Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell colleagues what happened with boss? Am I allowed to say if I’m still employed?

218 replies

SofieM0 · 25/04/2022 18:39

Grievance at work partially upheld. Advised (by friends, peers, other HR colleagues) not to appeal as it’s basically end of my career, outcome unlikely to change and I’d have to resign anyway.
Grievance against boss so he definitely has influence. It was a drunken verbal and physical attack, witnessed by many. I can’t stay in the job. Feel let down by company not to mention the working relationship is untenable for me.
AIBU to tell colleagues (inc other female direct reports to him) why I’m leaving, am I even allowed to whilst I’m still in employment? What about new employers, can I tell them the truth whilst I job search?
I’ve asked my HR but they’ve said they can’t discuss that until the grievance is formally closed (believe pushing me to not appeal).

OP posts:
PrincessPaws · 25/04/2022 21:14

CrazyCatLady13 · 25/04/2022 20:32

If your company has an external employee assistance programme they normally offer free legal advice, and it's kept confidential from the company. I agree with a PP, do a subject access request now before they start to delete things. I'm a HR professional & I'd take it as far as you can, it's a good case for a tribunal

Most EAPs won't go near employment issues, it's not in their best interests to start pissing off the people that pay them, so the legal cover is for everything but employment matters

LemonGelato · 25/04/2022 21:06

Adding to advice not to resign yet (when/if you do I'd be clear it's due to their actions and so 'constructive dismissal), encouragement to appeal and get legal advice through whatever means you can. If you can't get hold of a solicitor in the 5 days, appeal anyway - setting out the parts of the outcome letter/decision you disagree with and why. You can expand on grounds before or at the appeal hearing.

Regarding 'being drunk' comment in the outcome letter - was this used as a reason for it to be 'partially upheld'? Because if so I'd go for that as something no reasonable employer would do - it might be mitigating circumstance for him if he was to face a disciplinary hearing but it's not relevant to the grievance, which is about the facts of what he did or did not do.

Agree with other advice so far about aiming for a settlement - if they want your silence they should pay for it. And they are just scaring about the 'bringing company into disrepute' if you tell other employers. If what you say is entirely factual and truthful, and said in good faith there is little they can sue you for. The outcome letter is yours - you can show it to whoever you like (though I'd redact any names/personal information about witnesses etc).

Betty65 · 25/04/2022 21:01

..a household name ehh!

Serious reputations risk at stake for them here.
Sad to say that it sounds like the organisation is rife with utter incompetence.
And, that the HR dept seems to be leading the way... so this might need escalating to the HR director or another senior leader (Director)

daisychain01 · 25/04/2022 21:01

It is not constructive dismissal. For a start, it would require the OP to have resigned at risk with immediate effect, employment contract effectively torn up, no notice period.

perfectstorm · 25/04/2022 20:59

Leigh Day are excellent. I know one of their senior solicitors, who is a lovely, lovely person, and I also know a family who were awarded millions due to a horrendous employment failure on the part of EY (completely different branch of the firm represented them).

They are highly regarded in this field and act solely for employees. They are the firm who represented the Deliveroo and Uber drivers and secured them employment rights. They can discuss what they call Conditional Fee Arrangements, which used to be called 'no win, no fee' but my friend tells me that it is often better, with a really clear case, to opt for traditional charging where the case is clear cut, as you get to keep more of the settlement.

www.leighday.co.uk

It's also worth checking your household insurance, as surprisingly often it contains legal cover, too? If so you won't have to pay, yourself, for legal advice.

I'm so sorry you are in this plight. Sadly, HR are going to try to protect their senior staff, and the company reputation, as a priority. Agree the Subject Access Request is important now. I'd send some random emails about anodyne matters, and print off a list of all sent and received emails, as you can cross refer when you get the disclosure (another friend told me that - also a lawyer but not in this field - he said he often sends emails mentioning a client before a SAR, to be certain everything is disclosed).

Redannie118 · 25/04/2022 20:45

Hi my DH was a trade union rep. The Union can provide specific legal advice and send a rep to sit with you and represent you in every meeting. They can also fully support you throughout any appeal or tribuneral. A quick Google will tell you your union for your area of business and you become a member the day you sign up. You can also demand that HR delay any meetings until you have representation. Any representation and legal advice are completely free. Your HR has already broken so many important employment laws already, having a rep present would stop that in its tracks as they wouldnt let them get away with it.

Changechangychange · 25/04/2022 20:43

Of course it would be hugely damaging to their reputation if this got out. Given that, I’m surprised they aren’t doing anything to mitigate that damage by sacking him.

If this was witnessed, it will have gone all round their competitors already. Don’t shut up about it, make a massive fuss. Get the police involved. Don’t let them sweep this under the carpet.

What they are trying to do OP, is drive you out, hopefully out of the industry entirely, and then they can say you are bitter and made it all up. It stinks, don’t let them do that to you.

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 25/04/2022 20:43

SofieM0 · 25/04/2022 20:02

Thanks @PrincessPaws 100% will do that tomorrow. And yes that was my disappointment - based on probability, they should have been upheld.

The witnessed incidents were admitted by the company (bc of witnesses) but not fully by the boss - he said 'memories were hazy'
He denied the non-witnessed incidents (obviously he wasn't hazy then...!?)

So they know for certain that his version of events is unreliable but have chosen to accept that version over yours anyway. That doesn't stand up to impartial scrutiny at all.

FangsForTheMemory · 25/04/2022 20:42

I was about to say it looks like constructive dismissal too.

saveforthat · 25/04/2022 20:36

I think you should take this to a tribunal (constructive dismissal) as there is no way you can work there after this. I am so angry on your behalf, please get some good legal advice.

perimenofertility · 25/04/2022 20:36

Three out of five, including verbal and physical, upheld. So what is the outcome? Is he being dismissed? Or are they suggesting you go back to work as normal with this manager? You might not appeal the other two, but you have grounds to ask for an outcome - ask to be moved, or for him to be moved, so that you don’t need to work together. Tell them you are going to report this to the police as you have witnesses and an upheld grievance. If they don’t act to protect you, look into constructive dismissal. You really need a union rep and/or some legal advice.

Tigerandthetea · 25/04/2022 20:34

This smells like constructive dismissal to me. Absolutely appeal and take it further. I bet you they’ll settle because if this were to go to tribunal and therefore public, it would cause far more reputational damage. Fight this please OP!

CrazyCatLady13 · 25/04/2022 20:32

If your company has an external employee assistance programme they normally offer free legal advice, and it's kept confidential from the company. I agree with a PP, do a subject access request now before they start to delete things. I'm a HR professional & I'd take it as far as you can, it's a good case for a tribunal

PinkBackpack · 25/04/2022 20:29

I cant give any advice and others have said some great things, but as a lay person reading along, this is shocking and I hope you are ok.

UpDownTouchTheSound · 25/04/2022 20:26

I would go to the police and they can request CCTV -

UpDownTouchTheSound · 25/04/2022 20:24

Have they asked you to sign a non disclosure statement? if they do they need to pay your legal fees to get you teh advice to do so in my experience.

And... make sure you get copies of all the interview statements and keep them somewhere safe

UpDownTouchTheSound · 25/04/2022 20:23

Was it an event organised by the company? Ie work drinks or similar.

As I had a verbal discriminatory attack thing and was told that legally the complaint had to be treated the same as if it had occurred in the office - we were out for a work-organised meal event.

ZoyaTheDestroyer · 25/04/2022 20:22

I would also seriously consider reporting the incidents to the police.

SofieM0 · 25/04/2022 20:05

@bowlingalleyblues good point - I do have legal on my house insurance

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/04/2022 20:05

I have been in the industry for 20 years and our competitors know me well and we have a lot of the same supplier accounts. This is why I think my work is trying to keep me quiet

Yes, that would do it Hmm

What a shame (for them) that a number of people witnessed this, so others may well find out anyway

SofieM0 · 25/04/2022 20:02

Thanks @PrincessPaws 100% will do that tomorrow. And yes that was my disappointment - based on probability, they should have been upheld.

The witnessed incidents were admitted by the company (bc of witnesses) but not fully by the boss - he said 'memories were hazy'
He denied the non-witnessed incidents (obviously he wasn't hazy then...!?)

OP posts:
bowlingalleyblues · 25/04/2022 20:02

Hi OP, definitely worth paying for a chat with an employment lawyer, I spoke to one referred by my household insurance, to ACAS and to an expensive firm of solicitors. Eventually agreed a ‘compromise agreement’, was paid 3 months gross pay, given a good reference and agreed never to sue them or discuss it. I did have people I trusted who I told the full story early on, so they made sure people knew what happened. I have several other friends that went down this route, and one or two that went to tribunal for constructive dismissal and won. All of us have still continued our careers, and it definitely wasn’t the end, although it was very scary and upsetting for a long time and apart from in one case the bosses were not affected. So sorry about what you went through, but you’re probably going to need to get some legal advice at this stage and not resign.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/04/2022 20:01

It's a sales division of a retail giant (very well known)
I am low rung junior and he is a Senior VP

Yes, roughly what I expected: sales, a very senior manager and a company so big they probably consider themselves untouchable

Disabuse them of that idea, OP - and if it comes to a pay-off, at least they can't play the "Can't afford much" card

Knittingchamp · 25/04/2022 19:58

I'm another one in favour of going to the police. I'm so sorry you have to deal with this awful situation. They've even admitted via witnesses that at least one physical assault happened as well as what could be termed verbal abuse.

daisychain01 · 25/04/2022 19:58

I don't understand their logic - several incidents were witnessed, those should be the focus of their attention,

In a sense, the non-witnessed incidents are no longer relevant, your employer has now indicated thus, by only granting you a "partially upheld" outcome. However, multiple incidents of witnessed abuse shoukd carry significant weight.

I would submit a new grievance, only covering the witnessed events. This could be what you take to Tribunal, provided they happened within the time limit of 3 months less 1 day. Keep your options open, even if ultimately you don't end up in the Tribunal court room, give them every reason to think you intend to.

You have tested their attitude, they've played their hand, now it's your turn to ramp up the pressure. Its like a game of poker. It's not over til it's over - they could still make this monster resign, even if they continue to give you every impression they are sticking by him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread