Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it just gets harder for first time buyers?

143 replies

chatterbug22 · 25/04/2022 19:54

We rent a new build 2 bed and are lucky to do so cheaply, we have landed on our feet with it really as properties on this government scheme are cheap and we have two very decent sized rooms with a nice big secure garden.

The goal is to buy in the next 18 months, and we are lucky enough to be able to save quite well. We have good jobs, both on the average salary for people in the UK and we’re not yet even mid 20s. We are up north. The help to buy scheme in our area is capped at £228,100. A year ago you would get a 3 bed semi for that. 6 months ago you’d probably get a 2 bed for it. I have just browsed today out of curiosity and there is absolutely NOTHING that falls under the scheme, apart from a 2 bed terraced smaller than our current house in a not very nice area?!

How is anyone supposed to do this? Demand seems crazy at the moment. Are we best to compete with it all or just stay out until it crashes (which I’m guessing it inevitably will).
I don’t want to needlessly be paying rent that we will never see again but nor do I want us in a situation where we are priced out of our depth.

Boggles my brain!

OP posts:
XjustagirlX · 26/04/2022 08:43

shivawn · 26/04/2022 08:19

I did the whole starter home thing and would recommend avoiding it if you can. I agree with previous posters that its an outdated concept. Buy the best home you can afford and that you can see yourself staying in if moving isn't possible in the future.

I have friends raising families in tiny appartments because it's impossible for them to move up the ladder now. I bought a 3 bed older home that we luckily have been able to extend and improve on but I still wish we'd stretched for our preferred house type back when we bought. My house value has increased by over 100k since we bought but that's no good to us when the houses we want have increased by 250k+.

I agree with this - buy the best thing you can afford now do you can if needed stay there longer.

@shivawn if your current property has increased by £100k surely you can use that as a deposit on your next house which has increased by £250k? I think the moving to the next ladder works deposit wise but probably not earnings/repayments.

eg near me
5 years ago 2 bed terraced £100k, now £200k
3 bed semi £200k, now £400k

do the people who bought the 2 bed now have £100 equity plus their original £10k deposit plus other capital monthly repayments say £120k equity.

this is a 25% deposit on the £400k house plus legals and sdlt.

the deposit is doable, but the limiting factor is actually wages haven’t increased.

desiringonlychild2022 · 26/04/2022 08:43

@Notreallyhappy if I didn't have internet, we would both be unemployed! Hybrid working lol. Ditto for my £135 Xiaomi smartphone, I need it to login to work as the system sends a verification to my phone! My first property bought 3 years ago is a 2 bed flat in London and I can tell you the 60k deposit was not saved by scrimping on meals out!

Actually we saved it by living at home and not paying London rent! We are saving to move onto the next flat and paying an extra £1k in mortgage overpayments to facilitate that but at a certain point, it's about earnings/inheritance more than scrimping! It is the case in London and increasingly the SE, this would soon be the case all over the UK. The prices might not increase but inflation would mean that it is harder to save so the only solution is to earn more.

Notreallyhappy · 26/04/2022 08:36

Overthebow · 25/04/2022 20:13
Our first house 5 years 7 years ago was the small two bed. You go for what you can afford then work up the ladder. Most first time buyers, even 20 years ago, don't start off with a three bed house.

Exactly this..my first house was a 2 up 2 down...£240 mortgage per month on a £860/month wage. It cost £20 per week for coal for the boiler.
We weren't any better off then.
We didn't have to have sky or netflix, Internet, iphones a car, meals out and holidays..

desiringonlychild2022 · 26/04/2022 08:34

Just a thought- someone who isn't even mid 20s is unlikely to know what she wants from her 'forever home'. How many DC, how many bedrooms, catchment areas for schools? those may be premature questions. I had no idea when I bought at 27, all I thought I needed was 2 bedrooms (1 for only child DC and in a good school catchment). post covid, I think I need a home office and a larger kitchen... maybe you get a clearer idea when you are in your 30s, I will report back when I am in my 30s.

She is likely to want to move anyway and given her salary is likely to increase, she would probably be in a better position to get a larger mortgage. In fact even if she was in a good position to buy the 3 bed, I think it highly unlikely she would stay in it for the rest of her life.

yellowsuninthesky · 26/04/2022 08:31

When DH and I bought, we each bought a flat. When we met each other and got married, we then sold them to buy a small three bedroom house (actually two plus boxroom). We then sold that to buy a larger three bedroom house and haven't moved since.

I agree compromises have to be made. There are lots of houses out there, but possibly not where you want them. Then you have to decide if location or size of house is more important. Or whether you want to be near good schools or a railway station for commuting etc.

I also think it's better to buy an older house, even with maintenance. New builds are often leasehold or have service charges for unadopted roads etc.

Sunshineandrainbow · 26/04/2022 08:29

chatterbug22 · 25/04/2022 19:54

We rent a new build 2 bed and are lucky to do so cheaply, we have landed on our feet with it really as properties on this government scheme are cheap and we have two very decent sized rooms with a nice big secure garden.

The goal is to buy in the next 18 months, and we are lucky enough to be able to save quite well. We have good jobs, both on the average salary for people in the UK and we’re not yet even mid 20s. We are up north. The help to buy scheme in our area is capped at £228,100. A year ago you would get a 3 bed semi for that. 6 months ago you’d probably get a 2 bed for it. I have just browsed today out of curiosity and there is absolutely NOTHING that falls under the scheme, apart from a 2 bed terraced smaller than our current house in a not very nice area?!

How is anyone supposed to do this? Demand seems crazy at the moment. Are we best to compete with it all or just stay out until it crashes (which I’m guessing it inevitably will).
I don’t want to needlessly be paying rent that we will never see again but nor do I want us in a situation where we are priced out of our depth.

Boggles my brain!

Please can you tell me what the government rental scheme is.

ReadyToMoveIt · 26/04/2022 08:28

shivawn · 26/04/2022 08:19

I did the whole starter home thing and would recommend avoiding it if you can. I agree with previous posters that its an outdated concept. Buy the best home you can afford and that you can see yourself staying in if moving isn't possible in the future.

I have friends raising families in tiny appartments because it's impossible for them to move up the ladder now. I bought a 3 bed older home that we luckily have been able to extend and improve on but I still wish we'd stretched for our preferred house type back when we bought. My house value has increased by over 100k since we bought but that's no good to us when the houses we want have increased by 250k+.

The fact is though that for many now, a ‘starter home’ is the best thing they can afford. And waiting until you can afford better means pricing yourself out of the market.

Foolsrule · 26/04/2022 08:27

The help to buy caps are ridiculous. They’re around £400K where we are but houses on new estates are into the £500-£600K bracket, so people are excluded from the get-go.

desiringonlychild2022 · 26/04/2022 08:23

@InvincibleInvisibility

I started out with a 2 bed flat in London, now saving to upgrade to a big 3 bed flat like you...interestingly when my MIL was looking to upgrade from her 1 bed flat in London in 1997 she looked at big flats too but found they were too expensive, and the 100 sq metre run down Victorian terrace was more economical (she still lives there). It's weird but even though houses have gone up in value more than flats, I find that big flats still aren't much cheaper than the smaller terraces but overall are better value as they have more internal space...

shivawn · 26/04/2022 08:19

I did the whole starter home thing and would recommend avoiding it if you can. I agree with previous posters that its an outdated concept. Buy the best home you can afford and that you can see yourself staying in if moving isn't possible in the future.

I have friends raising families in tiny appartments because it's impossible for them to move up the ladder now. I bought a 3 bed older home that we luckily have been able to extend and improve on but I still wish we'd stretched for our preferred house type back when we bought. My house value has increased by over 100k since we bought but that's no good to us when the houses we want have increased by 250k+.

Aprilx · 26/04/2022 08:13

So you are in your 20s both working in good jobs so presumably on a decent trajectory, but you are seemingly are only considering buying with a government scheme and want a large house. Perhaps it is getting harder for first time buyers because expectations are so high these days.

desiringonlychild2022 · 26/04/2022 08:12

Echoing what PP said about FTB buying smaller properties. This is in London but London was a lot cheaper then.

My MIL bought her 1 bed flat in London in 1989 at age 27 with her ex (in his 30s). Had 3 kids in the flat before moving onto 3 bed terraced house in same area in 1997. DH and I bought our 2 bed flat in 2019 also in Zone 3 London at age 27 and age 29 respectively.

I don't actually know anyone in London who would start off in a 3 bed house and I doubt it was the case even in my MIL's time. As prices rise outside London, this may be the case as well. In London, even the people who bought 2 bed houses tend to buy them in not so nice areas.

beastiev · 26/04/2022 08:10

@Tiredalwaystired this is what im struggling with. Good salaries, equity, moving out of area but the next rung is getting further away. We just lost out on one we offered 20k more on.

beastiev · 26/04/2022 08:06

I was a FTB in the 80s

exactly, things have changed!

Clymene · 26/04/2022 08:04

I bought my first tiny flat in a crappy area when I was in my 30s. There was no way I could have afforded one in the area I was renting in. Or indeed anything close to the size I was renting.

You're getting onto the property ladder.

PlntLady · 26/04/2022 08:04

It's so hard atm!
We live in the north west and just moved I to our first house. We paid 230k for a 3 bed semi. The clincher though... we made massive compromises! It need completely gutting in every way, it much further out than we wanted and is on a mixed private owned and council estate.
We saved for years for deposit and fees. When we started looking we couldn't find anything and in the meantime house prices we spiraling. By Oct last year we were spending every spare evening and weekends viewing houses. We put sooo many offers in. We were really lucky to get this house as they has a lot of offers. However, we only managed to get it by going 10k over the asking price and had to up our deposit to 16%! This took every penny we saved and were literally scrabbling to save for fees as the sale was going through... but that's how most ppl start out.
It was really hard but looking back now, well worth it.
Keep at it, decided your absolute no compromise areas, through everything you have at the deposit... and just look at everything you can. Good luck. 🤞

Stoppedsmokingnowgrumpy · 26/04/2022 08:00

If you wait for the mythical crash op you will be renting for the rest of your life

MintJulia · 26/04/2022 07:43

Overthebow · 25/04/2022 20:13

Our first house 5 years 7 years ago was the small two bed. You go for what you can afford then work up the ladder. Most first time buyers, even 20 years ago, don't start off with a three bed house.

This.

I was a FTB in the 80s and then, like now, a first home had one bedroom and a box room. I don't know anyone who started with a 3 bed house.

Tiredalwaystired · 26/04/2022 07:37

All very well to increase equity but what’s the point if the next step on the ladder is increasing equity at the same percentage rate - so therefore gets even further out of reach? Plus the increasing stamp duty on top.

A benefit to my kids when we shuffle off this mortal coil but not a fat lot of good for us.

InvincibleInvisibility · 26/04/2022 07:17

We bought our first flat when we were 25 and 27. A small, one bedroom flat on the 6th floor with no lift.

The reactions of people around us were interesting:

  1. Silly buying your main home in city so young. Rent in the city and buy a holiday home
  2. How can you afford it? We can't (said by a couple earning the same as us but renting a flat over twice as big as the flat we bought and refusing to consider buying anything smaller)
  3. Great decision, wish I'd done it so young. Instead I'm looking to buy my first flat now aged 35 with 2 DC and it's so hard affording anything big enough

We stayed there 4 years then bought a bigger 2 bedroom flat (moving with a newborn was not fun but worth it).

Stayed there another 4.5 years then moved to a nice big 3 bedroom flat which we would happily stay in until we retire.

No way could have bought the 3rd flat any earlier. We needed our various promotions and the equity from the previous flats (only the 1st flat made any extra money).

I agree that moving isn't fun but its all about compromise. Even if you get "stuck" a few years in your "starter" home, you're still increasing equity every month.

Iamthewombat · 26/04/2022 00:41

You go for what you can afford then work up the ladder. Most first time buyers, even 20 years ago, don't start off with a three bed house.

Don’t you think it is odd that a couple each earning average wage, in a relatively cheap part of the U.K. (the OP is up north, I assume not Alderley Edge or Harrogate) can’t afford a three bedroomed house? I do.

It’s a sign that houses are overvalued.

I see that the posts urging the OP to live in a hovel and never have any fun, ever, so as to save more have begun. Great.

It is tough for FTBs but expecting your first home to be a three bed in a nice area has never been realistic.

Er, it has. I was able to buy a five year old three bedroomed house in 1998. I was earning average wage, and it was in a decent area, commutable to Manchester. It is much more difficult for FTBs now. I wouldn’t be ruling out a correction, by the way. Recession on the horizon, inflation plus higher interest rates.

caringcarer · 26/04/2022 00:21

My first house was a 2 bed terraced house. It needed loads of work and was damp too but we loved it. I had our firstborn there. We moved up to a 3 bed terraced in next street. Then 6 or 7 years later a 3 bed semi. Then 4 bed detached. Now in 6 bed detached. You work your way up the ladder one rung at a time and when you get a chunk of equity you can move up. That is how it works. Very few jump straight up on to second or third rung of ladder straight away without family help.

EL8888 · 26/04/2022 00:18

It’s been like that for a while. Typically people have to do usually something dramatic to get on the property ladder. For us to do it then we moved to a cheaper area and bought somewhere that needed a fair amount of work. As well as the saving money and cutting back etc

horsemadgal · 25/04/2022 23:28

DashboardConfessional · 25/04/2022 22:27

This is what the OP is referring to. Maximum full price of a new build on which the government will provide a 20% equity loan.

Thanks Dashboard, makes sense now. I'm in Scotland and I think they have stopped doing them here.

ImplementingTheDennisSystem · 25/04/2022 22:40

It's terrible, yes. BUT you're looking to buy a 3 bed as your first home. That might not be realistic. In 2010 we moved from renting a spacious 3-bed townhouse to buying our first place - a 1.5 bed flat that needed work.
We lived in it for 4 years and bought a 2-bed terraced house, then 3 years later a 4-bed detached.
Your first home doesn't have to be a 'family' home straight away - you might have to build up to that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread