Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it just gets harder for first time buyers?

143 replies

chatterbug22 · 25/04/2022 19:54

We rent a new build 2 bed and are lucky to do so cheaply, we have landed on our feet with it really as properties on this government scheme are cheap and we have two very decent sized rooms with a nice big secure garden.

The goal is to buy in the next 18 months, and we are lucky enough to be able to save quite well. We have good jobs, both on the average salary for people in the UK and we’re not yet even mid 20s. We are up north. The help to buy scheme in our area is capped at £228,100. A year ago you would get a 3 bed semi for that. 6 months ago you’d probably get a 2 bed for it. I have just browsed today out of curiosity and there is absolutely NOTHING that falls under the scheme, apart from a 2 bed terraced smaller than our current house in a not very nice area?!

How is anyone supposed to do this? Demand seems crazy at the moment. Are we best to compete with it all or just stay out until it crashes (which I’m guessing it inevitably will).
I don’t want to needlessly be paying rent that we will never see again but nor do I want us in a situation where we are priced out of our depth.

Boggles my brain!

OP posts:
SexyPortugese · 26/04/2022 14:32

tiledo · 25/04/2022 20:34

@Octomore yes but I was explaining why the concept of the ladder is outdated.
For many it makes sense to future proof what they buy rather than have lots of moves. Plus ever rising prices make it harder to move up the ladder, that's why so many buyers are stuck on it.

I have to admit I've never seen the reasoning in buying something cheap and then working up the ladder, every time you move house it costs money in moving costs and solicitor fees, not to mention uprooting and building net networks all over again. I get it if it's the only option but personally I'd rather wait and keep saving until I could get something I actually wanted to be in for the long term. We didn't buy until we were 31 but waited until we could afford a decent sized semi that in theory we'd never have to leave.

PomPomChatton · 26/04/2022 14:14

When I bought my first house all my friends were buying small, old properties that needed a lot of work. But it didn't take long for these to run out. We did find another doer-upper for our next house but it wasn't easy to find. It's harder to add value when all the major work has already been done. Whilst I had to make sacrifices, I know how lucky I was.

DashboardConfessional · 26/04/2022 13:51

desiringonlychild2022 · 26/04/2022 13:47

@DashboardConfessional thanks for sharing. interestingly my flat was £65k in 1995 (so not miles off), now a very similar flat in the same development is listed for £450k! Yes I would place this house in firmly FTB territory.

I'd say in my particular area of West Yorkshire the increase is about 4x since the mid-90s, whereas where I live now in the SW it's about 6x increase. There were basically no flats, because if you had £40k for a 2 bed terrace you got a garden.

Mamabananananana · 26/04/2022 13:51

were in the same shite boat.
saved my deposit up. Myself. No help. Private letting. Boom. Chaos
ive registered interest on a new build out of desperation, only for then to tell me the price it is now, will go up. !?
and noe my ridiculous private let is evicting me so i have no idea how that's going to affect my mortgage application over the next few months( fingers crossed. Are we the only ones praying for a crash?)

desiringonlychild2022 · 26/04/2022 13:47

@DashboardConfessional thanks for sharing. interestingly my flat was £65k in 1995 (so not miles off), now a very similar flat in the same development is listed for £450k! Yes I would place this house in firmly FTB territory.

ReadyToMoveIt · 26/04/2022 13:41

Shamoo · 26/04/2022 13:34

The whole market is insane at the moment.

We are looking to move. Called about a property that went up last week. Called the day it went on the market and they already had 26 viewings booked and weren’t allowing anymore. So you can’t even get to see places!! We are bidding on a different one and there are 12 bidders at full guide price, so they are doing best and final offers for the 12 people so it’s going to go for way over asking.

Insane.

Weirdly, where I am, nothing is moving. Houses are sitting there unsold for months.

Shamoo · 26/04/2022 13:34

The whole market is insane at the moment.

We are looking to move. Called about a property that went up last week. Called the day it went on the market and they already had 26 viewings booked and weren’t allowing anymore. So you can’t even get to see places!! We are bidding on a different one and there are 12 bidders at full guide price, so they are doing best and final offers for the 12 people so it’s going to go for way over asking.

Insane.

DashboardConfessional · 26/04/2022 13:27

desiringonlychild2022 · 26/04/2022 12:17

@Iamthewombat well of course i didn't mean all 3 bed houses. But I wondered if there was a specific housing style in parts of the north from a certain era- compact, was meant to be relatively affordable for workers and their families in earlier times, and so it would be inconceivable that it is not attainable for a young couple. Like my friend in wolverhampton once sent me a link to show him what he meant by ex council terrace with no garden (and this was apparently standard in a lot of northern towns) . Cos I said I have yet to see a terrace in my area of london without a garden, and terrace houses in London can be absolutely massive. In truth, the terrace that he sent me a link to was very small, smaller than my flat even.

The answer is yes, there are particular types of Edwardian 3-beds that are very common in Yorkshire and the Humber (assuming this is OP's region from the HTB price cap - it's where I grew up) This is an example of a "3 bed" where I'm from. It's priced as it is because it's on a main road. 68 square metres!

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/115852712#/?channel=RES_BUY

This is where my best friend grew up, 3 kids and one income. This is what you bought when you had £49k in 1996 instead of £120k for a 4 bed detached.

OfstedOffred · 26/04/2022 12:29

Surely everyone downgrades to buy?

We went from renting a swishy central london flat to a shabby old conversion flat out in the suburbs. It paid off though, we just overpaid as much as we could and then in time could move on to a house but we did move further out again to go from a flat to a house.

AllOfUsAreDead · 26/04/2022 12:28

TammyOne · 25/04/2022 20:52

Yeah this idea that you buy a starter home is really outdated. Most people I know didn’t buy til 30s or40s and had kids already. Moving is ££££. It’s also not always the case that people always bought worse than they could rent. My parents first house was a large 3 bed with a big garden when they were about 24. In your situation OP, since you’re young, I would probably try for an older house that needs lots of work, and definitely not a shared ownership. It is shit though. Basically it benefits the banks, and people who already have expensive houses, but it’s awful for everyone else.

It is outdated. I'm glad we bought a house in 2019, but we are stuck here now except for a miracle. Prices have gone up massively in the local area, some of them to insane prices and the house/area isn't worth it, but people are buying them still. That's their problem though, I imagine some are regretting it now with everything increasing, but that was their choice to make.

Prices might come down in a year or so and we can maybe buy something bigger then, but we shall see.

desiringonlychild2022 · 26/04/2022 12:17

@Iamthewombat well of course i didn't mean all 3 bed houses. But I wondered if there was a specific housing style in parts of the north from a certain era- compact, was meant to be relatively affordable for workers and their families in earlier times, and so it would be inconceivable that it is not attainable for a young couple. Like my friend in wolverhampton once sent me a link to show him what he meant by ex council terrace with no garden (and this was apparently standard in a lot of northern towns) . Cos I said I have yet to see a terrace in my area of london without a garden, and terrace houses in London can be absolutely massive. In truth, the terrace that he sent me a link to was very small, smaller than my flat even.

girlmom21 · 26/04/2022 12:11

@Iamthewombat the poster who asked that question was being sarcastic because another had compared the OP's wants to a 3 bed house elsewhere

Iamthewombat · 26/04/2022 11:58

That, in case unclear, was a demonstration of “ask a stupid question…”

Iamthewombat · 26/04/2022 11:57

are the 3 bed houses in the north quite small then?

yes, every single one of them. Tiny. They haven’t even heard of stairs in County Durham, didn’t you know?

desiringonlychild2022 · 26/04/2022 11:43

@perenniallymessy London has been 'stabilizing' from 2015 to 2021, but it hasn't really helped lots of people tbh. I did buy within that time frame but know more people who can't afford to. House price crashes are cyclical anyway and we do have the ingredients for it- high inflation, high pressure on household budgets, increasing interest rates.

perenniallymessy · 26/04/2022 11:36

desiringonlychild2022 · 26/04/2022 11:26

@perenniallymessy I am hoping for prices for flats in London to drop so that I can upgrade to a bigger flat and pay less stamp duty. Sadly no joy yet:( I would even sell my flat at cost or lower as it would still be cheaper for me. That was how a lot of older londoners I know upgraded. The younger londoners are still buying flats and moving up the ladder but most have inheritance.

I am in my 20s so am also looking to increase salary but it would be good to not pay so much stamp duty.

But surely you can see that a drop of more than 5-10% would be a disaster for the economy overall?

We have plenty of equity so could easily weather a big price drop and still be able to remortgage etc, but plenty of people would end up unable to sell and unable to remortgage to lower rates when their fixes end due to insufficient equity. Additionally, people will avoid downsizing, so those bigger houses people can now afford to move into won't be coming on the market.

A long term price stabilisation does much less harm overall to existing homeowners whilst also benefitting first time buyers/upsizers (maybe not immediately but in a few years at least).

LollyLol · 26/04/2022 11:30

In other words: lower your expectations, make sacrifices, and don’t assume you are telling anyone under the age of 45 anything new.

LollyLol · 26/04/2022 11:26

To an extent I do agree as income vs house price ration is always getting worse and the market is particularly mad at the moment.

However I felt EXACTLY the same as the OP as a FTB 15 years ago.

My fiancé and I moved 30 miles west to get a property we could afford. Previous to that I lived like a student renting a small room in shared houses for years, and planned my career moves and finances very carefully (quit a career I loved because it was never going to pay the bills).

To boost our deposit my DH and I postponed getting married, and I moved into his shared house for 18 months - we had the tiniest space and lived on top of each other. We worked our backsides off doing overtime to boost our income and cut down on everything - kept our credit profiles clean.

We were anxious about our first mortgage, terrified of being pinched by rising interest rates.

we were hyper conscious that if we’d been able to buy ten years earlier we’d have made a killing from property price increases and been extremely well off. That feeling of having missed out still kinda haunts me (as I knew some people from uni with rich parents who did buy property right out of uni, and did make a fortune).

i think it’s often very tough when you start out, and huge sacrifices are needed and very low expectations; and if you are only able to “start” in your 30s because you’re just getting yourself established in your 20s, that’s pretty normal for recent generations.

desiringonlychild2022 · 26/04/2022 11:26

@perenniallymessy I am hoping for prices for flats in London to drop so that I can upgrade to a bigger flat and pay less stamp duty. Sadly no joy yet:( I would even sell my flat at cost or lower as it would still be cheaper for me. That was how a lot of older londoners I know upgraded. The younger londoners are still buying flats and moving up the ladder but most have inheritance.

I am in my 20s so am also looking to increase salary but it would be good to not pay so much stamp duty.

desiringonlychild2022 · 26/04/2022 11:14

Iamthewombat · 26/04/2022 10:58

Shocked? Really?

How dare the OP have ideas above her station!

She’s not asking for a three bed house in Clapham. She and her partner want an ordinary three bed in the north. What’s shocking about that? She’s allowed to be annoyed that she can’t afford this very standard aspiration.

are the 3 bed houses in the north quite small then?

Is it smaller than this ; a standard 3 bed house in my area: www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/118819379#/?channel=RES_BUY

my MIL has a very similar house in a nearby area and it was her second property/forever home. She knew a young couple- accountant and lawyer plus they had help from family. Their first property was an art deco 2 bed flat (similar to our flat we bought in 2019) followed by a 2 up 2 down in Hampstead Garden Suburb (which is the same value today as this 3 bed house). Then they divorced, but the husband remarried and now has a larger house in a cheaper area of north london.

LegMeChicken · 26/04/2022 11:12

What part of the ‘North’ are you in? Trafford in greater Manchester, or affluent Cheshire very different from a remote part of Lancashire.

perenniallymessy · 26/04/2022 11:12

Totally agree that the housing ladder doesn't work for lots of people now.

If FTBs are in their late 30s onwards, as so many are now, then they have often reached towards the top of their potential earnings so won't have big salary rises to help take them to the next level. Stamp duty- in the past the stamp duty boundaries would have meant that people would have avoided stamp duty on many first and second homes, but these days even a starter home will have thousands of pounds to pay in stamp duty. And until recently, the low inflation rates meant that the real value of your mortgage wasn't falling, so increasing your mortgage for a bigger property is less affordable than it was in the past.

I don't think that a housing crash would be good for anyone (might benefit a few FTBs but would totally screw up the economy), but we could certainly do with a very long period where house prices only rise at or below inflation, or even completely stagnate to allow wages to catch up a bit.

I also can't get my knickers in a twist about long mortgages meaning that people are due to pay into retirement. If the alternative is renting forever then surely it's better to have a mortgage that you might be able to overpay at points so it might be mostly gone by the time you retire?

desiringonlychild2022 · 26/04/2022 11:06

girlmom21 · 26/04/2022 11:01

Why do that when you have the money to do it younger?

You also don't know what will happen in your early 30s. Maybe your job pays significantly less in real terms compared to your 20s. But if you have a mortgage based on prices 10 years ago, you are likely to be able to afford it due to making mortgage payments for 10 years which would reduce the LTV.

girlmom21 · 26/04/2022 11:01

cestlavielife · 26/04/2022 10:48

And then have a mortgage into your 60s rather than being mortgage free by 50? No thanks.

Buy in early 30s
20 year mortgage or 25 years
Ends before retirement
What s the big deal?

Why do that when you have the money to do it younger?

Iamthewombat · 26/04/2022 10:58

eurochick · 26/04/2022 10:47

I'm pretty shocked at a ftb wanting a 3 bed house! I started out with a 2 bed flat and took in a lodger to help with costs. My now husband bought a one bed flat. We were both living in flatshares to save up before we bought. We had those flats for a few years and then combined our households and moved in together. At that point we could manage a small 3 bed in an "up and coming" area. We are both lawyers and were on above average salaries. I think your expectations are unrealistic.

Shocked? Really?

How dare the OP have ideas above her station!

She’s not asking for a three bed house in Clapham. She and her partner want an ordinary three bed in the north. What’s shocking about that? She’s allowed to be annoyed that she can’t afford this very standard aspiration.

Swipe left for the next trending thread