Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my DS that he can sort his own mess out from now on

92 replies

OnYerBike2 · 25/04/2022 14:30

I have a DS currently in his first year of university. He has really struggled to settle since he started, not making many friends and falling behind on coursework. He’s bright, articulate and empathetic, but lacks confidence and social skills.
I’ve tried to help suggesting societies he could join, counselling etc, but he is just so unenthusiastic about everything. I thought things were improving but he’s back in the same situation again.
How are you supposed to help someone who doesn’t want to help themselves? I’m so mentally drained by it all, also coping with other stuff and just feel like washing my hands of it now. AIBU?

OP posts:
CatsOperatingInGangs · 25/04/2022 16:56

I could have been your son OP. Whilst bright and capable I felt completely out of my depth at Uni, dropping behind in my studies, crippled by anxiety caused by undiagnosed autism.
I couldn’t organise myself and I spiralled out of control. I really needed an adult to tell me it was ok to change my mind and maybe Uni wasn’t for me but I felt like I was letting every down down by quitting.
Maybe your your DS needs “permission” to leave. Give him options - leave and get a job, maybe go back to Uni when he’s older. Perhaps he’d be better staying at home and studying if he doesn’t want to leave Uni completely. Could he move his place to a Uni closer to home where you could help with organisation?

bigbluebus · 25/04/2022 16:53

My DS struggled in his 1st year at Uni. He dropped out. He decided he still wanted to do a degree (in a different subject) but took a year out, got a job in retail and reapplied for a year later. He grew in confidence so much in that year he was back home and working. He went on to complete his degree in his new chosen subject and then a masters the following year - living away in a city 3 hours away. Incidentally my DS has an ASD diagnosis.

Maybe your DS is just not ready for Uni life and dropping out and finding a job will be the making of him. If he gets an ASD diagnosis it will unlock some support for him should he reapply to Uni at a later date.

Gowithme · 25/04/2022 16:53

I see OP that your son also is going to be assessed for ASD. Of course he needs support, as much as you can give him, this age is so hard for anyone with autism especially as emotionally they can be quite behind. It sounds like he struggles with executive function (organisation of work etc) which is typical of ASD, and the social anxiety and general anxiety are typical. Telling him to join a club is really not going to help him.

I think socially you have to just let him get on with it, and if that means not socialising then that's fine - but I think it might be helpful to tell him that it's fine for him to spend most of his time alone rather than trying to make him be sociable. He probably thinks he should be sociable and that may be why he's unhappy - because he feels different. Reassure him that it's fine for him not to want to socialise much and could he use that time to break his work down into small manageable chunks and plan when he is going to do each bit. Often the thought of starting something when you have ASD is so overwhelming you just never start - but if you break it down into smaller chunks and get started on a chunk then you get into it and it's actually fine.

Give him loads of love and understanding OP - he really needs it, and remember that things that would work for others might not work for him.

Bodher · 25/04/2022 16:48

Sounds like my DS too.. he stayed until Xmas of his 2nd year. He hated student halls, hated the lectures. Made one friend there. He has school friends from year 7 so it surprised me hi only made one friend.
he Did try but before the xmas I said if he didn’t want to be there then come home but he had to get a job or an apprenticeship. He came home and has worked ever since, even left home late last year. I honestly think if I’d not said come home his MH would have suffered

maybe Uni just isn’t for your son.

I feel schools on and on about Uni and for some it’s just not for them.

CharityShopChic · 25/04/2022 16:44

I really hate this shitty "18 is an adult" bollocks. There is not a parenting switch which is flicked to the off position at midnight on a child's 18th birthday. This attitude that young people who are just 18 must completely fend for themselves with zero input from parents is just so alien to me.

@OnYerBike2 I totally hear you. I have a son of a similar age who is just coming to the end of his first year at Uni. These last two years have just been awful with disrupted schooling through the pandemic, and this year he has been in university for laboratories SIX TIMES IN TOTAL since October. Everything else is on line. All lectures, all tutorials. They have been dealt a very shitty stick and your boy is not the only one struggling. Mine is too. Also very much agree that their normal teenage development has just not happened as the world was shut down for 2 years.

It is true that the drive to get help has to come from them and not from you as a parent. My son had an assessment for DCD (development coordination delay - dyspraxia) just before Christmas so that Uni could put measures in place for him such as doing exams on laptops and extra help with organising himself. We had to pay for this privately as the NHS waiting list is impossible and the Uni can't diagnose, only act on the diagnosis given. If you're anywhere near Glasgow i'd happily recommend the people we used who assess for all manner of difficulties. I sat in on the assessment at DS's request and it was really helpful as the psychologist was asking him things like how good he was at remembering appointments and DS was assuring her that yes he was awesome at it - she saw my face said otherwise. After he got his diagnosis that opened doors. He had a needs assessment at Uni and has access to all sorts of software for time management, mind mapping, reminders, project management - not all of which he'll use, but the tools are there to help him.

The other thing which helps DS a lot is a wee part time job. He volunteers one morning a week in a charity shop which he loves, and has a summer part-time job set up doing admin and sorting the post in a local business. Something routine, with set rules and processes and which he knows he can do well has worked wonders for his confidence.

Good luck to you both.

AchillesPoirot · 25/04/2022 16:42

You can ask if if he would let the uni talk to you. If he sends an email that should get the ball rolling.

Gowithme · 25/04/2022 16:42

EddyF · 25/04/2022 15:05

This is so encouraging to hear. OP, my youngest brother is EXACTLY the same as your brother and it brings the family nothing but worries. He is super intelligent but lacks social skills/has anxiety and is all over the place. My uncle offered him an opportunity abroad to take some time out etc and he didn’t even reply!

Hopefully it will get better for us.

Eddy F I'd say your youngest brother is ticking boxes for ASD there. I could imagine my son (with ASD) doing the same.

OnYerBike2 · 25/04/2022 16:37

chisanunian · 25/04/2022 15:59

It is the pits trying to support a dc with social anxiety through a degree course. The university WILL NOT discuss, support or assist the parents in any way whatsoever as the student is deemed an adult who can ask for help themselves. What passes the authority by is the very fact that someone with social anxiety can't ask for the support they need, because they have social anxiety. And they do therefore need someone such as a parent to advocate for them.

So they are caught between a rock and a hard place. Their parents aren't allowed to help, and the university won't help unless the student asks for it, and the very nature of their social anxiety means that they can't bloody ask!!!

(I've been there, can you tell?).

The whole system for supporting students with anxiety is a bloody mess.

Sorry misunderstood that. I see that parents can’t advocate for them 😣

OP posts:
OnYerBike2 · 25/04/2022 16:32

Also yes, he has contacted the university about counselling but isn’t following up to arrange dates, same for the tutor, student services or his new GP. Bottom line is that he is an adult and I can’t do this for him.
I wasn’t aware that parents can get involved with referral for social anxiety. Worth looking in to.

OP posts:
WorkHardPlayHard1 · 25/04/2022 16:26

Covid has really dented peoples confidence and social skills so have a bit of sympathy but be firm but fair xx

OnYerBike2 · 25/04/2022 16:26

Thanks everyone, particularly those who have given practical support or have experience of this. Both his dad and I are university graduates too, so familiar with all this to an extent, however that was 30 years ago.

OP posts:
Tecksupport · 25/04/2022 16:19

Does he actually want to be there? University isn't the be all and end all. My partner was miserable at university and dropped out in his final year. He got a job instead and worked his way up to a level he enjoys. That was the right decision for him in the long run.

I also hated uni but had an end goal so I knew it would be worth it in the end and stuck it out.

In your situation I would be supportive if he wants to vent, but not take over organising tuition etc. Ultimately that is up to him.

ittakes2 · 25/04/2022 16:18

Has he always had trouble with organisation and social skills? Could he be on a spectrum abs need extra support from his uni?

SpiderinaWingMirror · 25/04/2022 16:17

My dd really struggled. I wish I had listened more tbh. Esp bearing in mind she was just 18. She left school where she had a core of 6 good friends and really just didn't seem to fall in with like minded people. I would say don't give up. Help him focus on the work instead and make sure he passes the year. Take the pressure off finding friends and stuff. Dd did a house share for year 2 which was OK and then moved back to halls for year 3.

chisanunian · 25/04/2022 16:14

LuckySantangelo35 · 25/04/2022 16:01

She can give advise and guidance sure but it sounds like she’s already done all of that hence is so exhausted and drained by him.

Ultimately he is an adult and it is up to him whether or not he takes on the advice and helps himself. If he doesn’t and leaves uni then it’s not a case of he can just come to live with his mum and be financed as if he were a child.

Controversial opinion on mumsnet I know as we are supposed to cosset our offspring until there in there forties or beyond on here!

As I mention in another post of mine, that's all very well, but the whole point is that people with a mental health condition such as social anxiety genuinely can't sort themselves out.

Think of it as being like a wheelchair-user faced with a closed door and a sign which tells them to ring the bell for assistance. The bell is too high up for someone in a wheelchair to be able to reach it. So the reason they need help in the first place is the very same reason that is preventing them from getting the help they need.

jytdtysrht · 25/04/2022 16:13

It’s difficult. If he struggles socially then joining a society may seem overwhelming for him.

What is he interested in or what did he used to do in his spare time?

Is he close enough for a visit? Do you have a dog he misses? Is he struggling with basics like cooking?

I would keep listening in your position. He may not be talking to many people IRL. If he gets online to communicate with random people, this can sometimes be more negative (eg anorexics who encourage each other).

does he have a GF that he misses? Or friends he misses?

if it is really bad, could he change university?

I8toys · 25/04/2022 16:08

I don't care how old my child is I will be there for them even if its just to listen.

Does he enjoy university, his course? My son started last year and the thought of him miserable and thinking it was a mistake would upset me so much.

If he needs to come home offer that to him. Start again do something else. Maybe he doesn't know how to help himself. Definitely get him to talk to his Uni support.

OnYerBike2 · 25/04/2022 16:07

DoItAfraid · 25/04/2022 15:45

@OnYerBike2

Am I correct in thinking he ended his high school years in Covid? If so, that really is an exceptional set of circumstances.

Agree with PP that you need to help him mind map and create structure etc

Yes, I think lockdown and Covid restrictions didn’t help with his and many teenagers development.

OP posts:
2bazookas · 25/04/2022 16:06

Those sound like symptoms of depression, and the university has resources to help. If you can, persuade him to contact them. If he doesnt( which could also indicate depression), then contact his university tutor to alert him that your son is struggling.

Many students struggle to adjust in first year; it's not unusual and he won't be the only one.

IAmAWomanNotACis · 25/04/2022 16:06

Have you tried asking him "what is it you'd like from me? help finding solutions or a listening ear and sympathy?"

thisplaceisweird · 25/04/2022 16:06

I remember being at uni and just wanting someone familiar to moan to and get some sympathy when I was feeling sorry for myself. My mother would always try and 'fix' my problems too and become overbearing. All I wanted was a 'oh gosh that sounds tough, you poor thing'

dustofneptune · 25/04/2022 16:04

Sorry, just saw that he's on the waiting list for ASD assessment :)

dustofneptune · 25/04/2022 16:03

Has he ever been tested for ADHD? I'm just wondering since you said he's struggling with motivation and organisation - and depression/anxiety/self-esteem issues can definitely run alongside this. (I was diagnosed with ADHD during my placement year at uni, after my supervisor recognised the signs - and I had all of the above issues).

Either way, it sounds like he needs support. In your shoes, I'd ask him how you can help - i.e. just to talk, to offer suggestions, etc. Most of all, he probably wants to feel loved and cared about, more than anything. Do you validate him and empathise and really listen to him? Or do you find yourself jumping to solutions because you don't know what to say on the emotional front?

In terms of getting him some help, I'd suggest something like him going to chat to someone at the Student Union - they usually have guidance people there. For him to just join social groups or seek a counsellor probably feels daunting and overwhelming - whereas if he just chats to someone informally at the SU, they might be able to connect with him and help to steer him to the places that could help him?

RampantIvy · 25/04/2022 16:01

What passes the authority by is the very fact that someone with social anxiety can't ask for the support they need, because they have social anxiety. And they do therefore need someone such as a parent to advocate for them.

Spot on @chisanunian

LuckySantangelo35 · 25/04/2022 16:01

She can give advise and guidance sure but it sounds like she’s already done all of that hence is so exhausted and drained by him.

Ultimately he is an adult and it is up to him whether or not he takes on the advice and helps himself. If he doesn’t and leaves uni then it’s not a case of he can just come to live with his mum and be financed as if he were a child.

Controversial opinion on mumsnet I know as we are supposed to cosset our offspring until there in there forties or beyond on here!

Swipe left for the next trending thread