Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it just gets harder for first time buyers?

143 replies

chatterbug22 · 25/04/2022 19:54

We rent a new build 2 bed and are lucky to do so cheaply, we have landed on our feet with it really as properties on this government scheme are cheap and we have two very decent sized rooms with a nice big secure garden.

The goal is to buy in the next 18 months, and we are lucky enough to be able to save quite well. We have good jobs, both on the average salary for people in the UK and we’re not yet even mid 20s. We are up north. The help to buy scheme in our area is capped at £228,100. A year ago you would get a 3 bed semi for that. 6 months ago you’d probably get a 2 bed for it. I have just browsed today out of curiosity and there is absolutely NOTHING that falls under the scheme, apart from a 2 bed terraced smaller than our current house in a not very nice area?!

How is anyone supposed to do this? Demand seems crazy at the moment. Are we best to compete with it all or just stay out until it crashes (which I’m guessing it inevitably will).
I don’t want to needlessly be paying rent that we will never see again but nor do I want us in a situation where we are priced out of our depth.

Boggles my brain!

OP posts:
DashboardConfessional · 25/04/2022 22:27

horsemadgal · 25/04/2022 21:42

Are you meaning the Right to Buy ISA? As you can transfer to a Lifetime ISA and then can buy up to £450K. Apologies if it's something else.

This is what the OP is referring to. Maximum full price of a new build on which the government will provide a 20% equity loan.

To think it just gets harder for first time buyers?
Blossomtoes · 25/04/2022 22:02

Overthebow · 25/04/2022 20:13

Our first house 5 years 7 years ago was the small two bed. You go for what you can afford then work up the ladder. Most first time buyers, even 20 years ago, don't start off with a three bed house.

This. My first house, bought in 1991, was a two bed terrace. It is tough for FTBs but expecting your first home to be a three bed in a nice area has never been realistic.

beastiev · 25/04/2022 21:58

@ComtesseDeSpair because it is outdated. I'm sure you are aware that most FTBs are older today which is one of the main reasons. And that we have had a long period of low interest rates & low inflation. Plus the change in starter prices vs earnings.

Catlady2021 · 25/04/2022 21:46

The bottoms line is house prices are rising too much.
I know of houses in 2000 you could buy a 3 bed semi in suburbs for £70k.
The same houses now are now £650k…

horsemadgal · 25/04/2022 21:42

Are you meaning the Right to Buy ISA? As you can transfer to a Lifetime ISA and then can buy up to £450K. Apologies if it's something else.

ComtesseDeSpair · 25/04/2022 21:41

TammyOne · 25/04/2022 20:52

Yeah this idea that you buy a starter home is really outdated. Most people I know didn’t buy til 30s or40s and had kids already. Moving is ££££. It’s also not always the case that people always bought worse than they could rent. My parents first house was a large 3 bed with a big garden when they were about 24. In your situation OP, since you’re young, I would probably try for an older house that needs lots of work, and definitely not a shared ownership. It is shit though. Basically it benefits the banks, and people who already have expensive houses, but it’s awful for everyone else.

Why is it outdated? I’m only 35 and it’s exactly what I did. Bought a one bedroom flat in a relatively run down area at 24; a two bedroom flat in a somewhat nicer area at 29; and a two bedroom house with a garden in an area I’ll happily stay for the foreseeable at 34. All in London, and taking a step up as my salary increased.

We can’t hark back to one very short and specific period between about 1970-1985 where particular cultural and socioeconomic conditions meant that housing was relatively affordable and use that as the baseline by which we measure things. Before then, the majority of people were lifelong renters. Since then, our population has changed, our demographics have changed, our way of living has changed, our expectations have changed. And I doubt most people would really want to reset all of that surrounding context back to 1975, even if it meant they could afford a bigger house.

chatterbug22 · 25/04/2022 21:39

@DashboardConfessional yep!!

OP posts:
DashboardConfessional · 25/04/2022 21:24

chatterbug22 · 25/04/2022 21:04

@DashboardConfessional I understand, and there’s the added worry of if the boiler packs in you’re responsible to pay for it. I don’t know, I wish there was a blanket solution! Making decisions is the hardest part of adulting!

It's all the things you don't really plan for that cost. For example, oven broke. Fine. Order new £400 oven. Oven trips the electrics. Electrician comes out, realises the wiring is an 80s bodge job. New fuse box required, plus electrician's time. And so on!

chatterbug22 · 25/04/2022 21:04

@DashboardConfessional I understand, and there’s the added worry of if the boiler packs in you’re responsible to pay for it. I don’t know, I wish there was a blanket solution! Making decisions is the hardest part of adulting!

OP posts:
tiledo · 25/04/2022 21:03

obviously it depends on your budget but stamp duty makes it's very expensive & the next place we buy we would like to stay at least 10 years.

DashboardConfessional · 25/04/2022 21:02

One thing though - the "we can afford x rent so we can afford x mortgage payments" argument is only valid with mortgages at current rates. Lenders will look at whether you could afford those payments if rates went from 2% to 5% to 7%. Which they might.

chatterbug22 · 25/04/2022 21:02

@TammyOne exactly. I find moving stressful (know everyone else does too) but I want to minimise the amount of times I do it. We are by no means rushing to have children but it’s a possibility in the next few years as with a lot of people at our age and stage, I don’t want to constantly be moving about and the idea of settling somewhere with space is nice!! Also don’t want to uproot the poor cat!!

OP posts:
chatterbug22 · 25/04/2022 21:00

@Favourodds thank you. I think we are it’s just so hard not to look at others and compare, but I need to learn not to otherwise I will never be happy

OP posts:
chatterbug22 · 25/04/2022 20:59

@GrumpyPanda interesting perspective. My other half actually lived abroad for some time growing up and said buying is extremely uncommon there, most rent. Weird how it varies so vastly. This is reassuring though so thank you

OP posts:
DashboardConfessional · 25/04/2022 20:59

It is very hard. We bought with a 5% deposit and a 35 year mortgage in 2008, just before the crash. Thing is, we did it in spite of knowing house prices were "high" and there was likely to be a crash. There was, of course, but that house is now selling to my friend's daughter for £200k when we both bought it and sold it for £123k. I don't really know how long I'd advise someone to wait out the market.

burgundy049 · 25/04/2022 20:56

Yes.
We have a 20% deposit, but are buggered by how much we can borrow cause of our income. (despite saving that 20% desposit while renting a similar £ per month as to what our mortgage would be).

We'd been looking for about 18 months, but had to pause on various points due to life being squiffy.

now looking again and what's in our budget seem to be barely anything.

Also - as you take longer to save we need more space due to WFH, and growing family), which means we migth need more deposit, or more income - but by then prices will have gone up again.
It just feels like a hopeless vicious circule.

TammyOne · 25/04/2022 20:52

Yeah this idea that you buy a starter home is really outdated. Most people I know didn’t buy til 30s or40s and had kids already. Moving is ££££. It’s also not always the case that people always bought worse than they could rent. My parents first house was a large 3 bed with a big garden when they were about 24. In your situation OP, since you’re young, I would probably try for an older house that needs lots of work, and definitely not a shared ownership. It is shit though. Basically it benefits the banks, and people who already have expensive houses, but it’s awful for everyone else.

Favourodds · 25/04/2022 20:51

You sound quite well placed to be honest.

Took me until my mid-30s and a couple of dead great aunts to buy!

tiledo · 25/04/2022 20:50

I doubt that I will be able to have a child despite us earning well above average. We don't have any deposit help available.

It's not a good thing that people can't even afford dc anymore. And so much of your life choices depend on family help as to earnings.

tiledo · 25/04/2022 20:47

If people are serious about buying then compromises might have to be made

Even people with 1m plus budgets have no choice but to compromise!

GrumpyPanda · 25/04/2022 20:47

Non-Brit here for a different perspective. Given that you're in a place you like, cheap rent and from what it sounds like a secure long-term tenancy I don't see the need to rush. It's good to saving and wanting to invest but investing in property really isn't the only way to do it. Do a couple of sessions with a good financial advisor and depending on your medium-term plans (relocations? Kids? time frame?) consider investing in a mixture of broad global index funds and shorter-term assets. The financial advisor can run comparison scenarios for you on both options. I'm based in Germany atm and the business pages run articles all the time on "when/how many years for buying to be more beneficial than renting". Many many people don't buy until well into their 30s or later and many remain renters forever even if they could afford to buy. You're still quite young, and if you've saved and grown your savings by investing there's no reason why you wouldn't be just as well placed several years from now.

tiledo · 25/04/2022 20:46

@Tiredalwaystired exactly. We are trying to buy our next property but when prices increase by 20% or whatever that's a huge whack on what you are trying to buy.

Overthebow · 25/04/2022 20:45

tiledo · 25/04/2022 20:34

@Octomore yes but I was explaining why the concept of the ladder is outdated.
For many it makes sense to future proof what they buy rather than have lots of moves. Plus ever rising prices make it harder to move up the ladder, that's why so many buyers are stuck on it.

Makes sense to them but realistically it’s buy what you can afford. If people are serious about buying then compromises might have to be made. Otherwise people are free to rent the three bed house if they aren’t willing to compromise.

ReadyToMoveIt · 25/04/2022 20:43

spuddy56 · 25/04/2022 20:41

Any I know are trying to buy a first family home by the age of 35, not 25. Potentially too late to have families anyway.

I doubt that I will be able to have a child despite us earning well above average. We don't have any deposit help available.

We bought our first house at 34 and 35… took us that long to save a deposit. Downsized from our rental. We already had 2 children by the time we bought.

Camomila · 25/04/2022 20:43

I think we were guilty of having overly optimistic expectations when we first started looking...now we'll be happy with another 2 bedroom flat a similar size to the one we are renting but with no mould!

We probably should have bought before having the DC but my DM had breast cancer young so I took all those "have DC before you are 35" warnings to heart.

Swipe left for the next trending thread