Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell colleagues what happened with boss? Am I allowed to say if I’m still employed?

218 replies

SofieM0 · 25/04/2022 18:39

Grievance at work partially upheld. Advised (by friends, peers, other HR colleagues) not to appeal as it’s basically end of my career, outcome unlikely to change and I’d have to resign anyway.
Grievance against boss so he definitely has influence. It was a drunken verbal and physical attack, witnessed by many. I can’t stay in the job. Feel let down by company not to mention the working relationship is untenable for me.
AIBU to tell colleagues (inc other female direct reports to him) why I’m leaving, am I even allowed to whilst I’m still in employment? What about new employers, can I tell them the truth whilst I job search?
I’ve asked my HR but they’ve said they can’t discuss that until the grievance is formally closed (believe pushing me to not appeal).

OP posts:
supercatlady · 26/04/2022 06:55

My husband used our home insurance legal to pursue an unfair dismissal claim (redundancy) - they provided full representation at tribunal hearing but it was settled outside on the day in his favour.

Loopytiles · 26/04/2022 06:50

Lodge the appeal and be specific about what you’d like to happen, eg if he’s not being sacked that you do not have to report to this person anymore.

You have insurance, so seek legal advice.

Pursuing a grievance or even a tribunal claim doesn’t mean ‘the end of your career’ - don’t think thinking like that is helpful.

Resigning would be taking on a huge personal risk. It’d be at least equally likely to negatively affect your career as pursuing a grievance or legal case through the appropriate channels, whilst remaining in the job or staying while you apply elsewhere.

It wouldn’t be sensible to discuss grievances with your past employers with potential new employers. unfortunately, recruiters won’t have much information and will often regard it as a ‘red flag’ about you.

What would your goal(s) be of discussing what happened and your thoughts and feelings about your employer’s handling of it with your current colleagues?

lovemelongtime · 26/04/2022 06:47

First off get your appeal lodged, secondly don't say a word until this is over ( nothing to be gained at all and risks the appeal(, thirdly start looking asap for another job. Wrong but you need to move on.

See how the appeal goes and if necessary follow the constructive dismissal route.
Follow the process, but really don't start talking about it to others.

notaflyingmonkey · 26/04/2022 06:40

If you do reach a compromise agreement, it's worth looking at this organisation that was set up to help victims understand non disclosure agreements:
https://cantbuymysilence.com

Moodycow78 · 26/04/2022 06:38

You can discuss what you like with whoever you like your company cannot stop you, I'd tell everyone including the police x

needmorethanthis · 26/04/2022 06:33

He said “memories are hazy” of course he’s hazy he was drunk! Definitely appeal and pay for an hours advice for a solicitor. You need an employment solicitor. At least a letter saying you intend to involve the police and pursue a criminal complaint unless he is dealt with. Could you force them to move you to another dept. It’s not ok that you have to leave and no your career is not over at 38.

Dobirdseversleep · 26/04/2022 06:13

This is appalling. Did the incidents happen during work time or work sanctioned events? Not that it should make a difference but it probably does. I’d also want to understand whether their behaviour in this would contribute to constructive dismissal. The law is very specific and relates to their breach of your employment contract but given the element of sex discrimination here, even openly in the letter, then you might have a case. Ultimately it’s legal advice that is needed.

in your shoes I don’t think I could stay, so effort needs to be on getting an appropriate settlement and marketing yourself to a competitor. Fwiw, I hired someone last year who I know through the grapevine had had some issues with their boss and were currently on long term sick (this wasn’t formally disclosed to me at all by them, I just knew). I knew that my team in my organisation would be a good place for them and it has been so far. I hope they are happy, they seem to be, and I really do value them.

Huckleberries73 · 26/04/2022 06:07

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

BornBlonde · 26/04/2022 05:45

No advice but having RTFT wanted to send you a HH. Glad you have good advice and I'm disgusted at how you have been treated

Frazzled2207 · 26/04/2022 05:33

You’ve had very good advice here.

good luck- sounds very difficult but the manager should not be allowed to get away with this

Pickabearanybear · 26/04/2022 03:48

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Ponderingwindow · 26/04/2022 03:45

Can you tell potential employers? I have no idea about the legalities of your case.

should you tell potential employers? No. You should not. If you need income you need to consider how you market yourself. Just knowing that you filed a grievance against a former employer, no matter how justified, can make a potential employer skittish about hiring. Add on the layer that it was over a matter of personal behavior and people get even more scared. It doesn’t matter that it isn’t fair for you to be judged negatively for using the proper process when your workplace superior did something egregiously wrong. They now know you are someone who will stand up for yourself. That should be seen as an asset, but it’s human nature that it actually makes potential bosses nervous.

Zonder · 26/04/2022 03:29

How awful. All the best for today.

Crazylazydayz · 25/04/2022 23:33

I know I’m a bit late as you have had a lot of good advice.

  1. HR etc. are praying you don’t appeal. You now have a plan to appeal and how to get the help you need. They are being very naughty telling you not to appeal, it’s your right. If someone try’s to say don’t appeal, respond with so should I just lodge an ET1.
  2. when you get advice ask about lodging an ET1 - that will worry HR.
  3. If they invite you to a Without Prejudice meeting this is where they will discuss a compromise agreement e.g. you leave quietly and we will pay you x. Make sure you take someone with you to take notes. Your employer has to pay your legal fees if you go down this route.
  4. As part of the appeal, advise that the manager must be moved as grievance partly upheld. You are the victim so he should be moved.
  5. Do not tell anyone/potential employers whilst you are employed as this could see you disciplined.
Good luck and sorry you have had to go through this.
SecretVictoria · 25/04/2022 23:09

@Redannie118 With most unions you have to be a member for at least a month before they are obliged to help. They also cannot help in a case that has already been started if you weren’t a member at the time.

SofieM0 · 25/04/2022 22:55

@Betty65 I had no plans or thoughts on leaving before this. I love my job and took the less senior role to get back to doing what I loved. It’s also very niche and I have carved out a great spot for myself and have an excellent reputation. I will be gutted to leave but I can’t stay now. There’s no outcome here, at the minute. If he got moved (at the very least) I’d consider staying but also feel a bit let down by the company. Also I’m active in the womens leadership groups at work and I can’t promote that anymore. It’s just sad.

and for those that asked, I do have legal cover on my home insurance.

OP posts:
Betty65 · 25/04/2022 22:46

...on top of all this is a major question for you...?

Do you want to exit or do you want to stay?
The answer will also determine the best approach for you personally...
Lots of good advice has come through but the answer to this question might also help carve out the best route for you to take ...

Usernameinsponeeded · 25/04/2022 22:45

Good luck OP x

SofieM0 · 25/04/2022 22:36

Wow everyone I am overwhelmed with all your messages and thank you for taking the time to write and help me. There’s some great info in here and I’m going to sit down tomorrow and pull it all together. Then go through the ACAS and legal steps.
And I will update again tomorrow on this thread with where I’ve gotten to. 🙏

OP posts:
browneyes77 · 25/04/2022 22:33

PrincessPaws · 25/04/2022 19:55

HR person here, I would absolutely appeal on the basis of him admitting it and the fact that it was witnessed 3 times so even though the other two weren't witnessed, on the balance of probabilities it is likely that the other two did happen. It isn't court, it doesn't have to be proven beyond all reasonable doubt

It also buys you time (you can withdraw your appeal later if you want to) to start discussions about a settlement agreement. It would be in their interests to offer one in exchange for continued confidentiality (including after you leave).

I would also put in a Data Subject Access Request for copies of anything that mentions your name, or your initials, particularly between/manager/HR, or (specified) Senior Managers/HR, (specified) Senior Managers/your manager, or any notes /file notes from the same. Ask for anything in email, teams, WhatsApp, message, written notes etc. DSARs are a pain in the bum to manage, and it sounds like your company is pretty rubbish so it's likely that someone somewhere has committed something in writing that they shouldn't, so it may make them more likely to want to settle

If you do settle, and there is a confidentiality clause you do need to honour it

Recruiter here. This is good advice OP.

I would also be careful about discussing it with people at your workplace in the meantime. At least in the workplace itself. If you have a work bestie you trust that knows about this already, that you can speak to outside of work that’s one thing, but be careful about just telling everyone else why you’re leaving. If you appeal, your employer could try and use you discussing it with others, against you.

As the incidents were witnessed by other work colleagues, then when you leave I’d guess it would be highly likely they’ll all discuss it between themselves anyway, if they haven’t already.

Pickabearanybear · 25/04/2022 22:22

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Pickabearanybear · 25/04/2022 22:19

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

HollowTalk · 25/04/2022 21:32

Legally I mean.

HollowTalk · 25/04/2022 21:31

Banter can't be used as an excuse when one person is so senior to the other though can it?

Isonthecase · 25/04/2022 21:23

Wrote a massive message about this and it won't post so here are the bullets:

Go off sick with stress. That buys you time.
Speak to ACAS to get legal advice and work out if they've broken the law or their own policies.
Make printed copies of everything related - emails, outcomes, policies. They may well know you're doing this but it helps show you're serious about a tribunal. It helps if you need to update the police with this as then that's a copy off company servers that's harder to argue you're not allowed to do.
Report to the police asap. Ask ACAS if you can discuss the police report even if not the actual grievance. Be factual - e.g. I've reported so and so for the police for an event he admitted can be proven to be true.
Don't discuss the grievance as that can be gross misconduct.
Is there something for a sexism case on him treating you differently to a man? Think that's unlimited payouts so they're more likely to settle out of court with a non disclosure agreement (which should be about 6 months pay as a starter).
Be extremely clear on the outcome you want from the grievance. It's been upheld - how are they preventing it happening again and supporting you in the wake of it? If you're reasonable it also helps.

It's a crappy process so please get mental health support. I've been through it with HR thankfully on my side after someone threatened me at work and it was incredibly stressful and took months to come out ok but it is ok now and I'll be stronger and more informed going forwards. More to the point, I'll recognise the bastards sooner and know how to beat them.

Good luck.