Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ASD DS being banned from nursery

60 replies

Verity226 · 25/04/2022 17:06

DS 4yrs with ASD, he's in receipt of an EHCP and due to start a special needs school in September which caters solely to autistic children. In the mean time he's at a special needs nursery, note 'special needs' as it's a nursery which advertises itself as being for disabled children who need extra support. Most of the children there have autism, and some have learning disabilities. We've had a few issues with them with things such as toilet training but didn't want to cause DS too much disruption as too many changes isn't good for him and hes leaving in July, they're OK for the most part.

Anyway DS has had a bad day today, not unusual for a small child with autism. He has meltdowns and does can sometimes throw things. The nursery know him well, he's been there 2 years. He's never been sent home due to meltdowns before, they just remove bim from the situstion and handle it. He's far from being the only child there with challenging behaviour.

Today OH has been told at pick up that if DS is having another bad day tomorrow then he can't go in "because there is small children there now" - the small children being new starters.

The nursery caters to children between the ages of 2 - 5 years.

AIBU to think that's not an acceptable reason to stop him going in? You can't exclude the older children for exhibiting the very behaviour you claim to be there to support.

She's going to call me at some point this evening to tell me the same as she told OH and I would appreciate some unbiased input as I don't want to go in all guns blazing if I'm being unreasonable.

OP posts:
Verity226 · 25/04/2022 18:24

TheVanguardSix · 25/04/2022 18:15

Two things stand out and the first one I'll approach with a question.
If it's a special needs school/nursery, where's the sensory room? There really ought to be one or at least a sensory space.

The second thing that jumps out at me is that your little boy comes across as totally stressed in this environment. What's the staff to student ratio like? Does he have a key worker assigned to him?

So the nursery is based in a church hall, the nursery have the use of the hall, an office and a smaller room which is the 'quiet room'

That smaller room is used for the children's nap time (nap time is generally from 1pm - 2ish) but when not used for sleeping it is used for watching videos on a projector and winding down at the end of the day. There are bean bags etc. I see no reason that DS couldn't have been taken in there to calm down.

He did have a named key worker but she left some months ago. New staff have started since but we haven't been made aware of another appointed keyworker.

OP posts:
Nerdymummy · 25/04/2022 18:17

I would ask what they are putting in place to help behaviour such as sensory breaks if finding it difficult to regulate. I would also ask have they got observations to highlight triggers (used to drive me mad when told that my ds was doing things out of blue when there was always a trigger and was just them using excuses and as soon as I asked what had happened before could easily see what had happened) I would also ask for early annual review. They can't use new children as excuse, they should have risk assessed to see if they could meet all childrens needs and that they had appropriate staff ratios. Good luck. If it was school it would be seen as unofficial exclusion but not sure how it works in nursery. Certainly in school they would be in trouble. It can be impossible to know what kind of day it will be and alot of time it's based on outside factors so how do they expect you to know

TheVanguardSix · 25/04/2022 18:15

Two things stand out and the first one I'll approach with a question.
If it's a special needs school/nursery, where's the sensory room? There really ought to be one or at least a sensory space.

The second thing that jumps out at me is that your little boy comes across as totally stressed in this environment. What's the staff to student ratio like? Does he have a key worker assigned to him?

Verity226 · 25/04/2022 18:02

Alot of brilliant advice here thank you all

Just chatting to OH now and he suspects it'll be a staffing issue that they omitted to mention as they don't want it highlighting.

Parents don't go past the foyer when dropping off and picking up so we don't know how many staff are working on any given day.

There has been quite a high turn over since DS started two years ago. The only consistent staff members are the young apprentices who have been there since he enrolled, the other members of staff seem to come and go quite regularly.

If it is due to a staffing issue and they're not able to manage something like this for that reason, where do we stand? What does that change?

OP posts:
Verity226 · 25/04/2022 17:46

toomuchlaundry · 25/04/2022 17:43

I would have thought they would have phoned you with serious concern, especially if threatening to tell you your DS couldn't come in

I know right.

DS was a bit irritable when he was dropped off this morning so I asked for an update in an hour or so to tell me how he's doing. Nobody called so I called them and was told "it's manageable"

I could hear DS in the background shouting but was assured it was OK and they have it under control.

OP posts:
LisaSimpson73 · 25/04/2022 17:46

lifewithsomeonespecial · 25/04/2022 17:18

No advice OP but just wanted to say my DS is 4 and is permanently excluded from pre school and he has profound autism Flowers

That sounds really tough I'm sorry. Do you have a place lined up for the future?

candlesandpitchforks · 25/04/2022 17:45

Could it be as he gets bigger or on days of a really bad day he's venturing into territory of hurting younger children in a serious way .

I totally understand that he wouldn't ever intentionally do this but it maybe that your son is completely outside of the nursery skill set to deal with (even with their expertise in this area a everyone has a limit I suppose) and may need very different care ratio than the one he's got now .

which if is the case he must be entering into the realms of hurting other or himself in a very frequent and or higher intensity way.

It maybe risk levels have increased and they foreseeing it a for gone conclusion and therefore insurances won't cover it as something is going to happen and it's become unsafe

Marty13 · 25/04/2022 17:44

How on earth do they expect you to just "know" he is having a bad day ? My son (NT) can be perfectly fine but get irritable later in the day if he's tired, I can't predict that happening or not, and he's your average non-SN child - I'd imagine an autistic child would be even less predictable !

I have little experience but I'd suggest asking :

  • What has happened for them to no longer be able to meet his needs when they have for the past two years ?
  • What has been done to support DS ?
  • Presumably other children exhibit the same behaviour, how do they manage it ? Surely they're not just excluding everyone ?
  • What do they suggest going forward, as surely they must be aware that routine is extremely important to autistic children and this type of disruption would be hugely detrimental to him.
After the phone call send them an email outlining what has been said so you have proof in writing. Maybe remind them that he'll be leaving soon - they may be willing to do more if they realize that it's only for a couple more months.
Verity226 · 25/04/2022 17:44

OH said he has relayed it word for word and definitely isn't mistaken. He hasn't hit or bit any other children no, not once since he started there 2 years ago. The vast majority of his behaviour he focuses on himself like banging his head or throwing himself to the ground, however he does throw things indiscriminately so that is a concern although no child has actually been hit by anything he has thrown.

I don't understand why they couldn't just escort him into the quiet room and/or remove the toys from his reach.

OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 25/04/2022 17:43

I would have thought they would have phoned you with serious concern, especially if threatening to tell you your DS couldn't come in

caringcarer · 25/04/2022 17:37

Has his behaviour got worse at nursery recently? Most likely another parent has complained they don't feel their child is safe. Has he bitten or hit another child recently?

Bobbajobs · 25/04/2022 17:35

Has hubby definitely relayed this correctly? (my husband often misinterprets messages from nursery when he's passing the message to me, especially when it's a stressful pick up!) Or maybe an inexperienced member of staff making an off the cuff remark?
I would expect them to present you with a report/case/examples of extreme behaviour for example, if there was good grounds for him to not come in or they felt he was a danger to other children. Definitely call for a meeting with them, it's not a conversation to be held at the door at pick up in any case.

Verity226 · 25/04/2022 17:30

Double posted sorry, the site glitched .

OP posts:
Verity226 · 25/04/2022 17:30

Thank you all so much

So when they call I will:

  • ask what steps they had taken to manage the situation before concluding they can't manage him
  • tell them I'm requesting an urgent EHCP review (I take it I will need to contact his EHCP case manager rather than just make the request to nursery? Im fairly new to the world of EHCP's and don't have much first hand experience yet)

Yes I agree it's not acceptable for OH to have been told in such an offhand way when there wasn't time to discuss it. They've also lost DS comforter somewhere in the building and said they didn't have time to find it at pick up so we're in for a stressful evening as it is. I'm not happy about all of this.

It's not his first day back after Easter no he went back last week.

Will Google the solicitor thing now

OP posts:
Verity226 · 25/04/2022 17:29

Thank you all so much

So when they call I will:

  • ask what steps they had taken to manage the situation before concluding they can't manage him
  • tell them I'm requesting an urgent EHCP review (I take it I will need to contact his EHCP case manager rather than just make the request to nursery? Im fairly new to the world of EHCP's and don't have much first hand experience yet)

Yes I agree it's not acceptable for OH to have been told in such an offhand way when there wasn't time to discuss it. They've also lost DS comforter somewhere in the building and said they didn't have time to find it at pick up so we're in for a stressful evening as it is. I'm not happy about all of this.

OP posts:
MahsAllToff · 25/04/2022 17:27

Verity226 · 25/04/2022 17:17

Thank you that's exactly how I feel too.

He knows his routine and if he's banned from going in tomorrow then he's going to really struggle.

Call a solicitor this evening - I had to do that. I left a desperate message saying the school weren’t allowing my son back without xyz (medical issues in my situation) - the solicitor was working late and phoned me back and said they were bang out of line and could not exclude without xyz having been done. I knew this so sent him back in and there was fuck all the school could do except to make arrangements to meet his needs properly.

toomuchlaundry · 25/04/2022 17:26

I assume it is possible he hurt a child by throwing something at them. A child threw a a quite heavy wooden toy at DS when he was at nursery. Luckily it didn't hurt him, but that child forever became known by DS as the girl who threw the toy at him.

YouHaveYourFathersBreasts · 25/04/2022 17:26

Verity226 · 25/04/2022 17:22

He has been irritable all day, not complying, throwing himself on the ground, throwing toys

Is it his first day back after the Easter holidays? That usually affects my son (older but also with ASD). Even transition from the weekend of no nursery/school to actually going there can be hard going sometimes.

MahsAllToff · 25/04/2022 17:24

Call a SEN solicitor. They can’t just tell you one day that he can’t come back. Even if you don’t employ the solicitor, they can advise you on your rights. I had to do that.

and as someone else suggested, get this all in writing. Especially the measures that they have taken to ensure that your child is adequately supported so as not to be excluded and to protect other children.

As superslide said call an emergency ehcp reciew to get him 1:1 if they can’t meet his needs any other way.

Its amazing how things can change with regards to support once you assert your rights.

YouHaveYourFathersBreasts · 25/04/2022 17:23

They of course have a duty of care to all of the children at nursery. But that includes your son. Excluding him in any way is not acceptable unless as a last resort when all other avenues have been explored. Doesn’t sound like they have. To be told in what sounds like an offhand way, while your child is distressed/has been distressed is unacceptable too. I would be asking what steps they are/have been taking up until this point.

Verity226 · 25/04/2022 17:22

toomuchlaundry · 25/04/2022 17:20

Do you know what his behaviour was today?

He has been irritable all day, not complying, throwing himself on the ground, throwing toys

OP posts:
Verity226 · 25/04/2022 17:21

lifewithsomeonespecial · 25/04/2022 17:18

No advice OP but just wanted to say my DS is 4 and is permanently excluded from pre school and he has profound autism Flowers

I'm so sorry 😞

Do you have a plan in place for September? Will he be going to a specialist school?

OP posts:
Verity226 · 25/04/2022 17:20

gogohm · 25/04/2022 17:17

You need to find out if there's new or more challenging behaviour particularly aggression towards the new children? Their duty of care is to all children so if they cannot keep others safe with your dc there they need to act

No there's no aggression towards the other children, he's more likely to hurt himself than somebody else. He throws things though so there's always the chance somebody will be caught in the crossfire if the situation isn't being managed properly (which it should be)

OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 25/04/2022 17:20

Do you know what his behaviour was today?

Verity226 · 25/04/2022 17:19

LisaSimpson73 · 25/04/2022 17:15

When they say he can't go in, do they mean they'd like you to keep him at home until his mood improves or are they asking him to leave the nursery?

I think you need to call an Emergancy review meeting too and find out what needs to happen for the nursery to feel that he and the other children are safe.

Is this a temporary thing because of poor staffing and new children starting or will it be like this from now on.

Ask lots of questions and don't be fobbed off op. Good luck.

They're saying they just can't have him in if he's having a bad day, not a case of giving me a call if he's struggling just "don't send him in"

OP posts: