Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell colleagues what happened with boss? Am I allowed to say if I’m still employed?

218 replies

SofieM0 · 25/04/2022 18:39

Grievance at work partially upheld. Advised (by friends, peers, other HR colleagues) not to appeal as it’s basically end of my career, outcome unlikely to change and I’d have to resign anyway.
Grievance against boss so he definitely has influence. It was a drunken verbal and physical attack, witnessed by many. I can’t stay in the job. Feel let down by company not to mention the working relationship is untenable for me.
AIBU to tell colleagues (inc other female direct reports to him) why I’m leaving, am I even allowed to whilst I’m still in employment? What about new employers, can I tell them the truth whilst I job search?
I’ve asked my HR but they’ve said they can’t discuss that until the grievance is formally closed (believe pushing me to not appeal).

OP posts:
catgirl1976 · 26/04/2022 17:55

God i didn’t read the full thread. They are already offering a settlement? You’ll have to get legal advice in that anyway by law. Maybe take a settlement but get a solicitor and push for loads. Cannot believe they will protect a violent bully. They are in huge breach of thier duty of care

catgirl1976 · 26/04/2022 17:53

You must appeal

then you get legal advice leave and sue for constructive dismissal

failing to appeal will lessen the potential award should you win at tribunal

SofieM0 · 26/04/2022 17:51

Yes I’m going to get a lawyer, tried 3 today and waiting for call backs from them all.

OP posts:
yellowsuninthesky · 26/04/2022 17:31

Dobirdseversleep · 26/04/2022 16:22

What is really disgusting about this is that they are effectively willing to pay you off to protect a bully. He assaulted you, they have witnesses. They know it happened. But they want you to go quietly and to keep him.

It is absolutely unbelievable. But it isn't. It happened to me too (with a female boss, so different issues, but still, why keep her and pay thousands to pay people off).

Anyone who works in HR - tell us why you support this. Why don't you sack perpetrators, rather than paying people off?

OP if they offer you a settlement you should accept no less than six months' net pay. Given there's a sex discrimination angle here you could get a year in my view. But six months minimum.

Changechangychange · 26/04/2022 16:54

Crazylazydayz · 26/04/2022 16:24

Wow. Whilst you are the victim here they are clearly signalling that they are choosing to keep your boss over you. I assume he must either be a technical expert or have specific information that gives him leverage. Very unprofessional.

Only you can decide how much time and effort you are prepared to put into this. If you can get another job a settlement agreement might be the right option. However, you would have a lot of support on MN if you decide to pursue this but don’t underestimate how stressful it will be.

@Level75 gave really good advice and you have also sought specific advice.

Good luck.

Doesn’t surprise me at all unfortunately - have seen this happen more than once. Leave, but get as much money out of them as you can (police involvement may help here, hiring a lawyer will definitely help).

Ellie56 · 26/04/2022 16:34

This company (a household name you said? Shock) sounds unbelievably shit. That very important twat male manager should have been sacked. He brought the company into disrepute not you! Angry Absolutely disgusting. I hope you take them to the cleaners.

Crazylazydayz · 26/04/2022 16:24

SofieM0 · 26/04/2022 15:42

Update - I spoke to HR and my intent to appeal so that I could confirm appeal deadline. They said straight away that if I feel I have to leave, they will go ahead and arrange a WP meeting and facilitate a settlement agreement. So they know...I am waiting on legal companies to call back to help with that.
I didn't need to say anything at all, it was offered immediately!!!

Wow. Whilst you are the victim here they are clearly signalling that they are choosing to keep your boss over you. I assume he must either be a technical expert or have specific information that gives him leverage. Very unprofessional.

Only you can decide how much time and effort you are prepared to put into this. If you can get another job a settlement agreement might be the right option. However, you would have a lot of support on MN if you decide to pursue this but don’t underestimate how stressful it will be.

@Level75 gave really good advice and you have also sought specific advice.

Good luck.

Dobirdseversleep · 26/04/2022 16:22

What is really disgusting about this is that they are effectively willing to pay you off to protect a bully. He assaulted you, they have witnesses. They know it happened. But they want you to go quietly and to keep him.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 26/04/2022 16:06

If you decide to take a settlement, don't assume their offer is fair. My darling of the industry employer with multiple awards for best place to work etc offered me what they said was "fair". As I had nothing to lose I countered with a much higher figure and we settled on a little over double their original offer.

SofieM0 · 26/04/2022 15:42

Update - I spoke to HR and my intent to appeal so that I could confirm appeal deadline. They said straight away that if I feel I have to leave, they will go ahead and arrange a WP meeting and facilitate a settlement agreement. So they know...I am waiting on legal companies to call back to help with that.
I didn't need to say anything at all, it was offered immediately!!!

OP posts:
MrsPinkCock · 26/04/2022 15:14

OP, you can write to them and tell them that you are intending to appeal but also informing them that you will provide your full grounds for appeal shortly if you can’t put together everything before the 5 day appeal deadline. But in all honesty they’d be on very dodgy ground refusing to hear an appeal just because it was submitted slightly late - as long as you provide the grounds “without unreasonable delay” then legally they will still have to address it.

FWIW it’s fairly common for a grievance to be “partially upheld” when a company knows that they hold some liability. Tactically they feel that upholding part of a complaint is enough to placate the employee, whilst also attempting to swerve liability.

If you are looking to bring a claim then please do seek legal advice first as the advice you’ve had on limitation periods here isn’t correct!

PrincessPaws · 26/04/2022 13:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

I'm sorry, I know it is a common misconception from people on here but an ET1 really doesn't scare anyone shitless (nor do letters from solicitors)

notaflyingmonkey · 26/04/2022 13:18

do you have a union that you can speak to?

SofieM0 · 26/04/2022 12:34

Sorry that doesn’t make sense on reading back.
My original complaint was for sex discrimination. None of what happened would have happened to a man. There were multiple mentions of pregnancy/maternity/being in a lower job because I was female/all physical contact wouldn’t have happened if I was male (admitted by them).
however when I wrote my statement they advised just to detail what happened in order.
it was not set out like a grievance letter. None of my grievances were numbered nor explicit.
next thing i knew - it was a grievance and I was being interviewed. I was actually happy with this.
on outcome letter they’ve decided on what my grievances points were and answered them so.
so I’ve myself up there…
although I will add to appeal that it wasn’t a grievance letter if legal advises so.

OP posts:
Loopytiles · 26/04/2022 12:30

Good progress OP!

look at the lawyer posters’ points above.

Loopytiles · 26/04/2022 12:30

Good progress OP!

look at the lawyer posters’ points above.

SofieM0 · 26/04/2022 12:27

Hi All
Quick update whilst I wait for people to call me back…
@TempName01 no personal relationship, I have only ever ‘met’ previously via Teams due to lockdown.

Called in sick. Waiting for doctors to get back to me.
Drafted appeal letter
Spoke to ACAS, spoke to home insurance legal (but rubbish) and waiting for a call back from LeighDay (thanks to PP who recommend). If I don’t hear anything I’m going to try Yesslaw (again thanks for recommendation).

Reading through everything multiple times I’ve realised that instead of answering all my sex discrimination points as that, they’ve pulled each one out and added it to a different point so it’s not answered.
eg. Upheld the inappropriate physical restraint (which they included a comment about it not occurring if I was a man) but don’t class that as a sex discrimination. Whereas my original statement was about it all happening in the first place because I was female. That was my issue!
I didn’t clearly state that in my initial statement tho - I’ve been discriminated against because I am female - due to only being asked to detail the events in a timeline. I wasn’t thinking. So I just detailed what happened and when. Rather than setting out as a grievance (didn’t know at this point it would be a grievance)

and for those that have asked this was a meeting and work social event. Organised and paid for by work.

OP posts:
TempName01 · 26/04/2022 11:52

Did you have a personal relationship with him?

Geezabreak82 · 26/04/2022 11:41

You can say what you want unless you've signed a non disclosure agreement. I would seek legal advice though if I were you though because it sounds like your work are screwing you over.

Changechangychange · 26/04/2022 10:33

The DSAR is great advice - my brother put one in when he was pursuing a grievance (made “redundant” so his boss’s boss could bring his new girlfriend over from another company). He found loads of really incriminating messages (stuff like “oh it sounds like he’s got legal advice, we need to go back and do the paperwork we should have done before making him redundant to demonstrate how we chose to eliminate his post”).

Even the stuff not directly related to the redundancy was helpful (his boss’s boss calling him “a cunt” to HR etc once they knew he was fighting the redundancy just demonstrated that they weren’t following due process). Big multinational advertising firm, so unfortunately being a household name doesn’t mean you follow the law or behave with any professionalism.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/04/2022 09:49

Also I’m active in the womens leadership groups at work and I can’t promote that anymore

That'll probably wind them up as well
It's obviously a brilliant thing to be involved in, but to mentalities like this I can practically guarantee that it'll be seen as "a troublemaking, entitled woman who can't take a joke"

Level75 · 26/04/2022 09:09

Employment lawyer here. I usually act for companies.

  1. Contact the police even if it's not take further. It will scare them into settling or taking it more seriously.
  2. Was this a work function/related to work? If so your employer is on the hook (vicariously liable) for the behaviour.
  3. Assaulting a woman in circumstances where you wouldn't assault a man is likely direct sex discrimination (unfavourable treatment related to your sex). You have 3 months from the act complained of to raise a claim unless you've got a decent reason for being late.
  4. If your employer refuses to move the guy or discipline him or accept the 2 unwitnessed incidents I don't personally see how you can still work there. You could resign (with or without notice) and claim constructive unfair dismissal.
  5. It sounds like you'll be in demand and able to get a new job easily. Compensation for unfair dismissal is made up of a 'basic' award of about 1k in your case and compensation to cover your loss of earnings until you get a new job at the same rate of pay or more. For you this element might be zero if you find new employment immediately.
  6. Compensation for sex discrimination overlaps with 5, but includes an addition element for 'injury to feelings'. This falls in a range of 1k to about 40k. It's v hard to guess what you'd get if you won but I'd estimate about 10k.
  7. The assault is basically in the public domain and I don't buy that they have power over you to keep this confidential. To disclose it would not be you bringing the company into disrepute. HE bought the company into disrepute! The confidentiality is really your bargaining tool if you wanted a settlement agreement - they will pay for your silence. Personally I'd tell everyone I could now before you bind yourself but that's not professional advice!
  8. If you want a settlement agreement it's best not to get a new job first as you can argue you'll be out of work for ages and say you need more compensation. Settlement agreements often contain a clause saying you haven't been offered or accepted a new job. That's because if you have then, as per point 5 above, you wouldn't be due much compensation if you sued.
  9. Finally, you don't need to bring a claim or enter into a settlement agreement if you don't want! Bringing a claim is v stressful and settling will silence you. You could just get a new job and tell the world what a dick he was and how appallingly your grievance was handled. I don't personally subscribe to not rocking the boat out of fear. I'd want my new employer to be a place where they don't think badly of you for discussing such an important matter. That might be idealistic but it's what I'd aim for in a new employer.

I'll probably think of more but good luck and we'll done for remembering to go for legal insurance on your house insurance!

splishsplashsploshsplish · 26/04/2022 08:29

It is not the end of your career. That is scaremongering.
Other companies who value their staff will take you if you are a good worker, esp if direct competitor.

I would apply for another job and appeal simultaneously. Stay strong and don't bow down to this bullshit.

I cannot believe that in this day and age you are being hushed up to 'protect the company' the man.

Well, I can but I just wish it wasn't happening to you.

BuanoKubiamVej · 26/04/2022 07:19

I am not a lawyer but my impression from what you have said here is that this most certainly is not the end of your career, you have plenty of potential with competitor employers in your industry and you do not need to fear for the future. Do not sign a non disclosure agreement or take a settlement that is conditional on keeping quiet. It is never a crime to tell the truth, it can only ever be a civil and contractual matter. You are currently obliged to "not bring the company into disrepute" due to your employment contract but the truth is that they are a bunch of bastards who are taking the side of a powerful senior man who attacked a junior female, it was witnessed and upheld and yet they didn't sack him. These are facts and you will be totally free to share them once you have left their employment if you don't sign any agreement otherwise.

I think you should be applying for jobs with competitors. On paper application forms just put "career development" as your reason for leaving but if they aak you in interview for anything that you can't honestly answer without referring to this situation you can honestly say "I'm afraid I can't give any more details at the moment as I am under contractual obligation not to bring my current employers into disrepute. Can we focus on the positive ways I willbe able to make a difference for (new company name) and leave that subject alone for now?"

Once you have a new job you will be free to share with others only the facts that have been established. That certain incidents happened and were witnessed and admitted and yet he wasn't sacked. That other events which you alleged were not upheld because they weren't witnessed. It would be inappropriate to spread information that goes beyond these proven facts (including the fact that your additional allegations weren't upheld due to being unwitnessed)

Non disclosure agreements really piss me off. It shouldn't be possible to buy people's silence.

SoManyTshirts · 26/04/2022 06:56

One reason not to discuss it widely while the grievance, appeal or case is active is that this could be seen as trying to influence the witness statements or outcome. A bit like reporting restrictions ahead of a trial.