Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that some people just don't get poverty?

555 replies

Ohsoworried · 24/04/2022 22:04

I've seen a few posts recently where people earning a fair bit of money (think around 100k a year) are complaining that they're struggling with money, don't have enough etc. I DO understand that it is all relative but equally, for people like me on a low low wage, in insecure housing, wondering how I'm going to pay rent, having to stop paying in to my pension for the extra £30 a month etc it does make me cringe a little. Things are a little better for me at the moment but it has been hard and my secondment is up soon so back down to low pay. When I left my abusive ex I was living in poverty. And when I mean poverty I mean in a refuge, no job because I had to relocate, no money for a deposit to rent etc. It's the choice between being able to downsize your house, not go on holiday for a couple of years, make sacrifices but still live comfortably etc, compared with not knowing if you'll be able to afford your bills. Of course I'm generalising and I'm sure there are people out there who are genuinely on high wages but have high mortgage payments etc who are struggling. I do sympathise. But I don't always think this is the case...

OP posts:
FlowersforEveryone · 26/04/2022 05:57

But this thread is about poverty, not all the other awful things that can happen to a person.

Because "all the other awful things that can happen to a person" doesn't result in poverty...
Illness and disability can lead to poverty even if you were once "well off"....

Basketet · 26/04/2022 05:51

TheBatKeeper · 24/04/2022 22:17

You have no idea what goes on behind anyone's front door, we live in a very nice area, full red bricked detached house, decent not new, but decent cars outside, but if you would care to pull the curtain back, I had my first brush with cancer at 18, then again at 30, then again at 51, my heart failed at 40 when I had my son, my husband is profoundly deaf, my much loved child is an only as a result of post partum heart failure at 40, then in 2019 when I thought the universe was finally finished pointing its finger at and laughing at me, I was diagnosed breast cancer at 55, You know nothing of other peoples lives.

Just wow! I empathesise with you @TheBatKeeper I really do. But this thread is about poverty, not all the other awful things that can happen to a person.

Imagine those who have similar circumstances to you, but live in poverty? Do you not think that financial instability would grind those people down even further?

DownNative · 26/04/2022 04:54

QueenCamilla · 26/04/2022 00:20

Poverty is NOT relative!
Struggling/not being able to afford food and roof over your head day in, day out is poverty! That's the same all over the world and exactly the same historically.

I grew up poor. So many people around that time were poor. Some struggled more, some less but factually all those families were poor. Nothing relative about running out of food money.

Poverty is relative as its not the same on a global scale. The world's wealth is concentrated in the West whilst the global poor pay perpetual debt to the West who then use it to provide welfare to their own relatively poor citizens.

African countries are paying massive debt to the West and their poor are much worse off as a result. They are effectively sending money to us - the global rich - and we use it within our welfare system.

Reality is being poor in Europe is NOT the same as being poor in Africa. Extreme poverty isn't located in Europe.

But it is in Africa.

Poverty is not the same anywhere and is relative. Children still work in poor countries instead of going to school, including mining which leads to our mobile phones. You don't see this in the West....do you?

to think that some people just don't get poverty?
to think that some people just don't get poverty?
Villagewaspbyke · 26/04/2022 04:54

@FlowersforEveryone totally agree. Poverty is relative. Also peoples problems and the perceived seriousness of them are relative. Someone is always worse off.

Ultimately though, peoples problems are important to them and it’s fine to ask for advice on mn regardless of your income level. Tbf op did say that wasn’t what she meant in her post.

@QueenCamilla I am sorry about what happened to you. I used to work in social work as a young person and I saw many people who needed help. Out of interest why didn’t you present as homeless to the local authority? Was it immigration status? Perhaps things have changed but in the old days you would have got help anyway.

poverty isn’t “designed by society”. It’s just reality that there have always been poorer and richer people. We are lucky in our society that we have welfare benefits, a minimum wage, free education and so on. In other countries people are often happy to work for food.

FlowersforEveryone · 26/04/2022 04:20

On a global scale poverty is relative.

Exactly this is all I am pointing out. But there can be relative compared to your burdens or a number of circumstances that change beyond control etc. Doing it tough and what is poverty for your situation is relative to every individuals circumstances regardless of their income. Someone on 10k a year might be living fine where they live and while their situation is stable but someone on 25k may have a different situation and circumstances causing them to struggle because they have less to live off and afford necessities due to a vast number of reasons. Perhaps the issue is using the word "poverty" and those who believe their situation is worse don't think it should be used by anyone else.

But as others have mentioned, people have the right to post about any and every problem regardless if it rates as important to the next person or not, those people can just not reply... This thread does seem to be a competition though over who has it worse. I have not actually seen anyone complaining about costs of something by choice or struggling with affording certain things being labelled as actual poverty. That label came up in this thread

LegMeChicken · 26/04/2022 03:58

@FlowersforEveryone On a global scale poverty is relative. But we have standards and measures on what it is in the U.K. those are the only ones relevant to the discussion.

You can’t compare the 6th richest country in the world to a developing one. And poverty isn’t just a moral problem. A healthy, stable educated workforce = vibrant economy. Less crime, higher standards of living etc. Who’s going to buy goods and services from local sellers if everyone’s too poor?
Countries like China, India have so much poverty, but also opportunities because of population size. We’re a small island, we need and can afford for all our citizens to be well fed, educated and securely housed.

LegMeChicken · 26/04/2022 03:35

@QueenCamilla You could have used the hooker money to go to the job? Gotten a different job? Asked for a salary advance?
However I’m speaking from a logical position. When you’ve already been beaten down so much you DON’T think the same way, and that’s the point of poverty I think.
People say it’s easy to just say ‘do X Y Z’ but you’re not in the same frame of mind as when you’re warm, well fed and with a safety net.

ThinWomansBrain · 26/04/2022 03:06

what I like about MN is that it is a window into other people's lives that I don't often encounter amongst my friends - but within that diversity, yes, some will be worried about paying utility bills/buying groceries and struggling to pay the rent, others will be posting about how much to pay their cleaner /whether to buy an £80 birthday cake/ how much to tip their hairdresser.

It's possible to have interest/empathy for both - but that doesn't mean because someone has a different set of problems to yours, they shouldn't be able to post here.

FlowersforEveryone · 26/04/2022 02:29

No, I didn't have it good because I was being abused at that workplace mentally and financially, couldn't eat when I was hungry or take a shower or wash clothes. The same applies to everyone else in a similar position in the world - that's a horrible situation to be in and it's lack of money that put me in that situation. Nothing relative.

Yes and that would be a terrible situation to be in for you but compared to some other countries and situations there it isn't as bad. Or is your situation bad compared to your location and circumstances? You can't really compare your situation to one of a third world countrys type of poverty. I know you want to try and make your point about you being the worst off in the world. But it just isn't the case no matter what extra details you drip feed in or create. I am sorry for the situation you were in I do imagine it would have been bad for you, but I'm not about to take away from someone else's misfortune or dire situation because it's not as bad as you think yours is...

Of course the overall standard of living in U.K. is better than a lot of other countries.

Exactly so everyone's standard of how they feel they are doing is going to be relative to where they live and the circumstances they're in. There isn't a blanket definition here. Even though those who believe they are worse off than others want people to think there is.

Rummikub · 26/04/2022 02:12

“Yes childcare is expensive. That's why you only have children you can afford “

i was married, had two dc, that was affordable. Divorced. So as a single parent I struggle.

Rummikub · 26/04/2022 02:09

Of course the overall standard of living in U.K. is better than a lot of other countries.

but Dont get side tracked by it. In the U.K. there’ll be poverty and hardship. And it feels like the govt doesnt care.

working hard and getting an education is difficult if certain things like stability and support are not in place.

And education isn’t always free.

dipdye · 26/04/2022 02:07

Yes childcare is expensive. That's why you only have children you can afford and go back to work as soon as possible working as many hours as reasonably possible, not comfortably.

^

Childcare should NOT be expensive. It needs to be subsidised. Because who's paying the price? Women, especially poor women.

QueenCamilla · 26/04/2022 02:05

@pixie5121 I clearly didn't have a mate. And by then I was very, very hungry - which closes some options but makes others acceptable.

Of course there are other options to be fed for the day (walk into the Church, beg, try to find soup kitchens) I took what seemed like the quickest out and no doubt in my situation it was!

The point is that ending up poor or homeless or on mate's floor has nothing to do with lack of "hard work" or lack of education and we don't all have the same options at the crossroads.
In my case an unfortunate snowball of events (and complete lack of other support) led to incredible struggles.

Someone from a financially stable background wouldn't even have considered that pub as an option, for starters! They'd be back at mum's food and board trying to land the next professional role.

QueenCamilla · 26/04/2022 01:46

No, I didn't have it good because I was being abused at that workplace mentally and financially, couldn't eat when I was hungry or take a shower or wash clothes. The same applies to everyone else in a similar position in the world - that's a horrible situation to be in and it's lack of money that put me in that situation. Nothing relative.

FlowersforEveryone · 26/04/2022 01:34

Unable to pay rent in London, I took a live-in job at a pub

A live in job in a pub where there was a floor a roof running water etc? How very privileged. Since its not relative remember those third world countries with none of that. You were doing fine in comparison right?

FlowersforEveryone · 26/04/2022 01:32

Poverty is NOT relative!

Well if its not relative then people are going thorough wars or live in third world countries and are starving with zero roof, food, or support via govt means etc... So they're probably worse off than someone struggling in a first world country and therefore they can't complain given others have it worse...

That's what meant by relative to one's situation but if you want to remove that equation then no one in the US, UK and many other first world countries can say they're poor in comparison...

pixie5121 · 26/04/2022 01:31

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

QueenCamilla · 26/04/2022 00:54

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

QueenCamilla · 26/04/2022 00:20

Poverty is NOT relative!
Struggling/not being able to afford food and roof over your head day in, day out is poverty! That's the same all over the world and exactly the same historically.

I grew up poor. So many people around that time were poor. Some struggled more, some less but factually all those families were poor. Nothing relative about running out of food money.

pixie5121 · 25/04/2022 22:24

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 25/04/2022 22:20

Of course we should all work part time.🙄

christmascup · 25/04/2022 19:42

Poverty is political. Just because you claim that someone you know will “laugh in your face”, which by the way is very rude, doesn’t change the fact that poverty is designed and maintained by the rich in order to stay rich. That you do not know this does not negate that, it just speaks to your ignorance.

This. And of course it's political.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 25/04/2022 19:00

Dp has a professional qualification and earns an average salary, as a team leader, yet, still drives 60 miles to clean on a Saturday. She doesn't have to.
Even now whilst planning the baby, she's thinking of adding some kind of income whilst she's off on maternity with full pay for 6 months.

Her brother clears over £2300 washing up in a restaurant, he works up to 70 per week. His wife supplements this income with part-time work in a factory.

This is the mindset of people who come from other countries with no social provision. Sit and politicize poverty with those people and they'll laugh in your face.

Poverty is 100% political though. Your partner's brother can only clear £2300 a month washing up because of a political decision to create a minimum wage. Remove politics from the equation and he'd be working 70 hours a week (or more) for food and a place to lay his head.

Also having to work 70 hours a week AND having your partner work to supplement your income just to afford a decent standard of living is really not aspirational. We should never be championing a situation where it's seen as a good thing to spend 45% of your entire week at work (not even including commuting times) and more fool anyone who thinks this is a good thing.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 25/04/2022 18:36

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 25/04/2022 15:59

Dp has a professional qualification and earns an average salary, as a team leader, yet, still drives 60 miles to clean on a Saturday. She doesn't have to.
Even now whilst planning the baby, she's thinking of adding some kind of income whilst she's off on maternity with full pay for 6 months.
Her brother clears over £2300 washing up in a restaurant, he works up to 70 per week. His wife supplements this income with part-time work in a factory.

This is the mindset of people who come from other countries with no social provision. Sit and politicize poverty with those people and they'll laugh in your face.

Poverty is political. Just because you claim that someone you know will “laugh in your face”, which by the way is very rude, doesn’t change the fact that poverty is designed and maintained by the rich in order to stay rich. That you do not know this does not negate that, it just speaks to your ignorance.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 25/04/2022 18:32

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 25/04/2022 18:03

Stealing from the poor.
What are they stealing?
Money, do the poor have money?
You do know money is a concept.

Even The Bible mentions the poor, the Matthew effect is a well-known phenomenon. Or was Boris in charge back in the times when Mathew was written?
😂

who are you talking to?