was all coming regardless. Look at our productivity

GhostofMaudFlanders · 26/04/2022 16:35

Unfortunately you are not going to get much sympathy here, as people are struggling on £15k full stop, never mind a £15k pay rise.

If what you are you saying is true, then your predicament isn't really something many on here can relate to . I'm assuming you earn £50k + and this increase has propelled you into the highest tax bracket , and that you have a big house so the utilities bill increase affects you more.

I appreciate that the intention of your thread is to wonder how others will manage if this has happened to you

Sushi7 · 26/04/2022 16:23

@Clementinemist what did you earn (after tax) each month in your previous job vs new job?

oshywatt · 26/04/2022 16:04

check your tax code !!

MigsandTiggs · 26/04/2022 15:44

The concept of career and life progression now seems to be dead?

More stalled, I would say because of a perfect storm consisting of the effects of the pandemic on education and businesses, slow global economic growth, rising inflation, and now the war in Ukraine. Stagflation, here we come!

Ohwellnevermindthen · 26/04/2022 15:36

Thedogshouses · 26/04/2022 14:17

I've reduced the rent on my flats to reflect t the rising costs. I may own a few properties as investments but I don't want to profit from other people becoming poorer.

That's very kind of you. Not many landlords would do that. Mine is using inflation as an excuse to charge us more.

MigsandTiggs · 26/04/2022 15:32

Steamedhams · 26/04/2022 09:13

Honestly, I would be tempted to opt out of the pension, depending on how old you are. My husband and I are late 20s and have stopped these. We plan to use any extra money to invest ourselves in property/green energy etc. Very risky but we think by the time we reach retirement age that a) we will be about 85 and b) the bubble will burst and they won't be worth anything. Instead, we bought our own home and are planning on making improvements to it to up the value and looking at our own retirement plans as there have been plenty of pension scandals in the past. I have older friends who have lost a huge amount of money on pension pots.

And, in case it wasn't obvious, I am in no way a reputable source of financial advice!

Don't worry, it was very obvious. Did your older friends lose money because of bad advice or because of they chose their own investments? Pension scandals tend to be of the owner helping themselves, Maxwell variety rather than insert pension provider goes bust. Pension contributions are made from untaxed income so you're missing out on that, plus when you start in your 20's, you have decades to accrue capital growth and dividends. You'll be missing out on the employer contribution too. Limiting investment to only two sectors - property and green energy is also a mistake as you need to balance risk with a diversified portfolio. I became interested in stocks and shares when I did A Level Economics and actually started investing on my own when I was in my 20's.
My DS and DiL went down the "property as pension" route. Tenants had a faulty dryer that caught fire and destroyed half the house. Insurance refused to pay out because the occupants weren't "professionals" even though it was let to a company promising to house their professional employee.
Me? I now use a firm of independent financial advisors/analysts and I'm satisfied with the returns, plus everything's now wrapped so that my DC can inherit it tax free.

ancientgran · 26/04/2022 15:28

Have you checked you tax code? Changing jobs can mean a mix up in tax code. Would be worth looking at.

BridesmaidPanic · 26/04/2022 15:17

In terms of numbers, ignoring any additional pension contributions and student loans that get taken from the increase in salary, I've used a payslip checker to see how much extra £15,000 would generate in net income based on a £15k increase at various starting income levels:

  • £0 to £15,000 gives net income of £1,154, so an increase of £1,154
  • £10,000 to £25,000 = £833.33 to £1,720.83 net, £887.50 increase
  • £25,000 to £40,000 = £1,720.83 to £2,570.83 net, £850.00 increase
  • £40,000 to £55,000 = £2,570.83 to £3,380.35 net, £809.52 increase
  • £55,000 to £70,000 = £3,380.35 to £4,105.35 net, £725 increase.
The lowest increase in net pay a £15,000 payrise creates is £725 per month, and it's only that low if you're already a 40% tax payer.

OP, if your costs (including student loans and pensions as well as fuel and rent, etc) haven't gone up by at least £725 it's worth checking that your tax code is correct.

If your new job is with a new employer, it's feasible that HMRC haven't got your tax code right and they've taken too much tax from your new payslip.

Justkidding55 · 26/04/2022 15:07

Humblebrag

Whelmed · 26/04/2022 14:53

I'm looking at a promotion opportunity at work, moving from part time to full time and a level up on the pay scale. On paper I'll be getting so much more money every month. In practice I'll be slightly worse off than I'm atm..... I have a few months to decide if it is worth it. It'll take roughly 2-3 years for it to even up.

GivenchyDahhling · 26/04/2022 14:46

I'm guessing it's a sliding scale of pension contributions, as is the case of teaching. So, in teaching, a £35k salary has an 8.6% pension contribution, a £50k salary has a 10.2% contribution. Adding in Plan 1 student loans, that means the take home difference is approx £530 a month. From that, take away an energy bill increase of £200 a month and a rent increase of £100 a month, it's quite easy to see how a £15k salary increase results in a comparatively tiny increase in take home income.

That said, I definitely would NOT support opting out of a public sector pension (or any pension really, but especially not a public sector one). Bonkers.

Figgygal · 26/04/2022 14:30

Even after tax how can that be possible?

Thedogshouses · 26/04/2022 14:17

I've reduced the rent on my flats to reflect t the rising costs. I may own a few properties as investments but I don't want to profit from other people becoming poorer.

LilyRose333 · 26/04/2022 14:14

Find some cheaper accomodation. Yes, this often means living in 'undesirable' areas, but that is one of your options. Also, me and my husband shopped around for our utility suppliers. There are some good deals out there if you look for them. Sadly the reality of life is that huge numbers of us work our butts off all our lives with very little to show for it in the end. It's wrong. It's unfair. It sucks.......but it's life.

tomatoandherbs · 26/04/2022 14:03

I'm well qualified and experienced in my profession, and worked really hard for this role.

and yet it would seem did squat all financial planning as to what your take home would actually be with increases in cost and you’re “gob smacked” 😮

Starseeking · 26/04/2022 12:15

Clementinemist · 26/04/2022 08:56

I'm not entirely sure how people have worked out that my take home pay would be £1000 more a month with my increase because that is definitely not the case! Plus I have 9% minimum pension contributions and student loan repayments. And yes, having a pension is good, but doesn't help me put food on the table now. I also suspect most younger people now are not going to benefit from pensions in the same way as pensioners today anyway.

I assumed your net of roughly £840 per month on a £15k annual increase based on being a higher rate tax payer.

There was no further information given in any of your previous posts given about pension deductions or student loan deductions until now, so it's unsurprising that no assumptions would be made about these by PP.

Adding your worse off by £150 a month comment to the £840 above gives approximately £1,000 total not available per month.

If your additional pension and student loan deductions come to £500 per month, it's still pretty steep for your bills to have gone up by £500, though it's possible.

It's good that you have had such a big pay rise meaning you can still manage paying the increases though, and it's not unreasonable to have expected extra money to have been available in your pocket!

It does sound like your pension contributions are quite high, so maybe have a look at reducing those by a couple of per cent for a few months to help manage rising costs.

Ohwellnevermindthen · 26/04/2022 12:05

beastiev · 26/04/2022 07:02

This is a shit time economically for a lot of people in the UK.

It's really been a shit time economically since the financial crisis. Then we had austerity, Brexit, covid & now cost of living. I do think for young people things are going backwards.

They didn't really learn from the financial crisis of 2008, they carried on doing the same shit but in a different way probably, and this is what we have ended up with. Same old corrupt and immoral ways of operating produce the same results.

I know people talk about the pandemic, but I would ask why the economy was in a shit state prior to that with a bigger deficit than before austerity measures were implemented in 2010, and why we weren't financially prepared for a pandemic in the first place when they are something that is deemed fairly inevitable when you look back through history.

LoveSpringDaffs · 26/04/2022 12:05

Gettingthereslowly2020 · 25/04/2022 21:35

I think trying to pick apart OPs finances is missing the point of the thread. I'll assume OP is being truthful and has accurately worked out that she's £150 pm worse off.

Whether she's wealthier than us or not is irrelevant. Like pp have said, it's not a race to the bottom.

No one should work their backside off to get a promotion which involves increased responsibility and end up worse off financially. It's not right and it's not fair.

Your logic is as daft as hers!!

That's really shit, I'm sorry this has happened to you. The cost of living increases are completely out of control

You're sorry she's got a £15k pay Rise

be serious.